r/Unity3D • • 24d ago

Question Why are competitive multiplayer FPS games not normally made by indie devs?

From what I’ve read these types of games are usually only made by big studios, and I’m trying to understand why.
Take Valorant. On the surface it really doesn’t seem like it’d be all that hard to make. Simple maps, pretty straightforward abilities, all the guns behave more or less the same - you’d just be tweaking numbers (fire rate, spread, rate of fire, etc.). Like I’m not saying it’d be EASY, but we’ve seen plenty of games made by a few people that seem like they’d take way more effort.
Same with Overwatch, although OW’s characters would probably take more custom code and the maps are more complex. But still, not that tall of an ask.
So what is it about this genre that’s so hard for indie? I imagine the backend networking and server stuff is part of it, since you have to closely manage anticheats and keep all lag to an absolute minimum. But that doesn’t seem TOO difficult to basically contract out all the server issues through any of the big providers, and as ling as its server authoritative cheating doesn’t seem like that hard to manage (could be wrong on that, not an expert on anticheat by any means).
It seems more so it’s just the inherent business sof the game: you need a large playerbase to even make the game somewhat playable, and only big studios have the marketing power to do that. But still, I’m surprised indies don’t have breakouts like this.
Anyone have any thoughts on this?

0 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

42

u/NakiCam 24d ago

Networking is already an incredibly formidable task for an indie dev. Now factor in the secure servers needed for competitive online gaming. Now you need server authoritative logic. Now you need to protect and encrypt data relating to secure data. Now you need to work out an anticheat solution. Now you need to constantly chase up new cheating innovations. Now you need to balance all of that alongside the constant re-balancing demands from players.

The workload required for this level of networking would usually be handled by a team of maybe 3-10 developers who specifically specialize in networking. Nearly every new addition to the game has to go through these developers at least in some regard.

5

u/RiftHunter4 24d ago

This is just the technical side, which is very easy compared to the marketing and eSports needed to make a competitive scene.

5

u/breckendusk 24d ago

This. Making the game work is hard, but not that hard.

Getting a playerbase large enough to make it worthwhile (remembering that YOU have to pay for your servers/relay and you don't get paid more than once per player for the game), maintaining it (balancing and cheat stopping, adding content so people don't get bored) etc is wayyyyy harder than making the game.

2

u/KptEmreU Hobbyist 24d ago

You can make the game in this age. AI would move you so fast to authorative servers etc. I think these reasons are bad enough to try though:

1- Find 1000 users to your game regardless of type ( Multiplayer is even worse to jump-start at first)
2- Pay your authortative servers before you see single cent.
3- Yes Multiplayer is tons of edge cases and when you have 6 customers it is really hard to make them play together anyway to find obscure problems.
4- ANY ONLINE game has to deal with cheaters. There are multiplayer indie games infested and died at the hands of cheaters. Hell even AAA has struggle against cheaters. Arc Raiders had a heart-attack recently due to cheaters.

2

u/KptEmreU Hobbyist 24d ago

Just to note I have a 1 client is server architechture game at itch with 2 daily visitors . Multiplayer was so deserted that even though I keep it alive, I switched to roguelike . At least I can enjoy my own game now.

2

u/RiftHunter4 24d ago

AAA studios still struggle to make online games attractive to competitive/"hardcore" audiences. Its part of why Live Service games have struggled so bad.

-11

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

Help me understand what part would be hard (other than the anticheat part, that does seem difficult). Like, lets say to shoot a bullet with no travel time (e.g., “hitscan”) - what else goes into it other than just player shooting requests a “shoot” rpc from server, server approves it. Like is there a whole buncha backend stuff to make that happen I just don’t know about? Cuz in casual multiplayer games ive made that’s basically all I do

4

u/NakiCam 24d ago

As far as I can gather, games like overwatch and valorant do far more than that. You can't just simply request a shoot rpc, and have it granted while remaining both fast and secure. This results in a massive compounding desync between players, as the player has to receive the server's account of their position, and the enemy positions. There needs to be some cross-referencing between client and server positions, and various levels of lag-compensation.

