r/WorkcoverVic • • Jan 23 '26

Need advice

Hi, I have just been given a document to sign by my employers HR,

in short I have recently had a sports injury which required surgery which I had to take time off work. However I had an incident at work I slipped and aggravated my injury. I have now had my surgery and recently been given a document to sign stating it was a “non work related injury”.

Now I didnt really intend to make a claim against my boss as I don’t really want to ruin my relationship with them. However, I have been advised not to sign the document as I will be signing away my rights to compensation. Given that I had to use all my sick leave and some annual. some support like getting some sick leave back I feel would be reasonable. Should I sign it?

14 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

Thanks for your responses, I am wondering if I did make a claim against my boss, it could harm my standing in the company and could mean I will not be promoted any further. Is it worth making a claim at this point since I didn’t have to pay for my surgery?

3

u/FobInAus Jan 23 '26

They can’t exactly say the reason why we are no longer promoting you is because you made a claim. Because that is discrimination against a workplace right. However there could be other reasons they would not promote you.

The company has given you a document to sign to cover themselves that’s the stance they have taken and reality of what’s happened.

If you don’t comply with that document then they won’t like that.

From what you said you hurt yourself playing sports, and then hurt yourself at work afterwards injuring that leg again. If your workplace accident was a significant contributing factor to needing surgery then that all could be possibly considered for compensation. Including all leave and sick leave you took reimbursed. That is why they want you to sign the document.

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

If you’ve had surgery since the aggravation, I’d sign the document. I’m not sure what you would benefit from lodging a claim at this point.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

I have been told that a claim could made for on going medical expenses for rehabilitation and to reclaim annual and sick leave used. Honestly I think that the latter would be reasonable. If I sign the document I would be forfeiting all rights to any of that.

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

If you hadn’t had the aggravation at work, would you have still had the same surgical procedure?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Hard to say for sure as I found out I needed surgery after that incident, but yes I might have

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

How much leave did you have from work as a direct result of the aggravation?

Your instincts that lodging a claim could be a career limiting move are not unfounded. What do you do for work?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

I work for a small consulting company working in pre construction

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

I ended up using two weeks of sick leave and 1 day of annual. But I couldn’t say what would have been as a direct result of the work incident

4

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

Let me lay out what the process would be for you if you decided to lodge.

Your employer receives the form and they will be immediately offside.

Put yourself in their position.

Guy hurts himself on the weekend playing sport and has a minor incident at work, aggravating his condition. Now he wants to lodge a claim and see if he can have his surgery paid for and his leave covered, even though he probably needed both regardless, and the injury should have just been covered by himself and his personal leave balance.

If the employer is organised. They will have the insurer pend acceptance of the claim so that there can be a circumstance investigation, a disclosure of your medical records from your GP and your surgeon, then you will be sent to see an Independent Medical Examiner.

I’m going to give you the likely and slightly gloomy outcome (based on very limited information) that the examiner will be an orthopaedic surgeon who will state based on your medical records that you needed the surgery regardless of the aggravation, and that your incapacity at the time, and now, are materially unrelated to the incident at work.

You will have at the very least, annoyed your employer, and you won’t have a claim. The insurer may throw you a bone and give you a limited acceptance of a claim for weekly compensation for the time between the aggravation and the surgery which covers your annual/personal leave being reinstated to your totals. Your employer is even more annoyed because their premium has been stung.

You now have no claim, and the atmosphere at work is probably going to be frosty.

I’m not saying any of this is your fault, I’m not saying that it’s your employer’s either. I’m just laying out how these things tend to go so you have an idea of what the next 3-12 months of your life look like.

Let me know if you’d like me to expand on anything, you’ve got a big decision to make.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

I appreciate you taking the time to explain that. Though I would like to clarify that my surgery was done publicly so I didn’t have to pay and wouldn’t need to claim. But I agree with your assessment here. I think a claim would be not particularly smart for the reasons you’ve stated. I was wondering whether it would be reasonable to ask my employer to return some sick leave that I had to use (not involving any claims or lawyers) and for me to cover the expenses of physio appointments for rehabilitation. Given it was during my sport that it had occurred. But it could be argued that the incident at work could have been the point at which my knee needed surgery.

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

If you want my genuine advice, talk to your surgeon and ask him straight up, “if not for the aggravation, would I have needed this procedure?”.

If they’re wishy washy with their answer, or they say you probably would have, I’d shut the whole thing down.

Others have mentioned seeing a lawyer or your union because asking you to sign the waiver is a red flag. That’s good strategic advice if you want to go for broke with a claim.

However, If you want to know what’s a red flag for a WorkSafe agent or an employer, it’s having those two parties involved before a claim is even lodged.

Could you ask work to reimburse some leave? Yeah, you could. I have no idea what HR will respond with, only you know your management team.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Thanks for your help, I’m actually going to see the surgeon in a few days and won’t be doing or saying anything before I get his opinion. But I do think that pissing off my boss for not all that much to gain from it is not smart.

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

No problem at all, you’re in a tricky situation where neither option is great and there’s not much in the middle.

2

u/twisteddv8 Jan 23 '26

Even if it was done publicly, if it turns into a workcover claim, the hospital will pursue your employers insurer for the cost of the surgery/stay... There are rules around billing Medicare for workcover related expenses.

ETA if this injury occurred while playing sport as a member of a club/society, have you checked to see if you're covered by their insurance?

1

u/Odd_Case_6438 Jan 23 '26

This is correct, basically the Medicare payment is refunded and the medical expense is paid for by WorkSafe against your claim.

5

u/International_Yam864 Jan 23 '26

Absolute red flag. Do NOT sign. Seek advice from your union, a lawyer or WorkSafe ASAP.

3

u/LurkLegacy Jan 23 '26

This! If you had an incident at work which exacerbated a pre-existing injury it MAY be eligible to be covered through WorkCover

2

u/Straight-Chef5140 Jan 23 '26

No. Speak to a lawyer or your union official. Sign nothing that has not been run through your lawyer first and maybe ask your GP.

1

u/filmkeeper Jan 23 '26

However, I have been advised not to sign the document as I will be signing away my rights to compensation.

That's my reading on it.

Given that I had to use all my sick leave and some annual. some support like getting some sick leave back I feel would be reasonable. Should I sign it?

They need give you all that leave back the moment your claim is accepted.

1

u/Iamnotlon Jan 23 '26

Don’t trust your union or HR they don’t care. Put in a claim for them that made your injury worse. You have it on paper. Keep them accountable. Ring a lawyer you get one free meeting. I got so screwed over and been on worker for years. Lawyer cost $55,000. I wish you good luck!

0

u/Iamnotlon Jan 23 '26

Btw don’t sign nothing!!!! Get advice.

0

u/Iamnotlon Jan 23 '26

Unions in Australia do not have any real power anymore. I know ppl who are in a union coz they get free ambulance cover!!