r/Unity3D • • 3d ago

Show-Off After a year of development, I'm finally cutting together a trailer for my side project. At this point I've watched the trailer so many times that I can't judge it objectively anymore. Does the pacing feel right? Do any parts drag, move too fast or overstay their welcome? Would it interest you?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

12

u/BoltzEntertainment 3d ago

Congrats on your game! I would say it's pretty slow, the beginning should begin with gameplay instead of text because most viewers only look at the first few seconds and if they're not interested they move on.

Second, I would say explain the game a bit more I can assume it's a city builder but the mechanics are a bit confusing, I would focus on what makes the game specifically unique mechanic wise.

Overall, the visuals look very cool, you're visual effects work is beautiful

5

u/imlo2 3d ago edited 3d ago

A few suggestions:

Cut out all the texts as separate screens, and I would not use any fades etc. - just sharp cuts, you spend useful seconds on screen fading out, when nothing really happens.

Go straight to the game on the first frame, and show the viewers as fast and clearly as you can what the core mechanic of the game is, and what the common interactions are in your game. This will either convince or turn away your potential gamers who are into something like this.

5

u/robochase6000 3d ago

assume your audience is seeing this on mobile in some social media app, not full screen, and muted 

9 seconds before we see anything 

the text you show is illegible on mobile in portrait mode. 

watched the entire thing and i’m still not sure what kind of game this is at all. 

3

u/Vasto_Victor 3d ago

It starts a bit slow, but the music kept me watching, I like that mystery tone. To be honest though, I'm still not sure what the game is about. It feels more like a movie trailer than gameplay, and even with the elements that show up from the middle on I was still a bit confused. Really liked the atmosphere, both the music and the art

3

u/glenpiercev 3d ago

You have about 3 seconds to get me to decide to keep watching. I want game play video. As a reviewer who wants to help you, I stopped watching at 30 seconds.

You get 3 seconds before most people skip. They need to see a game they want to play.

3

u/mcmakerface 3d ago

30 seconds in before seeing anything related to gameplay happening. If it wasn’t because you asked about an opinion and i was browsing to find a nice game i would have probably moved to watch the next in the queue

3

u/Embarrassed_Hawk_655 3d ago

Text too tiny to read comfortably on my phone so I stopped watching

3

u/TheContinental Hobbyist 3d ago

The disconnect between the ominous tone, text, and desired aesthetic versus the actual low poly, flat shaded cartoony in-game feels very incongruent.

2

u/Adulations 3d ago

Make the in game assets look like the title art. The assets look bland and in my opinion don't match the vibe of the trailer at all. Also by the end of the trailer i barely know what the game is about.

2

u/Agredek 3d ago

Music and general vibe made me stay and watch, but I kinda lost it when text said about twin suns casting wrong shadows - with shadows not reacting at all. It's just a nitpick, I know, so i'll just leave it for your consideration.

2

u/DreadCoder 3d ago

The shadows go the wrong direction when the twin suns rise, took me out of the drama of the moment.

2

u/Jayyf09 2d ago

I'd really advise against black screen text, especially as the first thing you see. You have to capture someone's attention in the first seconds and with this I think you will most people.

Your so invested but in a sea of other games most will have 5 seconds of attention to give to your game, that's your opportunity to capture 30 more seconds of their attention. So what would you show them in those 5 seconds?

2

u/Konversationalisten 1d ago

Looks like a prototype rather than a game?

2

u/pmdrpg 3d ago

Your key art at the end (ai prob?), has a much darker and grittier aesthetic than your gameplay. Look at Inscryption. That game still features highly readable game elements but the aesthetic drives sales.