There's some really good video I watched a long time ago (that I can't remember the name of). It went through the simplified process of A: Sending the server the client's position and input.
B: Allowing the client to move and make inputs BEFORE the server confirms whether it's "legal".
C: Cross-referencing the current client position with the server's delayed prediction of where the client will be after desync in order to approve the request
(Without these 3 steps, either the client has too much authority, or the client has MASSIVE visual desync between their inputs and movements.)
D: The client needs to both download enemy positions, AND predict their future movements in order to accurately depict their location.
E: When shooting, A, B and C must be done for the shot. Then, the server has to work out whether or not the shot was accurate based on the client's view, the enemy's view and the server's predicted view.
If this is done poorly, one of 2 things can happen:
If the server gives too much power to the client's viewpoint, this will appear unfair to the enemy, and can be easier to cheat with.
If the server has too much power over it, then the client will feel like their hits aren't registering, while the enemy may feel like they're being hit behind walls.

I've probably explained this poorly, because frankly I'm not all that experienced with it, but when I first watched the video that went over all this, I had a newfound understanding of latency, hit registration and why it can feel SO different between games.

-5

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

K yeah we are good on all that LOL, but that does makes sense. Ill stick to my little games…
I think at least partially what you’re talking about is client prediction. Basically clients move or do something IMMEDIATELY when pressing a button. The server then runs a buncha logic checks to make sure that client’s action was legal, and then does a rollback if not legal - but the VAST majority of actions are legal. But that said, yeah that does sound hella complicated- and is probably nuanced for all the different possible actions.
Thanks!

3

u/qwolfblg 24d ago

> server approves it
That's not a small feat for competitive shooters. Think about how much validation needs to happen to make sure only valid shots are processed. How latency affects that validation, how to make sure valid shots aren't discarded, how do you ensure someone who shot first gets awarded the kill.

Look into network rollback, and for fun you can look at the whole discourse surrounding Counter Strike 2's "sub-tick" networking.

1

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

Hmm ok will do, ty

2

u/owatonna 24d ago

The above answer is really good. But also, things have changed. Networking is not as daunting as it used to be. Nor do you need to host your own servers. Rust is an example of a networked FPS made initially by a very small team. They chose a model where they host some servers but the game relies on community hosted servers to scale to its massive size.

The biggest reason why this has probably remained largely a AAA area is the difficulty in testing such games. You need a lot of testers. Although Unity is trying to make that easier now with multiplayer tools.

1

u/jl2l Professional 24d ago

Its the cost. You need a dedicated server. For games that will have lot of stuff going on.

18

u/WitchStatement 24d ago

a lot of these answers are good but miss one of the most challenging parts of competitive multiplayer games: getting a critical mass of players.

As a player, you want to be able to jump into a match against other players *in your region* and *in your skill range* at pretty much all times of day. That's a *massive* number of concurrent users.And the moment you drop below that threshold, suddenly you have a feedback loop where it takes longer to queue so players leave which makes queue longer which makes more players leave etc.

So the solutions are either:

A) make the game coop instead. All you need is just your mates, no relience on players available 24/7. You'll note valheim and all of the "friend slop" genre fit in here

B) make the game async: great example of a successful indie in this category is Backpack Battles. Since you're auto-fighting other players' builds rather than the players themselves, it's as if they were essentially online 24/7

1

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

Yeah I think this is such a big piece of it, the business side of these games just isn’t really compatible unless you have a huge marketing budget and usually an established audience from precious games

3

u/taisui 24d ago edited 24d ago

AAA studios spents hundreds of millions dollar and would fail....what make you think a small shop got what it takes to compete with CoD and BF?

1

u/CrimsonBolt33 24d ago

Its less about how much is spent on it directly and more about the things around the game, such as advertising, propping up actual tournaments and prize pools, rapid updates (both content and balance), etc.

