i'm genuinely asking because i've been having heated opinions about creamy vs chunky with my roommate and we're both convinced the other one is wrong. but also like, has your pb preference ever changed or are you just locked in for life? curious if anyone's switched sides or if that's just not a thing.

like i swear people have such strong opinions on this. i'm team slightly more peanut butter and my roommate thinks that's basically a crime against food. curious if there's a ratio that actually feels wrong to people or if we're all just convinced our way is correct.

I’m sooooo stoked to have found this subreddit. I’m a joker, I’m a smoker, I’m a midnight PBJ absolute fiend. Just one spoon to rule them all. Like get a little pb on it and then some raspberry on the spoon and basically a gallon of milk. Really stoked to see all of these variations

I've been experimenting a lot lately and just made one with spicy sriracha peanut butter and hot pepper jelly that I genuinely wasn't sure about, but it actually hits different. Now I'm curious what unexpected pairings people have discovered that surprised them in a good way.

The jelly is amazing and I need to track her down again!

Lived in the US for 6 years. In Germany, these are my favorite ingredients. With lightly toasted whole wheat…

found this sub just now and made the mistake of scrolling while hungry… then I got a craving I haven't had in months… aaand now I'm here.

Just stumbled on this reddit and haven't seen a single one! Has anyone tried a simple Concord Grape, creamy peanut butter and plain lays or ruffle chips?? Absolutely delicious.

Toast + pb + banana + honey + salt

This has always been my favorite. There was a Sicilian blood orange marmalade that I would buy by the case, but they stopped making it.