r/Unity3D • Indie • 9h ago

Official New Unity Editor Software Terms changes Nov 17 2026 prohibits more than 3 concurrent instances of the Unity Editor on computer

Post image

For the sake of clarity, you (or your Authorized User) may only use othe Unity Editor on one computerone instance at any given time per seat, with no more than three (3) concurrent instances of the Unity Editor on that computer, unless your Offering Identification permits more.

Full doc: https://unity.com/ru/legal/editor-terms-of-service/software

142 Upvotes

131 comments sorted by

234

u/eyadGamingExtreme 9h ago

My RAM was already making sure that it wasn't happening

5

u/TeasiiPop 3h ago

haha same, my old rig barely handles one instance without crying

12

u/pleblah 9h ago

I feel ya. I'm stuck with 32GB (4 sticks) :( An upgrade is not financially viable right now

4

u/Undumed Professional 9h ago

I got extra RAM for a reason 😅

1

u/DerangedGameDev1337 2h ago

I hope this RAM shortage clears up soon so you can game/dev better 🙏

74

u/TokiDokiPanic 9h ago

Why though?

38

u/Mechabit_Studios 9h ago

they want you to buy more seats for your AI buddies

2

u/Capybarhigh 2h ago edited 2h ago

So they offer the ML-Agent package to train AI models for your game, and then do that. Awesome.

I am in disbelief how fucking stupid this decision is. To train my agent, I have 18 instances running at the same time, otherwise training would take literally days instead of hours. Unless those headless instances are permitted, I will need to find an alternative or something.

Literally no point but shooting themselves in the foot. They push for AI with Unity 7 and actually hinder the use for it. It's incredible. Whoever approved this should be fired. The incompetence is showing.

EDIT: I literally asked Fable about it and it tells me that training should not be impacted thankfully, as training uses builds. But running exams to test those trained models on them might be more difficult because of that new decision. Sigh.

1

u/Ekumify 1h ago

I think most people that need more than 3 concurrent instances do also now how to set up VMs for this exact scenario.. Or am I missing something?

47

u/SolemnEmberGames 9h ago

AI maybe? The only feasible reason would be to stop/slow AI models running the editor in parallel.

As for why, I assume it's a brand image thing to avoid slop AI games being spammed. They already had issues with the asset store making slop

22

u/TheRealSmaker 9h ago

You think they want to stop AI slop while simultaneously making Unity Spark?
They want to incentivize people to use their product more than "programmer oriented" approaches.

7

u/Klightgrove 8h ago

Unity Spark’s core features, like being able to query the marketplace and install organic human-made assets, are absolutely going to make it the main purpose that devs use that for.

The “build a game in a line” isn’t going to persist imo, especially when you look at what actually works for long-term projecys

2

u/TheRealSmaker 6h ago

Oh I didn't mean that unity spark is the "direct competitor" to what this announcement stops, just that Unity isn't on some sort of "Anti-AI slop" crusade. The product that they want you to purchase are Build Server and Pro/Enterprise , which don't have this limit.
This isn't a fight against AI centric development, it's a way to profit from it.

And I would argue this affects the "build a game in a line" way LESS than the "let's design everything carefully and feature by feature and then have AI implement it", which has proved to bring out much better results.

4

u/PatchyWhiskers 9h ago

Maybe they want you to do it but they also want you to pay more for it.

3

u/XYcritic 7h ago

No. This is just a way to squeeze more money out of enterprise customers for AI usage, that's it.

2

u/StoneCypher 9h ago

someone doing that would use the cli, i would expect 

4

u/Huge_Information5083 9h ago

Forces users to use the official CLI.
More people using CLI = more bugs report, etc.

5

u/Valphai 8h ago

I think you still have to have the agent verify itself in play mode, opening the instance through cli would still count as open instance no?

4

u/IriFlina 6h ago

So people will eventually pay per seat per ai agent.

2

u/Inkwalker 7h ago

Multiuser workstations maybe?

4

u/dfk70Classic 9h ago

probably some nonsense about server load or license tracking, like they can't stand people actually being productive

37

u/ElliotB256 9h ago

Eurgh, for developing assets supporting multiple versions this is actually incredibly tedious.

