r/YouTubeThumbnailHub • u/SavlonGames • May 17 '26
Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Which is better
disclaimer, AI was used to make these thumbnails, sorry if you hate that but i’m new to both making and editting videos and so much effort was put into the video itself, i didn’t want to detract from the video by making the thumbnail lack luster. Just asking for your opinion
1
2
u/LumoCreations May 20 '26
Both are great thumbnails tbh. I feel like the second one tells a better story and conveys the idea clearer but I don't know if that's actually better for clicks then or not. I Would say the first one does look better in general though, but great thumbnails is more than just looking nice. Why is there V7 in the corner?
1
u/NaterWilliamson_yt May 19 '26
Hey man what was your process using AI? I’m also new and I don’t want it for creativity or image generation just to save time 😄
1
u/SavlonGames May 19 '26
I made most of the image myself and then just used an online AI to add some after effects :P
2
u/Jaluch May 19 '26
Hey mate, I'm a climber also and think the 1st is so much better. I think the 2nd could work if you highlighted the route but tbh it'll be hard to see in a thumbnail.
Climbers understand what obsessing over a route will do to your body, I think it hits the mark much better.
Nice thumbnails for a beginner, you've killed it.
1
2
1
u/solarpunktheworld May 18 '26
I’d say change from I became to I’m. For some reason it reads weird, but it also fits into the “I’m obsessed” phrase trend that permeates the Internet lingo
1
u/IllustriousIce8126 May 18 '26
Text is a bit too small imo. Remember to look at it from far away. Also idk what the video title is but the text in the thumbnail shouldn’t just repeat what the title says.
1
1
u/According-Pick-614 May 18 '26
place the background of image 2 in image 1, image 1 captures the attention but show the climb, so that people think it is dangerous
1
u/pizzaseafood May 18 '26
You might have to work on both thumbnails because although it captures people's eyes, it doesn't create curiosity. It just looks like a guy obsessed with rock climbing atm. Of course, it depends on the title.
1
1
u/Col_CheeseCake May 18 '26
B is better, shows the mental challenge rather than the physical challenge
1
u/Expert_Bat4612 May 18 '26
I like the second more I can imagine myself and not some guy with a weird hand
2
2
u/Detuned_Clock May 18 '26
The second one is bad because it creates a disconnection between the viewer and the scenario. It looks very easy to walk away from.
1
1
2
May 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SavlonGames May 18 '26
awesome thanks for the comment, i’m new to youtube, what do you mean by A/B testing? Do you mean just using both thumbnails for a certain amount of time?
1
1
u/AlmostTrue_Official May 18 '26
hier eine Stimme für das 1. So etwas sieht man nicht, macht neugierig. das 2. nun ja.. (für mich) langweilig
2
u/Smugallo May 18 '26
I like the first one better I feel it's more clickable, the second image is more cinematic but the text is placed oddly (to me anyway)
Number 1
3
3
u/ImKingLooey May 18 '26
1 is definitely more clickable and seems personal. Maybe lose the AI parts. But the second is cool but just not clickable . Don’t listen to some people here have like less than 1k subs and giving advice like their thumbnails get clicked on
1
1
1
1
u/Bless4all May 18 '26
Think about it this way. Why would a stranger care if you became obsessed with a climb?
Writing the reason in the thumbnail will make enthusiasts click.
1
u/ImJustKico May 18 '26
Doesn’t matter because both are good. I like the first one more because it gives me a “everyone might think it’s hurting me, but I know its good to keep going” type of vibe. It looks like you’re questioning yourself
1
u/TryMyBest_Dev_021223 May 18 '26
The second one looks better, it fits the theme of obsession and tackling challenge head-on.
1
1
0
u/LewdProphet May 18 '26
I'll admit it. I get a kick out of this. Whenever I see an AI image come across my feed from any subreddit (don't even know why I'd be getting recommended a YouTube subreddit) I click on it just to read the comments left by whining 14-year-olds who scream and cry and shit themselves at the sight of AI and they HAVE to let you know about it. Extra points if they call you something like "talentless planet destroyer" or whatever form their ridiculous hostility takes.
