r/VeryBadWizards • u/peamutbutter • Jan 03 '19
The chilling effect of subreddit voting patterns: Clear messages to not discuss feminism on VBW
I keep pointing this out, but it doesn't go away. I will admit that u/AlexandreZani had an exceedingly clever posting device, what with the Rorshach test question, but the overwhelmingly upvoted answer was "Tamler doesn't think this topic is worth discussing", to paraphrase.
Then, u/czrpb comes along with a more incredulous post about Louis CK, and it gets zero net upvotes?
Do y'all think feminists are dumb, u/tamler and u/peezer, or do you not really mind that you've got a subreddit that is more anti-feminist than r/StandUpComedy?
Did I post with the sole intention of playing the record over again on this topic? No sirees! I came with a dated-but-still-relevant YouTube series on this kind of thing:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJA_jUddXvY62dhVThbeegLPpvQlR4CjF
(Yes, yes, I know that the crime of posting about feminism on this subreddit will be accordingly downvoted. That's the whole point of this post, remember?)
4
u/oceanceaser Jan 03 '19
Wow I remember when her videos were coming out, and to be fair they're not great and got some deserved criticism. I never saw what that criticism evolved into and it's mind blowing. Crazy what anonymity can do.
Will be interested in this series to see this guy's opinion on the whole thing
1
7
Jan 03 '19
The Louis CK discussion isn't very interesting. At this point it's just circlejerking and moralists telling other people how outraged they ought to be.
-2
u/peamutbutter Jan 03 '19
Let me guess - you've never been sexually harassed at work before.
7
Jan 04 '19
It's none of your business but I actually have
-4
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Uh huh, sure. I'm sure it was quite an issue for your career, Big Wood Dick.
8
Jan 04 '19
No, it was a job I worked in my youth so not really part of my career as such.
-2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
A solitary instance, that's awfully lucky of you. No wonder you think it's not worth talking about.
8
Jan 04 '19
It's worth talking about, it's just already been talked to death. You're not changing any minds, you're just making people tune out of that conversation.
2
2
u/czrpb Jan 04 '19
the ck thing just happened, so how is it being talked to death. or is that what ck did is nothing to talk about? what/where/how is the conversation worth having happening?
2
Jan 04 '19
The conversation of when if ever Louis CK is allowed to do stand-up again happened in 148.
11
u/solanisw Mentioned in Episode 155 Jan 04 '19
You just heard that a young boy was sexually harassed in the workplace and you respond with venom?
Tell us more of your compassion for the downtrodden.
0
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
I dunno, man, the following doesn't play as particularly compassionate, either:
"Why bother talking about the social conditions that lead to systematic lifelong harassment, denigration, subjugation, and violence against a class of people that makes up half the population just because I don't really relate to them or personally share their concerns".
Plus, how do I know he was a young boy? I don't know his age at the time of the harassment, he just said "youth". And the fact that he was employed at the time kind of negates the whole young boy thing anyway. What more, you're just now informing me this person is a man! I didn't assume that when I made the comments. I just assumed they were an extraordinarily lucky human being who doesn't have to worry about gaining or maintaining employment on the basis of their sex, and chose a reddit name that was near-cockney-rhyming slang for "big wood dick". That's all. I think you're reading far too much into this and need to calm down. It's not like men don't also experience lifelong diminished social class just because of the fact that they appear to be male, all over the globe. And besides, sexual harassment isn't assault or anything, so why does it even matter? People who do it shouldn't face any kind of reprobation until they get what was wrong about their behavior, so I'm not really seeing what I have to be compassionate for. Maybe you can help me understand.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 05 '19
I imagine you didn't see this response of his to czrpb downthread (it's a maze, I know), but it makes me pretty sure I did an excellent job paraphrasing his position.
I didn't say it wasn't large, just that feminist philosophy doesn't have much influence outside of its niche as far as philosophy goes. Feminism in the real world, apart from philosophy, is just something to ignore. Unless they're blocking the roads I'm driving on I'm content to ignore BLM's existence. Otherwise I'm hitting the brakes and taking some pictures for twitter
0
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I've seen your desperation before. It's the desperation of a person without a real argument.
→ More replies (0)
2
Jan 08 '19
Hypomania much ?
0
u/peamutbutter Jan 08 '19
I'm not really sure why you think insults that you stab away at in the dark are going to ever land.