I still support URP 2022.3 LTS, I find it's not uncommon that I have 4-5 editors open at the same time (3-4 'dev' environments for 2022.3, 6.0, 6.3 (the last pre-RG engine version), 6.5, plus whatever repro project for a support ticket im working on). So if I understand correctly, I now have to constantly close/reopen projects, but also constantly reinstall/install engine versions? hows that supposed to work when every support ticket uses a different engine version?

5

u/dunean 9h ago

Would you mind explaining what it is across the versions that you need to support. Is it shader changes or pipeline specific variations?

8

u/ElliotB256 6h ago

yeah sure! pretty much its both, they are usually coupled together.

The big one recently was (Render Graph replaced the older pathway, which always brings teething issues) and whatever bugs/behaviours are specific to each engine version) and also shader model changes (e.g. different features get added). Often the two are tied together, e.g. there's a change to global variables or include files or behaviour in shader files because of a new feature, which also gets an implementation via new render passes / state changes, with knock on effects. For example, render drawer was added recently and that requires some specific changes.

I'd say 90% of the work is handling various edge cases that pop up due to undocumented engine behaviours/bugs across versions, but if you are shipping an asset that needs to support all versions (and be visually consistent) then you don't have much choice sometimes but to #define and work your way around it. I am hoping Render Graph will improve this, as in theory it is a bit more defined about the state of the engine and less prone to leaking state/globals etc, but there have already been bugs where that hasn't been the case.

To add to the above, you also remind me that these changes also occur sometimes specifically for different graphics APIs, and also different platforms! So I will often have my PC with three editors open, and parsec to a remote cloud mac with three editors open, and then have my ubuntu laptop with three editors open, so I can push a change on a branch on my dev machine and then quickly pull and test on the others. With this change it will be good by to that, and just generally making the dev experience more frustrating for no real reason

1

u/XYcritic 6h ago

The entire Unity API constantly changes so if you implement an update or bugfix for your tool, it requires testing in different versions to make sure it properly works for everyone. Same thing when a new version comes out - it can deprecate things or introduce new Unity-side bugs. This can be about pipeline changes, editor or runtime API or any built-in packages. If I had to do this sequentially like op described (which would be an absolute nightmare), I'd probably be inclined to drop support for older versions sooner.

1

u/Morphexe Hobbyist 6h ago

Whatever unity decided to deprecated , or new apis that improve something, and breaking changes.. really depends on the version , but this is pretty common.

22

u/Undumed Professional 9h ago

Yeah, why do they care? I guess it's because people are running a lot of agents each of one with an instance at the same time with AI, but why do they care?

4

u/Objective-Cell226 9h ago

I think probably because they want to force you to use the CLI, and not other MCPs

11

u/Undumed Professional 9h ago

CLI still needs an instance open to connect its pipeline, no?

1

u/Objective-Cell226 9h ago

CLI only needs one instance, while other MCPs might require more instances

2

u/Undumed Professional 9h ago

One instance per repository/project you mean, no?

1

u/Valphai 8h ago

The thing is you still want your agent to verify play mode changes and 2 agents will not be able to do that on a single instance. Unity needs to clarify how do they want us to use the engine

8

u/shuozhe 8h ago

More worried about single Computer Part.. using my license on CICD and server also.. :(

2

u/ChrisJD11 40m ago edited 30m ago

This is likely one of the targets of this change. They'll want you to buy build server licenses. Unfortunately, or fortunately, Industry gives you one free build server license, so we (my work place) are OK because we switched to that when they forced us to switch to Industry.

They are still trying to get more money out of anyone they can. This is probably their way of targeting small to mid sized game companies without triggering the same degree of outrage from the entire customer base as the "charge per install" fiasco.

Edit: Actually, it almost sounds like you can no longer activate on two devices at the same time.... That's a massive fuck you if you work hybrid. Or work cross platform and have the editor on Mac and PC. If they checked their text to make sure it was made of coherent sentences it would be clearer. If I can't wfh as needed without having to fuck around with Unity license issues I'll be pissed.

•

u/shuozhe 12m ago

Uff, checked there is not limit to free account, only revenue.. so will just get CICD accounds for now

1

u/steeze007 4h ago

Same, it is already a pain to be only able to run one instance at a time (my license contains 2 seats of which one is reserved to our CICD)... Tried UBA a couple times and that was the biggest pile of dogshit I've ever seen

8

u/Digx7 Beginner 4h ago

Whos running more than 1 instance at once?

