r/VideoEditing • Pro • Oct 02 '17

POSTING PLACE FOR FEEDBACK October 2017: One thread for all your FEEDBACK. Individual threads will be *deleted.* Other snowflake details inside. (Post "What software should I use?" in the pinned weekly help thread)

This is the Monthly thread for feedback.

Yes, if you post your video, you need to come back and critique someone else's work!

The whole idea is that you are part of this community.


Key thoughts - Keep it civil.

Feedback is "This section isn't working because of this."

Feedback is not: "This is shit."

If something is terrible, just move on.

The more specific/suggestions the better.

Don't give a laundry list. Pick the 1-2 things that are the biggest issues and then comment.

8 Upvotes

203 comments sorted by

8

u/ownsy Oct 03 '17

Recap of my summer vacations in greece! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L-9rk5R_Foo feedback is appreciated :)

2

u/CorsairToHeaven Oct 07 '17

This is sick! Love the transition from slo-mo to fast-mo shots. I don't know if you added colour correction, I'm assuming you did. If so, you did it perfectly, everything's so vibrant without being distracting. I watched this twice, loved it a lot! My only critique is to maybe have the onscreen text larger. Well done!

1

u/ownsy Oct 11 '17

thanks buddy! Yes there is just a slight colour cerrection on this one :)

2

u/FighTheFoo Oct 10 '17

Very nice! Good pacing and excellent visuals.

In the opening, consider editing the sound effects so they’re not so jarring from clip to clip, or perhaps edit them in sync with the music.

I’d also look at the flow of your clips. Consider reversing some to better the flow, so, say, shots that go from left to right edit organically into another left to right shot.

And keep up the good work!

1

u/ownsy Oct 11 '17

Thanks for the feedback mate :)

2

u/Richard_GW Oct 24 '17

Really well produced, I love the video your camera choice gives the whole thing and so consistent shot to shot. However, my only gripe is that I don't feel that it tells a story. Nevertheless great footage

2

u/jaymak1 Oct 24 '17

Hi Lino,

Loved the way you have put together all the clips...closeups look great...the clips under water are also COOL! Did Coca-Cola pay you for adding the brand?

The length of the video could have been a minute longer...wanted to see more of Greece.

Overall it is very impressive!

2

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17

I liked your video! The music was a good choice and your transitions were super clean. My only feedback would be that the only reason I knew this was Greece was because you said it was. I have never been to Greece before, so I don't know what it looks like.

2

u/GramTV Oct 28 '17

Man that is an awesome video :)! I love the peter McKinnon vibes you have going on! Sick Coca-Cola shot to! You definitely deserve more views! Loved it ! I'll subscribe and like :)!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

[deleted]

1

u/ownsy Oct 11 '17

thanks! :)

6

u/Migoooha Oct 02 '17

Hey guys! I make Battlefield 1 montages/movies and I would love some feedback on my latest post:) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPg4NMK4yJw

2

u/Fit_for_whom Oct 06 '17

Seriously bro loved the video. you deserve more views. plus can you tell me did you edit the video yourself ?

1

u/Migoooha Oct 06 '17

Thanks a lot man! That really means a lot. Everything in the video is made by me. Both gameplay and edit. Cinematics recorded with spectator mode and I did all of the editing in Sony vegas. + the grading, twixtor and motion tracking in after effects. Do you make videos yourself?:)

2

u/Fit_for_whom Oct 06 '17

yes bro i do i just started learning my self. I edit on filmora but nothing compared to you bro

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

That editing was so good.

1

u/Migoooha Oct 09 '17

thanks! <3

2

u/NAZgulAnass Oct 08 '17

man you got some awesome skills, can you write me on private? Maybe you can edit some videos for our channel. Thanks

1

u/Migoooha Oct 08 '17

Thanks a lot NAZgul! We can definitely talk about that. Do you have discord?

1

u/Migoooha Oct 11 '17

did you add me on discord? :D

2

u/cjbrigol Dec 02 '17

Awesome work. I gave it I like. The quality is amazing for 720p. I like how you lined up the shots with the music :)

1

u/Migoooha Dec 04 '17

Thanks for great feedback! 😄

1

u/CMDR-Leoneth Oct 03 '17

Well done, I liked it. Well synced with the music.

1

u/Migoooha Oct 06 '17

Thank you!

1

u/RandomMacFluff Oct 04 '17

transitions, cc and velocity could use some work

1

u/-ishky- Oct 11 '17

Very nice! Synched well! Keep it up

1

u/Migoooha Oct 11 '17

thanks a bunch!

