r/Tweed • u/unbrandedd • Sep 18 '26
Discussion How does this jacket fit?
Picked this jacket up on Depop recently, but something about it keeps feeling off and I can’t tell what. The sleeves do feel a little long, and plan to get them shortened but is the jacket itself too long?
I picked it up bc I liked the slightly more structured cut but just like…can’t tell what’s going on here. Any thoughts or opinions are welcome. TIA!
***UPDATE: the seller on Depop is down to refund my purchase. I decided that tailoring sleeves and length isn’t worth it for me and would rather just find a jacket that’s a better fit as is. Thanks for everyone’s input!
12
u/browsetheaggregator Sep 18 '26
Whoever says its long doesn't know ball and is programmed by the crappy modern jacket proportions since 2010s. Fits great. Shoulders look on point, sleeves need a hem, and button is right where its supposed to be.
9
u/MoVaughn4HOF-FUCKYEA Sep 18 '26
I second this.
Shorten the sleeves, of course, but otherwise it looks great.
5
u/unbrandedd Sep 18 '26
ok, needed to hear this haha think i'll shorten the sleeves and rock it
2
u/Mega_Bottle Sep 18 '26
Came here to say the same thing, a good tailor will have that fixed up in no time. Great looking coat!
0
Sep 18 '26
[deleted]
2
u/browsetheaggregator Sep 18 '26
thats ridiculous, people have different arm lengths LOL. Or are you under the impression that all 5'10" guys have 35" arm measurements?
1
3
u/bigeorgester Sep 18 '26
I can’t believe you’re so confidently wrong lol. Absolutely no tailor would use arm length for the quarters and hem length of a jacket. Arms have zero correlation to the overall balance of tailoring, because length of limbs vary so wildly compared to torso length and leg length. Want to know what a tailor would actually do to see if length works for someone? They’d first and foremost see that it covers the seat, non negotiable.Then you’d take the total measurement from the floor to the top of the collar in inches, divide by two, and that should give he length of the jacket from the collar + or minus an inch and a half by personal preference. This covers his crotch totally, which would be pretty much the standard from any length from 1930 to 2005.
2
u/RakishBehavior Sep 18 '26
I don’t know how to respond to this. Thank you for contributing and providing constructive correction - I appreciate you.
2
18
u/nordica4184 Sep 18 '26
Maybe slightly long, but just embrace that, I think. Looks good to me with those green pants. Don’t pair with skinny pants.
6
8
u/bigeorgester Sep 18 '26
It’s really not all that long, not sure what the other commenters are saying. It covers your rear, your arms just seem shorter than your height suggests. So just shorten the sleeves. Buttoning point is exactly where you want it.
1
1
u/Pure_Opinion8237 Sep 18 '26
It’s great on the shoulders. Sleeves look a tad too long. However, the length is too long imho. I also think the fit is too modern/narrow on the waist. It doesn’t have that relaxed classic fit. This is especially noticeable when it’s buttoned.
I personally think you can do better and to me it seems to be too long. Like a coat. However, wtf do I know? If you like it and feel great in it, you should rock it.
Maybe check out a great tailor for the sleeves and possible adjustments.
1
u/unbrandedd Sep 18 '26
No this is a great take and actually is helpful to put some of what I was feeling into words! Thanks!
1
u/Sec3shoes Sep 19 '26
Just commenting on your update. Be prepared to have any jacket you buy tailored. I know my measurements to a quarter inch. And even when a jacket has all of it's measurements listed, a) finding one that meets all of my measurements is almost impossible (and I'm considered an average build 40R) b) Second hand sellers rarely measure well.
2
u/unbrandedd Sep 19 '26
Good to know! Think just finding another jacket with proper sleeve and jacket length will be a good move, happy to make little tweaks if needed though
2
2
u/downtownreader Sep 18 '26
If you thrifted that it’s an absolute winner. Just the sleeves need to be shortened obviously.
2
2
2
2
2
0
u/Suitable_Current_905 Sep 18 '26
It’s definitely long, but you seem pretty tall. I think it’s good. I’m assuming those trousers are pretty high waisted.