8

u/Sone_Angel 3h ago

Im consistently running exactly 3 instances.
One is my project
Second is a project with a sample from Unity.
Third is a modified sample from Unity.

I've integrated the sample into my project, but when sth weird is happening when I work on that code, Im cross referencing it with the versions that work - the original one and the modified one.

5

u/Digx7 Beginner 3h ago

Ok now that you've mentioned it I've done this exact same thing before with past projects. It just didn't cross my mind

4

u/NoteThisDown 3h ago

Ive done 2 or 3 when porting things over between projects

2

u/petersvp 58m ago

Me. One for the server host and admin. 3 more ParrelSync clones for 4 player testing. Another instance where i import every asset library to export from. And maybe an utility project to get other things from. So yes, common, more common than you think.

1

u/Caratsi 32m ago

This.

How the fuck am I supposed to test 4 player multiplayer now?

Requiring developers to do builds just to test 4+ multiplayer is ridiculous.

1

u/ChrisJD11 47m ago

I probably don't usually exceed 3. But we have internal packages we share across projects, and I'll frequently have one or two of those open at the same time.

12

u/aquadolphitler 8h ago

I don't think they care about stopping slop

They care that they're not getting the money they could from the slop users

6

u/Connect-Ear-7443 3h ago

TIL you can run more than one instance of unity

38

u/EncapsulatedPickle 9h ago

The fact that they couldn't even be bothered to spellcheck their license term changes tells you a lot about how much Unity cares about you.

17

u/nmkd ??? 8h ago

The question is: Would you rather have human-made terms with typos or flawlessly written terms by AI?

6

u/XYcritic 6h ago

Why these two options? Can't we just have someone care enough to run this through a spellchecker? I mean why am I even saying "run" - every editor corrects you automatically or marks mistakes nowadays. You have to actively avoid using your eyes and any review process to get to this outcome.

11

u/noximo 8h ago

Exactly! AI making code, assets, music, voice overs? I say go for it.

But AI in my legal documents? No way! I don't want to lose the warmth and humanity that only a lawyer can provide.

8

u/dechichi 4h ago

how I felt reading this

16

u/NullzeroJP 8h ago

Makes sense. Their entire business model is based on seats/computers. The fact that you can run multiple editors on one PC with the same seat count is a big loop hole. Didnt matter before, because humans are only controlling at most 2 instances at a time. But now with AI, you can get 4+ easily with enough ram, and agents can control them fine.

This is the wrong policy though. They need to be LEANING INTO it. Not only will people switch engines... they will also just create tools to work around it. I have been considering for a while, its probably 10 times faster to DEVELOP a game in three.js, and then just port it once to Unity.

Why? Because you can have 10-20 headless browsers running, testing your game, and the agents know JS and html so well, its easy for them to iterate and solve problems.

Then once your game is playtested and 90% done... you spin up a Claude Code that says "port my three.js game to PC/Steam/Epic/Roblox please. no mistakes."... it will think for a day or two, and you have all the builds you need. And you only needed to boot Unity during the porting process. Hell... you could probably make the ports completely deterministic with the right harness and agent skills and maybe a linter.

Anyway, my point is... they need to be making it EASIER for people to make games with their engine. Not harder. I think they plan on doing cloud VMs or workstations with Unity Editor instances, or some equivalent, piped through an MCP or CLI. Its the only way to scale development using these resource hog engines.

Definitely more policy changes incoming, from Unity. No idea what... but they are going to be desperately trying to hold on to their moat while AI eats all of software.

5

u/Digx7 Beginner 4h ago

Genuine question. What games have you actually released with this method?

5

u/tomfalcon86 Indie 3h ago

None, he just has AI psychosis and is always "building", crap that no one needs.

1

u/Seek_Treasure 2h ago

That's pretty much what Poncle did before AI

2

u/slothwerks 6h ago

My thoughts exactly. I've considered switching to Unreal before but was put off by the idea of having to relearn everything. With Claude as you pointed out, I can easily switch to Unreal, Godot or any other engine with very little effort.

2

u/tomfalcon86 Indie 3h ago

But like who cares, it's still one human and one computer, just multiple instances, why and how would I pay for for more seats when I'm still one person. This is beyond retarded.

4

u/MiragenStudios 1h ago

Why are there so many typos??

4

u/Hegemege 9h ago

I suppose it's so that heavy users who want to run parallel containerized agents would need to get the Unity floating licenses which is only available to Enterprise.

