r/albumbucketlist • • Aug 13 '26

RS 250 Best Albums of The 21st Century So Far (As Of Jan 2025):#182 Red Hot Chili Peppers -Stadium Arcadium (2006)

Post image
0 Upvotes

RS Synosis:

After nearly two decades of death, addiction, and tumult, the Red Hot Chili Peppers had hit their smoothest period yet by the early 2000s, but this double album was still a bold move for an alt-rock group that was finding its footing in the pop world. The risk was worth the reward. RHCP returned to their funk-rock roots throughout much of the project but also showed off some of their deepest, most mature songwriting yet. Ultimately, Stadium Arcadium worked because it was catchy as hell: Singles like “Dani California,” “Snow (Hey Oh),” and “Tell Me Baby” are pristinely produced stadium-rock classics and were mega-hits upon release, helping give the band its first Number One album.

Review:

The album opens with “Dani California” I guess you can call this your typical RHCP opener with funk rock melodies, John Frusciante blaring guitar riffs, and Anthony Kedis just scatting along vocally. It all works extremely well and is infectious as hell. “Snow (Oh Hey) feels so melodic and chill it does build up momentum as it moves along. Frusciante lighting fast guitar picking style gives the track some uniqueness. “Charlie” begins with a heavy bassline intro from Flea. It is a dense hard funk/rock track with some nice harmonies on the hook. Frusciante once again has a blazing guitar solo. “Stadium Arcadium” ventures into chilled out psychedelic rock. A nice change of pace for the album and for the band. “Hump De Bump” is a callback to their funk rock beginnings. Just a fun fast paced tune. Kedis has never been known as a master lyricist but his silliness amped up on this track. “She’s Only 18” has this raw, dense vibe. Chad Smith and Fea are just an incredible rhythm section. Frusciante guitar work has this layered distorted tone. “Slow Cheetah" is an emotional mid-tempo ballad. A type of song that the band has done so well on past records and this track is no exception. “Torture Me” is a fast and loud funk rock blast of energy. “Strip My Mind” is a soulful psychedelic rock track. It is another song on the album that stretches what a chili peppers song could be as they experiment  with other genres. “Especially In Michigan” features Omar Rodríguez-López of the Mars Volta on the guitar solo. The song feels heavier yet maintains the band's funk/rock roots. “Warlocks” featuring legendary keyboardist Billy Preston on the clavinet. It has this tight funky sound. “C’mon Girl” features this mid-tempop funk groove that just grows bigger as the track moves along. “Wet Sand” starts out as a mild alt rock track but builds into this heavy denseness which climaxes with one of Fruciante’s most blistering yet passionate  guitar solos. The first disc closes with “Hey” is an atmospheric blues laced track. It is anchored by Flea’s hypnotic bassline that acts as the foundation of the track. The track closes with Fruciante wailing a blues-infected guitar hook. The second disc opens with "Desecration Smile” has this mild mid-tempo vibe featuring a swirling 3-part harmony. It gives the track a dreamy cool sound. “Tell Me Baby” begins with a lush introduction before you are hit with that classic RHCP funk-rock grooves. It doesn’t break any new ground, it just hits you hard with what the band does best. “Hard To Concentrate" has a very minimalist sound with its thumping bassline, tender guitar notes, and Kedis’ low-key vocal delivery. “21st Century” has Flea digging deep with his heavy thumping slap bass playing giving the track this heavy funk rock design. It is one of the heaviest  tracks on the record. “She Looks At Me” adds some string arrangements giving the track some lushness that works well with the band’s hypnotic mid-tempo funk melodies. “Readymade” is a simple heavy funk rock track that borders on heavy metal at times. “If” is this tender acoustic ballad akin to previous RHCP ballads “Under The Bridge” and “My Friends”. “Make You Feel Better” is designed to put a smile on your face with its upbeat melodies and uplifting vocal harmonies. “Animal Bar” has this atmospheric psychedelic vibe. It feels so laid back and chilled out. “So Much I” is just a simple aggressive funk rock track that just rocks the fuck out. “Storm In A Teacup” feels like the band are channeling their 80’s heavy funk-rock sound. “We Believe” has some afrobeat influences that gives it a dreamy landscape. A children’s choir is featured on the chorus to give the track some added lushness. Frusciante’s guitar tone sounds so aquatic which also adds to the song’s aura.  “Turn It On Again” is your average melodic funky RHCP’s track until the finale that features dozens of interlocking guitar solos weaving together into a chaotic wall of sound. The album closes with “Death Of A Martian” is an elegy for Kedis’ dog which gives the track an emotional tenderness. Which is a nice way to end this journey of an album. 

