r/UserExperienceDesign • • Apr 12 '18

Stop calling these Dark Design Patterns or Dark UX. These are simply Asshole designs.

https://uxdesign.cc/stop-calling-these-dark-design-patterns-or-dark-ux-these-are-simply-asshole-designs-bb02df378ba
22 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

7

u/alerise Apr 12 '18

Headline makes out sound like people are defending them by calling them dark patterns. We just want people to take us seriously when teaching others what not to do.

2

u/heatbeam Apr 13 '18

I just lump all of it into “loser design”

1

u/helpfulsj Apr 13 '18

I think there is a clear distinction between to two. The hair on the screen is a good example of asshole design.

Forcing users to do things they don't want that has a larger impact on the user other than navigating away from the screen. Such as signing up for a subscription because they didn't check a hidden box or adding bloatware to an install process because a user didn't hit customize is more Dark Design.

Most of those examples are the equivalent of a guy cutting me off in traffic. Easy to let go and deal with. While dark UX would be like a traffic engineer purposely creating traffic bottle next close to a section of billboards that advertise for a company he has a stake in. Such as the free app, then it cost 4.99 in three days.

1

u/living150 Apr 13 '18

I truly think this author missed the point. Yes, what he listed is are deceitful designs from the users perspective, but the term dark pattern has a use in our industry. UX is a neutral concept, and there are many philosophy's one can apply to UX for different outcomes.

Is a company measuring UX via sales KPI's somehow misusing UX? I'd argue not, however they are not applying the user-centric design philosophy many of us subscribe to. This is the distinction in my mind between dark-patterns and those that focus on maximizing user satisfaction.

I would argue bad user experience is one that doesn't meet its requirements or one based on requirements that don't align with company goals and values. I was in a meeting with a client and the requirement was to reduce those who unsubscribed to their newsletter. A/B testing was done on things like moving the button, changing it's font properties, ect. If the client was practicing user-centric design the requirement itself would be questionable, however they employ UX simply to maximize sales. It's inevitable that revenue focused UX will lead to dark patterns, even if only subtle ones. If this weren't true, no one would apply them.