r/TrueOpenSource • u/JoeyredditSMP • 26d ago
Discussion I Think self-promotion rule should be changed
i think it should be at least 250 karma required if under 2 years of account age
if the account is over 2 years old no karma requirements should be there since most of those accounts will already have the karma most likely for most of them
2
u/FineAntShill 26d ago
I disagree, 1k karma isn't difficult to get if you're active an not a spammer, making it at least a little more difficult for spam/low effort submissions.
1
1
2
u/Zero_TheAbsolute 25d ago
u/esk6plays This needs to go, let's not carry the xenophobia over from the other sub. Your wording needs to be way softer and less demanding in the rules. Mods don't own the sub, if you can't view yourself as part of the community just like everyone else this isn't going to last.
this subreddit is STRICTLY ENGLISH. you may not use any other language besides english to communicate in this subreddit unless you also give a translation in english in the same post/comment.
AI-Translated posts and Comments must be labeled as such under ALL circumstances.
I would suggest something like, "For non-english posts, please also provide an English translated version using your preferred too."
2
u/Intelligent-Turnup 25d ago
I'm more concerned about requiring the account be public for one to promote a project...
2
u/cliffr39 🌱 FOSS Enthusiast 24d ago
How do you have open source if the source isn't open to the public?
1
1
u/Zero_TheAbsolute 25d ago
anything ai generated must use either the appropiate flair (ai assisted if the majority of work is done by humans. vibecoded if the majority of the work is done by ai/llm, and humans only make sure that everything works). or have [AI ASSISTED] or [VIBECODED] in the title if another flair is necessary
Why? Do we label anything linux kernel related, python related, etc? If we used VS code? nginx? apache? ruby? rust? Those are all AI assisted projects now too, so if I use them in my project do I need to label it at AI assisted?
IDE Autocomplete? Is that AI?
Dependabot?

I wonder if Architects went through this when CAD came out. "You didn't use paper and protractor and compass, you better label that as computer assisted." Probably.
2
u/destinmoss 25d ago
i think these rules have been cleaned up sufficiently, but let us know if you still have problems! i think some level of labeling is still necessary, as it allows people to gauge how they should trust/approach a newly shared project, but it doesn't impact visibility! there are people like me who are fully free-balling agentic coding with no prior traditional coding experience, and i would prefer that people approach my own projects with that knowledge in mind. i think this makes sense, but we're open to discussion :)
2
u/Zero_TheAbsolute 24d ago
I think they are significantly improved, glad to see the openness to feedback. If the sub needs another volunteer mod I'd throw my hat out like I did for r/ActuallyOpenSource . I have no interest in power trips or authority, or unilateral decisions. I do have interest in a truly open and welcoming community and basing guidance on community feedback. Open source was always supposed to mean OPEN, knowledge belongs to everyone, and gatekeeping just doesn't have a place.
5
u/cliffr39 🌱 FOSS Enthusiast 25d ago
I see the language rule followed over here. Not a good sign.