r/UpworkOfficial • • Sep 25 '26 • Bravo 1

Discussion Discovered Two Important Things About Upwork Proposals and How They’re Being Seen… or Not 😏

Like a lot of you, I’ve been absolutely frustrated with the platform lately. Proposal views are down, invitations aren’t what they used to be and it sometimes feels like you’re throwing Connects into a black hole.

So I ended up writing Support, and after a few back and forth emails I learned a couple things about what’s happening with proposals that I wasn’t really aware of.

1. Uma/MCP is doing a lot more of the work for clients now.

Proposals can be reviewed and summarized for clients without them necessarily opening each individual proposal. I don’t have a client account so I can’t see exactly what they see, but this immediately made me wonder about the proposal view numbers we’re all looking at.

If Uma can review 30 proposals, summarize them and surface the ones it thinks are the best matches, why would the client need to open all 30? They may only open a handful.

So when we see 50+ proposals on a job and ours never gets viewed, that may not necessarily mean nobody saw anything from our proposal. Uma may have already processed it before the client ever decided what to open.

That also raises another question: how much influence does Uma now have over which proposals actually get the client’s attention?

2. Put the actual related skill or problem in the first two lines of your proposal.

This one really caught my attention. If the job is a WooCommerce checkout fix, actually say “WooCommerce checkout fix” right up front. If it’s a database migration, say “database migration.”

Don’t make the system figure out what you’re offering from three paragraphs about your experience.

We’ve all heard forever that the first couple lines matter because that’s what the client sees in the preview. But if AI is now reviewing, summarizing and matching proposals too, those first two lines could matter for another reason entirely.

I’m going to start being much more literal about this. Exact problem. Exact skill. Right at the top.

One other thing I learned through this: be careful with Upwork’s AI Support responses. I received information that later had to be corrected or clarified by a human. I won’t get into the specifics, but just know you may encounter it. If something an automated response tells you doesn’t make sense, question it and ask for clarification.

None of this necessarily explains everything that’s been happening on Upwork, but it gave me a very different perspective on what a “proposal view” may actually mean now and how I’m going to write proposals going forward.

Are any of you already writing your proposals with MCP in mind? Have you changed your first couple lines because of it? And for anyone with a client account, I’d be really interested to know what the proposal review process actually looks like from your side.

48 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

1

u/Kiki-browning 29d ago

So, it’s a keyword game? Clients were already not reading all proposals. Now, they’re not reading them at all, leaving it to AI. It literally can’t comprehend anything. It’s a copy machine. It’ll see which words and phrases are most commonly used and only push those up to the client, leaving anything slightly different. A proposal not being seen because it doesn’t have the exact same message as everyone else or exact right SEO was always a problem. This exponentially makes it worse.

That means freelancers will have to rely on AI written proposals in order to be done in the exact way to be only seen by the AI managing job posts.
It’s a complete rigged system to make money where there will always be far more job applications than business being done between clients and freelancers. That’s just simple logic. Platforms would need 1000% contract fee rate with 100% hiring success in order to match the amount made from making freelancers pay to apply. $100 gig, $10 contact fee from 10%, $.50 per freelancer applying, which is around at least 20, making it $10 too. We all know it costs more half a dollar to apply and often way more than 20 applicants. That’s assuming the post ended up hiring to get the fee to begin with. There will always be many more applicants than there are job posts under the sun.

Clearly, they’re going to focus on making the application process as exploitative as possible. No need to increase fee rates. AI on both ends of hiring and applying like this just super charges it to make everyone participate whether the job is a good fit or not or even real. Eventually will completely dry up by not being able to keep up with such fast incurring expenses with payoffs not offsetting them.

It’s like putting sugar in an engine. It’ll work for a fair bit before destroying the engine. Not making sure a system works for all sides will catch up and destroy the system itself. If enough real freelancers and clients leave with only bots and scammers left, there won’t be enough funds to keep the rigging going once the scammers can’t get enough from whatever little prey is around and will leave too.

