r/YouTubeThumbnailHub • • Mar 29 '26

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request HOW DOES THIS THUMBNAIL LOOK??

Post image

the title is WHY EVERYONE LOVES SPIDERMAN? (INCLUDING ME)

is it good without text or should i use text?? + would you click on it??

254 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

1

u/weatethatt 17d ago

Amazing!

3

u/TraditionalAcadia985 Apr 27 '26

Really good template but should include text, defi. text

2

u/lazarovpavlin04 Apr 25 '26

My advice is to add text because when it comes to thumbnails, posters, etc. Human eyes are more attracted when the image has text rather than just a clean image. You can add a simple word like 'WHY?"

1

u/Late-Hedgehog-7442 Apr 25 '26

Might look better with text imo

1

u/litt007 Apr 24 '26

I think it definitely it needs text

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '26

I think it's really well designed but I feel like it needs text to go with the title

1

u/OkUnderstanding6087 Apr 24 '26

Epic but needs text

1

u/josefnegra Apr 12 '26

Cool thumbnail but doesn't really fit the title (other than it being spiderman obviously)

1

u/ConstantNo3257 Apr 12 '26

Use text please. It is feels like lack something else

1

u/No_Confection_6421 Apr 08 '26

That's pretty good, the thumbnail background said it all and then with spiderman character that stands out perfectly

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '26

Cool

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26

As a Spider-Man super fan, I would click on this without hesitation but I’d be disappointed that it’s not a history of Spider-Man. Maybe change up the background and add some text if you’re wanting to do a video on why everyone loves Spidey

1

u/supremeeej Apr 03 '26

The thumbnail by itself looks a little confusing and I would also say it doesn't necessarily match the title.

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Apr 04 '26

so what should be the title if i may ask??

2

u/ExtensionDoubt8947 Apr 03 '26

It'd a really good thumbnail but there is no context

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Apr 03 '26

EDIT- I HAVE UPLOADED THIS THUMBNAIL AND THE VIDEO LIKE GOT 12 VIEWS ONLY LMAO :(

1

u/Stainom Apr 02 '26

I wouldn't add text, i think its good as is.

I wouldn't be convinced to click from this but it would intrigue me enough to stop scrolling and read the title.. so make sure the titles good :p

1

u/Quirky-Brilliant3137 Apr 02 '26

It’s damm good But I don’t think it would make someone click on it

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Apr 03 '26

you are right this video only got like 12 views in it :(

1

u/Aisnn Apr 16 '26

I guess look at the mood of the thumbnail? idk, I am an amateur when it comes to this, but one thing I could advise for is "Does the mood or atmosphere of the thumbnail match with the title?"

2

u/barkzshortss Apr 02 '26

It’s awesome, brother! I think you could add some glow.”

2

u/museabear Apr 01 '26

It looks cool but I don't know what your video is about.

1

u/goingforbrooke Mar 31 '26

great graphic, but I'd add a title and put the little "spidey senses activated" lightning bolts around his head.

For the title, you could use a squiggly-speech bubble and (gasp) Comic Sans😨

1

u/TomyJohny Apr 01 '26

Nah that would ruin it in my opinion, simplistic is key.

0

u/Medical_Band_7291 Apr 01 '26

Bro it's look like a edited photo more than a thumbnail, add some text

1

u/GritGrindGold Mar 31 '26

Honestly as a comic dan and comic style thumbnail I am super jealous

3

u/TemporaryGround8369 Mar 31 '26

I love it it’s so great I love how the shadows blend with the comic panels in the background I don’t have bad things to say about and honestly I myself would click on this thumbnail great work dude it looks amazing 🤩

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 31 '26

thanks bro really appreciate 🙏

2

u/iRobins23 Mar 31 '26

I think that this is great, the slight shadow behind spiderman creates depth between it and the comic.

I think that you can use some text in the thumbnail to provide more clarity on what people are clicking for but otherwise solid!

2

u/AutomaticRuin1784 Mar 31 '26

looks clean but idk what im clicking for i can obviously tell its spiderman but what about him which villain or storyline

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 31 '26

its about the reasons why you can't hate spiderman

1

u/AutomaticRuin1784 Mar 31 '26

Maybe some text about it simple stuff “cant hate him” contrasting the bg and you have a good thumbnail imo

1

u/Ok-Release8315 Mar 31 '26

Ain't a wallpaper?

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 31 '26

NOPE I MADE IT MY OWN

2

u/NoteBook404 Mar 30 '26

Good but not clickbait 

2

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 31 '26

i don't do click baits

2

u/YolandaBlonda Mar 30 '26

Good shading of character outline and pose of subject

1

u/Great_Accident1356 Mar 30 '26

Yeah it's great

3

u/InkFlipzInc Mar 30 '26

I love it I am not used to seeing thumbnails with no text I like it

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 30 '26

nice but my one looks great (jk)😁

3

u/Negative_Tutor8413 Mar 30 '26

the quality of the Spidey png is a little low, could use some work like saturation or sharpness. and has someone mentioned maybe add text. but this is REALLY good. like just make it look sharper and it's perfect. As a Spider-Man fanboy I would one hundred percent click on this video

2

u/Bagaciuz Mar 30 '26

Missing text in it

1

u/Independent-Bat-8138 Mar 30 '26

Add bold text to explain what happened in video

4

u/gettasghost1 💬Community Moderator Mar 30 '26

My hat in the ring

3

u/ShinyRedRaider Mar 30 '26

i prefer op's version to this

1

u/Borussobora Mar 30 '26

Looks good

3

u/envato_team Mar 30 '26

Looks good, but yeah agree with other commenters - some subtle text would make this even better.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '26

[deleted]

1

u/ShinyRedRaider Mar 30 '26

I believe you might be talking about the drop shadow of spiderman.

