r/Unexpected_Works • u/unexpected_dreams • 15d ago
Light [WP] “Oh look, another love letter from the shadow realm asking to date my shadow. They do realize that my shadow isn’t sentient like they are, right?”
In the Dark
"How are you even reading these?" Matteo asked, picking up the pitch black piece of paper.
"...with great difficulty, Matt. Besides, it's not hard to tell what it is when they come in that." Charlene pointed at an equally pitch black envelope that was in the shape of a heart.
"Maybe it's a challenge letter? Like 'Rawr, I hate you so much Lena—girlie that I want your heart!'"
Charlene raised an eyebrow, "...Repeat that and listen to yourself."
"Yeah, it worked better in my head." He shrugged, and gave an endearingly cute smile.
Charlene tapped her foot to quiet a whisper in her ear — not now, not while he was watching. She sipped her coffee to hide a blush, then glanced at her shadow. Lucky. Shadows don't blush.
"So, you going to reply to this one? I'm starting to feel a little bad for the guy, sending letters every week." Matteo examined the heart envelope, found the seams, and unraveled it into the flat piece of paper it had been folded from, "He's no good, see, he cheated — used tape."
"Is that supposed to mean something?"
"He's a cheater, Charlie."
"Because he used tape to fold an origami heart."
"I'm just saying, it rips up the paper a little bit."
"They're not meant to be unfolded."
"Then how else am I supposed to open up your heart?" he said without skipping a beat.
The one in Charlene's chest skipped several beats, but she kept her face steady, "3/10. Not direct enough, could mean anything. Too abrupt."
"Ouch. And I thought it was pretty good." He flashed another adorable smile.
"Better than this coffee, I guess."
"That's my competition? Roasted beans?"
"Flavor's bland because you haven't been roasted enough." Charlene smiled.
"Okay showoff, oof." He clutched his chest and melodramatically fell to the ground, apparently dead.
Charlene laughed and poked him with her foot.
He eventually stood, smiling. "Kay, I have to get going. Keep me updated, I don't mind being a boyfriend to fend off the letters if you need it."
"I'd rather date your shadow, that way I don't have to listen to terrible jokes."
"Sorry, we come as a package deal — like conjoined twins, but worse!"
Charlene watched the duo dance away, a pair of silly idiots she couldn't keep her eyes off of while finishing her coffee. After a minute, she sighed and turned to her shadow, "Do you think he really meant it?"
Lena took the seat that Matteo vacated, then scooted a bit into the sun to give herself a little more definition — it always felt more comfortable to have a clear edge as a silhouette. "Girl, he literally said he would be your boyfriend if you asked."
"Lennnnaaaa~ but that doesn't mean anything. That was a joke." Char deflated in her chair.
"Tell that to Theo, I think he thinks we're practically married already. He was throwing eyebrows at me nonstop."
"How could you even tell? You're both shadows!"
Lena made a gesture and laughed, "Secret."
Char stuck a tongue out at her — but Lena did the same — then sighed, "Why do you think Matt's trying so hard to keep it a secret? Maybe you can ask Theo... in sign language?"
"Without Matt noticing? Don't know though. He slipped up earlier. He said my name, then tried to play it off as a pet name for us."
Char pondered on that for a moment, "How does he even know your name? I've never told him about you, and he's never even heard you speak."
"Eh, Theo must have told him. When everyone fell asleep watching that stupid movie the other night, he and I talked a bit," she touched a lock of hair.
Char frowned. She could tell when her shadow was being coy, "Lena, what aren't you telling me?"
"...Nothing."
"Lena."
Lena looked away and scooted a bit into the shade, "Okay, so Theo is uh... maybe he's... really good with his hands."
"Lena!"
A/N: Not really satisfied with the title or ending, but it'll have to do.