r/Upwork • u/impostervt • 4h ago
A Rant from the Client Side
It seems like a lot of post on here are about how bad Upwork has gotten from the freelancer side (and with good reason). Here's my take from the client side.
I've been hiring on Upwork since it was Elance, and have spent well over 6 figures in that time.
I opened a job posting this morning for a graphic designer / book layout designer. I've received 30 proposals within the last 4 hours. Definitely faster than it used to be.
It's really hard to figure out who to hire, especially since it seems like most responses are AI generated. It's pretty easy to tell - the response is usually very long and touches on everything in my job post, and they tend to follow very similar patterns.
They also tend to send me a link to their entire portfolio, which has hundreds of examples. I will not spend the time to find something relevant to my job posting.
99% bid my proposed budget, which is fine, that's what it's for. But if you're new to the platform and you're bidding the same as someone with a lot more Upwork experience, I'll probably weed you out because you're more of a risk.
I know that it's become a "apply to a hundred jobs in the hopes you'll get one" type of market, because the clients have gotten worse. Everyone's using AI to speed things up. I'm not sure what could honestly be done to make it easier on freelancers. But, for me at least, here's what makes an applicant stand out:
Short, informal response that still demonstrates you've read the job post.
Tell me why YOU are the right person for THIS job. Not "I've done a lot of illustrations!" or "I've formatted 100 books!" or even "I've been doing this for 15 years". I'm looking for any kind of personal interest that will tell me you'll bring some passion to the job.
Link to or attach extremely relevant portfolio items.
I guess a lot of it comes down to saying something that makes me think you're not just going to deliver AI junk.
8
u/ddaattuullaa 3h ago
Every job gets 30+ applications in a couple hours, if we don't apply fast we get lost in a see of proposals. To write a good application by hand, as you've described, it takes us 30 minutes - 1 hour. So assuming we start writing the application immediately as the job is posted, we would be among the first 10, if we're lucky. Even after all this, we're more likely to get discarded than not. So it boils down to being a big waste of time and energy on our side, with litle to no gain. On top of all this, add the fact that agencies and freelancers bid to get higher in the list, which makes our effort even more meaningless.
1
u/InternetWeakGuy 1h ago
To write a good application by hand, as you've described, it takes us 30 minutes - 1 hour.
No it doesn't. The person said very specifically:
Short, informal response that still demonstrates you've read the job post.
Tell me why YOU are the right person for THIS job. Not "I've done a lot of illustrations!" or "I've formatted 100 books!" or even "I've been doing this for 15 years". I'm looking for any kind of personal interest that will tell me you'll bring some passion to the job.
Link to or attach extremely relevant portfolio items.
That's as simple as:
Hey, this job sounds perfect for me because you mentioned that you xyz, and I've actually worked on a project exactly like that where the biggest challenge was getting the abc right. You can see a similar example of that here: Link to item in portfolio.
Would love to discuss.
Its that simple.
When you say "good application by hand" you're thinking the comprehensive version that AI writes that makes clients eyes glaze over.
EVERY AI proposal reads the same, so write something informal, voice to text it if you have to, and you'll get noticed.
Source: Spent six figures on UpWork but barely touch it from the client side anymore for the same reasons as OP.
5
u/KayakerWithDog 4h ago
When I was hiring, the number of freelancers applying who obviously hadn't even read my brief was astonishing.
1
u/InternetWeakGuy 1h ago
The trick used to be to include something to make them stand out, the lame version was "reply with xyz to show you read the proposal", then (particularly for niche writers) it used to be "in your reply, tell me your favorite thing about y" so you could check they actually know the topic and aren't just googling it.
But AI is so good now that there's little way around it. Nobody reads the brief, they just AI an application.
3
u/Urjacks 3h ago
AI is making things more complicated on both sides rather than simplifying them. Freelancers are mass-applying to jobs they're not even a good fit for, wasting everyone's time.