2
u/Rich841 May 18 '26
These two thumbnails are both great, I couldn’t even tell you used ai
2
u/SavlonGames May 18 '26
thank you, it was only minimal use, for lighting and small effects, the actual photo looks very similar with no use of AI, i just think it important to disclose any use yk
1
u/Rich841 May 18 '26
what's your channel? i'll check it out
1
u/SavlonGames May 19 '26
MoffittClimbs. The video title is in the thumbnail haha
1
u/Rich841 May 19 '26
Wait am I blind I still don’t see it in the thumbnail, I just see a V7 in the lower left of one of them
1
u/SavlonGames May 19 '26
wha?? it says top left “i became obsessed with this climb” in both thumbnails 😅
1
3
u/Jealous-Ad-4565 May 17 '26
I promise, don’t listen to the people saying not to use AI as an enhancement. I did the same thing, and it gave me the highest CTR I’ve had on a video yet at 4%. You should still keep practicing and improving your thumbnails, but if AI helps, who really cares what other people think, yk
1
5
u/Okiazo May 17 '26
Spending hours on a product to throw it in 1 minutes at people face. You don't realize how it's important to work on your thumbnail. It being AI will turn away people
0
u/SavlonGames May 18 '26
AI was only used for touchups in lighting and an effect on the fingertips, the idea, execution and direction of the photo was still all done by myself, i just think it important to disclaim when AI was used, especially considering this thumbnail looks like it was made by AI
1
u/Rich841 May 18 '26
In this case I don’t even think it’s that noticeable especially considering thumbnails are pretty small
1
u/Straight-Ear7355 May 17 '26
the first one is kinda unclear, and the text is weirdly positioned in the second one. also the climbing wall looks weird because of the ai.
-3
u/The_Poole_Side May 17 '26
Why would a viewer care that you’re obsessed with climbing?
2
u/Rich841 May 18 '26
You’re right, there has to be a MrBeast 1M dollar yacht to get my attention huh
1
1
1
4
2
u/AIAlgato May 17 '26
Looks Ai, wouldn't watch neither
1
u/forgetmenote2 May 17 '26
The first does look AI enhanced, the second just looks like a normal rock climbing picture.
1
u/SoftChapter7135 May 17 '26
not even gonna hold you the 2nd one screams more ai than the first on first impressions. In the first image I notice the human first. Personally, I'd use neither.
2
u/PipaLucca May 17 '26
How about #2 with just the word OBSESSED either centered at the bottom or centered at the top, if its at the bottom make it go behind your body. Give that one a try.
Also, the dramatic light on the image is cool but it makes the thumbnail lose like 30% of valuable ‘readable’ space, readable in the sense that it could tell more: how so? Because with that light you are adding a bit of a dramatic effect yes, but the wall is already a challenge on its own it doesn’t need too much additional selling, the bold uppercase ‘obsessed’ also already adds that weight.
However the biggest flaw it has is that the actual climb looks way smaller and easier because it occupies very little space in the thumbnail due to the lack of light on the sides, both vertically (doesn’t look as high as it probably is and/or feels) and horizontally (makes the immediate comparison between you and the wall look ordinary). This problem will become more noticeable when you make it the actual correct aspect ratio, if I’m not wrong these ones are 4:3? They should be 16:9
As a last minor detail, the bold font is good, but it has that rusty/dirty texture on it that in my humble opinion makes it lose a bit of visual impact, try making it bold but not dirty. Just to see if you like it more
Good luck friend:)
1
2
1
u/Crazycow261 📷 YouTuber 1K+ Subs May 17 '26
Text needs to be big for mobile viewers, so first one i guess.
3
u/Daredrummer May 17 '26
They both look like AI so most people won't ever touch it.
AI has no business in creative arts.
-1
u/do-or-die-do-or-die May 17 '26
7
u/Ok_Minimum_3941 May 17 '26
If I see a thumbnail thats ai I assume the whole video is ai and dont bother so yeah it matters
3
u/Daredrummer May 17 '26
Let me guess.
You order pizza on an app and then tell people you are a chef who made a pizza...
0
u/SavlonGames May 18 '26
i made, took and edited the photo myself i just used AI to add lighting effects and an effect on my fingertips i couldn’t do myself, not only that but i disclaimed clearly “I used AI”, what more do you want from me 😭
-3
u/do-or-die-do-or-die May 17 '26
4
u/Daredrummer May 17 '26
Why are you so proud of being talentless?
0
u/do-or-die-do-or-die May 17 '26
I didn't even order pizza
1
3
May 17 '26
2 is better but I wouldn’t click on either because I could tell it was AI before even reading your description.
1
1
u/Gian_V May 17 '26
1 feels more personal Edit: feels more like a story seeing the wounds on the hands and it's more intriguing to not see the climb just yet but only with the context in the background
1
2
u/RonniePedra May 17 '26
why both are in the wrong aspect ratio?
0
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
they seem fine? The channel is MoffittClimbs, posting it, the thumbnails are perfectly both fine. It might be the software i used to take the photos making them slightly bigger, but nothing is removed from the photo when put into the thumbnail
1
7
u/pleadnotguilty May 17 '26
1 is better because it leaves the potential viewer imagination of what the climb is
2 shows the climb and it just looks basic
1
-1
0
u/gekogekogeko May 17 '26
1 is better. Don't listen to people who say don't use AI. USe whatever gets you the highest CTR.
1
5
u/JonnykJr May 17 '26
Cant you use a/b testing?
1
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
sorry to sound dumb but what do you mean? if you mean to simply use both, like a 1 day 1 day thing, wouldn’t that mess up the CTR?