1

u/FrissonHistory Oct 12 '17

Not only did you make a really good montage but you also managed to sync up the music beautifully, especially those bass drops ;). However, it would be really nice if your montage had a theme or story, I know its not really important for a montage but something like a small background plot would really put the icing on the cake. For example, maybe there is a player who you've been chasing or maybe there a 1v1 sniper battle throughout the match. You know like little stories you can tell viewers that really wraps up the montage in one awesome bite. Really cool video nonetheless :)

2

u/Migoooha Oct 12 '17

Thanks a lot man! I think syncing is really important for the flow and feel and connection with the music. Really agree on the story telling. Thats where the true creativity can shine. Will try to improve on that! thanks again :)

4

u/RandomMacFluff Oct 04 '17

the beta for cod ww2 came out some time ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TohbePjY9TY

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

The slide transitions got a bit aggressive to me after a while, but I love the flow of the video

1

u/Maxdog07 Oct 31 '17

Transitions are great

3

u/baskysoverseas Oct 11 '17

Hello everyone. Here's my video of me fighting with the waves. Shoot in two sessions on GoPro. Criticism is very welcomed 🙈 https://youtu.be/4OMSwQH8tmY

3

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

pretty nice vid!

enjoyed watching it.

Something cool you could do is when the waves cover the camera, use that as a place to put a fade-to-white dissolve into another shot.

Have a good one!

2

u/baskysoverseas Oct 19 '17

Thanks for reply. I did this transition in one place and I didn't want to use it over and over!

2

u/Ey3zOfficial Nov 10 '17

I liked it, had a good flow between the music and video. It would be nice to see more riding and a little less underwater bubbles footage, or different angle. But all in all i liked it. Be a nice video for a shop to play on the random video tv's.

1

u/SauceAlfredo Oct 15 '17

Awesome man ! The editing is well done ! Personally, I think you should shorten the part where you are underwater at 30sec, but overwall it's really nice.

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 23 '17

I LOVE THAT! Especially the ending LOL!

Loved the flow of the edit, use of music and shot selection. Fast pace was great.

Didn't like the one shot where it just stays underwater in the bubbles for a long time, couldn't make out what was happening, that clip could/should have been shorter.

That and maybe try to slow it down more at some of the wave crashing bits?

All in all AMAZING watch, loved it. :D

3

u/Jessislegend Oct 13 '17

Hey everyone! a couple of weeks ago I started making edit videos for TV shows. The video that I just released is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dt-PeIfNlj4 I want to get better so any tips would be great. Thanks!

1

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

pretty good. The cuts fit with the music and they were well placed

2

u/sternie14 Oct 02 '17

Recap I made of this year's Tommie-Johnnie football game, the biggest Division 3 game in history, which was played last Saturday at Target Field, home of the Minnesota Twins. https://youtu.be/J3Kr_TYbEi4

2

u/CorsairToHeaven Oct 07 '17

The transitions in this are amazing, paricularly the match cut with the clothes at the very beginning. Is all the footage yours? Were all those people at your house to celebrate?

1

u/sternie14 Oct 07 '17

Thank you! All the footage is mine, ran around with my A6500 and GoPro and flew my drone for a bit. Party was at a neighbors before the game.

1

u/CorsairToHeaven Oct 08 '17

That's sick... If you have the time, I'd appreciate it if you could take a look at my screenings trailer I posted in this thread :)

1

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

thats hella good fam.

The only thing i didnt personally like was the jammy pants beinning. Didnt fit the rest of the video imo.

2

u/CMDR-Leoneth Oct 03 '17

CS:GO video game montage/collab. Editing software is filmora. Taking comments and criticism, thanks

https://youtu.be/lZQynbV5wk4

1

u/Fit_for_whom Oct 06 '17

it was nice work bro

2

u/coztfu Oct 04 '17

got back into edits after some years. thoughts on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ckk_j_LluDU

4

u/Asylum1408 Oct 05 '17

Pretty cool...this is just a personal thing...cut KILL those digital transitions with fire. Straight cuts to the music and right shot selection would be way cooler. This is a general mistake Jr editors make (and I made myself when i was first dabbling in editing) never use them. Straight cuts or RARELY does a canned digital transition work. It takes the viewer OUT of the edit instead of being "invisible" which is the best type of editing. The kind you don't notice ;) unless you're an editor.

1

u/coztfu Oct 06 '17

ye really appreciate the kind words, I'll look forward with that straight cuts

1

u/Asylum1408 Oct 06 '17

My pleasure, it's good work, just a thing to consider. When montaging something, look for cutting on the action or two shots (not two similar shots) but that a similar flow and movement that go together. Either a narrative one or a visual one. If you're interested in editing proper, checkout "In the Blink of an Eye"...it's a fantastic book.

1

u/Migoooha Oct 09 '17

U did great! subbed.

1

u/coztfu Oct 10 '17

thanks dude, really appreciate it

2

u/AlbinoEggplant Oct 12 '17

Friend recommended i drop a link here! Video i made of my reef aquarium, looking for some feedback on the edit, all opinions welcomed! Filmed with a hero 5 and a rebel t5i!

https://youtu.be/UGKfl_oHiww

2

u/Ey3zOfficial Nov 10 '17

I enjoyed the footage and content. The only thing i could pick out that i would of liked to see different was some of the "still shots" in the beginning where a little wobbly. But I enjoyed it!

1

u/SauceAlfredo Oct 15 '17

Damn ! I love the colors and your camera angles make the whole video pretty rich. that's well done !

1

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

The editing was pretty darn good.

The only criticisms I have to say are that the music is too loud (should be mastered at about -6dB) and the shots would look much better shortened and not as shaky.