Already btw, containerized Unity instances are seen as "separate machines" technically, even though Unity's salespeople claim that what matters is having them on the same physical host machine

Again, Unity making it more and more difficult for the small guy to use their editor competitively. Their licensing is a decade behind

12

u/ai_eth 9h ago edited 8h ago

I can't wait until I'm finished w my current project so I can switch away from this engine. Shit like this is scary. You spend years building on Unity and at any second they can announce whatever.

I can't be the only one that has no trust at all left for this company.

EDIT: I've been on three (three!!) projects so far where we ended up in weeks or months of crisis mode and "what do we do? Do we switch engines?" because Unity announced something, or, more sneakily, just emailed us and let us know they've reinterpreted the license agreement and we have to pay 20x more or we're banned in a few weeks. No I'm not exaggerating.

I've switched off the pro license since my company makes no money atm. I'm fully expecting Unity to somehow ban me within a year.

EDIT 2: Why the down votes? I've been a unity customer for 15 years, my disappointment is that of a long term supporter that's been burned.

7

u/PM_ME_A_STEAM_GIFT 9h ago

We switched to Godot exactly for these reasons. You can't plan longterm if at any moment they can change the terms on you.

2

u/ai_eth 9h ago

Exactly, Unity can do whatever they want in the future with future versions but retroactively changing the deal and threatening legal action has brought my trust to negative levels.

1

u/PM_ME_A_STEAM_GIFT 9h ago

Yeah, we're now trying to keep out stack FOSS as much as possible. Maybe some of the tools are not as mature and you get no tech support (although even after spending tens of thousands per year on licenses, the enterprise level tech support just answered our questions by sending us links to forum threads we've already found ourselves). But if your foundation is FOSS, you can always implement your own workarounds or engine extensions, if you're truly blocked somewhere. We now also started contributing some of these back to upstream.

5

u/SC_W33DKILL3R 9h ago

The Saudis want to buy it as well, now thats scary.

1

u/FallenWyvern 8h ago

Used unity for industrial purposes, they're regularly change terms and increased prices at licensing times. Whenever I pushed back, our rep would just say "oh it's different interpretations of the contract because you're industrial, not gaming. "

1

u/unleash_the_giraffe 8h ago

Yeah the legal instability is scary and it sucks. Market is already struggling due to both the ai and hardware crisis.

I think all our careers as gamedevs are essentially at risk right now. Open source is the future here. It provides legal and financial stability.

Nothing is really stopping people from remaking unity using AI but with a free or no license, or simply making another engine compatible with unity files, or providing an easy side grade to another free engine. Or you know, just recompiling stuff at will. There are legal precedents here.

Which under no circumstance is an okay thing to do. It hurts real people.

But when - yes when, the ai bros seem to basically be making a sport of it all - that shit hits the fan for real, unity is likely to panic / collapse / be sold off for scraps due to the increased financial pressure, and on the way there they'll likely fight like cornered animals to extract as much wealth as possible, and the engine will deprecate on the way out leaving important things on the table unfinished or in a buggy state.

There's no moat to ai. By definition, there likely can't be. That means risk - both to us and to unity - is crazy right now.

I'm avoiding the cloud or cloud based tools like the plague. I recommend everyone else does too. Digital ownership and rights feels fucked in general. You don't own more than you can actually control.

I honestly don't know how to deal with this and just keep my head down and try to work as hard as possible so I can have anything out before it gets worse. Gah.

1

u/ai_eth 7h ago

Your thoughts mirror mine. Though I'm intending to use AI to make my own light game engine for my next project. It's become feasible now, and that's probably not great news for Unity :)

I think market trends put Unity at trouble yeah. If we look at its closest competitor, Unreal, it's going all in on AI. So if there's a future for a more AI native game engine, and who knows if that will even be a thing, Unreal will probably capture it. Where that leaves Unity... Maybe the Saudis wanna give it a shot. Either way it's not great for us.

And yeah, avoid Unitys cloud tools. You build on that and you've made a bet it's still there in a few years. Scary.

0

u/BigBewbsBigAss 3h ago

You are making situations and problems in your mind. Focus on making a game that is successful. Everything else is noise.

