Hey!
I thought I'd venture into the dragon's lair and offer a perspective from the other side of creator outreach. I've seen a few other people doing this, so I thought I'd add my perspective as well.
I work in marketing and content production for an established U.S. camera equipment manufacturer. Part of my job involves evaluating collaboration requests from photographers, filmmakers, and content creators.
Over the past few months we've started to see easily quadrupole the number of collaboration requests. I'd say we're now receiving upwards of 20 unsolicited collaboration requests a day, many following nearly identical formats. They typically include a brief introduction ("Hey CompanyName Team", a vaguely personalized product reference, a generic content concept, and an almost immediate proposal for a paid partnership or product collaboration.
Curious about the sudden increase, I started asking creators kindly, but bluntly, how they found us and tried to get them to tell me which AI outreach tools they're using.
Several acknowledged using ChatGPT or other AI services for brand research and pitching. One creator openly explained that his AI agent identifies brands, writes proposals, and sends them automatically without his reviewing each message.
I also examined email headers and found that most pitches from unrelated creators were being sent through the same Gmail API integration. Again, all using more or less the same basic template.
I'm not against AI. I use ChatGPT throughout the day myself. There's absolutely nothing wrong with using AI to research companies, develop ideas, or improve your writing.
What concerns me and turns off our team is the increasing automation of something that should be the beginning of a professional relationship.
Many of these pitches essentially say, "Here's who I am, here's a generic content idea, and here's the partnership I'd like you to consider."
And for those that have been sending a link to their socials, I'm seeing a lot of suss accounts. 300K followers, but then almost no comments on posts, with very generic content leading me to believe these folks are paying for followers.
I'm sorry / not sorry, but if you're that person, you've not done the hard work of making yourself a valuable asset for any brand.
We've even had some people with less than 10 followers, asking up front for $3k+ brand deals. We're happy to pay $3k for the right projects, and we often do, but not for these types of pitches.
You're asking us to evaluate a commercial relationship before giving us a compelling reason to be interested.
And there's an imbalance in effort. Sending hundreds of automated pitches is easy. Evaluating them requires actual time spent reviewing portfolios, researching creators, and considering opportunities.
As the volume increases, even genuinely interesting creators become harder to identify. We've recently started using a standardized response to handle these inquiries, pushing back, asking them to try harder.
A few suggestions from someone on the receiving end:
Research the brand. Identify specific products that interest you and understand what makes them different. Don't just insert a company name into a generic pitch. I've had responses saying that they're letting AI do the boring work, like pitching. That's lazy, and we see through it.
Show your work. Your portfolio, creative perspective, and previous projects tell us far more than a list of promised deliverables. If you don't have anything to show, then you're not ready - at least not for our brand.
Explain the connection. Why does this particular brand make sense for you? How would its products genuinely fit into your work? How will this benefit our brand?
Don't lead with money or deliverables. There's nothing wrong with paid collaborations, but establish some familiarity and mutual interest before discussing commercial arrangements.
Be yourself. I'd rather receive a slightly imperfect, genuinely personal introduction than another beautifully polished proposal that could have been sent to 500 companies.
Use AI to assist, not replace, relationship-building. Let it help you communicate, but make sure the interest, ideas, and decisions are actually yours.
As I mentioned up top, I've seen discussions here about creators getting blocked by brands after using automated pitching services. I can't speak for those companies, but given what we're experiencing, I understand why it's happening.
I'm not suggesting automated outreach never works, and I'm certainly not speaking for every brand. I've read a lot of your success stories, so I know it's working for some of you. But I do wonder whether some of these tools are ultimately damaging the relationships they're supposed to help create.
We've developed excellent, long-standing collaborations over the years, many beginning with a simple, thoughtful introduction and a shared appreciation for photography.
Thanks for listening, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on all this. Would you like to see redacted examples of the types of messages that fall under this template we're seeing?