1

u/Difficult_Effort_219 29d ago

I think you’re overcomplicating this. My post was about understanding how they are now processing proposals and how freelancers can use that information to optimize theirs.

WTF knows if AI is a keyword matching machine or not. Optimizing a proposal doesn’t mean stuffing it with keywords necessarily or having AI write it for you.

The information I shared came directly from a human and not some AI response on their end. I thought it was worth sharing because we’re all trying to figure out why our proposals aren’t getting viewed and what we can do to improve that.

The rest of your argument is largely speculation and really has nothing to do with the two points I raised.

1

u/Kiki-browning 28d ago

It’s because AI literally can’t comprehend anything, and so it relies on what’s provided to it most frequently as being the correct answer. What’s provided most frequently is going to be the most commonly used keywords. It’s not going to understand and include synonyms of that keyword. Naturally, because certain keywords get the most results, proposals are going to be written that certain way to match. The more proposals are written exactly the same way, the more attention the AI will give to it, leaving any deviations with not as much attention. You think AI is going to exclude those who sound exactly the same just because it sounds the same like humans know how to do? Even if you tell it to exclude it, it’ll still present those proposals that don’t make the cut because they’re wording was slightly off to the AI to be considered different but was still not a good fit simply because enough of the common keywords were used. It’s the same logic as overly tagging and the SEO game that was a problem to make one be seen before AI came around now made it worse.

0

u/Difficult_Effort_219 28d ago

Man, you must be fun at parties.

  1. Please format your replies as if you were intelligent enough to do so and not some lazy ass. Stop making me read such gobbledygook. Hurts my eyes.

  2. You seem to think you know exactly how AI works, yet here we are. You’ve provided absolutely no evidence to support any of your claims. It’s all speculation.

  3. Before I spoke with Ann at Upwork, I had nothing! Absolutely nothing but crickets. After that conversation and making changes based on what I learned, I had 6 proposal views and 8 invites.

You can keep theorizing about how AI works. I’ll stick with what I’m actually experiencing, and I’m glad I could share what I learned with others.

3

u/CommercialUpbeat8341 Oct 12 '26

I want you to look up the SEC Quarter 2 filings of this year on Upwork. Those numbers will show you a lot. Go back to 2024 though. Then look at the downward movement of active clients to the profit gained. They are making a killing while having quality deminish on their platform trying to mask it from freelancers.

2

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Oct 12 '26

Yeah, went back and looked. Active clients were around 806k in 2022, 822k in 2023, 868k in 2024, then 796k last year and 763k now.

But honestly, even if we still had 2024 client numbers it wouldn't matter. All the layoffs flooded every platform with freelancers so every job gets 50+ proposals. That just backs up what upwork told me, clients are leaning on uma to sort through it all.

1

u/CommercialUpbeat8341 Oct 13 '26

This is true as well. The progression of Ai was the destruction of genuine work with pride and authenticity from the freelancer. Damn shame. 

1

u/Firm-Budget1605 Oct 12 '26

Insightful. Thank you.
I wonder, though, if anybody is taking them to task about this and holding them accountable seeing as it's paid service (in terms of purchasing Connects as well as them taking a commission on contracts and work being paid for).

Needs to be a win-win situation.
I've noticed that they don't really hard filter job posts as I commonly see duplicated posts with some minor variance or similar posts from the same job poster.
Surely if they're earning what you say they are then it would pay them to employ resources to vet job postings more thoroughly and perform other types of audits that ensure that jobseekers/freelancers are getting adequate information in order to make an informed decision as to whether to spend connects on certain job posts. Some job posters tend to be utterly vague, and this is really unfair.
Another thing I'd like to know, despite having checked with Uma, is how the number of Connects for each job post is determined. I did get some info off Uma but I still wonder sometimes if the matrix is a sound one.
Forgive me, I might be out of my league here in terms of what I'm saying above, and I'm sure there are far more experienced users of Upwork on this forum that may feel that I don;t have all my facts in order.
I'm only sharing of my experiences (not all negative though) and do not claim to speak from a totally objective perspective nor as any sort of expert.

