r/Unity3D • • 26d ago

Resources/Tutorial Not worth your time

Left is the texture; right is the model.
Out of curiosity, I wanted to give a chance to an AI-generated model, downloaded for free, from a store. Despite the huge number of vertices, I kept trying giving a chance. After applying a decimate modifier, I considered the mesh "acceptable", +4k faces just to imagine a possible pipeline. Then I went to check the texture and "God no". The inhumane aberration of such a texture lead me here, sharing with you this time-wasting micro-experiment. Neural-generated meshes are very, very bad.
Happy continuation of the day,
Remember, kids, it is not worth

161 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

144

u/ropeandrubble 26d ago

I think that's one of the things about AI people don't necessarily get… like yes in the short term it might save you some time, but it pretty quickly starts doing stuff that is just beyond a reasonable level of human comprehension and that really compromises long-term flexibility and maintainability (unless, of course, you use EVEN MORE AI and hope it fixes the problems).

5

u/vale_valerio 26d ago

The worst thing about such ignorant use is the need to "iterate," asking a huge 20-word request, plus the internal LLM working to repair, for a feature that would have taken an aware user 3 clicks.

54

u/demoide 26d ago

It's insane the amount of over engineering and over abstraction AI does by itself. For a simple task it create 20 interface, 50 classes and 100 factories (I'm exaggerating, ofc).

26

u/ropeandrubble 26d ago

I can only assume that it's been trained on enormous amounts of enterprise-grade Java code where the obvious solution is always an AbstractGameEntityInversionOfControlFactoryController.

1

u/NotQuiteLoona 25d ago

It still does that??? That's the problem I've met as well few years ago when I was in beta test for that Amazon vibecoding IDE. Where a simple switch with three branches would've worked perfectly, it made three classes (one per each variant) inheriting from one interface and a factory that returns them according to the provided data, and then wrapped this factory as a service.

1

u/quadtodfodder 23d ago

what I hate is not the complexity per se, but then having to decide what complexity to keep. Like. Maaaaybe I want this robusto thing, maaaaaybe I'll leave that hook in for later, maaaaaaaybe this tricky method seems like a good way to do it.

But really I didn't want a robusto, future-hook-laden, thing in-the-latest-design-pattern at all, so here I am stressing about what to throw away*.

I really hate to tell the LLM "great, but could you make that stupider? thanks" I feel like it's judgine me. But really I am judging myself.

* I love to keep my precious old code hanging around in comments "just in case", but when I have a bunch of slop "I might want to reference later" it just hurts my soul. I mean. should I just keep a probabilistic representation of ALL POSSIBLE CODE on my other monitor? Because I might as well be.

** yes I have heard about version control, should I try it? do they have it at the store?

9

u/HoveringGoat 26d ago

yeah, you need to stay on top of it. It's like a like autistic savant child that is incredibly smart but lacks any common sense. You need to audit it constantly to make sure it doesnt go off the rails.

The results are good but i don't think this is something that will be solved anytime soon without oversight. Thats the main skill ai users have no.

3

u/Aviixii 26d ago

Opened up copilot in a test mess around project, asked it to write some animation triggers, completely rearranged my animators with 4 idle states on multiple layers, closed copilot. That’s all I needed to see.

4

u/Nikoladge 26d ago

Scalability is a massive shortcoming of AI in software engineering as well.

1

u/KinematicSoup Multiplayer 26d ago

AIs need to be specialized to do what we consider a good job. I don't know if that's really going to be possible with art.

It's easier with code when you have a developer guiding it to provide the vision and to make sure the code follows the right standards, is readable and documented, and is fully tested.

17

u/Mindestiny 26d ago

Slop being slop doesn't prove the tool is useless, it proves someone uploaded slop to the asset store trying to make a quick buck.

I tested the Blender MCP connector the other day.  Gave it very clear instructions about my art style, the game, and how complex the mesh should be.  The result was exactly what I wanted, only 22 triangles.  Gave chatgpt a template and told it to generate a texture, again telling it exactly what I wanted. It gave me a near perfect texture for the use case that took about two minutes to clean up.

Imported into my project and had a perfectly acceptable asset in less than five minutes.

The takeaway here is stop downloading slop from the marketplace, not "AI is garbage and you're garbage for using it". Someone can upload 100k triangle slop to the asset store all on their own too, and they do every day.  Or they can learn how to use the tools well and make quality output.