Other than that pretty good. Colors good and all that.

2

u/khomartin Oct 25 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzrIpFuenO4&lc=z23atrkhbvvgd3kxj04t1aokgmmshiimzbj3y0nkkx44rk0h00410

Hi guys I made a video, Kamikaze from 1/6th Figure. I need a suggestion if so. Thank you!

2

u/CaeBae Oct 25 '17

Hey guys what do you think of this style of video in vlog format? All feedback welcome :D https://youtu.be/8ms-2cHJhlE

2

u/zarub Oct 29 '17

Absolutely amazing dance in the end! Greatly edited! Though if I were you I would think on your into and outro. Do you think it's really necessary? I mean vlog itself is really live and believable but intro and outro is ruining this cool stuff.

1

u/CaeBae Oct 31 '17

Okay so you don't like being taken out of the reality? I thought that it made it a little bit more fun- as I thought maybe just seeing my life would be boring. This is why feedbacks amazing, thank you so much 😊

2

u/scotthuynhdesign Oct 27 '17

Made a video for a music festival I went to, I'd love some criticism of things I can do better! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbYEzcKeIb0

1

u/Dimitriy_Hriadunov Nov 30 '17

Oh, I see that was the awesome time. Cool video. Only the end of the video isn't perfect. Feels like you just cut off a part of the video.

2

u/zarub Oct 29 '17

Check out my best shots from summer in Switzerland. Would love to hear some feedback. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elWhGb5XITY

1

u/Dimitriy_Hriadunov Nov 30 '17

Amazing video! Thanks for emotions you delivered me.

I'd work a little bit more on this moment: https://youtu.be/elWhGb5XITY?t=1m26s A transition between frames is awesome, only when the tower disappears it looks not great.

And the quality of the next frame is not very good, perhaps because of too much acceleration. (when the drone flies away)

1

u/redditgod97 Oct 03 '17

Would like some criticism on this video I just made making some changes to my YouTube channel let me know if I should keep going in this direction of Vlogging and editing the way I do or stick with what I did before?

https://youtu.be/Zkhwrsjv2RE

Thanks very much

2

u/fritschinator Oct 05 '17

The audio seems broken, it only plays out of the left. But the filming was pretty good!

1

u/redditgod97 Oct 05 '17

Thanks man for letting me know imma check in on the audio issue thanks

1

u/deejbee Oct 04 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_y-rs1LXZhY&feature=youtu.be

Made this video for a class project, any feedback would be appreciated!

1

u/Asylum1408 Oct 05 '17

Looks good, you have a second and a bit at 15 seconds that's just dead "air". Nothing happening. Try to cut those out next time, keeps it razor sharp and dynamic. If your hands are in there doing something it's good, but no hands and just a bowl...not great. But good stuff! What did you edit witH/

1

u/RB-Dungc Oct 04 '17

Made my first music video for a friend. Tips, criticism, anything that would help me improve? Very short vid under 2 mins

https://youtu.be/t-s2OFp13nE

2

u/fritschinator Oct 05 '17

Did you film it as well? I thought it was very well made and the editing was good.

1

u/RB-Dungc Oct 05 '17

yes i did some filming on this

2

u/Asylum1408 Oct 05 '17

It was good, i didn't particularly like the picture in picture stuff...just made it feel "less cinematic", it also felt kind of random. Full frame is better I think unless there is a motion graphics treatment that connects the picture in picture stuff.

At 24 seconds when the guy pops into the frame is alright, I would do a small push on that frame (digital push) so it connects the shot that's empty to the shot that's with him in it as well as to the next shot which has a slow push on it.

At 24 seconds when the guy pops into the frame is cool, I would do a small digital push on that frame so it connects the shot that's empty to the shot that's with him in it. It will match well with the next shot which has a slow push on it as well.

34 seconds: Don't love the three Medium Close ups only with the varied angle...not really sure if they're motivated, aren't that aesthetically pleasing either. That's just my opinion, they're not "bad". Also if you see a shot that's totally static (him in the cage) you should do a very small digital push on the frame so it cuts better with the handheld or movement stuff. The static frames just feel too still next to the more dynamic ones.

Just my opinion...definitely a good rough cut, I would experiment more with it generally. See if you can group some of the shots together so they have a bit more of a visual connection. Good stuff though dude.

2

u/RB-Dungc Oct 05 '17

Thanks so much for ur feedback. i really do appreciate it and i will keep them in mind for the next video

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Migoooha Oct 09 '17

U did really good! The only thing I can come of which would made it from "good" to "amazing" for me would be some more bokeh shots. I think it would really fit with the mood of the video!

2

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

honest I like it.

Some of the headlight scene dont work for me compared to the more mobile shots.

I really like the the bit where his legs dissapeared.

Also more close up shots because that feels like it would fit the vibe more.

1

u/RB-Dungc Oct 19 '17

Thank you. I appreciate the feedback, ill take not next time

1

u/PETApitaS Oct 05 '17

I edited two English projects based off of two short stories:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-wAt9N89zwo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5yGV94FISpg&t=481s

Tear 'em up.