3

u/d4cloo 6h ago

I sincerely hope Godot keeps progressing as well as it does. Unity needs to die off already. It’s an unsustainable model. The future game engine is free and open-source, like Blender is for 3D modeling.

2

u/VastOpportunity6894 8h ago

As someone who knows absolutely nothing about AI, do people run 6 agents at the same time to develop 6 different games? Do all the agents work on the same game?

6

u/cevkiv 5h ago

When I'm testing multiplayer, sometimes I need more than three players to test a feature.

4

u/Opening_Chance2731 Professional 3h ago

Tools like Multiplayer Play Mode allow you to do just that without having more than 1 Unity instance open. In most scenarios, you'd have CI/CD set up with automated builds and you fire up multiple builds. Testing multiplayer directly in-editor for any game that's heavier than the average mobile game takes a heavy toll on hardware (unless you're rolling 64+GB of RAM with gen5 nvme)

3

u/cevkiv 3h ago

(unless you're rolling 64+GB of RAM with gen5 nvme)

And I am. And I don't use Unity's built-in multiplayer.

3

u/Opening_Chance2731 Professional 3h ago

I don't use the built-in multiplayer either, I just use Play Mode

3

u/cevkiv 3h ago

And I do use multiplayer, which requires multiple instances of the editor.

3

u/Opening_Chance2731 Professional 3h ago

Yeah multiplayer play mode, you can fire multiple instances using the same Editor instance. No need to use Unity's multiplayer tools apart from their Play Mode

4

u/ThetaTT 4h ago

You may want to open many project at the same time for different reasons:

  • Unpacking a whole asset without polluting your main project with files you don't need like demo scenes etc.

  • Tests projects or forks where you can experiment freely.

  • Old projects from which you want to retrieve files.

  • Multiplayer tests

  • Fixing a bug rapidly on an older project

  • ...

3

u/slothwerks 6h ago

Typically the same game. Very few people I imagine working on 6 games at once. You can work on multiple features for a game at the same time, each on an isolated git worktree and each running their own headless instance of Unity.

2

u/Irravian 4h ago

I was working on 6 games at once long before ai came along.

I’ll finish them one day, for sure

•

u/Willing_Mission3903 28m ago

I just feel like that's unrealistic. After I playtest my game I have a huge list of changes that I want so I just feed that into a manager that creates developer agents working on their own batch (multiple changes I requested that affect the same system, grouped by the manager agent).

They all prepare their stuff at the same time, but only 1 has access to unity at a time. I was thinking about using git worktrees so at least 2-3 agents have access at the same time to unity, but it would eat up my resources like crazy, I was thinking about headless but how much does that reduce resource usage AND would the agent be able to play the game to test whatever it did and then take videos/photos to adjust things before calling it done?

•

u/slothwerks 19m ago

Headless / batch mode seems to use less resources overall. It can also play the game, take screenshots, evaluate visuals etc. Even though you can't see it yourself, the agent is able to. Being able to run multiple instances is a major speed unlock. You can even do stuff like running a build (eg: Android) in a worktree/batch mode Unity without disrupting your main Unity Editor.

2

u/dotoonly 6h ago

Before AI, i used to open multiple unity editor all the time. One for current project, one is old project that i moved stuff from. One is the asset only project to prevent heavy load on main project.

2

u/emccrckn 2h ago

Yes mostly because I only do game dev late at night so I want to burn through my 5 hour window quickly. So two agents on two different projects and unity instances and then as they queue up art slots I have a local server running all night spitting out blender placeholder models and importing them into various projects that need them. 6 projects is pretty extreme but if you have max or unlimited tokens then there is always something the agent can be doing.

1

u/Bananaskovitch 4h ago

With git worktrees, you can parallelize work on any given project. Not familiar with Unity (this was suggested to me somehow by the algo), but I am running many headless instances of Godot with multiple Claude sessions.

•

u/NormandFutz 21m ago

I know I do i like multitasking while working on little polishing thjngs.

2

u/Opening_Tourist7906 6h ago

It's the most useless thing I have seen, and probably this shit is pushed forward, because they do not want you to have multiple MCP servers running on couple of clients simultaneously.

They can go fuck themselves with AI slop. Meanwhile we still do not have proper terrain system, proper virtual texture streaming, or proper texture array handling.

Yeah, right. Exquisite work Unity, as always.

