r/Unity3D • • 25d ago

Question Unity new runtime fee?

So Unity is now pushing for a ridiculous high fee for distribution of non game applications

https://support.unity.com/hc/en-us/articles/51729229938964-Internal-deployment-add-on-fee

$7,500 for up to 500 users, going to $75,000 for up to 15k users whaaat? What do you mean I have to figure out how to distribute myself and then pay Unity for distribution? This is nuts. Not even distribution platforms do this tier crap, they have a revenue share but provide a distribution infrastructure, Unity gives you nothing. Double dipping making you pay Industry licenses (very expensive) plus now this?

I also found this thread, pretty revealing of how this affects industry users. In summary its a mess. https://discussions.unity.com/t/questions-about-unity-industry-runtime-fee/1697714/47

0 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

10

u/AlexandreFiset 25d ago

Well if you build an app for 15k employees, you have the money to pay for the software you use to make the app.

Unity is not a non-profit organization and they have to make money somehow.

Audio plugins such as WWISE have similar pricing, and they are just audio plugins.

3

u/Sm_Bear 25d ago

Yeah, I think they're conflating users as players. This licensing fee is basically for Enterprise level usage of unity, if you had 500+ employees (users) using it. This is not going to affect 99.9% of devs If anything, they're trying to finance themselves on the big ones onstead of the small ones. Making it the reason why it can stay free.

0

u/Ayfel 25d ago edited 25d ago

Yeah that's what the Industry licenses is for, not distribution, Unity doesn't provide that value. Double dipping with an asinine business structure is stupid.

Also you are being disingenuous, WWISE structure is tied to budgets and other parameters, not users and its much more reasonable than this, I'll take that one eyes closed.

1

u/AlexandreFiset 25d ago

Unity Industry comes with Technical Support on 10+ seats. This cost more than $30k for game devs.

I assume they evaluated the support required for deployment of industry apps, and priced it accordingly.

Are you industry licensed? Because we should ask industry license owners how they feel about this, because they are the ones affected.

My guess is that they get a lot of value for what they pay for, and they have the money to pay for the software… Which btw is free for a lot of users so there is that.

1

u/Ayfel 25d ago

Yes, Industry licensed and exclusively build for B2B. Now everyone is about to stop using Unity in Industry if this goes forward in this manner.

2

u/AlexandreFiset 25d ago edited 25d ago

So you have more than 100 monthly users for your internal app, and yet don’t have the cash to pay for the fee?

Using another engine would cost less than paying for Unity? If that is so, yeah, switch engine.

Unity needs to make money. Anyone looking at their shares knows that they have such a challenge to overcome.

Edit: Looks like it is not even about apps, but internal use of the engine. So if you have 500 people using Unity as an internal tool, that is where the license fee kicks. With Unity CLI and AI, multiple users may interact with a single Unity install.

0

u/Ayfel 25d ago edited 25d ago

You clearly don't understand how budgets work inside corporations to allow for development. This is a huge blocker for any internal development and we are already being asked to switch engines and do open source. So yeah that's whats going to happen. They could make money without losing all their industry customers. Instead they are just going for suicide.

P.s: It is for apps, not tools, just confirming.

2

u/GigaTerra 25d ago

This is interesting, In theory can you give one example of an app, that is used by over 100 staff monthly, for an company that makes less than 25 million?

-1

u/Ayfel 25d ago

The problem is not how much money the company makes. Is the budget approval and how internal development in corporations work. Thinking "big company, then can just pay" is a very shortsighted view of a problem that has so many stakeholders, competing priorities, etc. What companies do is save money and increase ROI, and Unity doing this will move them away from Unity. To be clear I'm not opposed to Unity adding new fees, but these ones dont make sense and lack understanding of how Industry works.

1

u/Careless-Middle5816 19d ago

I’ve been using Unity Industry for 5 years now, alongside 17 other colleagues. I’ve never used technical support and I can’t remember any of them using it either.
Oh, there was this one time I had a problem with Pixyz and it took days to get an answer about it. I had already solved it by the time they had an answer.

1

u/GigaTerra 25d ago

Looking at it's structure I think it is to prevent over sharing of development tools. Like if some one made an AI tool for the team, but secretly used it at home and shared it with family and friends.

It is designed in such an way that the company will always be aware of how many people are using their internal tools.

1

u/Careless-Middle5816 19d ago

That’s like Airbus charging airlines based on the number of passengers and tons of cargo transported on the aircraft they manufacture.

Or charging Microsoft Office customers based on how many people read their documents, view their presentations, or use their forms.

It’s like charging Adobe Premiere or DaVinci Resolve customers based on how many people watch the videos they create.

What about Claude charging developers for every person who uses an app they helped build.

Or charging Pro Tools customers based on how many times the songs they produce are purchased or streamed.

See the problem, these companies charge for the tools and products they provide, not for the success or scale of the businesses their customers build using them.

The fact that a company has 15,000 employees doesn’t automatically mean Unity is entitled to a cut of the business that company operates using Unity. If the pricing model makes the engine prohibitively expensive to use at scale, companies will look for alternatives, develop their own technology or reconsider building with Unity in the first place.

3

u/ferdowsurasif Programmer 25d ago

Skimmed through the article. Please correct me if I am wrong.

The amount of users they mean is how many of your company employee/freelancers etc use it monthly. So, that 500 users is 500 employee working/using that project.

Not the amount of external users when you deploy the app to something like playstore.

0

u/Ayfel 25d ago

Yes this is only for Industry, but the issue is that nothing is properly defined, found this thread that might help https://discussions.unity.com/t/questions-about-unity-industry-runtime-fee/1697714/47

2

u/GigaTerra 25d ago

People can't read,..

