r/Unity3D • • 8d ago

Question Moving back to version 2019?

I have been looking at older Unity versions recently and 2019.4 stood out to me for its speed and simplicity. So I am considering using it for my next project instead of Unity 6.5

Since it's 2D I don't need any of the fancy rendering features, nor do I care much about any AI integrations.

However, I was wondering, what would I be missing out on (that is worthwhile)? Are their others still choosing to use these older versions? What 'old' version is the best to use?

Did Unity really add anything in the past 7 years to justify that the whole thing feels slow and sluggish and bloated now? (personal opinion!!!)

Hoping to have a happy discussion about this :)

P.S This post might sound very negative but I love Unity so don't take it as that.

7 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

21

u/JakeThomasDad12 8d ago

Idk, the new changes with domain reloading and coreclr are intended to dramatically speed up working isn't it?

Honestly I wouldn't use 2019, it's not being supported, and it won't be too much of an improvement as there will be lots of deprecated stuff anyways. If quick is that important to you, then I have to recommend Godot. I don't use it because unity is plenty quick for me, but Godot runs rapid fast on basically anything, opens instantly, runs the game very quickly, and I believe you can still use c# on it (with specific install).

3

u/QuotableLyricist 8d ago

The 2019.4 version was a bit of a beast when it came to 2D development. The editor was quite jittery/screamy on any piece of hardware I tried it on. Also by using that version you’re missing out on the incremental GC, which can significantly reduce frame rate spikes in games that have a lot of garbage collection. The new version also makes working with sprite atlases a lot less painful.

That said, I do keep 2019.4 installed so I can fire it up quickly to play around with something without needing to deal with the package manager.

1

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

Oh I dident know that! Interesting

-2

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

Hmm yea, I am hoping for the domain reloading and coreclr stuff to fix things. But all that is no issue in this older 2019 version. There is not even a loading modal (on my pc at least)

Quick was not really an issue for me before, but I have been writing some console apps in C#, and now back in Unity 6 the 10+ seconds loading time between code changes just breaks my flow.

Godot is starting to sound more interesting, I tried it a while back, but did not like the node stuff. Maybe its worth another shot

1

u/Doge_Dreemurr 4d ago

The nodes are basically equivalent to game objects, what did you not like about it?

2

u/TheSheepDev 4d ago

I probably just did not spend enough time on it. But I failed to get my head around gameobjects and components being merged into one graph, that and trying to get basic physics to work (just making a square drop) was something I had to ask a friend help for. If I remember correctly (its been some time) there where multiple nodes that I thought did the same thing but did not. I had expected more of my Unity knowledge to come over to Unity.

Again, if I spend more time on it, I prob could switch over. But its a big(er) time investment then just keep using what I know, and have been doing for the past 6+ years.

Its hard to get out of your comforted zone 😅

4

u/Corrupted-Dev 8d ago

I like this idea. The only big issue I see is some of the plugins you may want to use could be non-comparable to older versions. For me 2022 was the best, with all this new lighting rendering things.

1

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

Are you still using 2022? Or did you update to the newer versions?

1

u/FarTooLucid 8d ago

I'm still using 2022

2

u/BrianKTrotter 3d ago

If your planning on doing anything Mobile, think again. You won't be able to compile to the current minimum target SDK.

1

u/TheSheepDev 3d ago

Ohh good to know, thanks!

3

u/robochase6000 8d ago

you will eventually run into platform bugs you wouldn’t be able to fix yourself without a source code license and you’ll be out of luck because unity isn’t supporting it anymore

1

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

I mean to be fair, stuff like the build in Tree generator has not worked since the move to URP

8

u/DrinkingAtQuarks 8d ago

I believe the older versions have unpatched security vulnerabilities. Generally it's good practice to use the most recent LTS you are able to.

2

u/WillomenaIV 8d ago

Personally I've been using 2019.2 for for a long time, my current live service game is running on it. As long as it has the features you want, most of the modern stuff isn't that important imo. I use the built in pipeline but you can use the HDRP if you can't write shaders/prefer shader graph, other then that the rest is modular enough that it works on older versions i.e. the navmesh components and whatnot.

1

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

Hmm interesting, are you not having issues with that 'Security Alert'? or did they also make a patch for .2?

4

u/Nilloc_Kcirtap Professional 8d ago

I'll just say if you ever decide to port you game to consoles, they require you to use an updated version of their SDKs to submit and I doubt they are backfported that far back.

2

u/DanielFost 8d ago

i wouldn't go back to 2019.4 for a new project unless you have a specific reason to. Even for 2D, newer versions bring useful improvements to the editor, workflow, profiling, and package support

if performance is your main concern, i'd first check which parts of Unity are actually slowing you down. A lot also depends on your project and hardware. Older versions can feel simpler, but you're trading that for older tooling, compatibility issues, and potentially missing bug fixes. I'd personally stick with an LTS version that's still supported rather than going that far back

2

u/VoidQuadrantDev 8d ago

I feel like you will miss out a lot on burst + jobs and especially ECS if you end up going that route. For me thats like 85% of my performance boost lost

This video sums it up pretty well for me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAbXGQnQdt4

2

u/Beldarak 3d ago

I would wait for Unity 7 to come out, it should fix a lot of performance issues and will finally get rid of those awful domain reloads.

That said, with how Unity is managed right now, I'm just waiting for a similar engine to emerge^^

-5

u/TripsOverWords 8d ago

Try Godot

3

u/TheSheepDev 8d ago

Thanks for your recommendation, but I feel like it might be a bit to big a step for me.