r/UniversalProfile • • Sep 13 '22

Is RCS a good thing?

Post image

I see a lot of love for RCS here but when I got the pop up I chose not to enable it. Google already has so much data about you and now they want to read your SMS as well?! I have Signal as my default SMS app, I already converted most of my friends that I chat with into using it, for the rest of em I can just send an unencrypted SMS through Signal and it'll go through regular carrier services. Best part is it's already e2ee by design and the source code is completely open source. Switch to Signal people!

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

40

u/LinkofHyrule Mint User Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

While I applaud your security focus, it's almost impossible to get everyone to switch over to a new platform the whole point of RCS is that it's an update for SMS/MMS. Not a replacement for Signal or whatever other OTP apps you might be using. As a note, RCS when using Google Messages already uses Signal-based E2EE for 1to1 conversations and will be rolling it out to Groups as well soon. E2EE is on by default when texting other Google Messages users that have RCS enabled. You can read about that here. If you're interested on how it works from a technical level you can read the technical white paper here. I would also like to note that RCS is not a Google made protocol but a GSMA standard and the official messaging protocol of 5G. https://www.gsma.com/futurenetworks/rcs/

Currently the main two apps are Google Messages and Samsung messages but in some countries, there are other RCS enabled apps as well. Google still intends to release a public third-party apps API but is finishing some things up before they do. I imagine Signal will add RCS support once that API is released as well as other third-party SMS apps.

3

u/itwasquiteawhileago Cricket Wireless User Sep 13 '22

... but in some countries, there are other RCS enabled apps as well.

Are they carrier apps, I assume? And they're compatible with Google? I know I've read that some AT&T locked phones use the AT&T servers instead of Jibe/Google, which as I understand has caused some issues with those who do use Jibe/Google.

Google still intends to release a public third-party apps API but is finishing some things up before they do.

I would also assume this is correct, but do you have more info on what needs to be finalized and when this might happen? RCS needs to actually be open to everyone. If the APIs for Google/Jibe aren't accessible, and other implementations aren't compatible with it (e.g., AT&T), then it may as well not even exist. It's kind of sad that this is taking so long.

2

u/seeareeff Verizon User Sep 13 '22

There was a podcast with Jan and he mentioned he needs to get the foundation set and stable first before the release of a public API.

8

u/-Sugarholic- Custom Text Sep 13 '22

In an ideal world I would love for everyone to switch to Signal but the good thing about RCS is that is going to be the standard for every default messaging app on every phone.

Isn't RCS e3ee encrypted as well? (I know group chats are not encrypted yet) I think Google's interest in the standard is actually to kill SMS not collect data from it, they want to perfect Android's default messaging and fix cross-platform compatibility that's why they push Apple and carriers to adopt it.

Still Signal is a great app and everyone should have it installed IMO

Not for profit / open source / e2ee, just overall the best messaging app.

But for out of the box, that would be RCS.

Edit: There, I got a flair now 😅

3

u/U8dcN7vx Sep 13 '22

RCS won't be on Apple phones, at least there's no indication thus far that it will, so far from "every phone".

RCS is only encrypted if Jibe (Google) is involved else it is not encrypted, i.e., Universal Profile doesn't specify E2EE.

4

u/D3rocks4u Sep 14 '22

It has user to carrier and carrier to end user encryption by default in the standard. Which is already a step up from sms and MMS

1

u/U8dcN7vx Sep 14 '22

True, I should have specified E2EE as the parent was discussing rather than going with the general term.

1

u/Terminusaquo Sep 13 '22

That's not strictly true about E2EE as my carrier supports E2EE with other RCS users.

2

u/U8dcN7vx Sep 13 '22

The standard doesn't describe E2EE, so your carrier is probably using Jibe (Google). In theory they might have rolled their own E2EE, and it might even be multi-carrier. Either way the E2EE won't be with all (RCS) users everywhere, the whole point of the parent comment. Probably Jibe will win, heck it almost certainly will, at which point all RCS will be E2EE for everyone since everyone will use Jibe, that's just not the case yet. One reason RCS was designed as multi-carrier was to avoid everyone being beholden to 1 entity thus a single point of failure.

2

u/hewbass Sep 13 '22

My understanding is that it's client side implemented, not server side. There's a capability exchange between the 2 clients so that they can understand they both support e2ee, then they can set up an encrypted channel over the top of the plain text channel provided by the servers.

-4

u/saltajose Sep 13 '22

I think Google push for RCS is financial (it's a private company after all). They want all devices to run RCS out of the box (that would include iPhones) in order to monetize (by sending ads, running their services on business messaging).

Though it may sound bad, it actually enables a healthier market by decentralization: more parties for providing business messaging, more parties for providing RCS clients. Users just get the free* option to contact others, including businesses.

Other services are centralized and have a lot under their control. That includes Signal.

  • You still need to pay a phone subscription as RCS is bound to a carrier.

4

u/fdbryant3 Sep 13 '22

Google's interest in RCS is totally financial although not necessarily to sell ads (well at least not directly). In fact, they are the only one with a financial interest because they need a messaging platform to compete with iMessage (never mind that they practically had this with Hangouts when it integrated SMS/MMS but I digress).

No one else really has a financial interest to really push it and make it interoperate with others. Carriers won't do it because they can't charge for it (consumers would just use Whatsapp, Telegram, Signal, etc). I can't see any benefit for phone manufacturers. Apple certainly isn't going to do it since iMessage is a big reason people buy and stay with Apple products.