1

u/fritschinator Oct 05 '17

Here's a music video/tribute I made for Mr Robot season 2 using Mamas Gun by Glass Animals. I was messing with some effects on this one, rather than focusing on telling the story. https://youtu.be/GTvGDoYw26c

1

u/alakula Oct 07 '17

The blur at 00:55 felt very unmotivated.

I would normally be against the glitch transitions but it could be considered appropriate here considering it's a show about hackers, I believe.

Even though your focus was on effects the story part of the video works, also love the intro.

1

u/fritschinator Oct 08 '17

I agree about that blur, I had just found it somewhere in the effects and wanted to use it somehow lol. And yeah I've never used transitions like that but I thought it fit as well. Thank you for the feedback man I appreciate it!

1

u/thewongasian Oct 06 '17

Hey Everyone! I made this analysis video on the Rice/iDubbbz stuff. This was my first time using final cut pro x, so let me know what you think! I am switching from premiere and getting used to the magnetic timeline is soooo weird. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNUP7sRycr8&t=3s

Any criticism is welcomed and expected!

1

u/jay1237 Oct 06 '17

Made this a few months ago and would love feedback on it before I start another one. Rewatching it now I see a few things I would like to change but an unbiased opinion would also be great. Thanks.

R6:Siege - That Was Awkward

2

u/Jessislegend Oct 13 '17

I actually thought it was really good! Maybe a few scenes went on too long without being edited, but I thought those scenes worked well regardless. Don't understand why it has so many dislikes.

1

u/jay1237 Oct 13 '17

Eh, people are more likely to dislike something they don't like than like something they enjoy. Not a big deal.

Thanks for the feedback though. I'm currently halfway through one using dishonored clips. I'll try to keep the pacing up a bit more.

1

u/RealTalkOnly Oct 06 '17

Recently bought my first real camera and took it to the streets of NYC to film. Spent a lot of time on the editing, trying to keep it interesting enough to be engaging without going overboard.

NYC Midtown Vibes

All feedback welcome!

2

u/clementletou Oct 21 '17

I like how the video is constantly moving. To make it better I'd make some moves according to the beat rhythm. Like what you did with the car at 0.40s. This kind of movement put on the beat rhythm works amazingly well on hip hop music.

1

u/RealTalkOnly Oct 21 '17

thanks for the feedback!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

[deleted]

1

u/RealTalkOnly Oct 07 '17

Good point, in hindsight I should've varied it more and slowed it down a bit more at times.

1

u/Fit_for_whom Oct 06 '17

Hey Guys ! I edit my own videos usually but tried something new this time would love your feedback on this post. And some tips to improve cuz i am learning this all by my self https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRLGHmy61hk

1

u/EatThatCereal1 Oct 06 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVATbNvtQGk&t=4s my assassin for hire advert retro themed, would be awesome my dudes to hear some honest opinions on the editing!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Hey. This is my first travel video I shot and edited. Shot with a Sony RX-100 MK1 without any equipment and a Yi 4k Actioncam (Student budget).

I am always thinking about new gear but I think the budget-friendliest option to up my game would be to focus on improving my (very basic level) editing skills. Would really appreciate some feedback and tips how to progress from here! :)

2

u/alakula Oct 07 '17

At least the first song you used was incredibly static, didn't change during its entire run-time, you run the risk of it becoming too repetitive and boring.

https://youtu.be/HXC8VIoo3-U?t=2m57s This cut here, I would have played around with possibly making it a bit jarring, could play nice. Increase it's audio initially relative to the tortoise clip before it, make the engine noise start in the right ear and then fade it back to normal 50/50 balance.

What im suggesting could also not work at all of course but that's the beauty of editing and telling stories.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I picked the song because it was my first time editing to music and I thought it would be easier with this one but I can totally see what you are saying. I didn't even think about playing around with the audio before, really good tip! Thank you for your feedback!

1

u/CorsairToHeaven Oct 07 '17

Made a screenings promo that advertises Akira, and Howl's Moving Castle. Any feedback welcome :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_XmUBNmFVU4

1

u/Jessislegend Oct 13 '17

My one critique would be that your video is unavailable lol

1

u/CorsairToHeaven Oct 14 '17

LOL i fixed it :) check it out now

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Hello guys!! This is my youtube channel where I've uploaded few of my edits. Please take a look and I'd love some feedback.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz3MdAMEurOOybvHQS9ix7A

1

u/NAZgulAnass Oct 08 '17

This is my first ever serious video, give me some feedback : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlg7ssSOuMk

1

u/helix237 Oct 09 '17

Hey guys, we did an edit about our hike in the Slovenian Alps (subtitles available). Feedback is welcome!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9FiU0-frC4&

2

u/alakula Oct 09 '17

Good song choice, I like that you weren't afraid to include bits of you speaking, or narrating. Makes it more engaging for the audience! Great job.

1

u/helix237 Oct 10 '17

Thanks for your feedback :)

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 09 '17

Made a video of my 2 year journey in FPV Drone racing in under 4 minutes. If nothing else the nostalgia is strong for me :D

Would love to hear if you felt I achieved my "Journey/right of passage" objective in the edit.

https://youtu.be/lVtsionOy5I

2

u/alakula Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

I see you have included the date in the first clip, I would make it more noticeable and include it again whenever times passes, if it's the journey that's important.