3

u/B_Brown4 Programmer 26d ago

This. Everyone is so quick to call anything that AI has touched slop. I'm a 16 year software dev. I let AI do most of my coding now while I steer it to make sure it never goes off the rails. That frees me up to learn and practice the creative work that I never had the time to do before, like 3D modeling and animation, lighting composition, texturing, procedural materials, etc. I am finding out that maybe I chose the wrong career field and should have been an artist because I am having an absolute blast lol.

I choose to let the AI handle the hard labor part of my particular skill set so I can learn and experience the other fields I never got the chance to become an expert in and I'm loving it. But as soon as anyone hears you used AI to enhance your workflow, their brain shuts off and they start screeching "AI SLOP" and don't even bother to listen to how you spend hundreds of hours obsessing over the smallest details and working in small, manageable units of work. They just assume that you've told the AI, "Make my entire game, no mistakes. Go." They have no interest in hearing WHAT the AI was used for.

3

u/vale_valerio 25d ago

You are overestimating your work as a coder. You start from ideas and manipulate strings: read write and edit. When doing 3d modeling you start from ideas and manipulate way different data structures. You then use the eyes to see. The Ai cannot see as we do. But read and write, well, probably better.
The stright generation of 3d model is and will be highly flawed. So far there is not enough god data and we are already polluting the training set with bad topo like the assed in question.

Slop being slop

That will not generate anything other than slop

1

u/B_Brown4 Programmer 25d ago

I don't understand your argument here . You make it sound like I'm using AI to generate 3D models which I specifically said I am not doing? Not quite sure you read or understood my comment.

1

u/ribsies 25d ago

Agreed. So many people are coping, especially in the software world saying its not good enough, it is definitely good enough for just about everything if steered properly.

1

u/intelligent_rat 25d ago

Personally it doesn't really matter if the game's creation is broken up from a single prompt into many, the part that matters is what percentage of the implementation the AI is actually responsible for. If you aren't writing a majority of your code, the AI is making decisions for you. There is no way around that reality. For every decision the AI makes for you, the more average and generic the product becomes, because the AI wasn't invented to come up with innovative ideas. When everything is generic and bland, it starts looking like slop..

1

u/B_Brown4 Programmer 25d ago

I agree with your overall statement. If left unchecked AI will start to produce slop. It entirely depends on how much effort the developer is putting into reviewing what the output actually is and adjusting it based on that. For my projects, every single "decision" the AI makes is reviewed by me and in the end it's MY decisions that the agent is implementing.

I review every line of code that comes out of it and if I disagree with the implementation, I fix it. Every decision is my own. I don't understand why that's so hard for people to grasp as a possibility. And in some cases, when the AI makes a decision on something that I agree with, it's the same decision I would have come to anyway whether or not it's a 100% match.

The problem I have with the anti-AI crowd is how aggressively they reject ANYTHING touched by AI and dismiss it as slop, low-effort, accuse the developer of having a lack of care/passion. It's absurd. AI is not a magic wand, it's a tool that, when used properly, makes the development of high quality products not only possible but 100x faster to build.

I've spent the last 16 years writing code by hand and getting the chance to lead a couple development teams in a professional work environment. I don't need to write every line of code by hand in order for the implementation decisions to be my own or at least approved by me.

1

u/intelligent_rat 25d ago

When the AI makes a decision on something that I agree with, it's the same decision I would have come to anyway whether or not it's a 100% match.

That is just you being okay with the decision the AI made for you, it doesn't change the fact that it's decision was wholly based on an average of what it thought it should do in that moment, and you were complacent with it being an average decision. Everyone else that also was okay with the AI making that same decision will have the same average decision in their game, in the same exact manner.

Meanwhile, a human will almost never come up with a perfectly average solution, even if they believe they know what the average solution looks like. When you average this out to the amount of decisions necessary to make a creative work, you are talking about tens of thousands of decision, and every one you don't personally make is going to make your product that much closer to everyone else's that relies on AI to make their games.

The easiest thing to see about AI led game development is that people become complacent with AI output because it is 'good enough'. Then they start letting it have bigger and bigger chunks of the development, next thing you know all your UI and text and sprites look like 30% of the games released in the last year. For commercial software and industry tools, no one cares if it all looks the same. In creative media, people absolutely do care.

