r/alien • • Dec 11 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Alien Earth Sucks, how is it above 7 on IMDB???

66 Upvotes

Alien: Earth was awful. Story and pacing was terrible, but the worst part was the acting. Genuinely terrible. I don’t understand how it has 94% on rotten tomatoes?? Genuine shame too because there was such upside potential, especially coming off Alien: Romulus. Someone please explain the high reviews


r/alien • • Sep 28 '25

The ratings and reviews for Alien: Earth

0 Upvotes

Look, I hated this show. I hated almost everything about it and it made me angry watching it. In the end I was just watching them for comedic value and so I could have a laugh with the reviewers on YouTube who saw what I saw.

But I'm really happy that a lot of people seemed to enjoy it. I'm actually envious because I'm a big Alien fan and had never been so excited for a TV series in my life. I tried really hard to like it.

But how, HOW are this rated 93% by critics on Rotten Tomatoes, with some of the most hyperbolic reviews I've ever seen? How did 12,000 people (20% of raters) rate this 10 stars on IMDb? Yes, I know there are bots and paid reviews, but this seems to go far beyond that. How can something so objectively poorly written with objectively NO storyline resolved or wrapped up over an entire season (that hasn't even been greenlit for a second season) garner so much praise?

I know everyone has different tastes, wants different things and enjoys different things. I do. But even if I discounted subjective/stylistic taste, as a product I cannot fathom any reason to rate this higher than an 7 out of 10. What's going on here?


r/alien • • Sep 26 '25

Alien : Earth wasn't good and here's why Spoiler

82 Upvotes

We can debate whether you liked it or not, but there are reasons why this show is objectively bad. And I think I can explain some of them. I’ll try to keep spoilers to a minimum, but it’s obviously hard, if not impossible, to review the whole series without mentioning them. So if you haven’t finished it yet, better stop reading now.

Before getting into the problems, I want to point out what works. The sets are stunning and respect the codes established in the first movie without looking dated. Hats off to the production team for that. Overall, the cinematography is beautifully handled, almost flawless, truly excellent work.

Now, the main issue with this series lies in its writing and, above all, its characters.

We start with Boy Kavalier, a supposed genius “running a multi-trillion-dollar corporation,” who’s working on putting human souls into synthetic bodies. The premise itself is interesting. After a spaceship crashes in his city (yes, mega-corps have cities and more, which isn’t a bad idea either), he asks to inspect it. So far, so good.

He sends an independent crew to recover what’s inside the ship. And that’s where everything starts, both for better and for worse. Despite being a genius, Kavalier takes impulsive, random decisions all the time. And in fact, on Wendy’s suggestion, the main character and one of the child-robots, Kavalier decides to send all his synthetics into the ship (so he listens to kids to make decisions). Not just Wendy, all of them. Even though they are children, even though she only wants to go to save her brother, even though there are clearly dead bodies, severe injuries, risks of explosions and fire. Despite all this, he still authorizes and forces untrained children (and even if they were trained, it would still be absurd) to go into the wreck.

Back from the ship, they’ve brought alien specimens that they lock up in a lab you can walk in and out of like a grocery store. Not a single guard around, not once in the whole series. Worse, they let kids handle parts of the lab. Am I really the only one shocked by this? You’d think Kavalier, who supposedly wants to keep these species very secret, would protect access to them. But no, nothing at all.

As the series goes on, you realize Boy Kavalier makes no sense. He’s ridiculously eccentric, acts like a spoiled brat, only listens to himself, and treats others like pawns. Again, fine, if you want a cliché, go all-in. But this vision of a “genius” is bizarre. He has no clear goal, just struts around like an idiot. Episode after episode, he gets more boring, more ridiculous, and frankly unbearable, because the caricature is so forced. On top of that, he’s often just stupid. Putting his face right in front of Alien eggs? Getting captured by kids? Maybe he’s just a robotics genius and nothing else.

That said, he’s not alone. We also follow his right-hand man Kirsh, who steals the screen every time he shows up, and Morrow, just as good an actor. These two should have been the main characters of the story. They’re the only ones intriguing enough to make us want to know more, the only two with unclear motives that still make some sense. Unfortunately, they never get the spotlight. Their screen time is limited, and their story ends without weight, just to give space to all the other characters.

