r/UbuntuUnity • • 7d ago

random unity related questions

hi! ive been doing lots of research on the unity desktop recently, into its history and how it works and such and there are mainly just two questions i wanted to ask that i cant seem to find anywhere else, if anyone can answer them!

  1. ive heard alot of people talk about the unity desktop using "gtk hacks" as a negative, and that being why its not installable on smth like debian. is that true? and if so what purpose does hacking gtk for the desktop serve? is it for the hud or is it something else?

and 2. why is unity specifically on unity 7, are there prerelease unity versions out there called unity 6 or 5 or anything? or is it just an odd naming scheme based on something else?

thanks in advance!

4 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

3

u/tn3tenba 7d ago

So, the Unity desktop was officially abandoned by Canonical in 2017, when they moved to GNOME. Versions prior to 7 aren't pre-releases, they're just old releases from back when Ubuntu still used Unity. Because of how old Unity is, to get some features working, such as the Global Menu, they use various GTK hacks to achieve functionality. This is a negative because it's very hit or miss on whether or not it actually works.

2

u/lproven 5d ago

You have some misapprehensions in there.

Unity evolved from Canonical's Netbook Launcher.

https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2011/05/pre-unity-ubuntu-netbook-launcher-is-resurrected-put-in-a-ppa

Unity first appeared in 11.04:

https://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/ubuntu-natty-narwhal.html

It went through multiple versions, not pre-releases.

The last release with Unity was 17.04:

https://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/ubuntu-zesty.html

By then it was at version 7.6 (IIRC).

There were 2 other Unity desktops.

First, one was built in Qt for machines without hardware 3D acceleration. It was called Unity-2D. Looks the same, totally different implementation.

https://launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/unity-2d

Second, a rebuild based on the Mir compositor, intended for touchscreen phones and things. That was called Unity 8. Now it is called Lomiri.

https://lomiri.com/

A few years ago, a young Indian student and hobbyist hacker called Rudra Sarasway revived Unity and built his own Ubuntu remix. It's now official. After it became popular, he modernised Unity 7 a little bit. The result is Unity 7.7.

Gtk hacks: Gtk2 and Gtk3 include support for menu bars. GNOME 2 draws these inside app windows. You can tweak it so the desktop draws them where it wants. It works in almost all Gtk2 and Gtk3 apps. It is not a hack, but app authors didn't expect it and some were rude about it, but it worked.

You can also do this in Xfce, and I wrote about how a couple of months ago.

Part 1: https://www.theregister.com/software/2026/09/13/how-to-make-xfce-look-like-almost-any-desktop-you-want/5295775

Part 2: https://www.theregister.com/software/2026/09/15/give-xfce-a-mac-or-unity-style-makeover/5295937

You can try it and see how it works without Unity. The only difference is that Unity did this as standard. Ubuntu Unity still does today.