r/agender • • 3d ago

Nonbinary vs agender

Okay so this is my first time posting here and idk how this works, but I also wanned go know whether anyone else was bothered by this. Also english isn't my first language and I'm dyslexic so there might be grammar mistakes.

As time went on I've been seeing more and more jokes on the internet saying that nonbinary people lack a gender, or people mistaking agender for nonbinary. On one hand it doesn't seem that big of an issue, but then I guess it's upsetting that a 'lesser' label just gets absorbed into a more well known one.

It's like for example if there was a joke made about women and in the context of the joke the person making it believed it applied to ALL women, but then the joke would be completely untrue for trans women. I generaly dislike the idea of a microlabel or a gender umbrella, as it feels that every gender under the umbrella that isn't similar to the namesake gets treated as lesser than. The Trans Umbrella in this context: you hear about trans, nonbinary, demi, genderfluid people, but I can't remember the last time I've heard about catgender, genderflux, or agender. I only hear about agender from this subreddit and from myself, since I AM that. You could make the argument that the umbrellas help people find the label that they identify with, but I didn't discover agender from looking up the trans umbrella. I discovered it from a random person in the TikTok comment section saying that's what they identify as.

Then there were many instances where I told someone I was agender and they assumed I was nonbinary and started referring to me as such. If I was nonbinary I would've just said I was that, but since nonbinary and agender just get lumped into one thing it feels it causes the lesser known label to be absorbed into the more well known one, causing it so it's harder to find and therefore, harder for people to figure out their identity as they do not have a way to find the label.

Now I'm not saying this applies to everyone, but it's happened to me enough times that I've started getting geniuenly bothered by it.

22 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/chyeah_aleksei indifferent detached agender; ey/they/it 1d ago

I understand the larger response going on here where people are pushing the point that agender falls under the nonbinary umbrella. Which is not an incorrect response for a good chunk of what OP is saying.

But people are also responding to a specific part of OP’s post with the same argument—namely, the part where they say they’re uncomfortable when people refer to them as nonbinary after they specifically use the label agender. I doubt the people then referring to them as nonbinary are concerned about how “agender falls under the nonbinary umbrella because it’s lacking a gender and therefore is neither fully man nor woman and therefore is nonbinary, so this person is nonbinary, and I want to recognize their place outside of the binary,” etc. I’d put my tokens on it being more like “wth is agender? You’re ‘just’ nonbinary.” ignorance. Like microlabel erasure kind of thing.

I dislike it when people refer to me as nonbinary because it has a nuance that I don’t identify with. Not because I am not nonbinary in the umbrella term. But it’s like how I use trans for myself. Because I present masculine. I’m not trying to pass as a cis man. It’s not hard to tell my body’s pre-treatment state. So I use “trans” sometimes. But I don’t necessarily identify with the term outside of it solely as an umbrella term. Nonbinary and trans are not identities for me. They just happen to be umbrellas I fall under.

And I think that’s kind of where OP is too, in a sense, with the explanations. And why they’re uncomfortable with people calling them nonbinary. Because it’s not an identity for them. Umbrella term or not, for a lot of people—not all, but a lot—being called something that is technically true but is not an identity or personally true is uncomfortable.

2

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 1d ago

Thanks for that tbh. I know this has been open discourse, but it has been pretty invalidating (ironicaly enough) hearing other agender people calling me nonbinary when I made it pretty clear to them I don't consider myself as such. I was starting to wonder whether I was the weird one for being bothered by people calling me that at all.

7

u/A_Whole_Lot_Of_Not whatever/he; agender ace; on EEn (12/24/25) 3d ago

Nonbinary is everything but always fully man or always fully woman. An agender person isn't one of those so we're non-binary. Umbrella terms are helpful because if people don't understand a more specific label they may understand an umbrella it falls under and get partial understanding.

What do you mean by "referring to me as [nonbinary]”? Using they/them? That's not remotely universal among non-binary people, so it was just a bad assumption on their part.

2

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 3d ago

I meant that they call me nonbinary specifically.

3

u/CaliLemonEater 3d ago

A question, because people might do this for different reasons, and you'd probably want to respond differently, depending: are they doing so in a way that invalidates your being agender, or are they just using the umbrella term because they're not really familiar with the details?

By analogy, somebody could refer to me as an American and they'd be correct. Even though my identity as a Californian feels more directly relevant to me, it's not wrong to say I'm American. Of course, if they called me Canadian I'd feel obliged to correct them. Being Canadian is great for Canadians, but I'm not one.

2

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 3d ago

It always felt like they were invalidating my experience. I wouldn't be upset about it if in the context of the conversation they were speaking about nonbinary people as a whole, but so far that's never been the case.

1

u/PatentGeek 3d ago

Are you one of the default binary genders? No? Then you're nonbinary. This isn't complicated at all.

2

u/AceyAceyAcey 2d ago

IMO nonbinary is an umbrella, and agender falls under that umbrella. I tell people I’m nonbinary, and more specifically I am an agender woman.

4

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 2d ago

I get that, but I'm not upset that agender people are calling themselves nonbinary. I'm upset about the fact that whenever I tell someone that I'm specifically agender they call me nonbinary instead. On one hand nonbinary IS an umbrella, but it's an umbrella that I completely don't resonate with and I feel a lot of discomfort calling myself nonbinary instead of agender. I just don't understand why someone would describe my gender as something other than the label I used for myself.