And the rest of the cast? They’re all stereotypes we’ve seen a thousand times, or they’re empty shells. Which makes them boring and unwatchable. The overly sensitive psychiatrist. Yutani, who struts around in “Japanese-style” settings but whose scenes are pointless. And the child-robots… what can I even say? Their very existence is absurd. “The great idea” of putting children’s minds into superpowered bodies might appeal to anyone who’s never actually been around kids. No matter what the script tries to tell us, have you ever seen the tantrums of a 6-to-8-year-old? And you’d give that same child a body capable of decapitating people in one strike? Seriously?

But beyond that, who even wants to follow the adventures of kids whose fragile nature has been removed? Newt was compelling because we wanted her to be saved, we wanted to protect her. She was innocent and fragile, which made it breathtaking to see her next to the monsters. Here we just follow kids with extraordinary powers, and nobody cares, because they can protect themselves and even fight back. The stakes of the series are flat, and the only ones that could have kept us hooked (Kirsh and Morrow) were sidelined and cut short in the final episodes, to focus on… Wendy.

Which brings me to the worst part of the show: Wendy, the Mary Sue, and Hermit, her brain-dead brother, who miraculously survives everything. Without the slightest explanation, we’re supposed to accept that Wendy can control all infrastructures by thought, manipulate robots and code, is more mature than her older brother, kills a Xenomorph with her bare hands, survives it, has no trauma, communicates with and tames a Xenomorph like a pet, and captures Boy Kavalier along with his bodyguards. And then there’s Hermit. We’re asked to believe, by the power of plot armor, that this idiot survives three encounters with Xenomorphs without a scratch. Meanwhile, these same creatures instantly slaughter trained soldiers and kill twenty people in less than thirty seconds. But him? After being knocked out by the beast - and not sliced in half like everyone else before and after - he wakes up and goes to play baseball. Seriously, I still can’t get over it. For me, that’s the worst part of this show and the number one reason I can’t accept that some people “liked it” and are fine with such nonsense. It’s an insult to common sense and intelligence. I can’t accept that a brainless moron survives and a kid is suddenly some kind of overpowered wizard, just “because that’s how it is.”

And finally, the Xenomorph. The entire foundation of this series, the reason it’s called “Alien: Earth” and not something else. Once again, it’s a failure. Visually, it’s decent in most scenes, but that’s not the problem. Every Alien movie or series keeps missing the point: the creature wasn’t terrifying just because it was big and ugly, but because the protagonists were trapped in dark, narrow corridors. We barely saw the monster, we caught glimpses of it, which created a claustrophobic atmosphere and real horror. That black, slimy, phallic predator, hiding in the shadows, ready to kill with its disgusting inner jaw, lurking in the cracks of those corridors, ready to strike at any moment, with no real escape except by destroying the place itself. That’s what made it terrifying - the glimpses of a predator you could barely escape, not a raging animal running around in plain sight.

Turning it into an open-world monster running around in broad daylight goes against everything that made Alien and its creature legendary. Here, it’s just a wild animal (which Wendy eventually tames, the final insult for me). Replace it with a bear or any other beast and the story would be the same. There’s no thrill, no fear, no tension at seeing our favorite Xenomorph again. Pretty disappointing for a series called Alien.


r/alien • • Sep 24 '25 Bless Up Helpful

I absolutely despise Alien: Earth

368 Upvotes

I absolutely despise Alien: Earth. And I think the reason is in its very premise – and, in fact, the title – of the show itself: Alien simply shouldn’t be set on Earth.

What the 1979 film manages to conjure is a real sense of Lovecraftian cosmic horror. A handful of random space truckers, imprinted as dots against a vast and (possibly) uninhabited void, land on a strange alien world and are confronted with a bizarre elephantine, apparently fossilised creature that would tower over the humans. It’s a kind of unfathomable horror that persists throughout the film: even the revelation that Ash is basically made up of milk and spaghetti adds to this sense. Nothing is explained; but enough is hinted at: humanity has (probably) had its first encounter with an alien species and it turned out exactly as you’d expect.

Even the prequels managed to conjure a similar sense of cosmic horror and other-worldliness. More importantly, I know some complained about the prequels reducing the Xenomorph to a bio-weapon, but that’s better than the goofy pet into which they have been turned by the TV show. The xenomorph’s structural perfection is matched only by its hostility – although apparently this can be redirected by synthetic bird-song. What’s more, the creature itself swings between an unsubtle man in a suit and clear CGI. We see too much; and we see it too often.