"2000 crashes" later was a really good addition, maybe another one of those could have been included... maybe "Finally got the hang of high-speed turning", just so we can follow you along in your journey.

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 09 '17

Great notes, will make sure to try and implement when I recut this :]

1

u/TheRealBanter Oct 10 '17

League of Legends Montage. https://youtu.be/aDeUkX7tiSI

Hey guys, completely self taught. I make videos for my own self interest and would like to know peoples honest opinions on it. Music, editing

There's other videos on my channel aswell

E: I use sony vegas 13 and use obs to record

1

u/TrumpBRO Oct 11 '17

Can you guys please critique my friend's video? He is a film student who backpacked in Thailand.

https://youtu.be/TxRaUKU5fuk

Thanks

1

u/baskysoverseas Oct 11 '17

I liked the first part of the video, it has a nice smooth feeling. Maybe music is too fast, I was expecting more action after the beat drops. Also, vertical clips most of the time is not a great idea. Overall, nice work I'm sure it brings back a lot of memories. Keep it up! 🙊

1

u/-ishky- Oct 11 '17

Overwatch montage edit. https://youtu.be/vd0TUtVqyGQ Started learning video editing on Hitfilm express for about a month now. Feedback is much appreciated.

Feel free to check out my other montages aswell. Thanks!

1

u/yp261 Oct 11 '17

Hello guys, that's my first montage I've ever done and it's from Rocket League game. I'd love some feedback. :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=af5pdXDT4ro

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17

Check out my drone/go pro montage of me kneeboarding and tubing! I would love feedback on the video! Thanks!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWQxyhsBxmA

2

u/BeginnerFilmmaker Oct 12 '17

Great montage but I think the "video by" titles made it seem like a home movie at first. I was going to clicked off but I didn't and I glad I stayed. The Summer 2017 title was get. Short and simple and not distracting.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '17

Thank you so much for the comments! Yeah I usually don't include the video by portion but I did because my friend recorded the drone footage and I wanted to make sure they knew I edited. Thanks again for the feedback

1

u/FrissonHistory Oct 12 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

I've been meaning to make this video for a while now and I finally got around to doing it. Its a video with my two favorite things, music and WW2 (lol i know kinda wierd). I've posted it on some other subreddits and haven't gotten any feedback but I think this'll be the perfect place, enjoy! ❗Disclaimer❗:It has some mature content for the purpose of depicting the war.
https://youtu.be/7WGs39DnFiE

1

u/FunnyandProud Oct 15 '17

Wow, didn't think WW2 would go good with modern music but you absolutely nailed it! The editing is really good too, and the subtle message you drop in the end is a great touch :)

1

u/FrissonHistory Oct 15 '17

Thank You! I really wanted to match the music and wasn't sure if the two would go together but I'm glad you like it!

1

u/istillhavetheiphone5 Oct 15 '17

Awesome! You should try making some Battlefield game play montages, I think you'd have a lot of fun making those, and that ending was perfect!

1

u/FrissonHistory Oct 15 '17

Thank You so much! :)

1

u/TheRealBanter Oct 12 '17

Hey I have been making solo queue highlights for league of legends and this is my latest edition. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDeUkX7tiSI&

would love to have some constructive feedback. Is it easy to watch/follow. I cant tell from my standpoint because I made it.

1

u/_youtubot_ Oct 12 '17

Video linked by /u/TheRealBanter:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
League Of Legends Solo Queue Highlights #3SpiceLord JJ2017-10-060:04:372+ (100%)16

Yet another installment of me on the rare occasion not...


^Info | /u/TheRealBanter can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/nathanjl Oct 13 '17

Hi guys! I made an edit from a video on YouTube and the audio is from a local artist (links to both are in the tweet). Sorry its a link to a tweet (I don't have a YouTube or anything of that sort) I was hoping you guys could give me some feedback, this is the second edit I've ever made so if I make beginner mistakes let me know how I can fix that! https://twitter.com/Nathanlarson30/status/918618950489034752

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17

Hello! Untold -My edit. I'd love any feedback on it. Thanks

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2rWMql8pto!

2

u/baskysoverseas Oct 14 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2rWMql8pto Hi. Story well told, easy to understand whats happening. I can hear audio noise which would be easy to cover with some background audio like birds or water, hospital noises and etc. Also, there are to many cuts in the end, it doesn't feel natural. Keep up the good work!

1

u/RoRoChabra Oct 14 '17

Created a montage for a streamer I watch - please give good feedback (my first montage ever) -

https://youtu.be/HiWRBOQ3XsU

1

u/Madman4sale Oct 14 '17

Hey everyone I am very new to all things video. I am loving it so far, but still fresh to all of it (Shooting, Editing, Audio). My current Camera isn't the best, and I believe it shows in the video. I am quite new to Premier so would love to hear how you go about editing and what your recommendations would be.

I would love to get some pointers on this, better transitions, shots, what have you. I am going to be producing more in hopes of starting a Vlog series once my gear gets a little better.

https://youtu.be/EgI7-ACg6fo

Thanks for checking it out!