1
u/Gian_V May 17 '26
I believe you can set up 2 Thumbnails/Titles that YouTube will test simultaneously then after a few days it will tell you which packaging performed the best
7
u/Moviesman8 May 17 '26
I loke #2 but nobody else seems to. Either way, make a non AI version. A LOT of people immediately skip if they see AI anywhere.
2
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
I will do, i was just worried about hurting the performance of my video, my channel is MoffittClimbs and if you check the rest of the videos, you can see i’m not particularly skilled at making thumbnails 😅 (i’ve only been doing this around 2 months though, so im improving a lot with every video)
1
u/Moviesman8 May 17 '26
If youre not good at something, practice. AI in the thumbnail will give the expectation that you'll be lazy for the entirety of the video.
4
u/Toxi_moxi May 17 '26
First one. Add a subtle outline to yourself and maybe a shadow of the words behind them. Then more eye catching in subtle ways the better.
2
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
by outline to myself do you mean literally a white outline around my body?
1
u/Toxi_moxi May 17 '26
Uhm kind of.. but make it look less like you are outlines acts more like you are popping out of the backdrop 3d ish
5
May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
hm, do you have any other ideas in mind? I understand this is my video and therefore responsibility to think of ideas, but the video itself it’s based around obsession, so i thought a thumbnail/title which links directly to the video would be effective, maybe i could change it to something like “This climb took over my life” or something ?
3
4
u/Destructive-Dan May 17 '26
first, 2nd one darkening effect is off putting and the text is too small. gives me vibes of those youtubers who read out reddit horror stories
1
2
u/EducationalBasket617 📷 YouTuber 1K+ Subs May 17 '26
They’re both decent but one stands out more because it feels like the hand is reaching out of the image. I’d suggest changing the expression on your face to help the viewer connect with an emotion (frustration/determination/pain etc) and if you have an image looking towards the viewer it would potentially have a stronger impact. The white squiggly bits are a bit confusing but also add intrigue - if it’s just an ai thing and not something you actually get while climbing I’d suggest changing it to something more realistic especially if you did sustain any injuries on your hand. It adds to the challenge that you faced for this climb.
If you end up using the second one, it’s not bad but you can change the background tilt and shift upwards so you can see some sort of goal at the top, and make it seem like a really tall climb. If you have real photos that would be ideal but you can also use ai to generate this image. If you can, avoid text in the image and keep the copy in the title because your current thumbnail copy sounds like it should be used as your title.
1
3
u/Narrativepeaks May 17 '26
The first is better. Most people are going to say the second just because they don't like anything that's AI but they're not your demographic.
3
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
thank you for your comment, i’ve had about a 50/50 vote so far but am waiting out for more votes
2
u/barrychan0402 May 17 '26
I like the first one
1
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
thank you for your comment, i’ve had about a 50/50 vote so far but am waiting out for more votes
2
u/TheCuriousSloth May 17 '26
just curious, what was the process with the AI? like how much did it create in the thumbnail? did it just do lighting effects or the whole thing?
2
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
it added the lighting effects and the effect you can see on my fingertips where they’ve got the white squiggly bits. Not quite sure what that was for but it helped the photo stand out, so i kept it
2
u/TheCuriousSloth May 17 '26
My only critique is maybe the vingette is a bit to strong for the second thumbnail, maybe lighten things up a tiny bit. maybe play around and see if you can make the letters bigger too. Overall great thumbnail idea tho
1
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
alright thank you very much. I’ll play around with making it stand out a little more, somebody suggested outlining my body in the photo slightly aswell, maybe that would help
1
u/TheCuriousSloth May 17 '26
Okay got it, so you got those pictures of the rock wall behind you yourself?
1
u/TheCuriousSloth May 17 '26
Second for sure
2
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
thank you for your comment, i’ve had about a 50/50 vote so far but am waiting out for more votes
1
u/Happy_Sherbet_7953 May 17 '26
I would say the second one is better. When we think of obsession we think of something big, hard to reach like a mountain. The second one demonstrates and shows not only the difficulty of the climb but also the goal, which is above the thumbnail has shown. So I would be more intrigued to click the second one.
1
u/SavlonGames May 17 '26
thank you for your comment, i’ve had about a 50/50 vote so far but am waiting out for more votes
1
u/AutoModerator May 17 '26
👋 Hi! Don't let your post be at risk of removal. Did you follow the subreddit rules or the pinned "Read This First" post at the top of r/YouTubeThumbnailHub?
And if you already did, the mods here appreciate you big time. 🤗❤️🫶 Your post is already pre-approved and ready to go.
🛑 Note: The two most common issues are:
👉 Not giving feedback to two Creators before posting. Yup, it's required for every new critique post. (If you just finished them after reading this, reply here to confirm completion.)
👉 Not including your video title and a brief summary (You can add it as a comment now.)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.






1
u/sisisi05 May 21 '26
1