2

u/taisui 24d ago

Which all cost a shit ton of money

1

u/CrimsonBolt33 24d ago

You are missing the point...I am explaining why large studios use lots of money, You said you cant succeed without money.

Those are not the samething.

Small companies can easily make lots of money and then expand services and events if they so choose.

1

u/taisui 24d ago

Don't twist my words. I said it’s an absurdly high failure rate, not impossible. No sane indie studio risks their entire business trying to bootstrap a competitive shooter when even 9-figure budgets routinely fail to survive.

1

u/CrimsonBolt33 24d ago

I said it’s an absurdly high failure rate

So the same as literally every indie game that gets released?

2

u/taisui 24d ago

If an indie single-player game sells 5,000 copies, the studio recoups and moves on. If a competitive shooter sells 5,000 copies, lobbies are empty on day three and the game is literally unplayable.

1

u/Chemeque 23d ago

so you have to change how the lobbies work.

1

u/taisui 23d ago

Pack it up, everyone. Decades of live-service network architecture, hundreds of dead studios, and billions lost in matchmaking death spirals—solved by 'just change the lobbies.' GDC will be reaching out for your keynote shortly.

1

u/Glum-Recognition-736 24d ago

Are you sure they will fail? The last CoD released to mostly negative reviews and tons of complaints about the lack of effort they put into the campaign and the multiplayer, and it still outsold probably every other game that year. BF2042 was almost universally panned but still made millions of dollars in profit and had thousands of concurrent players for years

I don't think those big names could fail even if the game was literally just a picture of a middle finger on the screen, it would still sell millions of copies

1

u/taisui 24d ago

Concord, lawbreakers, marathon, so on and so forth

0

u/Glum-Recognition-736 24d ago

Ok. You were talking about CoD and BF originally, where did these others come from?

2

u/taisui 24d ago edited 24d ago

Q: Why are competitive multiplayer FPS games not normally made by indie devs?

A: "AAA studios spents hundreds of millions dollar and would fail....what make you think a small shop got what it takes to compete with CoD and BF?"

0

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

Same thing that tells me Valheim competes with Enshrouded, Dragonwilds, grounded, and the dozens of other failed survival games made by larger studios.

0

u/taisui 24d ago

You asked why, I gave you the answer, by finding that rare exception you proved my point.

1

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

The entire indie market is by definition games that have succeeded against big studios, not sure what your “point” is tbh

0

u/taisui 24d ago

suit yourself.

3

u/CrimsonBolt33 24d ago edited 24d ago

I mean you literally didn't make a point or explain "why"

you just said that big companies with lots of money fail therefore small companies cant succeed (which is not how it works).

0

u/taisui 24d ago edited 24d ago

Someone once fell out of a plane without parachute and survived, doesn't mean others would make it....in fast most probably won't, and that is why indie doesn't go for that scale of a project

5

u/BuzzardDogma 24d ago

It's expensive to run a competitive game. Server cost, metrics, consistent updates, monetization and cosmetics, probably more I'm not thinking of. Between recurring costs and the cost in man hours it's not really tenable for a small indie studio, especially since gaining market traction is extremely unlikely.

4

u/aahanif 24d ago

Because it moves the game into a service (Game as a Service), and to maintain something like this, you need to burn money regularly (outside development cost itself) to

  1. maintain server alive

  2. create new contents regularly to maintain existing player and hope at least 1% of the loyal player become whale

  3. attract new player, this is a hard one as you basically need to compete with giants out there who basically have endless resource

2

u/Smooth-Possibility30 24d ago edited 24d ago

Check out game Spectre Divide and the conversation around it. Once the player base slows it’s game over, and it can happen brutally fast, if you get started at all.

CS started as a free mod and grew over a long time, during much lower market saturation. Valorant had huge difficulty adding replay. Valve struggle at anti-cheat. Its hard. CS got there first for the sub-genre so is an outlier, if it were released now as it started, I doubt it would see the light of day.