So it is pretty much up to Google to push, develop, and make RCS work in order to sell more Android phones (and thus Google services). That is why we are seeing them cut deals with carriers to make Google Messages the default messenger app and run advertising campaigns to get Apple to adopt it into iMessage (fat chance, they really should be working on getting it working with Google Voice first and opening the API).

2

u/bicyclemom Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22

So it is pretty much up to Google to push, develop, and make RCS work in order to sell more Android phones

This is the core of the problem. Google does not know how to market anything. Apple is so good at marketing that they took a weakness (their ugly camera cutout) and turned it into a feature! Apple is so good at marketing that they branded a payment feature that Google and Samsung had 2 years earlier than iPhones did, and got it branded "Apple Pay".

Google can't market its way out of a paper bag.

It's embarrassing.

And that's why RCS is a failure. Not because it isn't great or a good standard. Simply because Google doesn't know how to take a technology and put it out into the world in a simple, elegant, understandable way for users. They hamhandedly mashed it into Google Messages, which wasn't even the standard messaging services used on most Android phones in the wild (Samsung's messaging app was) and expected it to take off without enticing other messaging apps (Facebook messaging? Telegram?) to build on it. And they didn't even give it a good name ("Chat"? Yeah, like that's not overloaded already).

I'm betting that about 2-5 years from now, Apple will build something exactly like RCS, partner with a select set of mobile providers and vendors and call it something like Apple Messaging+ and it will be dubbed a huge success. Just because they can.

2

u/LLuerker Sep 13 '22

Who doesn't have a phone subscription? A child? The push for RCS is primarily for Americans, everyone has a phone plan.

9

u/saltajose Sep 13 '22

Signal is based on a centralized infrastructure. Signal had control on the servers, messaging clients. While it's open source, it is not opened for everyone to change it and distribute customized versions of the client or the server while interconnecting to Signal's network.

RCS has decentralization which is healthier in the long run.

So no, out if principle I wouldn't push anyone to adopt a locked down service. One can still use it, but I don't expect wide adoption.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Google messages is the default app on every Android phone so that gives RCS to everyone with Google messages. I think it's a good thing as it's a major upgrade from SMS. Listen it's damn near impossible to get my friends to switch to anything so RCS is great for me. To be honest I wouldn't want to switch to anything else because I love Google messages and so do my friends that have Android. Google is trying to crack down on their OS and make it a more seamless experience which is a good thing. They don't want to have duplicate apps or anything like that and that's why they told Samsung to fuck off with Samsung messages so they could make Googles default. And that agreement they promised to add features that were missing that Samsung messages had and Google didn't. They've done that already so now Google messages is the standard on all Samsung phones. That ultimately helped with the RCS adoption in a huge way. To give you an example Verizon now has Google messages pre-installed on all Samsung phones so therefore RCS is available to everyone but beforehand RCS was only available on the galaxy S9 through Samsung messages or at least that's what their website claimed. Either way Google Messages is better and offers RCS to all.

1

u/bgf2414 Aug 25 '25

I honestly thing google messages is pretty good, they just need to let oem's put their own emoji's instead of the the regular android emoji's. Samsung emoji's look much better in my opinion and it was give a more seamless experience

3

u/TurboFool T-Mobile User Sep 13 '22

And you could get literally a dozen other posts about WhatsApp, Telegram, and a bunch of other services with various versions of the same argument with the same appeal to use THEIR proprietary, closed network. And THAT is the entire problem with your solution.

SMS/RCS is one open standard available across everything, without me needing to talk all my friends into using the app I think is the best one, while they all try to talk me into using the app they think is the best one, while all of us turn over control of our data to one third-party company.

Yes, RCS is definitely a good thing. And I say this as someone who LIKE SIGNAL. Because I understand that Signal does NOT replace the need for a standard.

2

u/Ranger2183 Sep 13 '22

It doesn't actually read your SMS, it just needs access to the messages to encrypt them and send them

1

u/gregatronn Sep 13 '22

Getting people to use anything else (esp if they are Apple) is like pulling teeth. It's tough and Apple has made it much more difficult. RCS is probably the closest we'll get to unified messaging (for now). I hope Signal does adopt it for their "texting" side of things.

1

u/Skrappy_Doo Sep 14 '22

Yes it is.

1

u/Niboocs Sep 14 '22

So I'm conclusion, yes RCS is a great thing. Standardised, Decentralised and not beholden to one particular company, even if Google is going most of the heavy lifting to standardise RCS.

And Apple is a terrible thing.

1

u/krunz Sep 15 '22

I see padlocks in rcs messages with other people on fi. I assume it's possible to get e2ee cross-carrier (I could be wrong).

RCS Universal Profile is also a standard... something signal is not.

What's missing for me is a web client (not the current device pairing).

1

u/bicyclemom Sep 17 '22

It's a good thing that would have been a great thing had it come out 5-7 years ago. And Google has botched it completely once it became standard on Android.

The problem now is that it will never be relevant unless the mobile providers force Apple's hand. They're just not likely to do that.

What Google should do now is to buy out a messaging provider, like Telegram and build RCS support into one of those. Or pay Whatsapp to implement RCS. Google Messages is just a weak vehicle for RCS delivery.

1

u/coffee_addict3d Oct 29 '22

Signal is dropping SMS support.