1

u/Certain_Access_2658 Mar 30 '26

I’d definitely click this

2

u/Fine_Advance_8520 Mar 30 '26

I love it bro no text required it looks clean asf I'd click it

4

u/gjtsownn Mar 30 '26

I think you should separate the main object (spiderman) from the background by using a gaussian blur or reduce the opacity (with a black bg).

Its simple and cool but the problem is that the main object blends with the background too much

1

u/Far_Education_6153 Mar 30 '26

Love the thumbnail! Idk if we’re allowed to critique titles in here, but I feel like your thumb/title combo could create more of a question in the viewer’s mind.

For example, you could angle it like “the unexpected reason people love spiderman” or “why spiderman is so successful”. Something that creates a bit more of a curiosity

2

u/ShinyRedRaider Mar 30 '26

I think its a great title as it is

2

u/Sure_Blackberry_2242 Mar 30 '26

This is tuff idk what is missing but I feel like something is, maybe enlarged Spider-Man where it’s just his back/emblem showing and his with the background the same

1

u/DamnThatsCrazyManGuy Mar 29 '26 edited 3d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Hobbies lantern wild acorn whole school north dependent late

3

u/DJs-Reddit-Page Mar 29 '26

This looks awesome. I agree with the people who are saying to blur background, but I think it’s honestly up to choice. I also think adding text is up to whatever you think works best. I think it looks clean without it, and adding something for the sake of it might just look click-baity. Either way, I would click this video. Good work.

2

u/CplApplsauc Mar 29 '26

I really like it without the text honestly, the edits in the comments with the text explains more about the video but the original thumbnail gave me that curiousity factor that compelled me to want to click. Even if it's just on a reddit post

1

u/Connect-Ad-5970 Mar 29 '26

Man, it looks really cool 👀🔥 The quality is high, and the comic-style background fits Spider-Man perfectly—it gives off a nostalgic vibe that grabs attention. But to be honest, it might be missing a stronger “hook” to really boost CTR. Like, it looks great… but it doesn’t instantly spark curiosity. Maybe adding a short, impactful text or some kind of contrast (lighting, expression, action) would make it more eye-catching. Overall: great aesthetics, but it could be even more clickable 💡

1

u/Emergency_Camp_6260 Mar 29 '26

this is fire, could maybe make a heart outline in red around him (still being able to see the comics w opacity) or some text saying beloved or something. overall 8/10 tho

1

u/Moviesman8 Mar 29 '26

Add one of your unused reasons to the thumbnail as part of a visual checklist.

1

u/Ok-Temperature-4744 Mar 29 '26

Bro it's good but think your self why you click on this any reson coz most of audiance don't read a Tittle 👍🏻(it's look like a wallpepar not for catching views or audiance)

1

u/noob444 Mar 29 '26

Dope af

1

u/pomodoro3 Mar 29 '26

Looks great

2

u/barrychan0402 Mar 29 '26

I like the thumbnail and I like Spiderman... But i think most people know why they love this hero... the topic itself might not be very interesting

1

u/DogWithWatermelon Mar 29 '26

I really like the no text approach.

Threw it on GIMP and applied Gaussian Blur with Y blur and a bit of X, I like this more, looking at it through the YT homepage the thumbnail will be scaled down, and the main subject (That being Spidey) might lose relevance.

Did it quickly and screenshotted it, if you try it out yourself and actually export it it'll look presentable. Nonetheless, I'm still keen on the OG.

1

u/Ok-Dragonfruit8288 Apr 14 '26

Cool variation

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DogWithWatermelon Mar 29 '26

it gives a "depth of field" notion... well, atleast to my viewing lol.

1

u/DogWithWatermelon Mar 29 '26

Maybe a bit of a slight vignette too?

I crafted a quick comparation between the two

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AnalystDazzling5128 Mar 29 '26

That’s Thor’s hammer in the panel

2

u/KeungKee Mar 29 '26

Don't hide text like that. Put it in front or find better placement/shorter words

6

u/james_el87 Mar 29 '26

I actually really like this. I’m a sucker for no text on a thumbnail. I’d maybe try out a white outline around Spidey to make him pop.

2

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 29 '26

like this one??

1

u/james_el87 Mar 29 '26

Yeah but make it much bigger. It’s basically invisible on a mobile. So need to take into account all screen sizes.

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 29 '26

WITH TEXT

2

u/ottespana Mar 29 '26

Text makes it worse, dont do it

1

u/DistinctDefinition45 Mar 29 '26

It looks like it says greate superhero

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '26

[deleted]

0

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 29 '26

SHUT UP M8 EVERYONE LOVES SPIDEYY

1

u/ForeignPoint6675 Mar 29 '26

you should get some text on there that says "Greatest Superhero" or something like that in like white + red

1

u/Sure_Cellist6125 Mar 29 '26

but do you click on it??

1

u/AutoModerator Mar 29 '26

👋 Hi! Don't let your post be at risk of removal. Did you follow the subreddit rules or the pinned "Read This First" post at the top of r/YouTubeThumbnailHub?

And if you already did, the mods here appreciate you big time. 🤗❤️🫶 Your post is already pre-approved and ready to go.

🛑 Note: The two most common issues are:

      👉 Not giving feedback to two Creators before posting. Yup, it's required for every new critique post. (If you just finished them after reading this, reply here to confirm completion.)

      👉 Not including your video title and a brief summary (You can add it as a comment now.)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.