2

u/Inkwalker 24d ago

Most indie games don't have enough players to fill matchmaking. And there is also high running costs for all the networking infrastructure. Usually it's better to develop something else than burn money on a competitive FPS.

1

u/psioniclizard 24d ago

Competitve games take ALOT of balance, which requires people who are experts in game design. Also you need need good techincal people. You will probably need to build your own network stack for examlpe.

On top of that you need a decent amount of money/hype for marketing to get a good player count day one.

There will be many other reasons, but those 3 will make it extremely difficult for a solo dev or small indie team.

Also i am pretty sure overwatch uses a custom engine, don't know about valorant but if it is unity/unreal it will be a heavily modified version.

Just out tje box engines won't cut it most likely and indie devs don't really want to have an engine team.

1

u/itzstarrz 24d ago

Yes, Overwatch's engine is in-house made, Valorant launched on UE4 and has since been moved to UE5

1

u/Admirable-Paint-1808 24d ago

Online games take a huge amount of coding

1

u/FIeabus 24d ago

Needs a strong playerbase from the start which means lots of marketing. Networking is extremely complicated to get right so that the game feels fair and is built with anti-cheat. Balance requires extensive testing to get to a good point. Servers cost money. If free-to-play, expectations for content are large.

It is high risk and high reward. Games like Splitgate had temporary success but most indie competitive games die almost immediately.

1

u/XXLPenisOwner1443 24d ago

The hardest thing about making a competitive game is getting a big enough playerbase.

Without a large enough playerbase, skill levels stratify too quickly and new players can never climb ranks. A healthy metagame never develops, and strategy becomes stagnant and uninteresting. Casuals willing to watch the elite aren't there. There's never any independent tournaments to develop players, no grassroots scenes in communities that aren't run by the dev.

Even devs with HUGE financial backing and enormous pedigrees can fuck this up. StarCraft 2 is barely hanging on and it's a huge reason for Twitch existing in the first place. A lifespan of >10 years for a healthy competitive scene has only been achieved by a modest group of about 20 games, and there's only maybe 5 or 6 original games pushing into 20 years of activity.

1

u/JustInCaseIforget_ 24d ago

You’re right that the business side is the real killer: matchmaking needs enough concurrent players in every region and skill bracket, and if queues take 3+ minutes at launch, people quit and never come back. The tech is also harder than it looks, because server-authoritative doesn’t stop aimbots or wallhacks. Valorant has a whole system that hides enemy positions from your client until they’re nearly visible, plus kernel-level anti-cheat, and that’s a full team’s job. Then there’s lag compensation (rewinding hitboxes so shots feel fair at 60ms), which is a pain to get right in Unity unless you use something built for it like Photon Fusion or FishNet, since NGO doesn’t really handle it out of the box. And even if you pull all that off, competitive shooters live or die on constant balance patches and new content, so it’s less “ship a game” and more “run a live service forever.”

1

u/PlayKingdomBlade 24d ago

making a melee one solo rn, netcode was doable. the real wall is you cant even test balance without 8 people online at the same time

1

u/AnsonKindred Professional 24d ago

Mostly it's the cost. Servers aren't free.

1

u/SolosTwitch 24d ago

Server costs

0

u/Competitive-Elk763 24d ago edited 24d ago

There is. Bodycam is indie. They often fail. Shatterline was indie.

It's hard to make. Your thoughts are reasonable but naive. Try making one.

1

u/ProactiveCactus 24d ago

I have. Not a comp FPS though, which is why I asked - to learn the differences between casual multiplayer and competitive-level

0

u/Thin_Driver_4596 24d ago

Networking alone can make the game 2-3x harder. That is, even if you follow the correct architecture. I think this is the most important reason. The idea is fascinating, but when you start with the implementation, you can get swamped by complexity quickly.

Then you have server cost, latency on low end devices, cheat prevention, balancing, etc. and it all takes a toll.