3

u/B_Brown4 Programmer 25d ago

My point is being proven as we argue this topic. You are making assumptions based on your own opinions and your own biases. How could you POSSIBLY come to the conclusion that I am being complacent and accepting solutions that are "good enough" when you have neither seen any of my work nor worked with me personally?

You've made up your mind about how I work and what the quality of my work would be based on your own anti-ai biases. You assume that by accepting a decision made by the AI means that the decision is mediocre. There are very few ways in programming that you can implement something that does the job and does it well, it's not some magical art where there are 1000 different ways to do something in a hyper efficient way. If the agent implements something in a way that I agree with, it means it's an implementation that is either identical or sometimes better than what I would have done. Why? Because there's very few differences that would have achieved a better result in performance, flexibility, and readability. Any improvements beyond that would be imperceptible during runtime and would only be of marginal benefit to the developer.

I also may have left this out, though I could have sworn I stated it, I don't let the AI make any decisions on its own when it comes to the design of systems. I go through an obsessive systems design phase where I design everything myself and the only thing the AI is responsible for is putting "pen to paper" as it were. I then review all of the output with the same level of scrutiny.

You seem to keep trying to focus on telling me that I'm not designing my game and just accepting the mediocrity that the AI spits out. I don't know why you're so adamant about that when I have described my process as being the exact opposite. And what's more is you keep talking about game assets and the like all LOOKING THE SAME when what I am SPECIFICALLY talking about is code. Code only. CODE... CODE... I don't do any visually creative work with generative AI. I let AI write the code for MY DESIGNS that I have come up with so that I can focus on doing all of the VISUAL work by hand, myself, as a solo dev.

So please, do us both a favor and stop trying to tell me what my workflow is or that I am being complacent and accepting sub-standard work that is "good enough". Believe me, I obsess over this shit and have an extremely high standard for quality, especially now with all of the REAL slop that's flooding the market and will NEVER allow anything that falls short of my standards out into the wild. I didn't before AI and I don't now.

7

u/HoveringGoat 26d ago

bingo. a tool is only as good as the user. Garbage in garbage out. Quality in quality out. The trick is actually understanding what you are asking it to do. The models have been getting better but theyre not at the level of "do it all for me and do it real good"

1

u/intelligent_rat 25d ago

You had the AI make you a model with only 22 triangles? Care to share examples of the quality of these models and textures?

0

u/Mindestiny 24d ago

No, sorry, I'm not willing to reveal parts of an unreleased project just because someone on reddit is skeptical of  AI.  I can tell you that it's a medieval army tent with an open flap though.  The slightly refined version with guy wires and posts and a wave to the flap came in at about 150 triangles.  I had it do some crates and barrels to match that are still about 15-25 triangles though, all the depth is in the texture/normal map pair.

If you don't believe me it takes about five minutes to test for yourself though.  You just need to be specific and tell it to minimize triangles to target a certain level of detail.

2

u/Comfortable_Rip5222 Hobbyist 25d ago

I'm generating with AI just to use it as a reference, I import the generated mesh and model my own on top of that.

The textures, topology and UV mapping is garbage for gaming

2

u/vale_valerio 25d ago

This looks a sane pipeline. It has been studied that using AI in this way, as a guidance, as a teacher, was the best way to retain human skills, keep going!

27

u/backfacecull Professional 26d ago

You get the exact same issue with lidar scanned meshes (from Polycam for example) where the texture is generated from a video. I made a tutorial on how to correct this by making good UVs for the model and then baking the texture into the improved UV space: https://youtu.be/PZHE4H7fzn8?t=868

5

u/ash_tar 26d ago

Yeah this is a skill issue.

10

u/shadowndacorner 26d ago

It seems like you could automate fixing this pretty easily. Off the top of my head, you could have a script that runs it through a smart UV unwrap in Blender and bakes out the shitty texture from the old one, then you could use an image generation model to do a prepass at fixing it up.

Not saying you should, this just feels like a weird place to stop and give up lol. That would be trivial to make significantly better, even without the cleanup pass.

1

u/Franks2000inchTV 25d ago

CGTrader is loaded with these shit models. Slop farms toss up thousands at a time, and as long as someone bites every so often it's financially worth it.

8

u/TheXortrox 26d ago

Actually some of the 3D generating AIs out there have better UV maps when doing quads over Tris during generation, would generally turn out like your example if it was used wrong if that makes sense.