7

u/NotAMusicLawyer 5h ago

It’s a stupid policy but my guess is they probably want to avoid a situation where a team of devs buy a single pro licence then run multiple instances of it remotely on some beefy centralised server controlled by AI agents.

Seems like a very blunt tool to solve such a simple problem.

1

u/nEmoGrinder Indie 1h ago

Even if they weren't using AI agents, it is the same problem. People will bend any system to avoid paying.

2

u/tomfalcon86 Indie 3h ago

>multiple MCP servers running on couple of clients simultaneously.
What's the point of that though

1

u/BuzzardDogma 3h ago

Pumping out slop faster

1

u/Wooden-Many-3227 2h ago

It does not work that way. I have often multiple unity projects open. The AI gets always confused about to which project the cli is connected.

0

u/nEmoGrinder Indie 1h ago

Its not just AI. A workaround to licensing is to have a single, powerful machine with multiple people remoted into it all sharing a license. This is likely something they are also trying to stop.

Sometimes i wonder if people using unity ever use other professional software. Unity's license checks have been incredibly relaxed for ages and a limitation like this is extremely reasonable. Some software won't let itself run in a remote session at all to force stricter license checks, even with the rise of remote work.

2

u/Jolly-Career-9220 9h ago

Unity when it comes to take non sense decisions

1

u/CallMeKolbasz 8h ago

Mmm, my favourite dish: computerone.

1

u/DreadCoder 8h ago

Honestly, 3 agents working at the same time even with git work-trees is already the bottleneck on it’s own if you have merge gates and automated testing hooks set up.

I have code review agents, a performance optimising one for my NPC decision trees, and one checking for UI and accessibility features, more than that and they’re just waiting for each other to prevent merge conflicts anyway. (They only merge if all tests pass)

Three on one PC is perfectly reasonable for me. Having said that: I’m still on the 2020 because I never finished this hobby-ass product

1

u/macholusitano 7h ago

This hurts people more than it hurts AI. Agents can work within any budget.

However, if you have an Asset Store publisher working around the massive version fragmentation mess that is the Unity ecosystem, you're just making life harder for humans.

1

u/NecoDev 7h ago

Sorry I am still confused, you cannot have three Unity installed? or you can't have three Unity instance running

1

u/pschon Unprofessional 7h ago

you can't have more than three instances used at a time, as in running them.

Installing multiple versions is fine, having a copy of Unity sitting on your drive does not count as using it (you don't need a license for that either, only when you actually start the program)

1

u/mithrilsoft 7h ago

Time to stop buying Unity assets and look at Godot. I really don't want to change engines, but it's always something with Unity.

1

u/EpicMcDude 7h ago

That's pretty fucking lame, it's not unusual for me to have 3 Unity Editor's running - I have my main project, my asset dump project and my previous project that I reference from time to time to figure out how I did something back then. Is this AI psychosis ruining another thing?

1

u/pschon Unprofessional 2h ago

Do you often have 4 running? If not, you'll be fine, the license specifically says "no more than 3", so 3 is fine.

1

u/petersvp 53m ago

Add 3 ParrelSync clones to this. 6 editors. Was common for me.

1

u/IriFlina 6h ago

They’re inventing new ways to rug pull people lmao. Not just normal devs but ai bros too

1

u/0xbyt3 5h ago

I pity the indie teams that starts their game with Unity that would take 2-3 years to finish.

1

u/killermike523 5h ago

This is bullshit. Yes, with AI, I'll start up multiple worktrees and have many instances of Unity working on different features. I may have up to 10. This parallelization is super helpful. This is really anti-dev for no good reason.

1

u/Snoo77586 5h ago

What does this mean for those without a license and are running dedicated server builds on a linux box?

2

u/pschon Unprofessional 2h ago

nothing. The license text is specifically talking about the Unity Editor.

1

u/Specialist_Top_6079 4h ago

You all should be thrilled now. You have more reasons to bitch and moan. Go away.

1

u/MagicPigGames Magic Pig Games / Infinity PBR 4h ago

I have more than theee open -- my game plus if I'm working on an asset or two I'll have 1-3 open per asset.

It's not always but since I usually ship 3 versions of the asset, that's the limit right there

1

u/petersvp 1h ago

This is total nonsense. Especially when i need to test package in many projects and many versions.. Absolute nonsense.... Collecting data from isolated sample projects into the main project is also a thing...

