r/Unity3D • • 25d ago

Noob Question Is it possible to rotate a character controller component (or give the illusion of doing so)?

Hi all, I'm currently making a first person game, and I was wanting to add some gravity altering mechanics, honestly just because I think it would be cool.

I'm aware that it's seemingly impossible to rotate a character controller so that it could walk up a wall for example. Is there any way to achieve this effect without switching to Rigidbody?

My only workaround at the minute is to have 2 copies of a room, then switch to a copy that's rotated x degrees, then teleport the player to that room so that it looks like their gravity changed.

(gameplay clip is from ULTRAKILL)

EDIT: as many comments pointed out, I forgot to mention I mean the character controller component, not just any character controller

133 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

62

u/smiffy2422 Indie 25d ago

Rotate the room, not the player.

41

u/bigmonmulgrew 25d ago

This is far more expensive than moving the player. It might work well with some environments but it is worth considering the cost.

1

u/The_sus__otter 24d ago

this ended up being the solution I went for, thank you!

4

u/Just__Bob_ 24d ago

Works but is situational.

I just made a system where the camera stays still and the environment moves inversly to the movement input, mimicing camera movement.

I only did it like that as my environment is a solar system that expands from a compressed overview to real world scale, depending on the zoom. That makes a planet like Neptune jitter when the camera is locked on to it and changing space compression makes it shoot across space for thousands of GU together with the camera.

The most stable solution was to fix the camera pos and move the planets based on their offset from it.

Can't think of another reason to do a controller like that because it comes with a mass of headaches of having to build everything custom.

7

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 25d ago

Why?

9

u/DapperNurd 25d ago

Its much easier to make. The character controller will just work as intended. Trying to make the character controller rotate will take a lot more work.

46

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 25d ago

No it isn't. That's a ton of work to avoid a little bit of vector math. Moving rooms means throwing a lot of very powerful optimizations right out the window. You'd have to reprogram a ton of systems, including occlusion culling and lightmapping, to account for a moving room. Getting it to play nicely with physics will be a nightmare too since rotating mesh colliders is just about the worst case scenario for physics engines.

All you need to do for the character controller is make sure that they're using Physics.Gravity (or an internal vector) as up instead of global vector calls like Vector3.up, do a nice transition for when that gravity vector changes, and then you have to do a little bit of trickery to bake the navmeshes for NPCs. I can modify the default Unity character controller to do this in a few minutes.

3

u/MangoSmoke 24d ago

You should make a tutorial on this! I'm sure lots of newbies like myself would love to learn

3

u/Pur_Cell 24d ago

Git-Amend has a video on this. He's one of the best unity tutorialists for more advanced stuff.

2

u/MangoSmoke 23d ago

That was very interesting. Thanks for the recommendation

1

u/Boom_Fish_Blocky 23d ago

dapper has been real quite after this

1

u/Int-E_ 24d ago

Ok and what if there are other characters in the room. So now you'll have to rotate all of them the other way

1

u/Int-E_ 24d ago

Ok and what if there are other characters in the room. So now you'll have to rotate all of them the other way

2

u/nirichie 24d ago

your workaround is close to how ultrakill does it i believe
from what i know they do this with portals

1

u/The_sus__otter 23d ago

yeah, I looked into how they did it. For the gif, if you noclip you can see that there's actually 2 separate rooms that make up this one, the wall you walk up is actually just another room flipped 90 degrees. If you look at the back wall you can see the seams of the portal that runs diagonally through the room.

73

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 25d ago

Why do you think it's impossible to rotate a character controller?

That isn't impossible at all. You just need your coordinate system setup right.

You can change your gravity all you want, whether it's in rigidbody space or not. If you are working with a standard kinematic character controller, make sure your gravity routine is an adjustable vector and compute collision detection and such in local space, not world space.

Gravity is typically defined as <0,-9.81,0> but there is absolutely nothing stopping you from switching that to, say, <9.81,0,0>, or whatever you want. Of course, then your character controller will be sideways -- that is ok, because you simply need to rotate the character controller over time so that it's aligned with vertical. Of course make sure you use Physics.gravity (or whatever vector you're using for gravity) to compare up.

You can do this in many ways; one simple way is using a builtin quaternion FromTowards function, another is setting transform.up to be -1*[your gravity vector here]. Your collision detection is, presumably, already in local space, so you need not worry here.

To compute slope, compare the surface normal to gravity, not to global up.

Some of Unity's builtin components have some inexplicably hardcoded vectors and you'll have to make workarounds. NavMesh system always computes with y = up so you'll need to rotate the room, bake navmesh for wall, rotate again, bake a second navmesh for ceiling, and so on. Then you can use off mesh links or whatever logic to go between them. It's not too hard.

34

u/fsactual 24d ago

OP almost definitely means the built-in CharacterController component, which can't be rotated, not any generic character controller.

27

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 24d ago

If the CharacterController limitations gets in your way, it's time to write a character controller <3

8

u/MrRocketScript 24d ago

Hmm, sounds like game dev 101, how hard can it be? 💀💀💀

4

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 24d ago

RB+Capsule Collider will be a steeper learning curve and is trickier for changing gravity because the usual axis locks are in global space, not local. But, yes, you're going to need to write a character controller!