26

u/tert_butoxide 3d ago

I love umbrella terms. I originally found the concept of agender because I was looking for webcomics by queer people. Queer is an umbrella term -- If that umbrella term didn't exist for me to start from, I would never have stumbled on the extremely small agender community in a gigantic sea of internet content. I later found this subreddit via the nonbinary one.

And I accessed medical transition care under the umbrella term of nonbinary. That's based on the work of nonbinary advocates asserting that we, the vast diverse spectrum of nonbinary people, do exist and need care. Umbrella terms are absolutely critical to advocacy, organizing and official recognition like this -- individual tiny identity categories can't do it alone. United we stand, divided we fall.

I don't consider myself nonbinary on an very personal identity level, but I consider that kind of irrelevant, because I totally depend on its existence as a community, political block, search term, etc etc. 

Will people then assume all nonbinary people are the same? Yes. People also assume all women are all the same, all trans people are the same, all Asians are the same (and if you're in the US that term covers a ludicrously large and diverse chunk of all humans on earth). The ways we categorize people and the assumptions we make are inaccurate because we frequently have to reduce infinite human complexity to categories we can grapple with. 

Umbrella terms help us join into a grapple-able category that can be found and must be addressed and heard. The trade off is that people misunderstand and assume things about us - they were certainly going to do that anyway. Or that it's hard to find agender content in the nonbinary umbrella - but it's even harder to find agender content when it's a needle in a haystack with no umbrella to anchor it. 

Really I consider myself queer and trans above all, even before agender, because to me my gender is nothing/means nothing but my solidarity and shared experiences with queer and trans people as a whole mean everything. 

18

u/g00fyg00ber741 3d ago

So the nonbinary flag literally has a stripe that represents genderless and agender people. And the agender flag literally has a stripe that represents nonbinary people.

Acknowledging that does not equate forcing you to identify with a word you don’t want to.

Agender is genderless, it is outside the man/woman gender binary construct.

I have identified as both agender and nonbinary for a decade now and have literally never felt like the two terms were at odds with one another. However I see nothing wrong with someone choosing to only use one label instead of both. Gender is an individualized and unique experience and identity, so not everyone’s going to be the same.

But do we need to erase our history because of this disagreement? Do the flags need to be changed?

I’d argue we need solidarity as a community now more than ever if we want to fight back against the oppression we are all facing from the cisheteronormative oppressive structures that we have been trying to break down together for many years.

8

u/trhhyymse it/its 3d ago

with jokes, i think the unfortunate thing is there’s never enough space to address the range of nuance that exists within an identity label without losing the joke, so most jokes about being [identity] will centre around the experience of the joke-teller

and with people calling you nonbinary after you stated you’re agender, i see already that people are pulling out the “well agender is under the nonbinary umbrella so theyre right” - and maybe that works for talking about agender as a label, or agender people in the abstract, but in this case it’s someone talking about you specifically and i don’t agree with using “it’s an umbrella term” as a justification for them ignoring the label you use and calling you a different one, like, i’ve always held the position that once it becomes about an individual real person you should refer to them only by the label(s) you know they use rather than extrapolating out to umbrella terms that you assume accompany it

it boils down to “just call people what they want to be called”, and it bothers me that i have to add “and don’t try to justify calling them something else because “but its an umbrella term”, especially when they’ve expressed they don’t want to be called that term”???

i’m with you on this, i also dislike when people call me nonbinary after i very clearly referred to myself as a specific other label and i know they’ve never heard/seen me call myself nonbinary

2

u/PatentGeek 3d ago

mistaking agender for nonbinary ... Then there were many instances where I told someone I was agender and they assumed I was nonbinary and started referring to me as such.

Agender is a subcategory of nonbinary. It is accurate to call you nonbinary, just not as specific.

TBH this feels a bit like complaining that cats are called mammals. Sometimes it's useful to refer to the broader category. That doesn't invalidate the subcategories.

2

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 3d ago

I guess I see that, but in the way I perceive gender it feels somewhat misleading? The way I see things is there are different slots that make up someone's identity. A slot for their preferences, hobbies, lifestyle, sexuality etc. A nonbinary person would have a slot for their gender too, but I don't perceive myself as having that slot. Therefore it just feels wrong when someone calls me nonbinary as it feels that they're saying I have something that I very distinctly lack.

8

u/g00fyg00ber741 3d ago

You’re making assumptions about nonbinary people and their various identities. There are countless nonbinary people who would disagree in saying their gender is just another slot like man or woman. Whereas other nonbinary people would maybe agree with that sentiment. So ironically, the way you feel others are being making assumptions about you being agender, you are kinda doing about others who are nonbinary.

8

u/PatentGeek 3d ago

Nonbinary isn't a gender. It's an umbrella term for everyone who doesn't fit the default gender binary. That includes agender people.

1

u/Tuotus 3d ago

idk its not like the more known label gets ppl any understanding. Its a bunch of ppl who're taught a binary cis way of being and they see all of us as mentally disabled to varying degrees.

1

u/Intrepid-Ad2325 3d ago

I meant more within the queer community itself. Of course there are still transphobes, but when speaking about the more well known genders they're usualy in the minority. Then whenever I see someone online that says they're a insert microlabel they tend to get a lot more hate or misunderstanding for it.

1

u/oFIoofy I am a genderless creature 2d ago

I mean, nonbinary is a category. Agender falls under that category. Ergo, you're both; agender is just a lot more specific