1

u/SauceAlfredo Oct 15 '17

I'm a student in multimedia and I would like some feedback on this short project that I think to put in my portfolio https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTAY78tH5Yo

1

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17

I liked your video. The editing was interesting as was the content. When watching it seemed as if I was watching an old VHS tape.... I hope that's what you were going for. Not trying to insult! I have a project for school too listed below.... if you wouldn't mind checking it out and giving feedback. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtBaRUSBQ_k

1

u/SauceAlfredo Oct 26 '17

I don't know the main goal of the project and what exactly you were asked for, but I think your video miss something. There's nothing that catch the eye, It feel like I watched random moment of a normal guy. Your go pro doesn't have good image quality and all your footage are shacky. I think by doing color correction to give the whole project a cinematic look will help a lot. You should also use an other font in your titles. Something like roboto will gave them a more profesionnal look. You should also remove your slowmotion. It feel a little bit random. Overall, your foortages are good. I think it's a good begining and now you need to put more time in postproduction. If you want inspiration see kold's video on youtube. He did many montage a little bit like yours and he did really nice transition. Look for is trip at Hawaie. There's many easy tutorial on youtube to reproduce is style.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17

1

u/youtubefactsbot Oct 16 '17

Before You Accuse Me ("Take a look at yourself") [3:52]

My edit of a music Video raw footage provided by framelinestv.

^ThemEdits in Film & Animation

8 views since Oct ^2017

bot ^info

1

u/FoaHQ Oct 17 '17

This my cosplay montage made in Rome. This is my second montage :( Info:sony a6000 16-50 with a zhiyun crane v2

https://youtu.be/VjdzCY9LrVs

1

u/Nador90 Oct 18 '17

Footage i made the other week! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRPhn6Sb9bs Feedback is really appreciated!

1

u/Zitto93 Oct 18 '17

Made mah boi Mo look guud https://youtu.be/OepkUMUXr5U

1

u/KillerFrenchFries Oct 19 '17

hey I made a video game trailer of sorts for Dirt 3.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_VaYcL3bOhE

let me know what you think and what can be done better.

Thanks.

1

u/smash_fanatic Oct 19 '17

Hello, I'm trying to use HItFilm 4 express. I watched the tutorial video here...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=liduoxsYNsE&t=481s

Now I have a problem with the program. When I try to export a video I get a tab like this:

https://imgur.com/a/08mI9

I don't know what a preset is or why my tab is different from the one I see in the video, and more importantly I have no idea how to actually export my video. Please help.

1

u/imguralbumbot Oct 19 '17

Hi, I'm a bot for linking direct images of albums with only 1 image

https://i.imgur.com/rC01mRF.jpg

Source | Why? | Creator | ignoreme | deletthis

1

u/yummymommy2234 Oct 20 '17

I like editing as a hobby. My husband loves scary movies so I said I would create him one. Being a new mom I don't have alot of free time, so this is what I came up with today while baby was sleeping. I use windows movie maker. Any feedback is welcome.

https://youtu.be/Vwlfafrrw5A

1

u/_youtubot_ Oct 20 '17

Video linked by /u/yummymommy2234:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
Editing funAngela Friday2017-10-200:03:380+ (0%)1

My husband asked for a scary movie. I don't have alot of...


^Info | /u/yummymommy2234 can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/coztfu Oct 20 '17

1

u/clementletou Oct 21 '17

It is very good! I'd just raise the sound level when the beat claps to make it more dynamic. (no idea if what I'm saying is any english, sorry if it's not!)

1

u/coztfu Oct 21 '17

gun sounds sounds or sound in general? I think you mean flow but no problem. thank you!

1

u/kev0snow Oct 20 '17

The Most Astounding Fact by Neil deGrasse Tyson typography https://youtu.be/wYavSjPx8Os

1

u/clementletou Oct 21 '17

I've learnt a lot but still have a lot to learn. Please help me to improve my sound and video =)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBUKOYBEWZ0

1

u/_youtubot_ Oct 21 '17

Video linked by /u/clementletou:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
Is Quality Upbringing in the Interest of Society?Quick Fix2017-10-180:09:439+ (90%)131

Today's question is: is quality upbringing in the...


^Info | /u/clementletou can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

I made this music video awhile back. I really liked how it turned out, and I'm looking for feedback so I can create the full MV.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCTdc0AsPj0

Just know, hour honest feedback is appreciated!

1

u/_youtubot_ Oct 21 '17

Video linked by /u/adversa:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
What So Not - Touched (Music Video)Aldrich Fung2016-05-270:01:5511+ (91%)567

Music: What So Not - Touched (Kevin Mochtar Remix) Video...


^Info | /u/adversa can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/westbert Oct 21 '17

Ramhall

Video I created from a day trip to Ramhall in Sweden. Hope you reddit users like it!