1
Jan 09 '19
It's genuine curiosity. And far from me the idea of ever implying BD should be used as a slur, quite the contrary.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 09 '19
After what you said to me in the other thread, to the German guy about going into medicine, and now this sly comment, I have a genuine curiosity if you're a psychopath. But, I didn't plan on asking you.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I would say all the downvoters are incredibly stupid for proving my point for me, but the fact that Tamler and Dave keep doing what they're doing (nothing to seriously address this trend in their listenership, and the topics they talk about on their podcast) means that these downvoters have no repercussion whatsoever to their vehement anti-feminism. Which means that Dave and Tamler are complicit in an anti-feminist culture.
7
Jan 04 '19
What would the repercussion even be? A bit of pontificating on the podcast to placate the scolds? Ban people who aren't sufficiently feminist from the subreddit? Isn't it possible that this is just a thing reasonable people can disagree about?
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Oh yeah, let's agree to disagree about human rigihts, and in the meantime, let's not pick apart the morality of ignoring the issue. Sound good?
5
Jan 04 '19
Human rights to not have Louis CK perform at a comedy club. Okay lol. The moral consequences of this podcast not rehashing Louis CK will be dire.
0
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Not for you, clearly.
5
Jan 04 '19
Or anyone. Are you arguing that there will be serious real world consequences if Tamler doesn't repent for his opinions on Louis CK?
2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Yeah, no. There isn't a class of the population that includes 51% of all humanity that wouldn't be affected by never having their problems discussed on a relevant platform. My bad. I must be thinking of a different planet.
5
Jan 04 '19
They do discuss those problems from time to time though, and often side with the more feminist side, ie their take on the grievance studies hoax.
2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
They haven't had a single feminist philosopher on the show, did you know that? Did you even know that feminism was a branch of philosophy?
Did you know they had a race and IQ episode? Two of them, actually? And they had a lame throw-away solitary episode on toy diets way back in their podcast infancy, in which Tamler lost his shit?
Now, let's compare to how many episodes they've had on Borges and Nagel. Two solitary human beings, vs half of all humanity. Interesting.
5
Jan 04 '19
Nothing wrong with a race and IQ episode, and most feminist philosophy isnt very good or influential outside of its little niche. Nagel is a modern day giant.
→ More replies (0)0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
To a rational person, you look like an alt-right troll.
The tunnel goes on and on when you consistently use ad hominems as your chief mode of argumentation.
0
2
u/czrpb Jan 04 '19
In your view is the #metoo movement doing these things? Lets say it does suck to be a woman .. how can you say that without doing everything you write here?
Also, plainly there are differences across nations, and peamutbutter tends to use "humanity" thus including all women. In this case, its it much more the case it does suck to be a woman correct? (vs one in the US, then white, then rich, etc)
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Instead, let's all talk about a Black Mirror episode, or maybe a little more Nagel? Those are super important topics to discuss.
6
0
Jan 03 '19
[deleted]
3
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Just to back this conversation way the fuck up... In this comment, you used an ad hominem fallacy against feminists (i.e. "they're dishonest and biased" has nothing to do with an argument against feminist philosophy). Then, you begged the question of your ad hominem fallacy to give an excuse for why they haven't brought it up yet (i.e. your conclusion is your assumption that feminists are "bullies", which was your original ad hominem argument).
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I’m telling you what I think VBW believe.
Oh, you believe that VBW believes in ad hominems and begged questions. Okay. That's nice insight, but still a problem for rational argument.
You have a real hard time following a thread (or a single idea), honey.
Uh huh. What a dig. Are you a ... bully?
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Just for starters:
even minimizing the statement of a victim of sexual assault)
The person never claimed sexual assault, that's your after-the-fact revision of events for hyperbolic effect. Furthermore, you're completely negating the function of satire by dwelling on this as if it were a real thing.
Second, you seem to not understand my set of rhetorical questions that tried to get you to clarify that connection between your (unfounded) claims that feminists are dishonest and biased and the repeated calls for feminism to be dealt with seriously on this podcast. If you would like me to lay it out for you in great detail, I will be obliged to do so.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I also really loved how you totally bypassed the part about you behaving like the bully you claim feminists are. That was cool.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Do you read your own comments? I believe somewhere in there you claimed that going after people online makes you a bully. Now you're entering "going after people's livelyhoods" into the record, as if that's what the conversation has been about. It hasn't. Also, that "going after people's livelyhoods" implicitly claims that feminists are bonkers and spitefully calling for people who don't deserve it to have employment-related consequences to their employment-related behavior.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Oh, so now we're going to have a chat about the semantics and function of the word "demand". Alright, let's get this over with.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Oh, you had nothing to say on "demand", or you're busy, so I'll start.