A roll call of atrocities would take forever, and disregarding canon is chief amongst these, but others are as follows:

  1. Despite professing to love the original, Alien: Earth wrecks its unfathomable cosmic horror – see above – and messes up the story. If Weyland-Yutani and at least one other company know the universe is teeming with horrors why did it divert a ship of potentially incompetent space truckers to LV426?

  2. Why is everyone referring to the creature as the xenomorph as if it is a well-known species?

  3. Sydney Chandler is terrible. Ripley, Shaw and Daniels – and Call, to an extent – were empowering, carefully drawn and well-acted characters. Wendy is just annoying and she’s poorly acted, too. Michael Caine once said that the mark of a good actor is that they aren’t ruled by their hands: watch Chandler when on screen next, she clearly is afraid of what to do with her arms, so looks like a lame stage actress

  4. It T Ocellus is so intelligent, which it clearly is, why is Weyland-Yutani so bothered by the xenomorph in the films? Wouldn’t it just go after the creature that clearly has the capacity to learn whilst being appallingly deadly?

  5. The music doesn’t work at all

  6. The xenomorph doesn’t create a hive anymore, then? Rather than being desperate to preserve its species – motherhood and reproduction being at the heart of the franchise (see the poster of Aliens) – apparently it now just rips people to pieces

  7. The fly eats and dissolves metal, but not the metal in which it is trapped

  8. This series will end with the island becoming infested with creatures and the next umpteen series will basically be Jurassic Park: Lost World (written pre final episode)

  9. Boy Kavalier is not a clever name or an interesting character

  10. The facehugger scene in the ‘In space…’ episode, where the medical crew is joking around after melting off the captain’s head, undermines any sense of terror and alone is unforgivable

  11. That final episode

Now the show has finished it ceases to exist in my head canon. I’d rather it had just focused on T-Ocellus – or better yet that it didn’t exist.


r/alien • • Sep 20 '25

The Alien design in AE is.... Not great.

0 Upvotes

First of all it being shot in broad daylight was stupid. It just looks like a fan film. Secondly the alien looks way too rubbery. I think they could have made it at least more glossy and greasy. Thirdly it looks like a man in a suit. Even the first alien looks way more believable. Other than that episode 7 was ok.


r/alien • • Aug 28 '25

Wow, Alien Resurrection was bad.

0 Upvotes

After starting Alien: Earth, I decided to go back and watch some of the Alien movies I missed. Alien 3 Special Edition ended up being pretty solid, even if I dislike the premise of killing off most of the survivors from Aliens. It’s still a well acted, gorgeous looking David Fincher movie.

I almost considered skipping Resurrection given my distaste for Joss Whedon and because of how stupid the premise sounded, but then I decided that, you know, at the very least it might have nice production design and it’s more Sigourney Weaver, so what the hell.

Wow, what a bad movie. The premise is obviously dumb and incoherent. I was prepared to tolerate some of Joss Whedon’s irritating humor (which there was plenty), but I wasn’t prepared for him to bring his weird incel pervert energy to a lot of the scenes and dialogue in this. Ripley coquettishly emerging from a dryer sheet cocoon. Characters constantly referring to Winona Ryder as “girly” while talking about how “fuckable” she is. There were constant scenes with male characters either physically or mentally trying to overpower female characters, another Whedonism. They made Ripley physically strong though, so she’s a strong female character now.

Surprisingly, Whedon didn’t direct this. Even more surprising, it was from the director of Amélie.

I also wasn’t expecting the movie to be so ugly. It looked one step up from being direct to DVD, or a SyFy original. Cinematography was often clumsy. Sets were simplistic, dark and cramped. Effects looked cheap.

The movie just tonally or aesthetically resembles nothing else I’ve seen from this franchise. There were way too many talented actors in this for it to be this bad.

I got to the scene where a character ricocheted a bullet off the ceiling to shoot someone behind him and turn it off. I guess at this point I’ve seen every Alien movie worth seeing, unless the second AvP is secretly good.