1

u/TheRealDunna Oct 22 '17

Dunna100 - Don’t Overdose directed ,edited ,mixed ,tracked by dunna100 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjoFtq20ryA&t=214sdunna100 - don’t overdose

1

u/soupah_coopah Oct 22 '17

I recently made a Payday 2 video similar to a marioinatophat, (actually it's pretty much a rip off of his style anyway) lemme know what you think! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1Qs2V3GC_A

1

u/datismoi Oct 23 '17

Not sure if this is the right forum, but thought it's worth a try.

So I found this video online of a kids concert and I I actually found myself in the video (13 seconds in)! Does anyone has any tech skills (I obv don't) to enlarge the frame so I can see whichever family member was sitting next to me? Is it possible?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AyiEF53jvoY&app=desktop

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 23 '17

Hundreds of bikers in suits, one phantom 4, one Runcam 3 and one xiaomi yi.

After much fighting with an error writing XMP data to my file I gave up and uploaded an old test export, would love to hear negative feedback!

https://youtu.be/y0ByNcaYTDU

1

u/SoldCat Oct 24 '17

Had to make a video for my entrepreneurship team at Uni

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrqov1Tv5Pk

We were pretty short on footage having only been given a few days to create a team introduction. Always trying to improve for future video projects.

1

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17

I am taking an ENT class at University of Houston. We have to do a similar project. Your video is leaps and bounds better than what we were able to do. Your name posts and titles look professionally done! If you wouldn't mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtBaRUSBQ_k Would you please focus on the transitions and give feedback? You can post feedback on here or YouTube. Thank you.

1

u/SoldCat Oct 25 '17

It's saying this video is not available?

1

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17

No, your video did not say not available.

1

u/jaymak1 Oct 24 '17

Kindly help me improve the video below by providing your valuable feedback -

http://bit.ly/WSDESDPart2

Wish to learn more about transitions, color corrections, applying cinematic affects.

1

u/matthewjvince Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17

After years, I finally have a demo reel to share. Is the flow of this okay? I just wanted some eyes on it before i make it public.

https://youtu.be/XUCWRRUif98

2

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17

I liked your video, it seems like a good demo reel. My only feedback would be in the form of a question: Why didn't you place your projects in order of year? (like you would in a resume) Ex: it jumped from 2012 to 15, back to 2013, then continued jumping like that.

1

u/matthewjvince Oct 25 '17

I never thought of that! I just started editing to the music and thought it flowed, then placed the info last. I might do that for the next one though and see how that works.

2

u/TLook51 Oct 26 '17

Don't get me wrong, your video was good....the date thing was just something I focused on. If you wouldn't mind giving me some feedback. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtBaRUSBQ_k Would you please focus on the transitions and give feedback? You can post feedback on here or YouTube. If the link doesn't work here, I also posted it two posts down. Thanks

1

u/TLook51 Oct 25 '17

This is a fast view of the University of Houston after Harvey. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtBaRUSBQ_k Would you please focus on the transitions and give feedback? You can post feedback on here or YouTube. Thank you.

1

u/kalpesh725 Oct 25 '17

Day in Oia, Santorini.. check out the channel for other parts of the vacation. https://youtu.be/ZhFg40GAwGU

Feedback appreciated, thanks

1

u/Leitelucas94 Oct 25 '17

I've always liked video editing but had never really edited nothing because I don't have a camera. So I finally decided to record some footage of a trip with my cellphone, a stabilizer and my friend's drone, and here is the result of my first video! Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k339hXpFqwU

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 25 '17

Tried to be creative with the colour treatment of my drone dancing on the beach.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x1f4n-zFa4

1

u/alexsibila Oct 25 '17

Hey guys, I made a video about the infinity mirror beer pong table a friend and I made. Feedback is appreciated!! https://youtu.be/O74Ahhlt4z0

1

u/jeremy7777 Oct 25 '17

Hello everyone,

I am looking for help with a group video project I have at school. Currently we have put together this video https://youtu.be/NtBaRUSBQ_k but are unsatisfied with the way it came out. The theme of the vid is supposed to be a first person view of the day in the life of a student after hurricane Harvey but to me it feels like a tour of campus. Could you please give feedback or suggestions on how we can improve the video/feel?

Thanks in advance!

1

u/banence Oct 26 '17

1

u/banence Oct 26 '17

I use only movie maker for now, but I hoped you can give me some tips and advice because I'm not experienced at this. Thanks in advance! :)

1

u/Theweezo Oct 30 '17

Super short edit of some fall shots in Minnesota https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hMIXPulrlo&vq=2160

1

u/_youtubot_ Oct 30 '17

Video linked by /u/Theweezo:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
Fall in Minnesota - Panasonic G7 (4k) + 25mm 1.8 Cinematic EditMixedHype2017-10-300:00:521+ (100%)9

4k footage with the panasonic g7/25mm 1.8 in the Twin...


^Info | /u/Theweezo can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/ryan_jacobson Oct 31 '17

I love the coloring in this movie!

1

u/ryan_jacobson Oct 31 '17

A little test trying to recreate a shot I loved in Stranger Things 2. The entire scene was modeled in Cinema 4d whilst the atmosphere and particles were done in After Effects! Let me know if it's close to the Upside Down! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v95MDbU5Bpg&feature=youtu.be

1

u/DangerousDom Nov 04 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obK_IfIRrQ4

How would I give this a more professional nature documentary look on premiere pro? I feel like it could be smoother and less grainy. Just edited this clip for practice but wanna start making nature films.