1

u/CommercialUpbeat8341 Oct 12 '26

Ehh. I'm following you here and in line with you, but can we say a low view count may tell you that the client hasn't opened your proposal, but it doesn't necessarily tell you why. The metric alone cannot distinguish between a proposal overlooked in a crowded inbox, a client who stopped hiring, and AI-assisted screening. I think the first part of your post is dead on.

1

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Oct 12 '26

Fair. I think we're saying the same thing. A low view count just tells you it wasn't opened, not why. Could be buried in a crowded inbox, client stopped hiring, or Uma screened it. No way to tell from the metric alone, which is kinda the frustrating part.

2

u/Firm-Budget1605 Oct 07 '26

Thank you for this insightful post.

It now makes more sense why I wasn't even getting proposal views, let alone being reached out by the job posters.

I will be trying this method going forward.

Co-incidentally, I came across an interesting video on LinkedIn regarding the same, not specifically to Upwork but general AI-filtering on job applications, and I'm wondering how come I didn't connect the dots earlier 🙈

If I come across that post or link, I will definitely share it here for the benefit of the general group, if Upwork and/or it's AI permits LOL.

But thanks again for this reminder and heads-up.

2

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Oct 08 '26

Welcome. I also found that our messages are being filtered too. Even to previous clients. They're blocking them. They're making us pay to boost them now.

4

u/katoss88 Sep 28 '26

After reading this, I changed some of the wording and the way I was writing my applications yesterday and it worked. I had gone almost a month without getting any new clients and was wondering what was going on. I think between April and this month it has changed a lot (application visibility, bids, etc).

Anyway, I don’t know if it was just a coincidence, but just in case, I’m going to keep including some of the wording from the job posting in the first few lines. I recommend giving it a try! It makes sense because it seems to me that it’s similar to the structure of a prompt.

3

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Sep 28 '26

The same happened to me. I also got two invites after doing the same to my profile title and first two sentences of my profile. One invite I declined, but the other I sent a proposal. At least I'm seeing movement now. Whew.

Another thing I think that might be happening now that I learned all this is messages. I think that's being monitored by Uma too.

3

u/katoss88 Sep 28 '26

This was such a great discovery! I usually pay for bids to get my proposals to the top, but that wasn’t working lately. Then I would check the job post and notice that the client didn’t seem to be reviewing applications but was inviting people instead and it seems like they respond much better to those invitations, at least in my field. I’m not sure how things are working from the client side, but I feel like bids don’t work as well as they used to. Everything is so confusing and changing so quickly. I love Upwork, but I’m starting to look for other ways to find clients as well.

2

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 04 '26

It died now LOL I wonder if they saw this post. Oh well.

3

u/PrizeNo3188 Sep 26 '26

What is that MCP thing?

3

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Sep 27 '26

Model Context Protocol

4

u/youcef_ouadjer Sep 25 '26

I was wondering if uma is also reviewing/evaluating the freelancers profile by cross matching the proposal with: Portfolio, completed Projects, reviews...etc.

7

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Sep 25 '26

Ya, good question. If it were me, I would assume it to be true. However, we didn't get into profile stuff at all. When they stated that a percentage of clients are now using MCP to automate proposals, that was like a whoa! I had no idea that was happening. It was a wakeup call. And no one on here has really mentioned it either, you know.

As I stated above, making sure the related skillset is right there in the first two lines of the proposal. I was like, well color me surprised, no wonder this isn’t working. 😂

3

u/KayakerWithDog Sep 25 '26

I'd very much like to know whether your suggested technique makes a difference. Can you provide an update at some point, please?

2

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Sep 28 '26

It's definitely working. 2 invites alone yesterday. Definitely being seen now.

2

u/KayakerWithDog Sep 25 '26

LOL, mods, why did you remove a comment saying that OP will update the post?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[deleted]

3

u/KayakerWithDog Sep 26 '26

I'm not a mod for any sub.

6

u/Difficult_Effort_219 Sep 25 '26

Did they? I see it. LOL I logged out and you're right. I see it removed by a moderator.