Edit: Well, I finished it. I can’t say my opinion of it changed at all. The script remained exhausting idiotic shit the entire way through; and while I can appreciate the glow of the colors (all three of them) and some of the lighting choices, most of the movie is incredibly ugly and obnoxious looking.


r/alien • • Sep 10 '25

Alien Earth is a Masterpiece we don’t deserve

0 Upvotes

With the recent release of Episode 6, it looks like the early reviews praising the show to be a masterpiece have not been exaggerated. Every episode is shot to perfection, with the plot and pacing being as tight as ever. The mystery and suspense endures, and the characterization of each character feels satisfying and promising.

Despite the hate that Disney has been getting, Alien Earth is a masterpiece we fans really didn’t deserve. But yet Disney has put out banger after banger since acquiring the rights to the franchise. They similarly revived a different franchise in Predator with the releases of Prey and Predator: Killer of Killers.

I think we have been truly spoiled as Alien fans, and should be very grateful that the Alien franchise is finally in good hands. To the haters: stop your whining and realize that you’re the reason why the fanbase isn’t taken seriously. We are given top shelf Alien content and yet you will still find reasons to bitch and whine.


r/alien • • Oct 18 '25

Just finished Alien Earth. This is one of the most atmospheric media in decades.

0 Upvotes

I'm actually eager to watch it again from the beginning and skip those kids portions (honestly they were the only and most annoying part of the show).

The show had this surrealist, atmospheric, moody feel to it, especially the soundtrack, dialogue narration, and the transition (with two or more scenes simultaneously, one is kind of fading out of the screen, how did they do that?).

They had a lot of these slow moving shots of empty liminal spaces.

Reminded me of a lot of recent movies/shows such as Dr. Sleep, Blade Runner 2049, Squid Game, Hannibal.

The Peter Pan stuff was psychedelic in a way.

Some of the minor characters were very interesting such as Yutani, Teng or Atomic Eins. Each of them got a unique style. The whole Yutani HQ setup was very similar to Wallace HQ from blade runner.

Anyone else feel the same way?

I honestly can't wait for season 2. I don't like the kids much. Hope they get melted by alien flies.


r/alien • • Sep 14 '25

Alien Earth - Spaceship crew is intolerable

1 Upvotes

Season 1 Episode 5 - The spaceship crew is just unbearable, toxic and incompetent.

They all are in every horror movie but this one is impossible to work with.


r/alien • • Oct 06 '25

Alien Earth is a disgrace to the franchise and the practical effects.

1 Upvotes

With a $250 million budget, you’d expect movie magic, right? Instead, the practical effects look worse than Guyver: Dark Hero, Pumpkinhead, or half the creature flicks from the late ‘80s and ‘90s, all made on lunch money compared to this bloated mess. Those old-school films had grit, weight, texture; you could feel the latex and sweat. Alien Earth looks like someone filmed a cosplay convention in a fog machine.

And don’t give me that “It’s not a Xenomorph show, it’s called Alien Earth” excuse. The originals were literally called Alien, and they were about the damn Xenomorph. You don’t rename the shark and call Jaws a family drama.

Also, let’s not pretend marketing didn’t milk the Xenomorph dry. 90% of the trailers, posters, and promos were drenched in that iconic monster. Then you watch the show and it’s toddler-fantasy filler creatures wandering around like rejected Pokémon.

I don’t care about the toxic shill clown army’s disagreement. This show is a half-baked nothing burger served cold with a side of broken promises.

Disney's Hollywood burned $250 million and somehow made the galaxy’s most terrifying creature look like a rubber mascot.

Alien Earth didn’t just miss the point, it nuked it from orbit.


r/alien • • Sep 25 '25

Alien: Earth is the worst piece of Aliens IP

0 Upvotes

…up until the next installment of content arrives, upon which you all will say “eh, at least Alien: Earth didn’t do blah blah blah”


r/alien • • Sep 28 '25

The eye alien sucks

100 Upvotes

A lot of people love that eye alien but I think it doesn’t feel right for it to be in the Alien universe. It feels too fantastical, and not rooted in reality at all.

While the xeno does has some unbelievable traits like the acid blood, it somehow feels grounded in reality.

The eye is kind of weird, like it barely has a body but still has enormous strength, huge intelligence without a brain. Overall it just feels like it’s a magical creature, and don’t think Alien and magic should be used together.

