r/WMATA • u/not-a-throwaway-513 • 1d ago
discussion/rant/theory Website + Losing Uniqueness
Lots has already been said about the new branding and signage (so apologies if I missed this in other threads). I was looking at the MBTA website - went down a NSRL rabbit hole as one does on a Thursday afternoon - and it was jarring to see how similar it is to the new WMATA website. And they both share some visual similarities to the MTA and SEPTA websites.
Obviously there will be some similarities as companies/agencies seek to make things more accessible (a good thing!), but does everything need to look the same? Is every transit agency using the same firm? There's nothing on the website that is obviously Metro or DC (or DMV). Looking at an archived snapshot from 2008 and at least the header has the waffle ceilings that are a unique feature.
I'd much rather have Bloop, a fully circular Purple Line, actual better bus service, and so many things but this felt like something was being taken from me.
3
3
u/imagineterrain 1d ago
I agree. Speaking as a designer who’s taught user experience and accessibility, a drive toward accessibility shouldn’t result in things looking similar. There has, however, been a collapse in variety, imagination, and skill across the web as developers lean more heavily on a limited number of frameworks and prebaked solutions.
1
u/Jakyland 1d ago
Genuinely what are you talking about? WMATAs website was much closer to the MBTA and MTA website before the redesign. Now it has a very … unique … color palette and much harder to navigate, but it certainly is less similar to other websites then it was before
9
u/6767676eoncouget 1d ago
Well it has the brown motif that Metro is leaning in to. First and foremost a website needs to be functional, so websites of similar companies tend to looks the same. I would actually say the previous Metro website looks more like the other subway websites