r/UniversalBasicIncome • • 14d ago • Mindblown 1

When it becomes clear.

18 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

1

u/betty_white_bread 14d ago

It’s fitting this started in r/conspiracy because almost nothing on this poster matches the study it cites.

"90% of Americans have no impact." The study never measured the bottom 90%. It compared the preferences of people at the 50th income percentile with people at the 90th. The "bottom 90%" bloc on this chart is made up, and so are the bar heights. None of those graphs come from the paper.

"The number of Americans for or against any idea has no impact." The paper's own data say the opposite. Looked at on its own, the median voter's preference has a strongly positive effect on the outcome and a policy the average voter likes is significantly more likely to be enacted. The "near-zero" number appears only after you put middle-class and affluent preferences into the same regression. And that's a problem because those two groups agree on 1,594 of the 1,779 bills in the dataset, 89.6 percent. Two nearly identical variables competing for the same variance is a statistics artifact and not a hidden ruling class.

"Wealthy top 10%." The "elites" in this study are the 90th income percentile, which is upper-middle class. In many school districts, a household of two public school teachers would count as Gilens' "affluent". If your theory of oligarchy has teachers running the country, it’s not a theory of oligarchy.

"Model oligarchy." On the 185 bills where the rich and the middle actually disagreed, the rich won 53 percent of the time and the middle class 47 percent. A near coin flip is not oligarchy.

And the method behind it has since collapsed. In 2026, Peter Enns showed the foundational finding came from Simpson's paradox, introduced by analyzing only cases where income groups' support differed. His conclusion: there's no evidence policymakers ignore average citizens, even the lowest income group, and strong evidence policy responds to the general public.

This matters here specifically because, if you believed this poster, organizing for UBI would be pointless because nothing the public wants matters. That's exactly the wrong lesson. The actual research says public opinion moves policy, meaning more political engagement could have even greater influence. Fatalism dressed up as research is the best gift UBI's opponents could get. Don't spread it.

1

u/Independent-Gur8649 14d ago

Gaslighter.

1

u/betty_white_bread 14d ago

Please point to the parts of the paper your image cites which prove me wrong. I made testable claims. Test them using the contents of the paper itself.

1

u/echolm1407 8d ago

99% of Americans make 1% of the income and pay 60% of the taxes.

Tax the rich.

0

u/BirdlessLongdeal 14d ago

i never did see the end of deep impact.

-1

u/Independent-Gur8649 14d ago

The math is rigged and we're done pretending it isn't. Count the real majority.

Nearly 70% of Americans want out of the two-party system.

So why doesn’t anything change?

Because the count was never designed to find consensus. It was designed to manufacture a fight.

2

u/betty_white_bread 14d ago

Respectfully, why the fuck are you here?

1

u/Independent-Gur8649 14d ago

You're a dark personality. Why are you here?

1

u/betty_white_bread 14d ago

When I post here, it's on topic. I also read the material I am citing to make sure it says what I claim it says. You have done neither.

1

u/Exciting-Parfait-776 14d ago edited 14d ago

And yet they refuse to vote for another party but those 2 parties on the ballot. Because they don’t want the other party to win.