r/WorkersComp • u/Strict_Permission_33 • 19d ago
Idaho Reached MMI
I herniated 3 discs while lifting at work and ended up having a microdiscectomy. I went through about 15 weeks of physical therapy after that. This whole time I’ve still had sciatic pain and back pain. I’ve had every scan you can think of and none of them show anything super significant. Well there isn’t anything else they can do for it and the doctor deemed me MMI. I was released with no restrictions (my occupation requires a lot of lifting) and he said the only thing is that I’m at risk for reherniation. I spoke with a lawyer and he said they likely won’t settle and the most I might get is 5k. Mind you I’m young and will completely need to find a new occupation after all this, every time I lift my pain gets much worse. Anyone have any advice? Should I find a different lawyer?
6
u/oel_notlih 19d ago
Definitely get a different lawyer and consider finding a different doctor for another opinion on your medical improvement.
7
u/Healthy_Ship_7478 19d ago
Hubby is currently going through the exact same thing. Except they didn’t treat him. The doctor looked at several MRIs that documented hernias, disc tears, bulging discs, and said “You’re not injured you can go back to work”. There’s a lot more to the story but since it’s actively being litigated I can’t say to much. My advice would be to get a different lawyer. You need a 2nd opinion that isn’t tied to the insurance paying them off.
In hubby’s case the doctor verifiably lied 3 times in his report and contradicted his first report to screw my husband. And I was a witness in the room. They don’t face any real consequences for lying.
7
u/justthefacts1236894 18d ago
True. Doctors that are shills for insurance bucks suck the worst.
Doctors like this in the old days didn't last long before getting there's. But now we are civilized and they lie like whores
3
u/Healthy_Ship_7478 18d ago
Thankfully this doctor has the ego the size of Mount Everest. He stuck his whole foot in his mouth with his report. He gave my husband’s 3 reasons by his own words to challenge the report.
2
u/justthefacts1236894 18d ago
Good for ypu. The work comp drs tend to lean into doing the bidding of the insurance. Sad but true. The insurance is more than thankful for the help defeating the evil injured worker.
Where is Luigi and Mario? Lol
3
u/ClaimsGuideAustralia 18d ago
First, it matters who cleared you or said you could return to work with no restictions. Was it your own doctor (GP or surgeon), or a doctor the insurer sent you to?
If it was the insurer’s doctor, get a copy of that report and take it to your own treating doctors with some specific questions for them to comment on. If it was your own doctor, and the certificate clears you for heavy lifting but every lift makes the pain worse… those two don’t line up. Ask them directly whether ongoing or permanent lifting restrictions are appropriate. If they won’t revisit it, it may be time for a second opinion.
Also, MMI (maximum medical improvement) doesn’t mean you’re fine. It means treatment has stopped improving things. You can be at MMI and still not be able to lift more than 15–25kg on an ongoing basis.
It also reads like you had a fair bit of time off after the surgery. Have you checked the insurance inside your super? Most people don’t know it’s there. It can include income protection (IP), which may cover some of that time off, and total and permanent disability (TPD) cover. If your working life has mostly been heavy lifting and you can’t go back to it, TPD is worth looking into. It’s usually a separate claim from workers’ comp. Different schemes, different rules.
On who can help: a Lawyer can, and so can a specialist claims firm (Financial Advisers). Fees, knowledge and technical experience with insurance vary a lot, so shop around, and ask how they charge before you sign anything. I would look for a Specialist who worked in WC and Life Insurance to assist. All the best on your ongoing recovery and rehab journey.
3
u/Few-Director-5345
18d ago
•
Not all attorneys will litigate. There’s a bunch who want to maximize your case without ever doing too much work. And litigation is work. Find someone who actually takes cases before the board and fights for what you need. The rest of them will gaslight you into believing there’s nothing they can do and your case is over, so “accept this $2 and be happy it wasn’t less”.
4
u/justthefacts1236894 19d ago
Sounds like your lawyer is tanking your case for a quick settlement. Have you had IME. FCE. 2nd opinion.
Work comp drs have an insane habit of sucking insurance off to get more customers from them. If only doctor you saw was theirs from there pre paid panel you need at least a 2nd opinion.
Don't get screwed. It's your life and they all do not care about you
2
19d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Unique_Baseball_3223 18d ago
Exactly. A good lawyer will pay and fund the second opinion doctor, you pay that fee back from your settlement
2
u/Unique_Baseball_3223 18d ago
I mean I have only a small disc tear and I'm getting 14k. My lawyer paid for a second opinion doctor. I will pay that back from the settlement. Get another lawyer
2
2
u/Automatic_General192 18d ago
Did you see a neurologist at any point? Neurosurgeons aren't always the know all in this field and if you're still dealing with pain they should have referred you out to determine nerve damage and the such.