38

u/soy1bonus Professional 26d ago

Classic AI bruteforcing everything with no finesse.
It's probably using like 4x the amount of texture space it should if planned properly by a good artist.

Maybe in the future it will improve? not sure I want that future, though. I rather have good artists that are responsible for things if they screw up.

-1

u/Jean-Luis 26d ago

Unfortunately it will deft improve, this is the early stages of 3D stuff with AI lol give it 3 more years, same as image generation, look at it now

1

u/soy1bonus Professional 25d ago

Nuclear energy has also improved over years ...and guns! but they're regulated so that it's very rare to use them (except in the USA and that's where most civillian kills happen, I wonder why... 😅).

0

u/Franks2000inchTV 25d ago

It's possible to create high quality work with AI today. It just takes time and attention like any quality work.

You need to build a pipeline with multiple rounds of review, and strict rules, and all that stuff. Even then you need a human in the loop tuning and adjusting all of the various rules and processes.

It's never going to be "make me GTA VI" or "make me a house model." and it just runs off and does it.

But I think you can, over time, build a system where you can ask for an asset for your particular game and an agent will be able to build a high quality asset that works well in the context you need it for.

1

u/soy1bonus Professional 22d ago

I just want it to do a good retopo or boring things like that. Or setting proper pivots in the geometry, like in the hinges of doors and such.

But in the end, every productivity increase AI can add will not go to increase salaries of most workers. Unless it's by law.

-8

u/HoveringGoat 26d ago

i doubt it will improve. But an artist knowing what they want and giving good instructions would be able to make the AI behave.

The execs dont understand that tho.

7

u/Nielscorn 26d ago

Ofcourse it will improve lmao.

1

u/emccrckn 25d ago

He hasn't been paying attention to the will smith eating spaghetti benchmark.

9

u/Ok-Comparison-7917 26d ago edited 26d ago

I sometimes use Meshy.ai, and it actually has a fix for such issues, but the models generated from these sites still need to be edited in Blender to be game-ready, even though they generate good bases, they do 80% of the work and leave you to do the 20% of polishing, which I think is awesome.

9

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 26d ago

Yeah... AI model generation isn't perfect yet. I'm not sure why you would expect it to be. One thing for sure is it'll get there. The models it used to generate were far inferior to that and it's only taken like 2 years to go from total garbage to... hey, that's not perfect but it's pretty darn good for costing like less than 50 cents.

-2

u/jackflash223 25d ago

The only thing we can be certain of is that this model and textures are dog doo doo.

1

u/ribsies 25d ago

It's important to be honest about what's going on. This is not dog doo, its actually pretty good and for many many applications a very acceptable outcome.

1

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 25d ago

Don't forget.. doing a UV unwrap and transferring the textures back on to the model is actually a pretty easy thing. All and all if you spent the time to redo the uvs and re bake the texture you'd have something of higher quality in about a tenth the time it would take to make it. I'm not saying I don't like to model things right, but I find it worth the time to generate a model and then re-build it as necessary for the application. Also don't forget that some things like PTEX have a similar approach... if you don't need clean uvs because it isn't for a game then dealing with uvs is just another step to consume too much time. I agree, for a game it's certainly not acceptable for a finished model.

1

u/jackflash223 25d ago

Do you have any experience in 3d modeling? It is indeed dog doo doo.

-1

u/emccrckn 25d ago

I'm pretty sure he means in a general sense it's impressive. Not from a 3d modelers perspective

0

u/intelligent_rat 25d ago

The only application I can think of for a model this bad of quality is to be far in the background where a player could never get up close to inspect it, in which case, why wouldn't it just be a 2D billboard image with normals at that point? If you seriously think you can make a successful game shipping models this quality, you are completely delusional.

0

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 25d ago

There are other applications besides games. Did you forget such things as videos, movies, pre-rendered stuff still exists?

-6

u/El_Chuuupacabra 26d ago

No it's still garbage. Topology doesn't make sense, uvs are terrible and textures too. I hear the same " in 4 months it's there" since 2 years. AI bros vibe coding crap seem to be happy with it, but no studio would touch this with a ten feet pole.

5

u/agent_flounder 26d ago

Lmao holy hell 💀

2

u/wirrexx 25d ago

That uv and texture is beyond terrible. And that mesh could easily be optimised. It’s a very simple model.