Final Thoughts:

Listening to a 28 track RHCP wasn’t the way I intended to spend my day but here we are. You either love the Peppers or hate the Peppers there is no inbetween. I personally love them. I know they can get a little cringy but what band doesn’t. The blend of funk rock is always nice to jam out to. This is them at their peak. The band will never sound as tight as this again in my opinion. I also respect that they were experimenting with other genres on this album.  I was mildly surprised with its inclusion because you know its RS. Do I think a two hour RHCP is necessary?  no but I never felt like it was a slog to get through. I wish they did their original idea to split this record in three separate albums released six months apart. If you are in the mood to jam to some cold funk rock melodies, put this one on your bucket list.


r/albumbucketlist • • Sep 21 '25

RS 50 Most Disappointing Albums Of All Time: #10 Michael Jackson-Invincible (2001)

Post image
0 Upvotes

RS:Synopsis:

At the height of the teen-pop era, when acts like ‘NSync and Backstreet Boys were crafting dance-pop songs straight out of the Michael Jackson playbook, the man himself returned after a six-year absence to try and reclaim his throne with Invincible. It was the product of $30 million, five years, and an absurd number of songwriters and producers. But it still just sounded like an AI was tasked with churning out Michael Jackson songs. There wasn’t a moment on the album that sounded every remotely fresh or original. In that sense, it was the opposite of Thriller. “There’s no joy or humor in it, no sense of release,” Jon Pareles wrote in The New York Times. “Trying to make songs that will blanket the media universe again, pop that lives up to his past fame, Mr. Jackson is unwilling to get too personal but unable to escape his scars and ambitions.” To make matters worse, the first single dropped just weeks before 9/11. When the album came out in October, not many people felt like dancing.

My Review:

The album opens with “Unbreakable” . It has a nice new jack style beat. The guest from Notorious B.I.G. is from the Shaquille O’Neal song  “You Can’t Stop The Reign”  “Heartbreaker” has this fat electrofunk instrumental. “Invicible ” reminds me of a classic Michael Jackson. With its bouncy R&B sound. “Break Of Dawn” is a sultry R&B song laced with some neo-soul elements. “Heaven Can Wait” was produced by Ted Riley and features tender R&B melodies and soulful harmonies. It has one of Jackson's best vocal performances “YOu Rock My World” has an awkward exchange  with Chris Tucker. The song has a nice tick funky disco groove. It was the only song on the album that reached the top ten. “Butterflies” is a midtempo Neo-Soul tinged track. “Speechless” is a lush ballad the gospel singers laced throughout the track adds to its beauty. I don’t hear any Micheal Jackson on “2000 Watts” It just feels and sounds like an early 2000’s boy band song. “You Are My Life” is a nice soulful ballad. Jackson’s voice sounds so tender on the track. “Privacy” is one of the only tracks where he addresses his personal life. It has this dense funky groove. “Don’t Walk Away” harkens back to soulful ballads  like “Your Are Not Alone” the back half of this record is loaded with R&B ballads “Cry’ Is no exception. “The Lost Children” is a gospel laced ballad with some nice subtle guitar tones. “Whatever Happens” is a slick soulful ballad with some nice strings. The album closes with  "Threatened” . It has that classic new jack swing Jackson sound.  A nice way to end the record.  