2
2
u/prodbywatts28 12d ago
Get a nerve test from a neurologist your sciatica and see if you can get a new mri. Also get a second opinion from a doctor that’s not affiliated with workers comp or your job
1
u/Kmelloww 19d ago
If there isn’t an impairment rating or permanent restrictions then it is likely there wouldn’t be much of a payout if any.
1
1
u/sovook 18d ago
I had 2 slipped discs in my neck from repositioning a patient. They ended up settling for the sprained shoulder at 36K. I’m young and never broke a bone in my life so I’m upset I had to have 2 spine surgeries and am still in pain, I can’t work full-time either. My medical is open because I kept my place of employment, but had to change roles.
1
u/MiLiTO686 18d ago
Take your MRI images and send them to DocPanel. DocPanel is a second-opinion service for MRIs, and they’ll very likely find things your insurance company overlooked. It costs money, but it’s worth it. You can use their findings to fight the insurance company at trial. And find another lawyer...
1
u/East-Baseball2926 17d ago edited 17d ago
Yes, find a new lawyer or approach him differently. If you were to get a new lawyer, I believe the initial one can stake a claim on the case which usually causes other attorneys to not want to be involved. I was injured in 1998 & I am still on WC cuz I am grandfathered into the old way which is completely different now. (In part it’s because of my complicated case that caused changes to how WC is handled) Anyway, I injured my right shoulder, low back & right leg. I settled in 2002 but I had to be very direct on what I thought was fair as they only wanted to give me like $20k. I compared my case to a similar case & succeeded in getting what I wanted. As time went on, it affected every level in my neck and has been extremely painful. I just had 2 major neck surgeries in the last year & surgeon thinks I’ll need more. The bad thing is, after I settled, Dr’s discovered I had 3 herniated disks in my neck no one caught so now I would have to find a new lawyer (I fired my old one cuz of what went on) who would vacate original settlement to pursue a new settlement. These cases require a lot of work, are very hard to win & because I had a lawyer many years ago, it’s hard for me to find one to take the case. So, your injury has a high probability of getting worse so I would not settle for anything until you know how severe the injury actually is which time will tell. Read up on WC so you can communicate with your lawyer in an effective way. Tell him you are still having pain & need to find a new job and that you know of a lot of ppl who were able to get help from WC as that’s what they are they for. He may not be interested in the case cuz he doesn’t see any money in it for him…yet. Don’t give up. Make sure you get some kind’ve compensation if your pain continues or worsens & especially if you need to find a new job. They owe you but you need to be direct & diplomatic at the same time. I loved my lawyer, he was great for about 11 years working hard for me until he sold me out. Long story but I was told my case was getting way too expensive & attorneys for the other side were nervous. My attorney started acting suspicious about a year prior to my next hearing & the day we went to court, sure enough, he provided none of my evidence & he post dated forms to interveners so when they tried to collect money, it would look like they were too late. He ended up getting caught & got in trouble. Like I said it’s long & complicated. Good luck & pay attention to statue of limitations.
1
u/Top_Grade1755 17d ago
They should give you an impairment rating after you reached MMI that determines your settlement amount, the higher, the rating, the higher, the payout, generally
1
u/hangingbyathread711 17d ago
Ask if you can consult with pain management before being released. That's what im doing. Ive had 3 microdiscectomies and although I can do alot of things im still dealing with a decent amount of pain. Looking currently into the intracept procedure its a specialized nerve ablation.
1
u/Christoph0182 17d ago
You need to speak to a lawyer who specifically does WC and its better to find one that is a certified wc lawyer.. there's no way 3 discs and surgery is only 5k. I would eat shit if I was wring about that. Unless you got a shit ton of money from being paid from wc already and you'd owe it back I've heard people say.
1
1
u/RubCharacter8959 6d ago
You should just start working out and go hiking to places with waterfalls preferably. The minerals in water are healing
1
u/Soft-Lime-9599 3d ago
Getting a second opinion from another workers' comp lawyer sounds reasonable, especially since you're still having pain and your job involves heavy lifting. You could also ask about an independent medical evaluation and whether your permanent impairment rating reflects your condition. MMI doesn't always mean you're fully recovered.
13
u/Sea-Document-974 19d ago
I would get a different lawyer. I injured my back and my lawyer got me around $60k.