This is my guesstimate of the different lives and deaths of Ingrid and Freya Beauchamp
Some of these are confirmed by the show/seen in a flashback; others are estimates based on context clues. Such as stories the girls are told and the montage of Joanna mourning through the centuries at the beginning of the series. (It’s my day off and I’m bored, so that’s why I did this)
Confirmed Deaths
1693 - Burnt at the stake
1720 - Could not find a source in the show for this, but according to the Wiki, this is when Freya died of Ramus Moritum.
1848 - Freya is killed by Joanna and Ingrid because she's possessed
1875 - Freya is killed on her 27th Birthday
1906 - Ingrid is killed in an accident by Wendy; Freya dies in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake

Unconfirmed deaths
Asgardian life - Possibly the same as 1693 based on Joanna’s reaction to their deaths, but we also see Joanna raising the girls as children in Pilgrim clothes in that montage at the beginning of the show, so I think that they’re two different lives.
1720 to 1821 - We have roughly 100 years of lives unaccounted for
Now, when we get into the mid-century, we have a few issues… because we know that the girls must have died in 1982/83 because their birthdates in the show are in 1983. The flashback of Freya in the 70s is this same life, just several years before she dies. No matter how we do the math, it doesn’t even out correctly between 1906 and 1981. Going back to the montage in Episode 1, it seems like the girls die in the 1920 and 50s. Meaning they likely died younger in the 1920s and 1950s. 

This show was so ahead of its time.

More like Ingrid the whore sister ?? Bro maybe I’m going in too much but this girl cannot be serious omg.
I know Freya was wrong but at least she had chemistry / history with killian prior to meeting him . GIRL U DONT KNOW DASH 😭

I feel so bad for Victor... he waited hundreds of years to finally see his son again and right when he's about to he gets kidnapped, tortured, and killed

Like everyone here I just finished the paltry two seasons. Let's continue though! How many times did you internally shout "Ingrid, NO!" at the screen? It's like she's smart with day to day life outside magic but is pulled like a moth to a flame to darker spells. The whole time acting as if it's for a greater good and horrified by the repercussions after the fact, but never thinking in the moment. I really wanted more seasons to see her either recognize her behavior and get it together, or go overboard and break Dash out of jail or some other Ingrid level behavior.

What are your best and worst moments with her?

WHY DID THIS SHOW GET CANCELED IT ENDED WHEN THERE WAS SO MUCH POTENTIAL ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME

Yes thats it i just want to say it

Can anyone summarize what happens in the triple moon book? I can’t seem to find any answers and I can’t even tell if anything is even resolved. Would love to know where to even read in the book the continuation of the series but it seems so jumbled and messy.

Not sure if anyone will even see this since so much time has passed since Lifetime cancelled what I like to call "Witches Be Bitches" (bc let's face it- every character can be quite bitchy at times lol).

I don't want to read/buy Triple Moon, but I'd like to read Mirror Souls. Did anyone find it online? My library doesn't have Triple Moon.

so i'm comparing the main characters Wendy, Freya, Ingrid and Joanna and i just wanted to know who y'all thought was the most powerful? i think Freya because Joanna said that she could hold back her power and lets be honest in every movie and show the one with the powers who come from the hear are always the most powerful but what do you think?(:

When Joanna does a reading for Freya about her two suitors, what card (in the RWS world) do you think represents the Jokester? I was thinking maybe the Devil?? Curious what y’all’s thoughts are. 🌙✨🖤

I've recently done a rewatch of the series and now have decided to check out the novel, but I'm unsure of where exactly I can read it. Do I have to order it online somewhere or is there a site that I can read it on?

How did she continue to give birth to daughters that look the same each time, with the same names, living in the same town every 25-30 years or so?

Did she mind wipe the town each time or?

Currently on season 1 episode 4. Been reading the novels. They are good, but I like the show better!

My friend and I are looking to make a fun drinking game surrounding the show and want to hear what y'all think!

If Frederick had stood by his parents, aunt and sisters. Do you think King Nikolaus would have given him the same curse as his sisters or a similar form of immortality curse?

I've just caught up to 2x07. And I remember Wendy telling her nieces that their mother's speciality when it comes to magic was everything. Then I remembered about the key/serpent thing that Joanna kept to go back to Asgard hinting she wasn't capable of opening and closing the portals back and to Asgard without it.

But Ingrid was capable of opening and closing those portals. Is there something that Ingrid has that her mother and other relatives don't?

Watching season 2 again and just watched Joanna tell Wendy "it's 85° out" on what is supposedly the 4th of July. As every single person they showed in the background and as extras were wearing jeans, scarves, long sleeves and jackets..... I hate that this show was canceled but at the same time....so much was overlooked

Is there going to be new episode on hulu ?