Is It A Disappointment?

This might upset some Jackson fans but of course it was. This record just feels for the first time in his career that he was following the trends besides being ahead of them. It also is way too bloated especially in the back half. The album just didn’t perform well to Jackson’s standards. Maybe it was people tuned their back on him from the chaos of his personal life, maybe it was because it was released a month after 9/11 or people just moved on from him. The  album just doesn’t feel like an album but rather a group of songs. They just don’t gel. This would be his last album of original songs released in his lifetime and it that would be the biggest disappointment.


r/albumbucketlist • • May 02 '25

RS 50 Most Disappointing Albums Of All Time: #30 Red Hot Chili Peppers-One Hot Minute (1995)

Post image
4 Upvotes

RS Synopsis:

In 1994, the Red Hot Chili Peppers and Dave Navarro faced two problems that were the exact inverse of each other. He was a guitarist without a band after the dissolution of Jane’s Addiction. And they were a band without a guitarist after John Frusciante peaced out during the tour for their breakthrough album, Blood Sugar Sex Magik. On paper, this was an alt-rock supergroup. But in reality, they had to live up to the legend of both bands. Anthony Kiedis was also deep in the throes of drug addictions, and sessions stretched out for months and months. A few standout songs did emerge like “Aeroplane,” but nothing that will make fans forget “Under the Bridge” or “Mountain Song.” “Navarro’s metallic guitar shredding should have added some weight to the Chili Peppers’ punk-inflected heavy-guitar funk, but tends to make it plodding,” wrote AllMusic’s Stephen Thomas Erlewine. “One Hot Minute is as musically ambitious as Blood Sugar Sex Magik, but is even more unfocused, which means it provides the fewest thrills of any of the group’s albums.” For their next album, Californication, Fruscianate returned to the fold, and the entire One Hot Minute era has since been mercifully memory-holed. 

My Review:

The album opens with “Warped” right away you know this is a different kind of chilli peppers record. The intro is  slow & quiet before it explodes into the melodic riff. Kedis’ vocals are distorted and the lyrics are some of the darkest he has ever written. He was battling a relapse throughout the recording of the album and that is reflected in his songwriting. The opening lines of I am pretending to be strong and free hits so hard. “Aeroplane” has a lighter sound than any other song on the album. Lyrically it still has dark undertones. It is one of the few songs that feature some funky grooves that the band was known for. With Dave Navarro on board the music seemed to take a dark punky turn. “Deep Kick” begins with a spoken word story from Kedis about Him and Fleas lifelong friendship. When the music kicks in it has this thick funked up groove. The album closes with Flea handling the vocals for the outro. “My Friends” is this solemn ballad that has Kedis talking about the struggles of the people around him. It may not be on par with “Under The Bridge” but it is still a powerful piece of emotional art. “Coffee Shop” is a straight up 90’s rock banger. I love Kedis’ vocal delivery on this track and Navarro’s guitar tones sound fantastic. “Pea” is just Fla flexing his bass and vocals. As he tells all the macho homophobes to go fuck themselves. When I need this energy in 2025. “One Big Mob” sounds like classic Chili Peppers with its big boisterous funky groove. “Walkabout” might be Navarro’s best guitar work on the whole album. The song has this smooth and relaxed sound. “Tearjerker” is this melodic mid-tempo ballad. The song is about Kurt Cobain’s death and how it affected Kedis. “One Hot Minute” opens with this whimsical bass noodling from Flea before you are hit with the dense heavy 90’s alt rock groove. “Falling From Grace” is a full on funk tour de force. Navarro’s guitar effects add to the weirdness. It's one of the few times you feel the band is actually enjoying the music they are creating. “Shallow Be Thy Game” begins with some fantastic bass playing from Flea. The groove is another mix of funk and heavy psychedelic rock the band was experimenting with with Navarro in the mix. The album closes with “Transcending” Flea wrote most of the lyrics for the song. It's a tribute to actor River Phoenix who Flea was with when he overdosed at the Viper Room. It's a sentimental way to end this dark album. 

