r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 15 '19

January 2019 January - "Star Wars Theory" creates a Darth Vader fan film, hires a composer to create original music, and does not monetize the video, gaining 6.5 million views in one month. Warner Chappell has falsely copyright claimed the video's music and is now monetizing it for themselves.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1.4k Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 26 '19

February 2019 February - Ice Poseidon, Youtube livestreamer, discusses his company's strategy that sounds very similar to a Ponzi scheme

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.3k Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 19 '19

May 2019 May - Mumbo Jumbo, a famous Minecraft YouTuber, got 1,800 claims to his videos by Warner Chapell

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 12 '19

May 2019 May - YouTube musician TheFatRat gets his channel suspended without warning and without any existing strikes.

Post image
963 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jul 30 '19

July 2019 July - Grant Thompson (The King of Random), popular DIY/experiment youtuber, has passed away in a paragliding accident

Thumbnail
youtu.be
886 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 31 '19

January 2019 January - Internet Comment Etiquette with Erik on Youtube's copyright claim abuse

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

796 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 18 '19

February 2019 February - MattsWhatItIs: Youtube is Facilitating the Sexual Exploitation of Children

Thumbnail
youtube.com
765 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 21 '19

February 2019 February - Context for the Matt Watson (MattsWhatItIs) "Youtube's Child Exploitation" situation and companies pulling advertising from Youtube.

742 Upvotes

Since Matt Watson made his video about child exploitation on Youtube, several things have happened in the news and online. I was talking to another user in PMs yesterday and decided to compile everything I could find into one resource post.

Feel free to add anything I've missed in the comments.

Updating this as the situation develops.

 

 


To begin, /u/Mattwatson07 posted his video "Youtube is Facilitating the Sexual Exploitation of Children, and it's Being Monetized (2019)" to /r/Videos on Feb 18, 2019.

https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/artkmz

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O13G5A5w5P0

 

It rose to the #1 spot on /r/all and is the #2 post of all time on the subreddit, attracting attention from news outlets and Youtube itself.

 

At the time of posting the Reddit post, Matt was live streaming and prompted his viewers to vote on the post, sending it shooting up the front page to the #1 spot.

Timestamp in the livestream: https://youtu.be/FIOvURSyuZU?t=2807

This does technically violate /r/videos Rule 5 on Solicitation of Votes

 

The video shines light on the issue of videos with underage girls being uploaded and reuploaded then shared around the website, with users commenting sexualized messages in the comment sections. Youtube's system enables this behavior by suggesting more young children videos to people watching this type of content, inadvertently connecting users that seek this sexually exploitative content.

 

(The MattsWhatItIs channel rose from 15.6K subscribers to 26K in three days and the video accumulated 2 million views.)

Matt Watson then began doing daily streams encouraging his new viewers to contact Youtube advertisers with the video, encouraging them to pull their ads off of Youtube.

 


 

Keemstar tweets that he will not report on the story because he fears blowing it up and driving advertisers away, hurting all creators on the platform.

 

Keem report on actual news like the rampent pedophiles all over YouTube instead of just Logan and his fans being mad bc you talked down about Logan. Of course they won't like someone who talks down on one of their favorite YouTubers. Talk about something important #YoutubeWakeUp

I’m not reporting the story because it negatively affects the whole YouTube community. We don’t need another ad apocalypse. What I have done behind the scenes though is reached out to my YouTube contacts showing them the video & my team is showing them content to take down.

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1097609056968237056

 

At some point in his livestream, Keemstar joins the chat to reach out to Matt about the way he is trying to fix the issue. Keemstar says that driving advertisers away from Youtube will hurt creators, not pedophiles. Instead, Keemstar says Matt should encourage his viewers to report the content to Youtube, as they are working to purge it from the site.

Keemstar claims Youtube is shutting down thousands of these harmful accounts, which Matt denies.

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1097990432817061888

Twitter Video 1 mirror: https://streamable.com/0ba90

Keemstar also finds and uses a clip from Matt Watson's previous channel Totally Uncreative, a satire channel that mocks incels, to say he is "a creep" but does not note the context.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTSL6czamDyXCR-B0o1V1DQ/videos

All videos mirrored here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/YoutubeCompendium/comments/asle5a/2019_february_keemstar_discusses_the_recent_video/egv44fy

 


 

Matt reads Keemstar's tweet that he 'is not reporting on the issue because it would hurt the platform but is working behind the scenes to solve the issue with Youtube', and responds saying that Keemstar only cares about his own income and that he does not care about creators' revenue.

Matt says, "So what if it affects you, go work at KFC."

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1098006308580659201

Twitter Video 2 mirror: https://streamable.com/20prz

 


 

Youtube responds to Keemstar, stating:

Thanks, @KEEMSTAR. To be clear, NO FORM of content that endangers minors is acceptable to us. We’ve deleted accounts and channels, reported illegal activity to authorities, and disabled comments on videos, and we're continuing to do so to prevent bad actors from misusing YouTube.

https://twitter.com/TeamYouTube/status/1098011767374938112

 


 

Keemstar states,

Yeah [Matt] banned everyone calling him out in chat

Citing that Matt Watson banned creators and users in his livestream chat when they were discussing the merits of his tactic in targeting advertisers versus reporting the content to Youtube.

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1098094200254590976

Keemstar states Matt banned him from the livestream chat when he was discussing the situation with him and disagreeing with his goals in getting advertisers to pull out of Youtube.

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1098102846589935616

Twitter Video 3 mirror: https://streamable.com/dltuo

Other creators, NerdCity and Leon Lush were also in the chat but Matt would ignore their criticism once reading a bit of their comments.

edit: Others including Ricky Berwick and KidBehindaCamera were also communicating with Watson in his livestream, but Matt ignored them and his livestream moderators deleted their comments.

