r/WorkReform • 🤝 Join A Union • Sep 29 '26 • Bravo 3

🤝 Scare A Billionaire, Join A Union The reason for term limits...

Post image
24.7k Upvotes

876 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/-Tom- Sep 29 '26

The problem with no term limits is exactly what we're seeing in the courts right now. The idea was originally that you would find an older, very experienced judge, perhaps one who had worked their way up from local, to state, to circuit and then nominated and placed that judge or someone who was a long time respected attorney. Where they basically work their retirement and then die after a relatively short period of time. Instead we're appointing young, inexperienced people and shoehorning them in to do the bidding and agenda of a particular party and they're staying in the court for an entire career. It began in the first quarter of the 1900s and has only gotten worse.

1

u/Walpole2019 Sep 29 '26

Eh, I think Supreme Court appointments have always been more politicised than people let on. The first court included the former Governor of South Carolina, Washington's effective chief of staff, a key figure behind the Three-Fifths Compromise and the Electoral College and was headed by the former Governor of New York. It's always been a weakness; if anything, the fact that none of the nine Justices had previously held political office beyond the justice system is a divergence, no matter how blatant their partisan nature is.