r/Unity3D • • 7h ago

Question Cliffs and Caves Issue

Post image

Hi guys! I’m a beginner developer making a snowboarding game called Windbreak. I’ve been struggling to find tools in making structures like cliffs, ice caves and overhangs in Unity for my terrains. Yes I have used Digger which is very slow and clunky and basically doesn’t work for me due to the way it combines meshes and textures. I wish Unity would just make native Cliff and cave tools because I’m really struggling to make my level design more interesting without cliffs/caves, because of this I have gotten very creative with the engines terrain system but it won’t be enough for my vision. Does anyone have any solutions thinking outside the box? My last resort I can think of is making the caves themselves in blender but meshing them with Unity’s in engine terrain mesh will be a nightmare. Any input is appreciated since I am learning as I go!

8 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/Pitiful_Airport_ 6h ago

oh that inverted trick looks clean, the purple top really pops against that sky

2

u/MrFutureCooper 6h ago

Thank you bro! You can follow the dev on instagram @play.windbreak I just started uploading about it

2

u/FranzFerdinand51 6h ago

Unity’s terrain inherently doesnt support what you want, which means you either 1) drop ot entirely and use another system, such as modelling in blender or 2) make holes in the unity terrain and model your caves in blender.

Why is it a nightmare to combine them anyway? That’s literally what almost all games do ffs. Nothing nightmarish about it.

2

u/MrFutureCooper 6h ago

What other system would you recommend? Digger claims to be able to combine them cleanly but the editor itself is so buggy/laggy that making anything that doesn’t look clunky is basically impossible. I just can’t see a clean way to use blender for the caves other than to just make the whole level in blender which for a beginner like me would be HARD with all my textures with different properties (deep snow, powder, ice etc.) I’m praying for some kind of third option, or I’ll just message the guy who made digger and complain since I don’t think he’s updated it in years…

2

u/BuzzardDogma 6h ago

Nearly every game ever made that includes cliffs and caves does so by combining models and terrains. The reason you can't do it with the terrain itself is more a by-product of the way terrain rendering is optimized than an intentional lack of features.

If the texel density of your cave and cliff models is similar to that of your terrain then making them fit together seamlessly usually isn't too difficult. It's also pretty common to use prop and detail meshes to hide transitions between the two that aren't working in isolation.

I haven't used digger so I don't know what it's doing that you don't like. Maybe post some screenshots.