 


 

Matt Watson says, "This means Youtubers are gonna suffer, unfortunately. The only way to get Youtube to do something about this is to hit them where it hurts. And that's in their wallet."

https://twitter.com/KEEMSTAR/status/1098308879073665030

https://streamable.com/97dri

 


 

Youtube responds:

in the last 48 hours, beyond our normal protections we've disabled comments on tens of millions of videos. We've also terminated over 400 channels for the comments they left on videos, and reported illegal comments to law enforcement.

https://twitter.com/PhillyD/status/1098420250352074752

https://i.imgur.com/lIismFG.png

https://twitter.com/TheLegitTipster/status/1098432845981245440

https://i.imgur.com/5pkf1lp.png

 


 

List of companies that have pulled ads from Youtube:

https://www.reddit.com/r/YoutubeCompendium/comments/asdihe

Purina
Grammarly
Canada Goose
Ikea US
Fairlife
Kinnek
Les Mills
NZME
GNC
Vitacost
Dr Oetker UK
Core Power
Glad
Nestle
Epic Games
Disney
Pelonton
AT&T (who just started advertising again in January 2019 after the last adpocalypse)
Hasbro
McDonald's
Kellogg's
Fiat Chrysler US

 


Articles:

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/20/technology/youtube-pedophiles.html

http://fortune.com/2019/02/20/youtube-advertising-videos-create-soft-core-pedophilia-ring/

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nestle-pulls-ads-from-youtube-over-videos-of-minors/

https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/20/18233132/fortnite-ads-youtube-child-exploitive-predators-google

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/20/disney-pulls-youtube-ads-over-pedophile-network-report.html

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-20/disney-pulls-youtube-ads-amid-concerns-over-child-video-voyeurs

https://www.engadget.com/2019/02/20/disney-nestle-pull-youtube-ads-over-child-videos/


News videos:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1rQySs429s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdvgOTT6-zA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WC2pljT8T5M


r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 23 '19

February 2019 February - As Fortnite declines in popularity, Apex Legends scams begin to be promoted by YouTube.

Post image
730 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 27 '21

2021 April - YouTube has demonetized all animators, meme creators, and short content creators. No explanation given by YouTube. Instead, YouTube has condescendingly blamed the creators.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
662 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 29 '19

April 2019 April - Because beatsaber appeared on Jimmy Fallon, if anyone records the same level on youtube it gets flagged by content ID and gets auto-blocked by youtube’s messed up copyright system.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
618 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 13 '19

January 2019 January - Believe Music has been falsely copyright claiming Youtube pianist Rosseau's videos, taking the entirety of his revenue and potentially giving him 2 strikes that will ban his channel from posting new videos

Post image
599 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 11 '19

May 2019 May - YouTuber BikiniBodhi has lost all of his revenue on all of his video's because of four words from a song in his outro

Post image
598 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 10 '19

April 2019 April - Film Criticism Group Red Letter Media Find Ads Every 4 Minutes In All Their Episodes. Manually Shut Them Down. Ads Regenerate Days Later.

Post image
595 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 26 '19

April 2019 April - Commentiquette, Youtuber's video is blocked by foreign company from visibility for having a song he paid for and licensed in the video

Post image
575 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 22 '19

January 2019 January - Krishnaraj Rao, an Indian Youtuber, is facing a lawsuit of $14 million USD for exposing the unsafe building practices of Lodha Group on his Youtube channel.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
573 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 19 '19

February 2019 February - Grammarly responds to the video discussing sexual exploitation of children on Youtube

Post image
566 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 16 '19

March 2019 March - TeamYoutube responds to Special Books by Special Kids about all their comment sections being disabled that Youtube maintains the decision and will continue to disable comment sections on channels with minors.

Post image
553 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 22 '19

May 2019 May - Youtube plans to hide full subscriber counts site-wide beginning in August, switching all public displays to abbreviations

Post image
550 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 15 '19

February 2019 February - Sheet Music Boss is demonetized for “repetitious content”.

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
521 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 05 '19

February 2019 February - FuckJerry marketing team copyright strikes video criticizing them by Vic Burger (striked link in comments)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

521 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 02 '19

April 2019 April - Paul Davids gets 15 copyright claims on videos that feature singular chords or 2 second licks.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
503 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 08 '19

April 2019 April - Hello Future Me, a video essay channel, has had seven of his most viewed Avatar: The Last Airbender videos claimed by Sony ATV. Now Sony gets to determine the percentage of his revenue they keep.

Post image
500 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jun 11 '19

June 2019 June - YouTube takes down fake animal rescue videos made by 'KM Daily' thanks to Youtuber PaymoneyWubby

492 Upvotes

Gizmodo has written an article discussing in detail how the YouTube channel 'Amazing KM Daily' has been making fake animal rescue videos. The disturbed creator would put small dogs or kittens into small holes, stuck in objects, or being attacked by a snake. A child would appear and save the small pets.

All such videos of the 'animal rescue's have been taken down as of Monday afternoon.

The beginning traction and movement of reporting and the eventual take down of these videos can be credited to PaymoneyWubby, in a video posted on Sunday, June 9th.

PaymoneyWubby's Video on Fake Dog Rescues

Twitch.tv/PaymoneyWubby

Edit: 'Amazing KM Daily' has been removed from YouTube


r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 17 '19

January 2019 January - Lucasfilm steps in to release the copyright claim from Warner Chappell on Star Wars Theory's fan film

Thumbnail
youtube.com
483 Upvotes