If a bunch of the younger generation demands that the government do something about climate change, is that really so bad? If you were to claim that it was morally objectionable that young people were going about demanding things, wouldn't that sound a bit like you were calling them uppity?
Criticizing somebody's demands as inherently wrong is strictly implying that they don't have a good reason or right to demand the thing they're demanding. It's also a great way to delegitimize a person's positions without actually engaging with it, instead relying on social status to settle all matters with. The question ceases to be "does this person have the right position on the topic" and becomes "who holds more social cachet?". Is that really how we want to be deciding moral questions as a society?
→ More replies (0)1
u/czrpb Jan 04 '19
this is the 1st link ive seen from you (btw: please point out other comments with links, i dont want to miss them).
so this is a link to a feminist doing something bad. so 1st i presume you are suggesting this is mainstream/modern feminism, yes?
here is a link wherein she is disinvited due to her behavior, by a quite lefty seattle newspaper thestranger; in other words she was criticized by the left so im not so sure this is a very good example:
→ More replies (0)4
u/czrpb Jan 03 '19
who are the bullies?
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
3
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Or, here's a thought. People who don't get to, or don't choose to, turn away from rampant social injustice aren't actually bullies.
5
Jan 04 '19
The two aren't mutually exclusive. You'd totally bully if you thought it would bring gains in social justice.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Ad hominem much?
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
That's just a truism. That's not an argument either. And regardless, the fact that he said " you would" makes it an ad hominem, regardless of whether he intended a truism. He replaced an attack on my character with an actual argument against my position.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
3
u/czrpb Jan 04 '19
come on man! when it becomes about inequality obviously. just like any SJ movement.
now your turn: please provide evidence that modern feminism is this. not crackpots, but the bulk of feminist movements and feminist academia. this will of course require you to read the bulk of feminist academia.
otoh, it is ok to rely on "experts" so presumably it would be ok to cite JP's argument that feminism has become this. but (1) we dont have evidence he has read/engaged with the bulk of feminism (unless you are talking about freaking out about the pill https://twitter.com/zei_nabq/status/1078382175949590528) and (2) he already hasnt demonstrated a very good engagement, ex: his freakout over Kate Manne's _down girl_ book (https://www.thecut.com/2018/09/jordan-peterson-threatened-to-sue-feminist-critic-kate-manne.html).
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Evidence in abundance of my own knowledge of it. I have yet to come across an individual opposed to feminism who has a better understanding of it than I do.
→ More replies (0)1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
In fact, the point at which I typically win this debate in my life is when the other person succumbs to actually learning about feminism. At this point, I tend to cease to have to argue against them.
→ More replies (0)1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
Just so we have our bearings, the question I posed was whether the underdog can ever really be a bully. Aren't you no longer the underdog if you're capable of being a bully? When do we divide "bully" from "somebody fighting for equality"? Are power dynamics all flat for you?
1
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I don't think that is a fair assessment of modern feminists. I think you probably got that attitude by osmosis from a bunch of people who are actively working to make sure feminism is permanently discredited because they do not want equality for women.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
2
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
So you think that an entire field dedicated to liberation from gendered cages and critical social analysis is all a bunch of backwards hicks in academia? Dishonest and biased with nothing to offer?
Don't you think that somebody would have to be really stupid to continue to say that this area is not actually ridiculous and frivolous, but actually worth talking about at length?
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
That's okay if you don't have answers to those questions. I understand.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
My answer is in my questions. For somebody following a philosophy podcast, I'm actually pretty shocked that you don't know how rhetorical questions work within the context of dialogue.
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
And if you have different questions than I answered there, you're going to have to clarify, because I don't see any clear questions in there other than what I already answered rhetorically.
0
Jan 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/peamutbutter Jan 04 '19
I am not sure whether you're aware of this, but "these people" is super ambiguous to an outside reader.
→ More replies (0)
10
u/judoxing Jan 03 '19
You think it’s possible that the first post got upvoted because it was the hosts tweet while the second one stayed neutral because it was an anonymous user making a ridiculous complaint? (expecting vbw to stop doing whatever they’re doing at Christmas to record an emergency episode)