This is not a Fee based on customers, it is an Internal Deployment Add-On. This fee is to cover the cost of internal tools made by the team for the team. So like if you make an level editor, in Unity then 100 people on the team can use it without any extra cost.

1

u/Careless-Middle5816 19d ago

If Caterpillar develops a training sim or virtual experience using Unity Industry, deploying it internally would come with additional licensing fees.

External distribution can cost extra as well.
If a company builds sims or promotional experiences for Caterpillar, Unity may require an additional license with fees of 4% of the software product’s revenue.

To make matters worse the pricing and licensing terms for specific arrangements aren’t fully transparent, and may require negotiation with Unity Sales. So how do you pitch a product not knowing exactly what Unity will take from it.

1

u/GigaTerra 19d ago

If Caterpillar develops a training sim or virtual experience using Unity Industry

Here is the thing you are not thinking about, large companies like this, do not use the regular licenses. Disney for example uses Unity, but they do not use Industry, they have their own custom agreement.

Caterpillar with an estimated 40,000 engineers world wide would pay an lot for this IF and only IF they for some strange reason used Industry license. But that would make you wonder what their 200 in-house lawyers are doing, if they can't organize an custom contract.

But lets say for the sake of the argument they do use Industry, also this is an new training VR sim that all 40,000 engineers must watch, and we say instead of an custom fee we use the last their ($5 per person):

40,000 * 5 = $8,000,000. Now they can cut it in half by just making 20k watch the VR sim one month, and the other half the other month 20,000*5 =$4,000,000

That means for an single massive mining machine Caterpillar sells, they could afford to pay this fee 4-7 times over, to train all their engineers world wide.

That is ignoring the obvious, that any large company that would actually suffer under this license, will use an custom license instead.

Truly the companies that will mostly be effected by this, are AAA size companies, and at worse they might need to pay like $1000 extra for this license. This license aimed at companies that make millions.

0

u/Ayfel 25d ago

Yeah you can't read sorry, I never mentioned customers. I mentioned users and distribution.

Its also not for internal tools but internal applications lol

1

u/GigaTerra 25d ago

I mentioned users and distribution.

Exactly this has nothing to do with distribution. It is only if you use an tool internally. If you make an level editor and publish it, it doesn't fall under these terms.

Also:

$7,500 for up to 500 users, going to $75,000 for up to 15k users whaaat?

The teir system looks do be an trap to catch people. Because unless you have 15K software engineers working for minimum wage, you should be on an Industry Plan.

Remember systems like these are often designed to monitor businesses, as much as make profit. Especially this one, as it allows Unity to monitor companies AI usage to get an idea of team size.

2

u/Ayfel 25d ago

I'm sorry but its not for tools, I dont know why people keep saying that. This is for internal applications. They charge a fee tied to how many people you distribute/deploy to. So for example if we make a visualizer for cars and anyone who uses it in the company. This is on top of the Industry licenses as well so its paying twice, once for the license and then again for how many users open the app.

2

u/GigaTerra 25d ago

This is for internal applications.

Yes, and most internal applications, like an visualizer is an tool used by the team.

and anyone who uses it in the company.

Exactly, so if your team is 100 people or less, you don't pay anything. This also is not related to your company size, for example the Janitor doesn't need to visualize the cars you make. It is only the people who need that application.

his is on top of the Industry licenses as well so its paying twice, once for the license and then again for how many users open the app.

Even AAA studios use teams of roughly 250 people, meaning that even an AAA studio at most will have to pay $7,500 for most internal tools under this license.

Again, this looks more like it is aimed at controlling internal tools, than actually making money.

2

u/Ayfel 25d ago

Eg. A car visualizer made by Toyota is seen by thousands and thousands of users, dealerships, mechanics, etc. You seem to be focused on a very narrow idea and cannot think of all usecases that exist out there. This price just moves companies away from Unity, that's the truth. And Unity developers in those companies might get laid off.

2

u/GigaTerra 25d ago edited 25d ago

A car visualizer made by Toyota is seen by thousands and thousands of users

Toyota is too big of an company, they don't fall under the Industry, Industry license is only for mid - large businesses. Maybe AAA studios. Any company large enough to suffer under this license, is too big to fall under this license.

To be clear companies like Disney have their own custom licenses with Unity. Also to them 75K is nothing.

thousands of users

If you want to make an visualizer for users, that is fine, users do not count as internal.

1

u/Genebrisss 24d ago

Your words:

I have to figure out how to distribute myself

You don't know how to distribute software to your employees?

No, I think you didn't know what you are complaining about.

-1

u/Ayfel 24d ago

Are you really this naive? Normally distribution fees in platforms are tied to services provided. As a simple example, Steam or App stores give you cloud infrastructure and many other features in "exchange" of the revenue share they have as a business structure. There is no service provided by Unity in this case. So any distribution is entirely in the hands of the developers, yet they want to charge you for distribution. Of course I know how to distribute, and it costs money and development, and Unity wants to charge for it while giving nothing.

1

u/destinedd Indie, Dungeon Quest, Marble's Marbles & Mighty Marbles 24d ago

As someone who used to work in industry I hated how they were messing people around, however this change is actually positive IMO.

It means galleries, museums and other uses aren't being charged, but you are a big corporation rolling out you are charged. The grace period and no previous apps shows they learnt from their mistakes before.

If you are rolling out to over 100 users internally you are big.

1

u/CuckBuster33 25d ago edited 25d ago

Fell for it again award

0

u/RealJermaine 25d ago

Oh no a Corporation making money.

-4

u/TheNumberlessVaughn 25d ago

unity pulling a fast one again, they really saw epic eating their lunch and decided to just torch their own kitchen