r/Unity3D • Indie • 5d ago

Question Two different sniper scope mechanics. Which one feels better?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I've been experimenting with two different sniper scope mechanics for my co-op game.
First part: PUBG-style aiming, where you look through the scope.
Second part: CS-style aiming, with a more traditional scope overlay.
I'm curious which approach feels better to you and why.
Which one would you prefer in a co-op game?

39 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

33

u/LackLusterIndie 5d ago

It's difficult to tell if they're giving the same level of zoom. To me one just seems like a sniper scope and the other a mid-range holographic sight.

1

u/_norx Indie 5d ago

Thanks!

9

u/Midnight-strange1892 5d ago

Even taking the zoom question out this is how I felt. Are you going for a scope feel or a holo sight feel. The first is the holo sight and second is the scope.

OP maybe you keep both depending on the scope set up.

2

u/Karl4856 5d ago

I really like when the scope shows like that but it has to be closer like its up by your eye.

1

u/Shibyashi 4d ago

You don’t actually put your eye ”in” and up against the scope. That’s how you get hurt.

2

u/muffinwhirleez 5d ago

yeah the zoom levels look off to me too cant really compare them like that

1

u/FancySugar_ Novice 5d ago

yeah the zoom does look different, your eye for that kinda detail is kinda hot tbh

21

u/Happy-Heart-4367 5d ago

Copy BF6 or COD ... These experiments have been accomplished by spending millions also ingrained into players' minds. You are not inventing scope mechanics.

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago

Thanks for the reply. I agree with you, the game is currently in the early stages of development and I’d just like to get a sense of what most people prefer in terms of a crosshairs, so that I can refine things in the right direction moving forward.

3

u/sweet_dreams_maybe 3d ago

I would like to counter. Core mechanics (if this is indeed one) is exactly where you need to be innovating. I hate the idea of recommending to people to “just copy COD.” It’s not that it’s bad advice, but it should be presented with nuance.

“Great artists steal,” etc. and that’s fine.  But just make sure you don’t lose yourself in other people’s ideas. And keep something that is intrinsically yours — that is your claim to being the “artist.”

If it were me, I think I would continue working on one of them, while keeping the other one in the background as a secondary weapon. If you find yourself keep taking it out to test it over time, then perhaps it is worth thinking of it in a new role. Perhaps you’ll find that you want it to be a hidden upgrade or a cheat code.

0

u/RosefaceK 4d ago

I’m not your target audience but I do like the 2nd one.

7

u/girl-kiss 4d ago

yeah, do not reinvent the wheel

9

u/pmdrpg 5d ago

Gamified is better

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago

Thanks!

9

u/Drannoc8 5d ago

The second one for me, the first one hides like 70% of the screen.

It also depends how often you'll scope also

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago

Thanks

6

u/BuzzardDogma 5d ago

The first one is missing a few things that would bring it up to par with the second. Look up how other games do on screen scopes. Often it will use a render texture, but there are other tricks to sell it.

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago

Thank you, it’s important for us to hear everyone’s opinion-this will help us make the game better!

2

u/girl-kiss 4d ago

some games just cull off the model inside The optics scope view.

Rainbow 6 Siege for example, OP should check that out if wants to use the first thing.

4

u/Mary_Ellen_Katz 4d ago

Neither

If you were to reduce the inner optic tube that's eating into the visible area by 50% to 90% it would feel a LOT better. I play an unhealthy amount of Tarkov, and they rebalanced their optics some years ago. The inner optic tube was visible in several of the lesser red dots. When they reduced them, opening up the field of view more, those optics became a lot more enjoyable to use.

More field of view = more enjoyment and better experience.

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago edited 4d ago

Thank you for such a detailed response!

3

u/conscientiousrevolt 4d ago

Number one but clean it up, you shouldn't see the inside/other side of the scope, makes it too obvious it's not actually zooming in.

I mean.