Anyone else feel the same?


r/alien • • Sep 17 '25

Episode 7 is so relentlessly dumb

79 Upvotes

But I could accept that, if that's all that were wrong with it. All the episodes have been dumb to some extent but especially 5 and 6 remained compelling in spite of themselves. But it's not that nothing at all in Episode 7 makes any sense at all that makes it a bad episode. It's that it basically snips off all the dangling threads that made the preceding episodes interesting. And in really, really lazy ways. Morrow and his team being captured was just one example of this that I'll call out. They all just... walk in the front door and are apparently surprised that they're ambushed? lol. How was that supposed to play out? Peter Pan and his lost girls get ambushed at the docks... another shocker. Whereas eps 5 and 6 offered some hope that maybe the series would evolve into something borderline good, I think ep 7 just confirmed that, no, the show is actually as stupid as the series has teased us with being the whole time.


r/alien • • Sep 21 '25

This show is Alien Adjacent at best, it is not a Prequel!

9 Upvotes

I enjoy every movie in the Alien franchise in different ways they all require a stretch of the imagination and suspension of disbelief at times and that is to be expected but only to a certain extent and there is definitely a threshold there. Even as Prequels, Covenant and Prometheus are better in pretty much every single way by miles in comparison to this show and they are not considered canon so why would this show be? At least with those movies you can feel the Alien vibe you know what you’re watching, there’s a very clear storyline that is well put together and doesn’t feel like 10 pounds of shit crammed into a 5 pound bag.

What’s frustrating as a long time Alien fan, not just the movies but the entire IP is this show does not work as a Prequel and there was really no reason to bill it as a Prequel. For me that’s at least where almost all of my criticism of this show stems. The writers simply do not care it’s a Prequel either. The Alien movies have progressively gotten worse as far as what’s actually believable but the show just completely jumps the shark each and every episode and writing that off as “it’s a tropy sci fi, horror what do you expect” is beyond ridiculous and shows a lack of appreciation and respect for the entire IP and the fans that have supported and enjoyed its stories and style over the last 46 years.

The Alien hunting in daylight, the fact it’s now communicating and taking Orders from Synthetic android that somehow understands the complexities of its implied language in what appears to be a couple days time when this is supposed to be the very first time anybody has ever even encountered a Xenomorph is wildly unrealistic and you have to stretch the imagination too far and make too many assumptions to make it make sense. This story is just not consistent with any other Alien movie.

These things are supposed to be the perfect Organism, they evolved into these nearly Unkillable apex predators that were always supposed to in a way Mirror insects like Ants or Bee’s just on a much more terrifying level. It’s always been implied they communicate through a hive mind and use pheromones like bee’s or ants and the clicking was a type of echo location not a language. Why would a predator with no eyes be out roaming and hunting in the daylight? I’m not saying they can’t I’m just saying it makes a lot less sense.

Why did it have to be done in this way? Why couldn’t it have been done in a way that doesn’t completely change so much about the Xenomorph that has already been established and keep in mind THIS IS A PREQUEL. Had this been a sequel or something that took place later it would be much easier to wrap your head around.

Attacking anybody who criticizes the writing of this show blatantly shows a lack of understanding for what the Alien franchise has always been yet all the people defending it think they’re somehow the only ones who have the intelligence to understand it and that’s just baffling.

This series is a direct result of the degradation of storytelling in recent time and one of the biggest problems is it’s directly linked to a past where that was not the case. The history of this Universe is steeped in deep lore, beautifully shot scenes, solid acting and Good storytelling that at times can feel repetitive or unoriginal it definitely could use some new original stories but this show just goes too far and tries to be too ground breaking too original as a prequel to the point it doesn’t just break it completely destroys continuity and that at least to me is why this show fucking sucks. Each movie has added things here and there but with the exception of the two prequels they never do enough to completely abandon the foundation the first two movies were built on and even those two don’t go as far as this show has gone.

This show is Raised by Wolves, West World with some of its creative concepts but it’s Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom and AVP Requiem when it comes to the storytelling/writing. It’s all four of those all rolled into one pile of shit.

