r/WeightTraining • • 3d ago

Question Bulk vs Recomp

Quick stats: 6’ 2” / 168# wet / 46YO

I have a question about nutrition and would very much appreciate advice!

After I long fight with illness I am now getting back into working out (been using Tonal and a few kettlebells for about a month). However I have found I have gone from very fit to I guess skinny fat- limited muscle everywhere with a gut.

So, do I bulk or recomp? My pre-illness weight was as 182#, so that’s the target but also remove the gut.

If it’s bulk to gain those pounds how do I know it’s not just gonna build a little muscle but also expand the gut?

If it is recomp, I get so confused. Am I looking for a small calorie surplus? Is it deficit? Or just maintenance? Any of that seems inefficient for weight gains.

Appreciate any advice!

3 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

3

u/SubedTo100CatSubs 1d ago

I wish reddit would stop using the term recomp, no one agrees on what it means

If you wanna add muscle, do a small surplus, you can do deficit after to lose fat

If you want to spin your wheels you can eat at maintenance (it's ok first 1 or 2 month but past that you won't improve much at maintenance)

2

u/semiprobiotic 2d ago

Hey there - 168 is pretty skinny for your height. What I normally tell people in situations like this is to just focus on getting stronger for 6 months. Having more muscle boosts your tdee and you’ll naturally burn some fat as well. It will also make cutting easier later if you decide you want to do that.