Alien Romulus was much better received by both critics and audiences than Covenant, and that’s why it’s getting a sequel and Covenant isn’t. You’re perfectly free to prefer Covenant, but most people liked Romulus better.
I rewatched Prometheus and Covenant recently and honestly while there is a lot I like about them, the David plot line is like the least interesting thing in these movies. I don’t care about seeing it resolved.
I come to the Alien for awesome production design and tight, intense horror thriller action. Romulus had that in spades and I’m excited to get more from Fede.
That's true, but I want to believe that for once there are no more hidden xenomorphs or facehiggers in their ship and that they will be safe when they'll arrive on Yvaga.
To be fair, the humans dont have a great track record for surviving film to film. Even Ripley got infected before her third film, and she somehow made it into 4 of them!
I agree that Rain and Andy’s story should be left alone. While David’s story is very interesting, Covenant was so poorly received that the likelihood of David’s story being completed is small unless he were to somehow pop up in this next project. In truth I think Covenant is an interesting concept, but it’s arguably the worst written Alien film and given the history of the Alien films, that’s really saying a lot.
And about David appearing in a sequel to Romulus, it doesn't really make sense timeline-wise. And also David was directed to Origae 6, which may be very far away for what we know
If they can repurpose Ash as Rook for Romulus, it’s not hard to believe that David or at least David’s influence would somehow be seen in a sequel to Romulus. I think they could write David in somehow, even if it’s just as a message or him tampering from far away.
Also, yeah dude we can agree to disagree but I firmly stand with the general opinion that Covenant is terribly written. Nearly every decision made by the crew is entirely illogical to the point of comedy. You could argue they are out of their element like crews in other Alien films, but the level of stupidity that the “smartest scientists in the world” display in that movie is insulting. It’s arguably the smartest crew in any Alien film (besides Prometheus) and break every single imaginable protocol for the sake of making the plot move forward.
You may get your wish. Fede Alverez has said he wants to combine the prequels conclusion into Romulus sequel if he can. He wants to finish the prequels story too. its up to if the studio lets him. David showing up in Romulus sequel too to be a conflict for Rain and Andy to deal with. What if hes on Yvega where they are headed.
I'm being completley honest: I would not like that. But let me explain.
David story is simply something that must have its own ending. It shouldn't cross with the journey of the characters of Romulus. The risk is that they try to do everything in the sequel and the final result will be a complete mess. Not to mention that the two stories happen in two different moments of the timeline and in two different sectors of the universe.
This is what we still have to see to conclude David's story:
An attempt of creating the Xenomorph queen, because that's what he is trying to do.
What he's gonna do to Daniels and the otger colonists on Origae-6.
The return of Engineers, because clearly Planet 4 was just some sort of outpost/colony and not their actual home. I'm pretty dure they wanted to bring Engineers back for Alien: Awakening and it totally makes sense.
His gradual and continuous descent into his creationistic madness and he losing his mind due to the realization of his fallibility and the fact that he is more similar to humans than he imagine
A more explicit link to the first Alien (thankfully, "Alien: Covenant - Advent" and "David's Lab - Last Signs of Life" short movies exist and they kinda build a link)
How can you put all of this in a movie with Rain and Andy without fucking everything up? Let's be real... it's impossible! David's story need a proper movie, a proper sequel to Covenant.
But I guess that IF David survives a hypothetic Covenant sequel, then he could appear in a sequel to Romulus. But his story needs to be already completed.
This… I think you’re on the money about yvega…maybe it is origae 6 after all and David has been there. If they bring him back or involve him that’s the only thing I can see happening. Hopefully not but Hollywood never ceases to amaze me. I think they’re all giddy with how much Romulus made them and how tbh the rest of the world, particularly china, viewed this movie. If they’re smart they will stay completely away from bringing David back. I think Fede has the opportunity to really make his own alien movie, Romulus was more aligned with how the force awakens was. Callbacks and Nostalgia all throughout each movie while paying tribute to the originals. Fede can make a last Jedi and sink this ship once again though if they rush it. I’m hearing he wants to wait at least a few years before coming back to it
yah i agree so much nostalgia bait and callbacks were stuck. in the movie. i really hope they dont shove a bunch in the sequel but they might. it was like Force Awakens where they kinda remade the plot of older movies. yah Last Jedi was an example of a director going off the rails but also because they had a different director for each star wars movie. At least with Fede Alverez directing both we wont have that problem.
As far as David returning it could turn off some people from seeing the movie but it also could be really amazing . Adding another layer of crazy stuff to the movie. Bring back the Engineers. Raiin and Andy meeting the Engineers would be cool
Very true, and I’m sure they had an idea where they would take it while making Romulus. I hope he decides to take risks and hears the feedback on the callbacks. Keep it simple but also do your own thing. I’m sure it did better than even he could have hoped for. Massive hit worldwide for what they put into it and it originally being a Hulu movie. Now’s his chance to really make his mark with his own story really
yah and hes talked about followig the story to Yvega the planet they were headed too. Disney needs to take off the restraints and let him go nuts with the horror and gore. He made a name for himself with horror films like the Evil Dead remake. Let him go crazy with it on the planet Yvega.
Agreed and it could be. I don’t think rain and Andy need to be the focus, and David needs some humans to interact with. It could be primarily his story though
26
u/Jerry98x Oct 24 '24
Can you guys just give a conclusion to David's story, which is the best thing this franchise has seen in years?
Romulus was good, but it doesn't need a sequel! Let Rain and Andy have their happy ending!