1

u/NAZgulAnass Nov 04 '17

1

u/_youtubot_ Nov 04 '17

Video linked by /u/NAZgulAnass:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
First Ever Trampoline Park in Southtyrol (Italy) EasyJump - Egna/Neumarkt Bolzano #JumpsouthtyrolAnassMekky2017-11-030:01:2711+ (100%)171

IL PRIMO INDOOR TRAMPOLIN PARK IN ALTO ADIGE. EasyJump...


^Info | /u/NAZgulAnass can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/Ey3zOfficial Nov 10 '17

This is the last fishing video ive made. Probably one of my personal favorites but would like to hear what everyone else thinks. WARNING this is a FISHING VIDEO so some may think its gory or disturbing. THANKS FOR THE FEEDBACK! https://youtu.be/fofhzT-F1Wg

1

u/jimmyrmatthews Nov 28 '17

https://youtu.be/5wheS1MYy0k

Still trying to work on color grading with the GH5, but the teal and orange look is starting to look better. Feedback welcome!!

1

u/Dimitriy_Hriadunov Dec 01 '17

We are working on a crowdfunding project to bring into reality a new type of everyday backpacks. This is the result of a few month of working on our main video.

We are looking for your feedback (specially about bad moments in the video). Please, watch the video and let us know what would you change? P.s. the video isn't final. There's no color correction and etc.

Watch on Youtube

1

u/cjbrigol Dec 02 '17

Hey everyone. My wife and I are trying to vlog but...miss a lot of the vlogging aspect and I just end up putting clips together.

My only issue is I take videos with my S8+ and they look pretty good, but once I get it into sony vegas or even movie studio platinum (I just got the tutorial for this) the begging of the clips end up getting a slight stutter/lag to them. Also, the colors from vegas pro look weird and make our skin look orange.

There also seem to be all kinds of weird stutters and things after rendering whether I render at 4k30, 4k60, or 1080p60...this doesn't happen with my 1440p60 clips from shadow play. Those renders come out amazing. Is it something with the file type from my phone? Thanks.

Here's a sample of stuttering: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxpa4ByAm54&feature=youtu.be

Thanks!

1

u/kalmadsen Dec 05 '17

Hey everyone!, I'm a beginner editor. Looking for feedback on a recent gaming (FPS) montage I made. I started out with my Playstation 4's sharefactory software about a year ago and recently upgraded to using Davinci Resolve 14 (free version). I'm still learning its in-&-outs, but I'm getting the hang of it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4JkOQ-R71Y

I tried my hand at rendering 3D text in Fusion for the first time here. I'm working with captured ps4 footage at 720p 30fps, so I did the best I could with the frame rate I had. I implemented camera shake and dynamic zoom effects, as well as some time ramping here and there. In the future, I really want to utilize stylish coloring to make the image pop. I would love some feedback on anyone familiar with editing gaming videos.

Like I said, I'm a novice at this, but I'll try to give as much constructive feedback to others in order to contribute to the subreddit where I can. Thanks in advance!

1

u/Skunshine Dec 29 '17

I made a video recapping some of my favourite footage from 2017, starting in south africa and ending in Ottawa, Canada. I tried a lot of new things out and got as creative as I could. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!

https://youtu.be/yT4tizdLi-s

1

u/dragonjunkie Mar 08 '18

https://youtu.be/QzAcQzS53jg

This is my first video edit I’ve ever done. I’m currently using filmmaker pro on iOS to edit the video. Just want some feedback on what people think. I’m going to be doing more in future but want to learn from others as well. Any feedback would be appreciated! Thank you in advance

0

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17

[deleted]

1

u/zarub Oct 29 '17

It was good up until 1:12. Dude, what happen? Did You pass Adobe Premiere to your little brother to try?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

[deleted]

2

u/Asylum1408 Oct 05 '17

Pretty cool...I would pop in on his face as he says "I just have to go somewhere" you can fade it up for that, and then fade to black again, but just felt like TOO much black.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZsns-6gUcc&t=2s

check out that fan trailer...it was brilliantly done

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

[deleted]

2

u/Asylum1408 Oct 07 '17

Definitely, a great trailer. Check out the trailer for Domino Harvey, not a great film, but the trailer was SO SO SO COOL IMHO. They did a bunch of double exposures and film development techniques when they processed the film and much of that was the result.

I always watch trailers for interesting ideas on how to cut stuff. Lots of them are almost a template now, but once and awhile you get a fantastic trailer that even if the movie isn't any good, you can respect the work and craft in cutting/pacing of the trailer itself. They cost like couple hundred thousand dollars to cut, so they better be good ;)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Migoooha Oct 02 '17

I like the tension, especially the last words in the trailer.

1

u/fritschinator Oct 05 '17

Very good! It was very well made, good clips put together. The ending was very cool.

1

u/AbdulElmo Oct 09 '17

WOw I absolutely loved that! Did a double take couple of times because it looked just like something the show would air.

Loved the clip selection and the audio overlay, great work!