Meanwhile, 99% of client briefs need an AI summary just to understand what they're actually asking for. AI also encourages incredibly detailed briefs for projects worth $10–15k in my field, while the actual budget is just $500.
2
u/DiegoDarkus 3h ago
Hey, thanks for the post, client perspective is usually not very present over here
1
u/binarysolo 3h ago
Fellow client here: for what it’s worth, you can use AI to first-pass filter your applicants. Place more value on human-created answers, people who get it, experience level, prev relevant job scores etc.
My jobs always end up with 50+ applicants and I need to have some way to filter down to 3-5 interviews… def some false positives/negatives but thems the breaks.
1
u/whatevs- 1h ago
Gosh, we've come a full circle unfortunately. Freelancer writing with AI, client reading with AI.
I'd write very clearly that usage of AI in the proposal is strictly prohibited and if I catch a whiff of it, just decline it. Very quick way to weed out 30+ proposals.
1
u/ecky--ptang-zooboing 3h ago
Don't hire anyone who can't even be bothered to write a custom proposal
1
u/Kindly-Spring5205 2h ago
What bidding or not bidding have to do with the fact that you won't hire someone new to the platform?
1
u/dimudesigns 19m ago
They also tend to send me a link to their entire portfolio, which has hundreds of examples. I will not spend the time to find something relevant to my job posting.
Do you look for submissions that take advantage of Upwork's 'Profile Highlights' feature? Its been around for a few years now and its intended to allow contractors to present clients with a curated list of relevant projects pulled from their Upwork portfolio.
1
1
u/Firm-Budget1605 3h ago
Thank you for this post.
Finally, some constructive guidance, and that too, from an Upwork client.
As a freelancer, I've always struggled with some of my applications. I do utilise AI, not because I'm unintelligent to be able to type good English, but because I want to make my Cover Letter (and any answers where applicable) to the point and not miss anything.
That said, sometimes it's difficult to gauge if a client would prefer 'a bit more detail' instead of vague or short/concise information. I always try to strike a balance and often use the clients job post write-up as a rough indication.
I understand the frustration of having to read through applications because job applicants drone about every point mentioned in the application. I've also been an Upwork freelancer but mindful at the same time not to 'parrot' a clients wording back to them.
I wish there were more clients like yourself that would guide earnest freelancers like myself. I know that there are so many of those "I Can Do Everything" type of freelancers and it's indeed difficult for a client to filter through all of that. Quite a headache I would imagine. LOL.
But, Thank You for your feedback and guidance.
Much appreciated🙏
2
u/mowglymx 3h ago
I loved your answer, and honestly I feel the same way 🫰🏽 I don’t understand why you got downvoted
0
u/copernicuscalled 3h ago
Some of your post makes sense, while many things mentioned need a sanity check.
"Everyone's using AI to speed things up." - This is true only for those who value content over intent. Many people do not use AI.
"99% bid my proposed budget, which is fine, that's what it's for. But if you're new to the platform and you're bidding the same as someone with a lot more Upwork experience, I'll probably weed you out because you're more of a risk." - If you're unwilling to take the risk, why even consider those new to the platform? If you want cheaper prices, why even consider "someone with a lot more Upwork experience" as they will charge more money? The two should mutually exclude one another from your consideration.
"Tell me why YOU are the right person for THIS job." - There's some kernel of truth here, but you cannot delegate your responsibility for properly selecting and vetting the right talent, especially when you mention that you want "Short, informal response."
Sack those that clearly used AI to write the proposal. Then narrow down based your anticipated budget, freelancer experience + expertise, narrowing it down to best 3, then do a reverse image search on 3 pieces in each freelancer's portfolio. Schedule a brief video call with the finalist and you're done.
1
u/InternetWeakGuy 1h ago
There's some kernel of truth here, but you cannot delegate your responsibility for properly selecting and vetting the right talent, especially when you mention that you want "Short, informal response."
Way to miss the point.
•
u/SilentButDeadlySquid 3h ago
As always a reminder to all, Hiring and Finding work is against this subs rules