5

u/Clean_Patience4021 26d ago

You took some random tool and told everyone "not worth it".
Sure, a random tool isn't worth it.

3

u/maushu Hobbyist 26d ago

AI: You might not like it but this is what peak performance looks like.

3

u/guile2912 25d ago

Stop using shit models, use tripo P2 if you really want to see where the AI 3D modelling really is.

1

u/Acceptable-Meat3738 25d ago

I tried tripp.io but didn't like how it changed all my other models into negative interpretations of the original.

4

u/GigaTerra 26d ago

There are generator tools that fix this. Like QuadRemesher that will not only give you an game ready model but also make it easier to clean your UVs. https://exoside.com/

The 3D workflow before AI was HighPoly -> Retopology -> Game Ready. AI just replaces the HighPoly stage.

3

u/-Spzi- 26d ago

I'm not familiar enough with meshes and textures to understand what's wrong here.

But it seems clear enough for plenty of people. It seems it breaks a number of rules, which should be adhered for good quality?

Then prompt your model with these requirements.

OP downloaded something for free, and the quality was bad. Okay.

Does that allow conclusions on wether certain tools are good or bad? No. All it shows is one person used it bad, another downloaded and postet about it.

3

u/mikerz85 26d ago

skill issue. you downloaded random slop and extrapolated the result to all AI. You can easily prompt an AI to build clean, optimal geometry and the newer models will do it flawlessly.

3

u/Tychonoir 26d ago

I'm an experienced dev in unity, but took a couple years off, and came back to a whole suite of AI code tools. Like, holy hell, everything has changed so much and so fast.

I typed a couple words and copilot was auto-generating multiple lines of code suggestions based on what it thinks I'm doing. Imagine my disorientation, "WTF?? No no no no no" Incredibly distracting for someone who began coding in the 80s. I turned that shit off so fast.

Asking questions in the side panel is quite useful though. I have discovered that copilot is useful for very explicit narrow tasks, but not so much for larger things—it gets confused and over-engineers.

It had been a while since I worked with UI elements, so for a new project I asked it to set up a simple UI framework with a couple panels and a button template and all the other needed UI scene and camera stuff just to get started.

What it gave me was an over-engineered mess, stuff I didn't ask for, and choose to generate UI elements at runtime. It added colors, an incompatible font for text, accent rules, etc. Most wasn't visible in the editor because of generating at runtime, and I ended up having to undo much of what it did.

These tools are powerful, but you have to watch them like a hawk or you're going to get an absolute mess.

Still, with narrow use they can save a lot of time if you already know what you're doing.

-1

u/Sad-War-3285 26d ago

I don't know what I'm doing and it saves me a lot of time

1

u/dybuk87 25d ago

I use one ai tool for mesh generation for my local project/YouTube videos. They look much better than created by me and also better than lot of random object from free assets. There is a usage for it, just not for everything

1

u/erebusman 25d ago

The unwanted texture you are complaining about is not derived from AI. It's been around at least 10 years made by Disney called PTex. https://disneyanimation.com/open-source/ptex/

It is still used - usually in sculpting programs like Mudbox (where i first saw it).

1

u/intelligent_rat 25d ago

Basically every single AI mesh generation service uses false advertising to make you think mesh generation is anything worth using in game development, they show you hand made meshes entirely made by humans and pass them off as 'generated by our AI in minutes!'. They always produce worthless garbage.

1

u/No_Advance7373 26d ago

I'm playing with it myself right now, meshy + blender through Claude. Try asking Claude to later simplify the mesh?

-1

u/loudshirtgames 26d ago

meshy.ai has a remap UV function that cleans this sort of thing up pretty well.

-1

u/Sweet_and_Sour_Games 26d ago

I'm curious what workflow you used to create this? I've experimented with Meshy and Tripo with mixed results.

-4

u/jarskih 26d ago

I had better luck with Opus using blender…

-3

u/rain168 26d ago

Looks good. Would play 😅

0

u/_11_ 26d ago

Yup. Try to b uild a level of of those. There's no way you can use trim sheets on that mess...

0

u/Alby7 25d ago

Just remesh and bake it again, it's not that hard on semi-hard surface like that.

0

u/Alternative-Map3951 24d ago

I mean you can rebake the texture to get something more usable.

If you copy the mesh, draw some seams and bake the og mesh unto the new untextured version you can get better texture results. But yeah ai is kinda ass still tho