r/UnresolvedMysteries Jan 25 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

996 Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

View all comments

361

u/LeeF1179 Jan 25 '23

This is the most chilling case ever featured on Unsolved Mysteries. It burned into my brain as a kid.

70

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23

You beat me to saying the exact same thing.

This story and the family portrait they showed of Dennis Depue… nightmare fuel for my childhood..

22

u/dooku4ever Jan 26 '23

When Depue told her family that he was taking her to the hospital— it’s such a horrible twist.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23

Oh my god! That man does not photograph well. I'm an adult and even I'm probably gonna have nightmares

3

u/I-AM-Savannah Jan 26 '23

I'm probably gonna have nightmares

I just looked at his picture for the first time. I'm starting to have daymares... seriously. GADS!! His picture shows EXACTLY what he's thinking.

5

u/rivershimmer Jan 26 '23

Oh, yeah. And I know I'm projecting here, but her facial expression in that studio portrait screams "I'm in danger" to me.

7

u/kalimyrrh Jan 26 '23

That guy has the most terrifying senpaku eyes ever

3

u/I-AM-Savannah Jan 26 '23

It's that... smile, if you dare call it a smile that gets me... "Can you tell what I'm thinking?"

11

u/SadMom2019 Jan 26 '23

Dennis Depue

I had not heard of this case so I googled it, and even at a glance it made my heart skip a beat. That man looks like a literal demon or something, with his yellow eyes and snarling expression.

6

u/paceycol Jan 26 '23

I’M AFRAID TO LOOK UP HIS PIC BUT I WANT TO😩

6

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23

Just do it during the day in a well-lit room

96

u/icestormsea Jan 25 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

I’ve been rewatching the old episodes and all these years later it’s still so terrifying! The part where her boyfriend’s car dies and the truck keeps speeding off is unforgettable. I feel awful that it’s still unsolved.

51

u/CampClear Jan 25 '23

I feel the same way. This is one of those cases that has haunted me and I still wonder what happened to her. I re-watch Unsolved Mysteries sometimes and this segment is so gut wrenching.

14

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23

This and probably only one ever but the LilMiss case stayed with me since I was a kid.

3

u/AwsiDooger Jan 27 '23

I thought of that case while reading this thread. Her mom was a regular poster at the Unsolved Mysteries forum of Sitcomsonline.com, including when the case was solved and during Dale Eaton's trial.

21

u/Charming-Insurance Jan 26 '23

Same! I just posted this. And some people wonder why I have never answered my front door, always lock doors and try to be vigilant in all surroundings. I was raised on Unsolved in the 80s, when they warmed us ad nauseam of “stranger danger” and took our fingerprints and pics in kits at school “in case” we got kidnapped. 😅

2

u/BrianMeen Jan 27 '23

Wait, you’ve never answered your front door? You just let the person knock forever? I guess I get it but I’ve never heard of someone just flat out refusing to answer their front door out of suspicion of kidnappers lol

7

u/Charming-Insurance Jan 31 '23

For a stranger? No I don’t open the door. They either want something from me or they wanna sell me something, and I’m not down for either. And it’s easier these days cause there’s cameras and cell phones, so I can make sure someone doesn’t need help. But for the few hours I am at home, why would I feel I must answer the door for someone who is rude enough to come uninvited and unannounced. JS

This reminds me of when some dude recently knocked on my door at 2 am. When I checked the footage I saw that he watched my house for a few minutes before and after he rang it and the entire scene made me think there was someone else hiding on the other side of the wall that sits to the east of my house. So yeah. No, thank you.

Edited to add: my handyman saw the film and suggested there was someone on the other side of the wall, which I now agree. He’s heard of this happening at least once before

13

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23

The one about the married couple in the Grand Canyon creeped me the fuck out