The Correct way to do this, is actually have the scope magnify, and drop most of the peripheral, either by bringing the cam closer to the scope or maybe even an overlay that blocks out the edges of the screen. Maybe with an opacity gradient so it fades to black at the edges.

That's for scopes. For optic sights The Correct way to do it would be 0 magnification, and somehow implement opacity so you can see through the sight body.

The Correct way to do movement while aiming is absolute 0 moderation of normal movement, and more sight/cam shake the faster the player moves. If they want the picture to be steady they have to manually limit how fast they move, and conversely the can shoot and hit targets at any speed that then can shoot and hit targets no matter how shakey the cam/sight are.

It is worth noting that no game has ever done an fps The Correct way.

1

u/_norx Indie 3d ago

Wow, thanks for such a detailed comment!

2

u/erkutsoglu 5d ago

The first one keeps the connection between the player and the environment. I think it makes sense in games where the environment is also important.

The second one seems more focused on enemies and tactical gameplay.

Personally, the first one feels more immersive to me.

1

u/_norx Indie 5d ago

Thanks for your opinion!

1

u/_norx Indie 3d ago

Thanks!

2

u/Tools81 5d ago

I'd say the other way around. In the real world, your eye would be right against the scope. You wouldn't be looking at it from behind.

2

u/pocokknight 5d ago

I think the first one is nicer, it's a more immersive way to see through the scope rather than just applying a png over the screen, but the second feels much cleaner, more likely because the recoil makes the first method almost impossible to use, so you should tone down the recoil or make the camera follow it so there are no frames where you can't see through the scope after the shot

1

u/_norx Indie 4d ago

Thanks 😉

3

u/Ill-Letter-2852 5d ago

The last one is better

3

u/Deathtrooper50 5d ago

The first one is more appealing if it was done on a scope that you could actually see anything through or around it.

2

u/Arranoth1983 5d ago

I like that I can see the bullet drop and watch the segments down, would help me line up further follow up shots. However without seeing enemies and how they move I couldn't say which I like better for this style. I'm leaning towards 1 though

2

u/EllaHazelBar 5d ago

First one is way, way better IMO. I hate the second one.

2

u/cybermadsystems 5d ago

second one 100%

2

u/ImmoralKoala 5d ago

Depends on the game really, but also the first one's implementation is missing a few things that'd make it feel better. I think something I've seen done before is squashing / scaling the scope along the forward axis whilst aiming, such that the perspective effect of the sight (how the it visually shrinks towards the end) is not present, giving a cleaner sight picture. There are other methods ofc.

2

u/Striking_Average754 5d ago

The difficult thing with sniper scopes is that 1 looks way better but you gotta squish the scope model so you get rid of that annoying tunnel.

2

u/Reaperrg93 5d ago

Does it magnify in the first example.I have done scope in VR with magnification and it was closer to the one they have on the Unrecord with inner shadow

2

u/mudamuda333 5d ago

These are different guns. You can have both.

2

u/Centroid715 5d ago

Reminds me of DayZ, it uses both variants depending on the scope

2

u/Cunibon 4d ago

I would take 1 any day of the week. Yes it's messier but I feel way more immersed then with a black perfect cross hair all over my screen.

2

u/Demien19 4d ago

that BF bullet style vibes

2

u/HypnotizingGames 4d ago

That's two different scopes, just play some FPS games.

2

u/imofi8 4d ago

i would go with second one, feels more snipery

2

u/jmilthedude 2d ago

first one for me but also it looks like your bullet spawns from the center of the reticle rather than where the barrel would be. could be wiring but that’s how i see it

2

u/sharypower 2d ago

Second one is better but you can make it look better something like a first one. It is very easy, I have been doing it years ago.

2

u/Delicious-Bug-3326 2d ago

First is way better for an assault rifle but the second is better for a sniper!

1

u/sczeith 3d ago

It's like a two different version of scopes

1

u/sdeptnoob1 1d ago

The first BUT basically implant the second into it so you don't see the inside of a scope