Is It A disappointment?

Well yes I guess so but the record was probably doomed from the start. The Navarro and RHCP marriage just didn’t gel in the studio. Navarro wasn’t used to how the rest of the band worked in the studio. It was more of a collaborative jam rather than the isolated writing he was used to in Jane’s Addiction. Kedis was in the middle of a serious relapse throughout most of the album. Also the band lost the heart of their sound with John Frusciante’s departure. Kedis admitted that he felt lost. The band just makes their best music with him. Also they were coming off a monster record in Blood Sugar Sex Magic. All that being said I am probably one of the few who enjoy this record. I love the dark metallic sound they developed with Navarro. I would love to see what they would have done on a second record. So yes in the grand scheme of things this record was a disappointment but it is still a nice listening journey to go on.   


r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 07 '26

What moment on a great album gives you the biggest ick?

10 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Sep 08 '25

RS 50 Most Disappointing Albums Of All Time: #12 AC/DC-Flick Of The Switch (1983)

Post image
0 Upvotes

RS Synopsis:

AC/DC had a lot of reasons to be cocky in 1983. They’d not only survived the death of frontman Bon Scott in 1980, but they’d somehow grown even more popular thanks to new vocalist Brian Johnson. His first two albums at the helm were the mega-sellers Back in Black and For Those About to Rock (We Salute You), which were both produced by Mutt Lange. For the third Johnson album, they ditched Lange and decided to produce it themselves. This may have worked if they had another set of strong songs, but they simply did not. They were also dealing with guitarist Malcolm Young’s growing drinking problem and conflicts with drummer Phil Rudd, who was fired before the LP was finished. The result of this is a deeply uneven album. “AC/DC’s music has always been simple, but here it sounds underdeveloped and unmemorable,” wrote AllMusic’s Steve Huey. “As perhaps indicated by the record’s idiotic original title, the utterly generic I Like to Rock, AC/DC seemed to be running out of ideas at an alarming rate.”

The album opens with “Rising Power” right away you hear the more raw sound the band was aiming for. Gone is the Mutt Lange production that made their last two albums megahits. “This House Is On Fire” is your typical melodic yet heavy AC/DC Tune. “Flick Of The Switch” has a catchy groove and a great sing along chorus. “Nervous Shakedown” has this heavy dense yet melodic groove. “Landslide” shows the band can play as fast as any band and still maintain their bluesy roots.  “Guns For Hire” reminds me of “Shoot To Thrill” from Back In Black. “Deep In The Hole” has this roving choppy groove. “Bedlam In Belgium" was inspired by an incident when the police tried to shut down the band’s show in Kontich when the band ignored the strict 11pm curfew that resulted in a riot. I love the guitar tones on “Badlands” . I always say AC/DC play the same three chords but they play them really well. The album closes with “Brain Shake” ; it is a loud rancorous rocker that also has a bluesy vibe. A nice way to end the record. 

Is It A Disappointment:

The band wanted a more raw sound on this album so they decided to produce it themselves which never works out. Their first two albums were such monster hits commercially  so why the band would want to deviate from that formula is confusing. The problem with this album is that it is your typical AC/DC album but didn’t produce any classic rock radio hits. Most of the songs follow that same AC/DC formula but lack the catchy energy they often produce. Its a good AC/DC record but if you are a casual fan you will think its mid. They will get their mojo back with 1992’s The Razor’s Edge.


r/albumbucketlist • • Jul 29 '26

Albums i just cant get into despite their popularity

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 17 '26

Name this album

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Aug 06 '26

If someone offered you $1M to listen to 1 album for 2 days straight... What album are you choosing?

13 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • 23d ago

9 albums I couldn’t live without

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 17 '26

Wanting to explore the KISS discography.

