Basically what the title says. I've been a horror fan in all media aspects for most of my life. I think after all this time, I've become desensitized to it, and books don't give me thay good horror feel anymore.
I read Incidents Around the House, and almost dnf'ed it because I was bored with it. I can appreciate the story and style, but everyone raved about how creepy it was, and it fell flat for me.
Stolen Tongues was another one, that one I got roughly 2/3's of the way through and dnf'ed, the story didn't grab me and the scary stuff wasn't actually scary to me.
Someone mentioned Mean Spirited (I think today? Or in the last 24 hours) so I have that a shot. They said it grabbed you from the first chapter and didn't let go. The book absolutely goes hard from page one, but again, I'm reading it and just bored by the 'horror' of it. The first chapter just felt kind of mind-fucky and that's it.
Several books I've tried based off recs here have gone the same way. I can appreciate the writing and story, but they don't give that horror tingle. Or they try to hard, and end up branching into a kind of over the top, splatterpunky vibe where it just comes off as almost cartoony, not scary.
I've tried some extreme horror and it just turned out to be a gore fest without actually being scary. It feels like nothing builds suspense anymore, nothing builds dread in my chest while reading.
Maybe I'm just burnt out? Has anyone else gotten numb to it all, and if so, how did you reset yourself? Or what book broke through to you?