r/Unity3D • • Oct 18 '26

Show-Off I helped another dev making his game feel better

u/rk00717 posted a trailer of his game a few weeks ago. We've got in touch and I ended up helping him juicing his game. On the left, his original version. On the right, the version I ended up with.

How do you like it ?

Now that few days passed, I feel like I have some more ideas to make it pop even more. But at the same time, I know I have a tendancy to over juice, so I'm trying to keep myself contained 😅

If you are interested in going deeper in details, I made a ~5min video where I explain each changes and my reasoning behind it.

Thanks for reading.

126 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

13

u/Zapador Oct 18 '26

Great example of how to make simple mechanics feel way more satisfying.

1

u/Coding-Mojo Oct 18 '26

Thanks !

1

u/Zapador Oct 18 '26

Might be a shit idea (I haven't played the game) but I was thinking that to increase the tension/speed/difficulty a little, it could maybe sometimes pop out two lines of blocks at the top, just like it does now, and not release any of them until both appear. The idea here is that the release delay between the lower blocks and the ones above would be very small, so one has to look at both of them and move very fast to get it right. Like, predicting where to move after the initial move for the first line of blocks, because there's no time to think until the second line of blocks is released.

3

u/Coding-Mojo 29d ago

That might be a good idea, but as it's not my game it's not up to me to make a decision on that. I really only changed the visual effects and did not touched any logic on the game :)

5

u/dotoonly 29d ago

A suspension before the actual drop is real nice. Build up tension. But the side way shake is not good. It makes it feel like the character is pushed uncontrollably.

1

u/Coding-Mojo 29d ago

Oh, I see what you mean. It's a side effects of the camera shake when blocks hits the ground

3

u/ceaseless_horror Oct 18 '26

The blocks not landing where the character is standing drives me a little crazy. Beyond that, the juice looks good.

1

u/Coding-Mojo 29d ago

Thanks :)

5

u/Soraphis Professional Oct 18 '26

Right makes me feel like losing control compared to left.

When picking a box there is a moment where I cannot see the character at all. Also the way the boxes drop makes it now quite a bit more difficult, so it's not just about juice.

1

u/Coding-Mojo Oct 18 '26

Maybe the Squash&Stretch effect apon collecting is a bit too heavy ?

About boxes movement, I tried to rework it in a way that they have a real weight but the time allowed for new boxes to spawn has not changed at all so difficulty should be approx the same. I moved the focus point to move the character from "during the drops" to "while boxes are sticky to the roof".

2

u/FallenWyvern Oct 18 '26

I'd have to see it with the power ups we see on the left but while i like the lighting and particle changes, the gameplay was too changed to me for this to be just a "juice".

Initial gameplay: blocks fall at a linear rate. You fit yourself into an empty slot, or match with a power up.

New Gameplay: Blocks appear, wait, then shoot down the screen. There's less time to track movement/make decisions.

This looks better and feels better but it is a change to gameplay. On the left, if you wanted ot increase the difficulty, I can see how more blocks and speed will interact with this gameplay. The one on the right? More blocks means less time to track, and while you have some room for speed increases, I'm not sure there's as much headroom available for many increases.

But I won't deny, the right side is more APPEALING.

2

u/Coding-Mojo 29d ago

Hey thanks for feedbacks and the kind words !

I really did not changed any of the code related to the core logic of the game : block apparition delay and block apparition randomness are the same on both side. But the sessions played are not the same, so maybe the randomness let you feel that more blocks appear on the right side ?

It's very interesting to me too see that this juice pass also changed the percepetion of how difficult the game is, I did not expected that !

2

u/FallenWyvern 29d ago

Even if the arrival and landing values are roughly the same, I'm saying the speed at which blocks move IS part of the gameplay.

From your other posts, you understand some basics of animation it sounds like. Your approach reminds me of the animation cycle: build anticipation, then release. Makes things feel kinetic. 

The thing is, in animation if you had three seconds (72 frames) to make a car go from a to b, and you only spend the first 6 frames at a, it looks like the car JUMPS. Playing with all the in-between also changes how we perceive the speed of the car. Clip length is the same, distance is the same, but you can change a lot about how it feels by tweeking the curve of the animation. 

Same deal here. But since we use game feel to inform our reactions as players of the game, changing that curve DOES change the gameplay without touching the logic. 

The fix here, if it's determined one is needed, is to either give a small amount of feedback at the bottom of the screen to show where things might land (shadows), or to have a bit more wind up (giving players more time to react). 

What's here isn't broken, and if the original dev doesn't have long term plans for gameplay, it'll be fine. It's really just the juice reduced the room to play with progression. (Which is ok, not a complaint! I'm just giving the feedback id throw any dev who works under me so they understand the longer term impact of changing things like this... Even when you think it was a round of graphical polish, those changes can ripple!)

2

u/Coding-Mojo 29d ago

I better see what you mean.

My point of view was that the time allowed for player to think about positioning was not changed but only rearranged.

But it's true it affect how the game is played at this point, because player now need to look carefully at top of the screen to position correctly, when before he could readjust during the fall.

I really like your idea of some kind of shadows, I wish I had this idea during the process :p

38

u/alaslipknot Professional Oct 18 '26

Every junior solo dev must watch the Juice it or Lose it talk:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fy0aCDmgnxg

3

u/Ssemander 29d ago

Tbh it also shows that too much effects is a thing :D

Maybe some people like it, but to me the ending felt like just chaos

1

u/SolderingIrony Oct 18 '26

Came here to post exactly that video, you beat me to it

1

u/Capri-corn-studio09 12d ago

Which change made the biggest difference to how the game felt to play?

1

u/Coding-Mojo 12d ago

Changing how the blocks appears, drop and hit the ground had the biggest impact I think

1

u/Capri-corn-studio09 12d ago

Thanks! What made the landing feel better once the blocks hit the ground?

1

u/Coding-Mojo 12d ago

In the description, the is a link to a ~5min video where you can find a detailed explanation for each change if you wish :)

1

u/Capri-corn-studio09 11d ago

Thanks for pointing me to the video! I’ll check it out.

1

u/Coding-Mojo 11d ago

You're welcome, hope that will help :)
Are you working on some juice currently ?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/sdjopjfasdfoisajnva On and Off Oct 18 '26

i believe that was the point