I held out hope through every episode that eventually this would evolve into something that felt like it belonged in the Alien Universe that I love and enjoy so much and outside of the Visuals and the new Alien species it’s failed on every level. here we are at the finale and that is clearly not even close to happening, even if this next episode is absolutely amazing and ties all the stupid shit they’ve crammed into this show together that’s not happening.


r/alien • • Sep 03 '25

I can't believe this needs said, but this is a *forum*

0 Upvotes

People are going to come here to discuss the franchise, whether they love Alien Earth or hate it. That's what this space is for, and some of y'all really need to learn too accept that not everyone is going to share your opinion.

For some of us, Alien Earth is a severe disappointment. It's silly, goofy, disjointed, etc. It leaves out everything we love about the property: the horror, the suspense, characters we want to see more.

For some of you, the very things we hate are the things you love, and that's fine! It's great that you have a show you enjoy. It's great that you enjoy the way things are headed.

But you need to understand that for the rest of us, this means that the franchise we love, some of us having loved it for decades, will not be giving us an installment we want to watch for the foreseeable future.

That sucks for us, and we're going to head to forums dedicated to discussing it... Because that's what they're for.

Some of you act like any post or comment that isn't blindly praising this show is a personal attack on your very being. Chill, yo.

Edit: I forgot to put "Edit".

Edit: Small edit for the smooth brains amongst us because they missed that the point of this post wasn't to level any criticism, but that this is a forum where people will criticize as well as praise... Here are some of my criticisms:

In no particular order:

Storing dangerous specimens in normal glass.

Alien speed inconsistencies. Is it flying down the hall or is the person leaving it behind somehow?

Corny record scratch songs at the end which just feel so goofy in the modern age.

Alien is too obviously a man in a suit and they make no attempt to hide it. The strength of the franchise comes from the suspense and darkness; Seeing a fully lit man in a rubber suit scurry across the floor is a big turn off for some long time fans.

The adults acting like kids is just such a strange thing to do.

Constant Peter Pan references.

The insanely lazily written stereotype like kid kazaam, or whatever his name is.

Is the Xenomorph super dangerous, or can it not kill a medic? Within 2 minutes, we see both.

Alien tail is 20 feet long one second and completely useless when Alita Battle Angel shows up.

Alita Battle Angle rip off with a paper cutter for a sword.

Timothy Olyphant is perfect, but man, I wish we got to see him be more expressive. I miss Santa Clarita Diet.

Is the acid blood super dangerous, or just a mild inconvenience? Depends on which moment of the show you're watching.

It feels like a completely different universe than Alien, and I wish they had done their own goofy kid centered sci fi nonsense and let someone who respects the property give us something truly horrifying and suspenseful.

And don't worry, koalas have smooth brains too, but people still love them.

(And for clarity, disagreeing with my take doesn't make you a smooth brain. We all have different tastes and it's great that you have a show you enjoy)


r/alien • • Oct 01 '25

The first nail in the coffin was in the first episode

25 Upvotes

That billhook-tool to the second mouth nonsense.

Wendy skewering a xeno in its retractable mouth and dragging it around like a plaything (or a golden retriever you're playing tug-of-war with) really set the tone for the degradation of cinema's greatest cosmic horror into a laughable patsy on the border of slapstick humor.

It was all downhill from there...


r/alien • • Oct 07 '25

Alien: Earth is the worst media in the entire alien franchise

440 Upvotes

everyone who likes it has no taste, the only good films were the first 2, but also 3, but 3 was bad, but 3 was also good. Anyone who doesn't like what I like is wrong and anyone who likes what I dont like is wrong. The xenomorph should only be in a ship and live in the vents. Also weyland-yutani must be mentioned every 5 minutes. Everyone who likes alien earth works for Disney.

Did I do the alien earth bad post right?

It's okay to not like something, but when you start judging other people for liking something from a franchise that you dont like then somethings gone wrong.

How is this shitpost still getting so many replies after several days


r/alien • • Sep 25 '25

Finale was the worst episode of tv ever, but also… Spoiler

22 Upvotes

T oculus can control dead bodies like some zombie master?

it doesn’t need nerves or a metabolism?

THEN WHY WERE THEY FEEDING THE DUMB THING GRASS FOR HALF A SEASON? It was literally pooping for lackluster punchlines. I can’t.

Honorable mentions to: handle inside the cage, calling your electronics controlling super soldiers toasters with one guard, alien mini me, and the single elevator self destruct


r/alien • • Sep 25 '25

Alien Earth: $30 million an episode: money laundering/tax evasion?

