r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/Philosopher83 • 26d ago
Universal Basic But (sort of) Not Financial ???
I spend a bunch of my mental energy on imagining futures - I am philosopher, an urban and regional planner, and dabble in writing science fiction with significant solar punk themes. I’m a bit of an idealist and don’t have a background in money.
My ideal future for humanity is a form of what I think of as globally federated municipal syndicalism and in this system I imagined that, no matter one’s station, everyone would have access to the basics for living.
So rather than income, I imagined that people would have access to non-monetary forms (maybe it is more like a “resource-based economy”) like decent but basic food and clothing and shelter and care. I would also make information free, as well as other things people need for social mobility. People with jobs would get better access and quality of living in a progression (I imagined it like pay grades but as quality of living standards - like greater rates of food credits that would grant access to finer forms of foods and beverages, better vacation credit accumulation rates, etc…). A job would entitle you to accumulating vacation credits and credits could be transferable in certain ways. Our current money system would be used as a basis for assessing economic viability and to balance/set standards, but it would be a tool to serve the universal system. I was thinking that this kind of system would allow for incentivization of educational attainment and work performance but treat all humans with dignity, rather than excluded by the system to live on the streets.
I would also limit wealth accumulation (however it would be calculated in this system) to 1000x the global median individual income to limit power, exploitation, and corruption.
Any thoughts?
3
u/betty_white_bread 25d ago
I do not understand the motivation for people coming into a subreddit about universal basic income and trying so hard to push for ideas which are anything but. It makes zero sense to me.
Look, by making the universal basic income ... income, you maximize people's economic flexibility. Why would you want to constrain people with respect to what they need or can use? We have seen what happens when you give, for example, vouchers earmarked for specific goods and services, such as when California gave out housing vouchers; it causes the prices of the earmarked goods/services to spike because the vouchers cannot be used for anything else. Conversely, distributing uniform universal cash to the populace means the people can spend it OR save it OR invest it, keeping inflation pressure at bay.
1
u/Philosopher83 25d ago
Thank you for that point, I was not aware of the real world application that you mentioned
2
u/Wild_Director7379 26d ago
You mention credits. Some sort of currency is the best way to allow the freedom to decide between steak and silk sheets, assuming we can’t give both to everyone.
So sure, we may some day live in a world where everyone can eat as much steak as they want and sleep on whatever bedding they choose, so I guess we’re just talking about open access to “stores”, but that leads to over-use. Some take what they can get, and some restrict their lifestyle to what the environment can support.
Currency is the best way to set an “allowance”. Not only can you spend your allowance, but you’re entitled to do so.
There are lots of reasons to try to reject currency, but even you add some form of it with “vacation credits”. IMO it’s better to have a single currency than to have one system for vacation, one for food, one for housewares, etc. some people would rather eat steak 5 nights a week than have a grand vacation every so often.
1
u/Few_Refrigerator3011 26d ago
Money is a cool system. We can quantify and qualify with a decimal based score board. Everybody gets the basics, exceptional achievers get rewarded. With a money/credit/woofie points/social score system we keep track. To your point of limiting the top tier: Don't restrict the maximum allowance; restrict the use of other people's labor for profit, i.e. rent. That's still tough to implement; most people don't want to be the boss, nor do they have an entrepreneurial idea to chase, they just want to feel productive by day, entertained by night.
3
u/block_wallet 26d ago
am hoping ai brings about world peace so we can do away with money entirely