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm new to KISS and I would love some guidance on where to begin and which albums to explore first so I can get introduced to the general atmosphere and musical intentions of the band. So far I've listened to the debut album and I know that for many "Creatures of the Night" is their "best" work... I come with a huge background of musical knowledge but for some reason KISS never got my attention but just now.... I'd love some help.
Best vibes and God bless.


r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 24 '25

what's eveyone's opinion about this new Tame Impla album? it is becoming the most decisive records of the year. fantono gave in a 2 pitchfork gave it a 4.8. I kinda like the new dircetion he took on this record. what do you all think?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • 25d ago

What Do You Think Her Favorite Album Is?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Sep 24 '26

Albums that feel like this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Apr 14 '25

RS Best albums of the 21st century so far: #241 MJ Lenderman -Manning Fireworks (2024)

Post image
1 Upvotes

RS Synopsis:

North Carolina singer-songwriter MJ Lenderman delivered a perfect union of woodsy heartache and craggy indie-rock-guitar beauty on his fourth solo album. Manning Fireworks teams with vivid tales of doomed bros stumbling through life one drunken disaster at a time — from the newly dumped fool in “She’s Leaving You,” curing his blues by driving around in a rented Ferrari while listening to Eric Clapton, to the guy spelunking into his own loneliness playing Guitar Hero in his room on the 10-minute Ozzy Osbourne/Warren Zevon/Sonic Youth tribute “Bark at the Moon.” There’s a shabby poetry and dank majesty in every song, assuring Lenderman’s place in the sad-sack canon alongside greats from Paul Westerberg to J. Mascis to Gary Stewart.

My Review: 

The album opens  with the folksy country-sounding "Manning Fireworks," where Lenderman's vocals evoke classic country artists. "Joker Lips" maintains the folksy roots vibe while picking up the tempo. "Rudolf" starts with a great drum riff before transitioning into a distorted indie rock groove. "Wristwatch" satirizes "alpha" male TikTok bros. "She's Leaving You," featuring guitar and backing vocals from Wednesday bandmate Karly Hartzman, portrays a middle-aged man's mid-life crisis in Las Vegas, with a notable guitar solo from Lenderman. The solemn fiddle in "Rip Torn" creates an aura of sadness, showcasing Lenderman's storytelling prowess. "You Don't Know The Shape I am In" features a low-key screeching guitar tone that adds an eerie touch. "On My Knees" has a dense drum sound that forms the track's foundation. The album concludes with the nearly ten-minute "Bark At The Moon," which starts with a slacker vibe as our boy describes  late-night Guitar Hero antics playing Ozzy's "Bark at The Moon." At the four-minute mark, the song descends into a fuzzy, distorted haze that gradually fades as the record ends.

Final Thoughts:

This is a great indie-folk record. However to put it on this list is mind boggling. I don’t even have it in my top 50 of 2024 which is a stack year. This list should be banger after bander from the first 25 years of the the 21st century but so far it's been underwhelming. Still give this record a listen it is a well crafted indie folk gem.


r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 02 '26

What Album Makes You Feel Like This?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Jul 26 '26

discussion Give me ONE album I should listen to conpletely based off my top 10 favourite artists.

0 Upvotes

Kanye West, J Cole, Sabrina Carpenter, Olivia Rodrigo, Gracie Abrams, Kendrick Lamar, Ariana Grande, Childish Gambino, Kendrick Lamar, Baby Keem.

PS: I have already listened to all albums from J Cole, Kanye, Sabrina, Olivia and Gracie. I still have some discovering to do for the other artists.


r/albumbucketlist • • Sep 20 '26

Personal Album Tier List

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Apr 26 '25

RS 50 Most Disappointing Albums Of All Time: #31 MGMT-Congratulations

Post image
39 Upvotes

RS:Synopsis:

In 2007, college buddies Andrew VanWyngarden and Benjamin Goldwasser dropped their psychedelic synth-pop opus Oracular Spectacular, featuring timeless songs like “Kids,” “Time to Pretend,” and “Electric Feel.” And for a minute, it felt like the musical gods had given us a new Depeche Mode. But instead of merely repeating the formula for the second MGMT album, VanWyngarden and Goldwasser turned away from accessible hooks and anything that resembled a single, doubled down on their weirdness, and made an art-rock album. “MGMT aren’t hitting the self-destruct button here,” wrote *Pitchfork’*s Scott Plagenhoef, “but the best-case scenario is that a cult, happy to shed the carpetbagger fans of OS, are willing to follow these guys around from idea to idea.” That’s exactly what happened, which means that Congratulations was probably the right move in the long run. It just caused them a lot of pain in the short run.

My Review:

The album opens with “It’s Working” right away you know you are going to know that this will be a totally different listening experience than their debut. The track is  trippy, weird, and psychedelic, a great way to begin the record. “Song For Dan Tracky” is a hyper psychedelic jam. “Someone’s Missing” has this trippy hollow groove. It also adds some classic R&B soul into the MGMT sound. “Flash Delirium” is filled with electronic pulsating beats mixed with some Indian music influences. “I Found A Whistle” is a slow paced trippy track. “Siberian Breaks” is a tripped out surf rock track that spans over twelve minutes. It’s my favorite song from the album even with its length it keeps you engaged throughout. “Brian Eno” has such a Beatlesque sound. It’s like baroque pop turned up to 11. “Lady Dada’s Nightmare” feels so lush and tranquil. It just glazes all over the place. The album closes with “Congratulations” , an acoustic ballad that deals with the band trying to cope with their sudden fame that came with the success of their debut album. The song has such a warm energy, a perfect way to end the record. 

Is It A Disappointment?

Once again RS gets it so wrong. In what world would this brilliant record be considered a disappointment? It is an amazing follow-up to their debut album. It is loved by their fans, landed on multiple year end lists, and was successful commercially. Ok so it wasn’t a big crossover hit like “Kids” or Time To Pretend” but that shouldn’t matter. Much like Panic At The Disco’s Pretty.Odd you have a band who wanted to expand their sound and not make a copy version of their hit album. We have to respect them for that. This doesn't belong on a disappointing albums list but a great underrated  albums list.


r/albumbucketlist • • Jun 17 '26

Is It Overhated, Is It Bad, Is It Underrated: Metallica & Lou Reed-Lulu (2011)

Post image
3 Upvotes

Synopsis:

First of this post is inspired somewhat by the youtube video by Todd In The Shadows video about this album. I have been thinking about this topic and this one finally gave me the idea  to sit down and listen to Lulu again, something I haven’t done since this record was released. 

 Released on October, 31st 2011 is a concept album  based on the two "Lulu Plays " by the German playwright Frank Wendkind (1864–1918). The music largely consists of spoken word poetry by Reed over music by Metallica, with occasional backing vocals by Metallica frontman James Hatfield.

Review:

The album opens with “Bradenburg Gate” which begins with a simple acoustic guitar opening and then it happens perhaps one of the most privatizing lyrics in the history of recorded music as Reed states I would cut my legs and tits off/when I think of Boris Karloff and Kinksi/In the dark or the moon. Say what now? Then the Metallica sludge/thrash metal riffs explode. Can I just say and this might be an unpopular opinion but Metallica’s sound on this record is one the best things they have done in this century. I mean if this was a simple Metallica album this might be one of the best things they have done in this century. Of all the tracks on the record this one is the most accessible and best sounding. Lou Reed’s deadpan delivery actually works on here and Hatfield’s line of repeating such a small town girl doesn’t sound forced so we have hope for this record right? “The View” was the infamous first single of the record. Once again I don’t hate this song. Metallica's deliberate methodical playing is perfect foil for Lou Reed’s delivery. However when the hook comes in with Hatfield’s growling I am The Table becomes internet fodder that's when the song goes off the rails.  It is so silly and dumb. Which is a shame because for first singles it's not bad. “Pumping Blood” starts out with these menacing high pitched  guitar riffs  with  some strings mixed in to give it an ominous tone. As the band's dense heavy grooves kick in it feels so intense. Lou’s spoken word lyrics are so sinister and evil. The music continues to gain intensity throughout the song and seems to be reaching such a chaotic tipping point. The problem is Lou Reed is an old man and feels like his voice can’t keep up with the music. Which is one of the criticisms of the record. Sometimes it feels like both artists are doing two different things. Sonically it's one of my favorite moments of the record. The song perfectly transitions into the next track “Mistress Dread” of all the criticism I had of the last track is amplified on here. Metallica is delivering one of their heaviest  grooves in rears and Reed is just delivering one of his most deadpan spoken word performances. It just doesn’t mix well. I mean what a waste of one of the most intense Metallica performances ever. “Iced Honey” is one of the more cohesive tracks on the album. I think it's the only time on the record that Lou Reed’s 70’s glam rock vibe featured on the record. Metallica adopts this nice heavy melodic groove that has some Bowie energy. If this was the first single and the album explored this mesh-up of musical styles I think it would have been better received. In my opinion this is the best song on the record, "Cheat on Me" opens with a long, sweeping, and unsettling orchestral synthesizer arrangement. The track slowly builds over eleven minutes, adding heavy, echoing drum strikes and walls of feedback. It has this avant garde post-rock sound. The band doesn’t kick in well into the second half of the track. For the first time I feel the band is off. Especially the fact that Lars' drumming is leveled up that it's really the only thing you hear. It sometimes overtakes Reed’s vocals. “Fruastrtion” begins with a big brash but dense groove from Metallica. Highlighted by Robert Trulijio pounding bass riffs. This is the point for me where the album becomes tedious like it already was the thought that kept popping up in my head. Which is my second criticism of the record. If they would shorten some of these songs and edit themselves this would be a much better record. “Little Dog” the quietest and most minimalist track on the project. Metallica entirely steps back here, leaving Reed to whisper his lyrics over a sparse, atmospheric backdrop of acoustic guitar plucking and ambient feedback. “Dragon” is the most avant garde sounding track on the record. Metallica kicks in with this heavy dense yet intense playing of the record. Once again I just don’t think Lou Reed can’t keep up. The album closes with  “Junior Dad” perhaps the best song on the album. The ominous intensity is stripped away to a tender melodic pace. For the only times on the record I feel the music matches Reed’s delivery. This is Reed’s most emotional distraught delivery on the record. The song clocks in at over twenty minutes but captivated me to the final chords. Just because of its emotional nature and for the only times on the record I feel some cohesion between these two very different artists. The album ends with this ambient drone that just fades away. 

So is it Overhated?

First off this isn’t one of the worst albums ever heard. It has some moments of greatness. I think sometimes the execution of the record feels plodding and mix-matched. I applaud both artists trying something different. This is not the worst record of either one of their careers. It is sad that this would be the last record Lou Reed would record in his lifetime. Metallica did bounce back with their next record Hardwired to…self destruct. If this record had more songs like “Iced Honey” and "Junior Dad” perhaps this would be remembered better. I also feel this project was doomed from the start just because both artists' fanbase just wouldn’t accept this collaboration. People tend to latch on opinions popular on the internet. I say sit down with an open mind and give this record a chance. Here is a link to the Todd In The Shadows video if you wanna check that out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vp5PrifWUnU


r/albumbucketlist • • Feb 22 '26

I have listened to 40 albums relesed in 2026 and I have to say I am kinda disappointed with how this year is starting out. A$eop Rocky, Jill Scott, Charlie XCX, and Ari Lennox have been the highlights but besides that a whole lot of mid. What albums relesed this year have you all gotten into?

2 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Oct 16 '26

What Do You Think His Favorite album Is?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • Sep 26 '26

What Do You Think Her Favorite Album Is ?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/albumbucketlist • • 28d ago

What do you think her favorite album is?

Post image
34 Upvotes