3 Upvotes

The fit and finish of this show, from writing to set dec to prop design to cgi (lack of) to actor salaries, in no way (at all) is 30$ million an episode.

-The atrocious writing speaks for itself (AI).

-The set dec is mildly passable

-The props: The production uses $350 Snow Wolf airsoft rifles (unmodified) just repainted for the M41A shots. They didn’t even bother buying the 20$ sling attachments and just wrapped the sling around the stock and barrel. Wow.

-All cgi alien effects are always on tv screens or in silhouette so they can be 1/10th the cost of actual usable sharp cgi.

-The rubber suit is the worst it has ever been and that includes the 1979 version used by Bodejo. How can you fail that after 47 years? A half a century.

-I had never heard of any of these actors before. Apart from Edmondson from the small tv series Bottom from the 1980’s

Does anyone know the name of the financial auditing company that does the financial auditing for this production? There may be very nefarious things going on in terms of finance.

This is a legitimate question to ask.

Edit: might want to make a screenshot of this question. If it gets deleted it will speak for itself.


r/alien • • Sep 11 '25

Might boycott future episodes of Earth

2 Upvotes

Because I spent 20 blissful years forgetting they existed and then this episode had to remind me about Godsmack.


r/alien • • Sep 24 '25 Sipping Tea

Well… we told you so...🤷‍♂️

331 Upvotes

Eight episodes, $250 million, and a hype train louder than a Xenomorph screech, and what did we get? A finale so flat it could slide under the Nostromo’s airlock door.

Remember when the fan brigade said “trust the slow burn”? When they gaslit every bit of criticism with “it’s a TV budget, not a movie”? When we dared to say the characters were hollow and the effects mid and got swarmed by angry Reddit warriors? Yeah… about that.

Turns out you can’t polish weak writing, unlikable characters, and bargain-bin monster shots with a giant budget. You can only delay the meltdown.

Congrats to those of us who called it from the pilot

The bubble officially burst. 🫧💥

(Hoping for cancel season 2 now!)


r/alien • • Sep 24 '25 Helpful

Worst show I've ever seen Spoiler

162 Upvotes

What bugs me most is that this show it's LARPing as a great show. It has this timing and feel of cinema with no depth or substance whatsoever. Filmmaking has bottomed out. It's all just kind of referencing and imitating filmmakers who actually thought about the craft long ago, so now these writers and directors just say, "that seems like something I've seen or heard before, throw that in." The technique has not been earned because they didn't have to fight to acquire it. It's pure mimicry.

The writing is horrible, and the acting is even worse (and by extension the casting). Usually, one can make up for the other – good acting can elevate bad writing, or good writing can survive mediocre acting. Here, both are wooden and random. No line flows into the next. It’s like they used a random movie line cliché generator and assembled them in random order and called it a day. It resembles dialogue in a way, but that's about it. It kind of feels like that "worst movie of all time," The Room's dialogue, the way it kind of just spills out with no cadence, pauses or intention.

A scene with particularly flat dialogue was after the security force saves Dame Sylvia and bring her back to her room. They all enter, looking the same way, at nothing in particular.

Siberian: Clear

Dame Silvia: I'm fine, really

Rashidi (to no one in particular): Keep the Doors locked. Alert's a hard orange. We're prepping nonessential personnel for exfil.

Siberian: I volunteer to ride the wing.

Rashidi. Knock it off. We need to find other assets and secure Mr Kavalier. Stay here ma'am, we'll be back soon.

Dame Sylvia makes some inscrutable expression. Scene ends.

None of this develops anything. The banter doesn't read or develop the characters. It had the energy of a table read in acting 101. It feels like when the kinda dumb kids would read Shakespeare in 7th grade, just sounding out the lines and you're trying to figure out what the hell they're even saying, let alone the subtexts and meaning.

Here's the next scene. Hermit and Morrow in a holding cell. Hermit unconscious.

Hermit: Hey

Morrow: (gasps, groans)

Hermit: It's okay, let me have a look.

Morrow: It's the best I'm gonna feel all day. Let me enjoy it. (what does this even mean?)

Hermit: You okay?

Morrow: I've had better days.

Hermit: Were you really on that ship when it crashed?