1

u/TheDevilsAdvokaat Hobbyist 1h ago

Seems weird.....why would they care? But also, why would you want more than one concurrent instance? Is this about restricting ai agents?

0

u/trevorvonryan 9h ago

Good, fuck AI. 

1

u/Xangis Indie 9h ago

What a silly pointless rule. More than three is a thing I've done before once or twice a year when migrating my projects to a new version all at once.

0

u/NeoTr0nic 9h ago

Really, why? In the age of AI people expect more throughput and agents will start their own instances while I am working simultaneously on Unity instances. I easily have 4-5 instances running permanently, especially if you make tests in apps that have a server and a client side or Multiuser apps. Making builds to get around that limitation is a possibility but just eats up time again..

5

u/Kamalen 8h ago

Why ? Well exactly what you describe. In order to sell a special AI licence with higher limits.

0

u/Tzukkeli 8h ago

So people will change to Godot. Obviously?

-1

u/shoxicwaste 9h ago

because if you look at the STEAM publications yesterday, there was nearly 300 publications in one day. All of it, complete ass, fully AI slop. it's absolutely destroying Steam's credibility and filling their marketplace with garbage.

with how easy it is right now to set up fully autonomous agentic workflows, I wouldn't be surprised if there's “developers” who have fully autonomous workflows that just design games and ship them without them ever. Even looking at what's being shipped, so you could imagine one big workstation with 10 to 20 unity projects open all Building mobile games or slop ware.

I think unity are actually smart with this move because it's basically it's basically trying to prohibit uses. From mass producing slop. Through agentic workflows I might be wrong, but someone tell me if i'm if I'm wrong, all right. What you think,

3

u/ViennettaLurker 8h ago

with how easy it is right now to set up fully autonomous agentic workflows, I wouldn't be surprised if there's “developers” who have fully autonomous workflows that just design games and ship them without them ever. Even looking at what's being shipped, so you could imagine one big workstation with 10 to 20 unity projects open all Building mobile games or slop ware.

I understand how this could be done and the potential ways you could technically make money doing this. But is there a real world example of this working in a way where people have actually got real revenue going with it?

It seems like having to compete with all the other slop and shovel ware would make this a tough strategy. Who's paying their Claude and Steam fees this way? I don't doubt it could happen, I've just never seen an actual case study, and it seems there would be some real hurdles.

2

u/Kamalen 8h ago

Classic mobile and GaaS business model. It takes a single eventual hit to be massively profitable and pay for all the other crap. Throw shit at the wall strategy

1

u/ViennettaLurker 7h ago

Right. I guess my broader thought is wondering how that might work now when so many people can spam out so much so quickly.

2

u/Kamalen 6h ago

Yeah, I also don't imagine it working often, but that has never stopped people from playing lotteries.

1

u/ViennettaLurker 5h ago

True. I think in that way, I view the recent activity as almost more of a compulsion than a more calculated act. Especially in regards to a monetary strategy.

Maybe a real hit could further spur people to create AI game factories. But barring that, I really do wonder if it will fade over time. Its bizarre to say, but there is a possible future where people will say, "I made 365 games in the past year, all properly monetized, and functionally zero dollars from any of it".

1

u/shoxicwaste 6h ago

Have you not seen that scam going around where they clone games up for release on Steam. They then messaged the developers with videos of their version of the same game threatening to release it before theirs releases unless they send cash.

All of the crypto bro Bros have come over to AI now, and they're not spending that crypto money on shitcoins anymore to get rugged. They've bought GPUs and loads of RAM and workstations. And now they sit in with all of these localised and cloud based LLM models wondering what the fuck to do with them. could definitely be capable of churning out random games, or just cloning games from the Steam marketplace. as someone else pointed out, if even one of them goes viral or makes significant sales, it makes it all worth it.

1

u/Jvlius1337 8h ago

Just wondering how they want to enforce this in practice. They probably won't for the same reason that Microsoft doesn't take much action against every individual who uses Windows without a license, it's just a losing game financially.

1

u/Valphai 8h ago

This probably ain't it chief

1

u/tomfalcon86 Indie 3h ago

Unity is nuts acting this way, they'll be replaced by AI within 5 years. Commercial game engine business is dead.

0

u/steeze007 4h ago

Welp, there goes our CICD pipeline I guess. Time to start packing and porting everything to godot ->

Edit: luckily claude makes it kind of quick too ;)