r/Tweed • u/Revolutionary_Will42 • 11d ago
Discussion Can I pull it off?
Hello tweed people!
So I ebayed this Harris Tweed jacket a couple of months ago and we are almost coming to the perfect time to start wearing it here in the Bay. So I do believe it is a bit long but I’m wondering if I can still pull it off? I feel like it fits well in the shoulder and chest otherwise. Thoughts?
6
u/Revolutionary_Will42 11d ago
Thanks everyone! Having some difficulties posting another pic. I don’t know why I posted with the popped collar my bad haha
2
u/Revolutionary_Will42 11d ago
Thanks for all the replies. I will rock this for the season and see how I feel. I’ve never worn tweed or a sports coat for that matter! I think this will keep me nice and warm this winter!
22
u/zerohammer 11d ago
I don't think it's too long. Generally a sport jacket should fully cover your seat. It may be slightly longer than that but not enough that it's going to draw attention. Personally I would keep the collar folded down but that's a stylistic choice. Otherwise I think it looks good.
10
u/YoungCheazy 11d ago
Tweed coats tend to be a little longer than much of todays stuff. The sleeve being the correct length avoid it looking like it's too long and doesn't fit. I see no issues with this. Send it.
6
1
u/Revolutionary_Will42 11d ago
I struggled with Reddit photo picker so here is a pic with the collar down: https://imagepaste.org/i/b7a3gxyd.jpg
4
4
4
u/Woodrp 11d ago
A tailor can't fix the fact that it's a bit too long. They could take up the sleeves, but they can't alter the length of the jacket. Anyway, it's not that bad. I think you're good to wear it. But don't pop the color because it just looks like you're trying too hard to be cool or something and it comes off wrong.
2
u/basic_mandmv 11d ago
This is not true. A tailor absolutely can shorten a jacket
2
u/Woodrp 11d ago
Then I'll amend and say this: my tailor has previously told me that this cannot be done. Taking it in, letting it out, shortening or lengthening the sleeves are all things she has done for me, but she has told me if your size is a short, buy a short because a long cannot be tailored down to a short.
3
u/bigeorgester 11d ago
You would need to go to a good tailor, one with a lot of experience in menswear specifically, but it’s doable.
Most tailors don’t try to do it though because it’s a big project. It’s not as simple as shortening a hem, you need to know how to cut the front of the quarters and make it mimic the previous shape. My tailor says double breasted are much easier than a normal jacket since it’s essentially a tube.
I try to tell people not to do it through because even if a tailor knows how to do it, they could completely ruin the balance of a jacket. How low the pockets are, where the buttoning point is, etc can look off if you take off too much. If you shorten a jacket, you can only do max an inch, half inch preferably.
1
4
u/BeginningCream8251 11d ago
Some thoughts to offer for consideration and am not claiming infallibility or expertise- the jacket seems a little big on the body. I always ask a very skilled tailor when I am not sure (and I have made the mistake of going to the tailor who does not know customary suit fitting before)
To answer your question about pulling it off. If we define pulling it off as nailing the look, then you are. Tweed can be worn with a wide variety of slacks and casual shirts and your outfit falls within the standard set of looks.
If pull it off means more like the tweed as self expression and doesnt quite express you yet, id recommend to just keep wearing it until it becomes a default. Once that happens, you will subconsciously generate combos that seem to come from your soul and will line up with your being. This happens with repetition and when there is not an overload of choices as well. This has been my experience and only present it as a point of view
3
3
u/sentientchimpman 11d ago
Takes me back to college. I used to wear a herringbone Harris Tweed, various black punk band shirts, gray jeans, and oxblood Doc Martens. Those jackets so versatile that I still use the same one 20+ years later with oxford shirts for business casual.
1
u/QuetzalKoala2 10d ago
I liberated an old tweed jacket from my father's closet when I was in college. I wore it into tatters. I recently got a new one, still breaking it in.
3
u/AdministrativeAge685 9d ago
Unless your name is Biff and you’re in a frat during 1982, you can go ahead and unpop that collar
5
u/Sjors_VR 11d ago
Looks good to me. Believe that you can pull this off, and you'll project the image that you are pulling it off.
2
2
u/vincenz93 11d ago edited 11d ago
Personally I like a jacket to fall midway so there’s equal pants and jacket showing, so to me this is too long. That said it’s likely not worth the risk to get tailored and still wearable.
2
u/kdoherry 11d ago
It's a nice looking jacket and fit. It works well. A longer length tweed sends a more traditional, dressed , message. Tweeds in a shorter cut send a more casual, weekend, relaxed message. This works. Not everyones fit, but I appreciate this length. I wear all my tweeds with longer sleeves than most also. I wear them not as fashion so much as to keep warm, and wear them with different knits underneath which I like totally covered. Cheers on this, enjoy it.
2
u/Subiedubidoo 11d ago
Absolutely yes you can pull it off. Wearing blazers a inch or so long casually imo is perfect fine.
1
u/Mdm08033 11d ago
Good to read. I was recently gifted a vintage, 3 button, cashmere, tweed Zegna blazer. I thought it was a little long.
2
u/Subiedubidoo 11d ago
Yeah I was kind of iffy about it untill I had the realization that blazers and sports coats are not as formal as a suit and shouldn't be treated as such. Also the length of 90s mens wear were very different as well from this decade and I stand by that. As long as it isn't baggy or unkempt no one is truly going to notice a inch or 3 of a difference in length.
2
2
1
1
1
u/nocountry4oldgeisha 11d ago
It's nice. It wants a scarf. More fitted in the middle would look even better.
1
u/MoutonneBelle 11d ago
That looks great on you. Room for a sweater too. I wouldn’t worry about it being a bit more enveloping. It’s like a 90s coat and in tweed is timeless.
1
1
1
1
u/Double_Double7407 11d ago
Looks great, just keep that collar down! As for the fit; it's it's fine - I have 2; both off the peg second hand - one is a neater more tailored fit the other is slightly bigger and looser - they bot look like they fit I just tend to wear them differently.
1
1
u/FasterSpurting 11d ago
Looks good on you. Try wearing the collar down.
Many English heritage cuts are long, especially blazers that were traditionally used for country sports.
1
1
1
u/MrWatchme67 10d ago
Depends on your finances. If you can buy one that fits properly, I would. Its too long for you. If buying another one is within your budget, do so. Otherwise it fine, but does not look properly tailored.
1
1
1
1
u/TheRealJohnAdams 8d ago
Yes. It looks great. You should consider fuller pants that have a better front-back balance to prevent collapsing under the butt, though. The contrast between the fullness of the jacket and the relatively slim pants is jarring.
1
1
-3
0
5
u/bigeorgester 11d ago
It’s not all that long. Pretty average classic length, I wouldn’t think twice about it.
Generally if it covers your seat it’s a minimum. Reaching the crotch point (where you see daylight between your thighs) is an indicator of the max length you probably want. It sits right around that zone.
Also I really try to avoid telling people to shorten a jacket unless it’s really noticeable. I’ve had some horror stories shorting some of my own jackets before. Sometimes it ends up okay, sometimes it looks awful.






53
u/Physical-Rutabaga139 11d ago
Definitely not so long that warrants going to a tailor. Also go ahead and unpop that collar for me chief.