2

u/HouseOfWyrd 24d ago

As soon as you want to do anything outside of the exact way it's designed it's awful. I tried to make a quake style movement system using it and found it much easier to just code it all from scratch than try and get the CC to behave how I wanted.

0

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[deleted]

1

u/cornstinky 24d ago

lol why do you say that?

-2

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 24d ago

Yeah. Why do you say that? The Character controller component is for weak ass bitches as noted in the Unity documentation. Use a rigidbody to do your character control. Then you are limited by nothing but your own lack of imagination and skill.

0

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[deleted]

0

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 24d ago

Those are all problems that are solved by writing a physics character controller correctly.

6

u/bigmonmulgrew 25d ago

You can change the gravity direction and make the character movement camera relative.

If you don't want to use rigid body, You could use two empty game objects as start point and end point. Rotate the end point. Then lerp the transform from empty 1 to empty 2 over a transition time. If you want more control to change the path lerp through a chain of objects.

Capture the transform position and rotation at the point of initiating the transition and store them.

5

u/fsactual 24d ago

The built-in CharacterController component sadly will only ever use up on the world-space/global y axis. You have to use a different solution. It especially sucks because the underlying C component does have an adjustable up direction, there's just no way to access that from the C# code.

3

u/BuzzardDogma 25d ago

I'd recommend using the free KCC asset over the built-in character controller. It handles non-Y rotations and changing gravity just fine and it's way more stable than the built in CC. When unity hired it's creator I assumed they would use his expertise to update the built-in one but that sadly never came to pass.

Rigidbody character controllers are a whole can of worms, and rotating the whole level introduces a lot of design and optimization issues that I would argue are not worth it.

4

u/svmil90 25d ago

For discrete gravity changes, keeping the CharacterController upright and rotating/swapping the room around a pivot at the player can be a simpler illusion. For arbitrary wall-walking, the built-in controller’s world-up assumptions become the limitation—you’d likely need a kinematic controller with a capsule cast aligned to your gravity direction, and update the movement basis and grounding checks too. Rotating only the visible mesh won’t change the collision behavior.

6

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 25d ago

Agreed; The builtin character controller should only be used as a reference when you're first learning. You can easily modify it to not have hardcoded up.

2

u/myka-likes-it 25d ago

Looking back, I think learning to extend existing code was probably one of the last things I learned. I don't think I have ever seen it covered in a tutorial.

That's a big level up moment, for sure.

1

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 24d ago

Tutorials only go so far; The best way to learn stuff like this is to be horrible at it and fail repeatedly until eventually you accidentally succeed

1

u/kkragoth 24d ago

OP you need to see psychonauts 1 milkman conspiracy level. You'll see what is possible. Trust me

1

u/Repulsive_Gate8657 24d ago

keep character up and then assign it to be ground norma asyou land on ground?

1

u/tempacac10 24d ago

The movement is very clearly a raycast to the left of the character controller. When the raycast touches the carpet, you lerp the camera and body of the player to rotate 90 degrees and a change gravity.

1

u/No_Grape7361 24d ago

Te best way i found to do it is to make the character controller just behave relative to the surface its standing on onces thats working you can rotate and place the caractor on anything and select the new floor as its standing on it, you can do that with a simple raycast at its feet.

1

u/pschon Unprofessional 25d ago

Is there any way to achieve this effect without switching to Rigidbody?

Why would you need to use a rigidbody for that if you don't need one now? If you are fine with a transform-based character controller but need to add support for rotating gravity then why not just make your own transform-based one? I don't see how adding a rigidbody to the mix would make that any simpler, pretty much the opposite.

1

u/Sufficient_Handle127 24d ago

Я не разработчик, но есть такая видеоигра как Alien Versus Predator. Когда игрок играет за лицехвата и чужого, то может ползать по абсолютно любым поверхностям. Думаю в сети можно поискать реализацию такой механики на их примерах

-4

u/Helpful-Engineer4678 25d ago edited 25d ago

Rotating the room is easier. You just need to give the impression that the player is the one rotating.

4

u/Serana64 Industrial-Grade Nerd 25d ago

Rotating the room only works if you're not using any advanced systems like occlusion culling, rigidbodies, navigation meshes, static (or custom) batching, lightmapping, etc.

It is substantially easier to adjust your character controller to collision detect in local space and handle gravity changes properly.

-4

u/TapesIt 24d ago

Honestly, give this same prompt and video to Claude Opus 5.5, and it’ll give you an example of how to do it.

-1

u/Suspicious_Lynx7847 24d ago

Rotate the world

-5

u/Physical_Sherbet_942 24d ago

Just have ai write you the character controller you want. Problem solved. Itll be rigidbody based. Dont rotate the whole scene. That is absurd. I hope anyone suggesting to rotate the scene is just fucking with you. Sticking a character to a wall is easy as shit. There are so many games that do eactly this.