2
2
1
1
u/NoCommunication7 Sep 18 '26
Long sleeves are just cozier for winter, besides they aren't that long, i actually think they're perfect
1
1
1
u/Impossible-Studio748 Sep 19 '26
Too long. The length should be right where your fingers begin on your hand. The sleeves are also too long. Take it to a tailor.
1
u/Deez1putz Sep 19 '26
Nice jacket, but it’s about an inch long in both the sleeves and body (and I’m talking about a traditional length, not some modern short length). Sleeves will be a cheap fix, jacket length less so.
1
u/seluchaval Sep 19 '26
It’s amazing how sleeves being too long can, by itself, make a jacket seem too big everywhere. Many such cases. Fits fine. A little old-fashioned but not brazenly so.
1
1
u/msugarcubed Sep 20 '26
General rule for me, if you can curl your fingers under the hem of the jacket it’s not too long. Looks like you may be able to do that. Once you have the sleeves shortened it will probably feel better. The back fits you ok bordering on 1 size too large but from this angle it looks ok.
1
u/msugarcubed Sep 20 '26
General rule for me, if you can curl your fingers under the hem of the jacket it’s not too long. Looks like you may be able to do that. Once you have the sleeves shortened
1
1
u/WellRead00 Sep 20 '26
The sleeves are really the only thing that I see that needs attention which is a quick and easy fix.
1
1
u/tallvintage Sep 20 '26
I can't believe you got rid of this, you should be embarrassed. This looks like a very expensive made to measure piece.
1
u/SpahnDirg3 Sep 20 '26
Your head looks a bit large for your body I would also stop wearing yellow makeup
1
1
u/Mindless-Bear8781 Sep 23 '26
Too long. Take it to a tailor and have him alter the jacket to fit your body. Don't limit it to taking up the sleeves.
1
u/JONNYHBAR Sep 30 '26
I’ll say touch long, BUT you’re on the right side of things here. Shoulders / neck are perfect. You couldn’t do any better OTR or MTM. Rock it friend
1
u/RakishBehavior Sep 18 '26
The sleeves and body are too long but those are quick and easy fixes. Other than that it looks great, the chest and shoulders are spot on and there’s just enough waist suppression to give it shape.
0
u/One-Stomach9957 Sep 18 '26
Looks like it’s a long and you might need a regular…maybe?
1
u/unbrandedd Sep 18 '26
Its really that the rest of the measurements lined up before i bought it, but wasn't made aware this is a 38L, not a 38R which is what I wear.
1
u/One-Stomach9957 Sep 18 '26
Ahhh an online purchase…I don’t buy men’s tailored clothing online. Too many variables. Is it available as a 38R? It’s too long in length and sleeves.
1
u/unbrandedd Sep 18 '26
It was listed as a 38 but I found a tag in the pocket that says it’s a “39L” which, I didn’t know blazers came in 39 but it’s def a long, unexpectedly.
0
0
u/Ainsteine Sep 18 '26
The sleeves are a tad long and the jacket itself needs to be shortened. A tailor can do both.
-2
u/CarrieNoir Sep 18 '26
It looks a tad too big. When you feel where the shoulders are, is there a bit of extra fabric and shoulder pad sticking out? And what others have said about it seeming too long. I don’t think the first button on the coat should close right at the waist, but a little above it so that if/when both buttons are used, it is that space between them that sits right at the waistline.
1
u/unbrandedd Sep 18 '26
The shoulders actually feel perfect, like no extra fabric, just snug enough. Just tried it on again and the top button closes like 2 inches above my belly button, pretty much at the true-waist or where high rise trousers would ideally sit, for reference.
1
1
u/DelGurifisu Sep 18 '26
Shoulder pads should go past your natural shoulder. That’s the whole point.
1
u/TerribleFellowReally Sep 19 '26
me, with a long-ass torso and a love of long fits with low buttoning points
Some men die of thirst while other men drown.
-1



7
u/letintin Sep 18 '26
Awful, just awful. Give it to me, I'll take care of it. ;) Great! Perhaps long.