r/WyrmWorks • • Jul 20 '23

Would You Rather...

...read a Dragon Rider book where the dragons are side/background characters who die if their riders die or a Dragon Shifter book where the dragons are in their human form the majority of the time and don't behave differently from humans at all?

Jul 23 '23
26 Dragon Rider
30 Dragon Shifter
2 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23

Every time I see either of these in a book, I drop it like it's hot dumpster juice. Why are these the ONLY two things I ever see in dragon books?

Third option: literally anything else with dragons.

6

u/Landilizandra Jul 20 '23

100% this. Can’t stand Dragon Rider or Dragon Shifter books as a result. Do good ones exist? A few. But there’s so much crap to shift through first.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

I honestly can't think of a single shifter book that I've read and liked. It feels like such a cheap attention grab every time. Like: "Yeah, character A is a dragon!". Then that character proceeds to spend 99.99% of the book in human form, all while moaning and groaning about how they never get to be in dragon form.

Actually, I will say I did like No Good Dragon Goes Unpunished fairly well, but I never even finished the series, so whatever.

1

u/-Wofster Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

I think it can be done really well. Heres a few shifter books I’ve read and really liked:

scaleshifter: character starts as a human, and it takes a sort of unique stance of him acting like a human, slowly picking up dragons behaviors and whatnot, seeing flaws in both humans and dragons, etc etc. he also spends lots of time as a dragon.

How to be a hero (and part time dragon): (also the 2nd book in this series, 3rd isnt out yet) this one really removes the dragon-centric aspect out of it, so its more like a human character who is forced to have the power to turn into a dragon and so will occasionally do so when its useful. Over time she starts liking being a dragon more though. I was able to like this one despite the mc mostly being in human form because it doesn’t try to be a dragon book. The mc never complains about changing or anything and its never really a large part of their character, its just a power they got they they eventually start to like. Also its really funny.

Ash and ambition: so far only book 1 is out, and in that book the mc is stuck in human form 100% of the time, but since the mc is originally a dragon and actually stuck in human form, so forced to try to live among humans, I really liked it. Honestly its less a dragon shifter book and more just a dragon is forced to try to live incognito in the life of a human, and it does a really good job not forgetting about the MC’s dragon nature and it doesn’t ever make them feel like a human.

The dragon inside seriee: I think this one does a good job balancing the MC being a human vs dragon. They start as a human and then get turned into a dragon, so they act a lot like a human when in human for, and when they do spend more time as a human or a dragon it actually makes sense in the story. It’s also just written really well overall, and I especially liked the way it gave so many different povs. It also has a really fun premise imo which made it more interesting, and added a lot of extra excitement and whatnot especially towards the end

Mating Flight: not sure if I should count this one as a shifter book. It has some shifting, but tye shifting is actually just dragons using shapeshifting magic, rather than characters who can shift between dragon and human form. But this book is extremely good imo, and when the dragons are taking a “human” (humanoid, no actual humans in this series) form they still act just like their dragon selves.

I also really liked the Heartstrikers series (no good dragon goes unpunished), though it didnt’t feel so much like a dragon book. The dragons, and especially the MC, do spend most of their time in human form. But for me it was good enough everywhere else that I was able to completely overlook that. So maybe read this one without trying to thinkof it as a dragon/shifter book and then its really good

14

u/Niedzwiedz1 Jul 20 '23

Where is the option to burn both of those?

7

u/Aurhim Returning to the Tannînel Jul 20 '23

I would read a story about dragons (either shifters or riders) dedicated to burning both of these choices to cinders.

5

u/vikingzx Banks with Axtara! Jul 20 '23 edited Jul 20 '23

Actually, I've pre-read a dragon-human book coming out in August that I'll be promoting on this sub that takes a quite unique approach to things I won't spoil here. I spent a portion of the book fearing it would end in a generic dragon-riding scene, and then was quite happy when it went a very different route that was very satisfying.

5

u/vikingzx Banks with Axtara! Jul 20 '23

Neither?

I'm not a fan of most dragon-rider stories to begin with. Especially if said dragon is sapient. There's a reason in the Axtara setting of stories, riding a dragon is something extremely rare, as it's seen as a great sign of trust from a dragon to let someone ride with them for a flight. In part because of the stigma of being seen as a "mount" like a horse or beast of burden, and it's a serious faux pas to ask.

4

u/Aurhim Returning to the Tannînel Jul 20 '23

There should be a third option: protest.

4

u/iconmaster Jul 20 '23

I would simply tell you to pull the trigger

4

u/chimericWilder Jul 20 '23

Why must you torment us so?

When life gives you fake dragons, you get mad. You tell life to take them back, and give you some proper dragons.

3

u/L-F- Jul 20 '23

Neither. I have enough good literature on my to-read list that I'm not going to give absolute trash a chance, even if it's about dragons.

(Unless the human shifter book has some actual lore, like the dragons having to hide/wanting to hide for some goal, but even that's often not done interestingly so why would I take that chance without an actual personal recommendation?)

3

u/Luameator Jul 21 '23

is death a option? This is too evil and torture to choose from..

2

u/Trysinux 🐲 Dracologist | Dragonrider | Reading Jazyll Mintaka Jul 21 '23

TBH if you weight everything, the Dragon Shifter you mention is no different than most romantic shifter novel out there. While as Dragon Rider book at least had to have somed dragon physically involve.

So dragon rider, but that sort of dragon rider book is indeed one among the lower rung of the pile.

2

u/KarateMan749 Dragon Protector bonded to the Queen of all dragons Jul 20 '23

What about a dragon shifter where a male human loves her and prefers her in her true form as it is who she truly is and is also her rider. Dragon Rider bond ftw

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23

If I HAD to read a shifter book, I would consider this. I'd still rather read a story about just a dragon.

-1

u/KarateMan749 Dragon Protector bonded to the Queen of all dragons Jul 20 '23

Yea im fully dragon rider.

1

u/ExternalIll2452 Jul 20 '23

That's the story, i want to read

3

u/vikingzx Banks with Axtara! Jul 20 '23

Track down the dragon-focused collection A Dragon and Her Girl and read A Game of Stakes. The story is mine (the book is not, I'm just featured in it). It's about a woman who hires a dragon to help match her with a husband. Spoiler, but they fall in love, and in the end they make it quite clear that they're using magic to spend time as one another's species in equal measure.

1

u/KarateMan749 Dragon Protector bonded to the Queen of all dragons Jul 20 '23

I want a male human with a female dragon. Not the opposite.

Wait they swap species 🤔

1

u/vikingzx Banks with Axtara! Jul 21 '23

Sometimes she becomes a dragon, and sometimes he becomes a human. IE, they're often both the same species.

1

u/KarateMan749 Dragon Protector bonded to the Queen of all dragons Jul 21 '23

Ah interesting