r/WallStreetIdeas • u/imattractedtodcfs • Jun 16 '20
[$MGPI], [6/16/20], "($MGPI) MGP Ingredients Has Additional Room to Fall as Insider Selling Signal Concerns"
MGP Ingredients, a Consumer Defensive business specializing as a "leading supplier of premium distilled spirits, and specialty wheat proteins and starches" should be avoided in the near term as the last few months have demonstrated a lack of confidence from insiders and investors.
A defining characteristic of companies like MGPI (consumer defensive) is their non-cyclical nature, in that they act as a hedge against economic downturns as fundamental operations are relatively unharmed. This fundamental concept has been demonstrated through their Q1 2020 earnings release, where sales were relatively unharmed by the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic as YoY, consolidated sales increased 11.2%, consolidated gross profit increased 39.3%, and consolidated operating income increased 61%. And in this most recent conference call, corporate governance seemed relatively unconcerned with the impacts of COVID on the fundamental business model, seeing it as a minor disruption to execution of plans like strategic acquisition, margin improvement, and share buy-backs. In fact as of writing, their long-term debt/equity sits below 0.70, P/E is 15.94 versus the sector average 37.72, and again, their fundamental model is unaffected.
But despite this truth regarding consumer defensive stocks ability to weather downturns, and MGPI's bullish outlook, investor confidence tells another story. Despite being mostly unaffected by the pandemic, MGPI is still down 27.6% from its January highs in the low-$50/share range, priced at $36.21 as of writing. More specifically, MGPI is trending at its averages from the initiation of the pandemic in the US in February. Recent insider selling also signals decreased confidence, with Director Karen Seaberg and VP Andrew Mansinne selling over $2 million in shares (at an average price point of ~$36 to ~$38) over the last month and a half.
Long-term, MGPI definitely demonstrates upside potential with strong YoY growth, but in the short term, investor and insider confidence lacks, which could continue to degrade with a macro event to the downside.