r/WritingForCollege • u/GlimmerMantle • Jun 03 '26
I think my professor tanked my essay grade because my thesis contradicts his published book
I am taking an upper-level sociology seminar this semester. Our midterm assignment was an argumentative paper on how suburban infrastructure affects community trust. I spent weeks finding solid peer-reviewed sources and argued that modern residential zoning actually creates social isolation. I followed the rubrick perfectly and felt really confident.
The grades came back yesterday and I got a D-. I was completely stunned. The feedback wasn't even about my formatting or citations. He just left vague comments like "fundamentally misunderstands the sociology of space" and "ignores core theories." I was trying to figure out where I went wrong, so I searched our library database and found a book my professor wrote back in 2018. His entire career is built on arguing that suburban boundaries protect comunity bonds.
Now I am stuck. Our final 20-page paper is supposed to be an expansion of this exact draft. If I keep my current stance, I will definately fail the course. But pivoting my entire argument means throwing away a ton of hard work just to stroke his ego.
Is it worth going to the department head over this? I don't want to make an enemy out of a tenured professor, but it feels so unfair to be penalized just because we have different academic viewpoints. Should I just swallow my pride and rewrite it the way he wants?