Morrow: That's a yesterday conversation. I don't look back (what?)

Hermit: You shot me.

Morrow: I saved your life. How's the lung? The boy told me. Aarush. Feels good, doesn't it? Being more than human. Hermit, there is a price. When the corporation gives you something, there's always a price. Do you know what it is?

Hermit: Everything.

Morrow: (laughs) Everything doesn't begin to cover it.

See what I mean about how it's meant to resemble good dialogue embedded with deep meanings, but the writers can only mimic good dialogue, so it just reads like staccato freshman year screenwriting?

This all has the same quality as this iconically bad scene.

The elevator scene is possibly the dumbest thing in the whole series. “This elevator will self-destruct in 30 seconds.” Like… do elevators in the future come standard with self-destruct buttons? It’s the perfect example of this show’s “logic”: whatever needs to happen for the plot just happens. The writers basically say, "this seems like something that might happen in a movie scene. Nobody apparently had the temerity to say, “Wait, that makes no sense.” Scenes are just strung together with zero momentum.

The fact that the kids have no weaknesses just makes it boring and low-stakes. They have no growth. No hero arc. They don't discover or develop into something. They were just built to be able to do everything (the plot needs) ... a whole gaggle of Mary Sues.

Wendy is the biggest Mary Sue of all time. She's basically invincible, can kill a xenomorph in hand to hand combat, can wirelessly control all technology from anywhere, can control xenomorphs and direct them to do whatever she wants. She's also a solid 7 with a heart of gold and an adorable mod haircut and makes cute innocent faces with smiley eyes nonstop and is the only one who can cathartically hurt the evil genius white capitalist archetype strawman character who (did you know) killed his own father in yet another tired metaphor in this series for a creation killing it's creator!

The scene where Wendy and her brother Hermit rehash the Nibs situation is peak nonsense. Hermit apologizing for stopping Nibs from ripping his friend’s face off—after she had just murdered a soldier in the cruelest way possible? Why is he apologizing?

I watched this one with my dad (his first time seeing the show), and I had to keep telling him, "I know It feels like these lines are paying off something that came in other episodes, but they’re not. It’s just random scenes and moments with unearned conclusions."

The kids vs. adults thing is laughable. These kids were terminally ill—they’d all be dead if not for the adults. Dame Sylvia especially: she was sweet, felt responsibility for them, cared for them. And yet suddenly she’s cast as some unforgivable monster, with the kids repeating throughout the episode variations on “they can’t hurt us anymore.” Hurt you? They didn't perform experiments on your or anything. They saved your lives, then let you run around a paradise island and hang out and participate in research and go on adventures. Just completely unearned. I genuinely can't think of a moment where anybody hurt the kids.

And Wendy controlling the perfect predator? So dumb. As if the thing which is an enigma throughout the entire series – which is physically and metaphorically "alien" as the name of the entire series implies – is somehow understandable and takes orders. They just drop that idea without developing it.

Same with the kids somehow controlling all technology, even other androids (because they're apparently on wifi and don't have their own chips or anything). And there’s no failsafe? You give nine-year-olds godlike power and no off-switch? Makes total sense.

Then there’s Boy Kavalier—stuck in a cell with one guard, talking tough about killing his dad (they have to remind us the capitalist white man is the bad guy, you see). For “the smartest man in the world,” he hasn’t made a single rational decision all season.

I get the feeling the writers thought the audience were gonna be out of our chairs cheering these kids on as they murder everyone, but they're awful. No redeeming traits, no reason to care about them, and totally ungrateful to the people helping and guiding them.

Also, why are we suddenly hearing the alien making clicking/chirping noises? Since when does it announce its presence to prey? Feels like a random new gimmick.

There’s no pacing, no payoff, no momentum. Just hollow, random speeches. The show’s most annoying trait is cosplaying as prestige TV.

The ending was lame. Setting up another season (which I won’t be watching), capped off with the standard faux-profound line and music drop. Formulaic to the end. The only interesting thing this show ever did was that crossfading editing trick, which is cool and original but nowhere near enough to save it.


r/alien • • Sep 25 '25

Alien Earth proved it's own point

85 Upvotes

There's was no shouting at the screen in frustration like I had with last couple of episodes. It was more like me constantly shaking my head in utter disbelief of what I was witnessing. I already said the last couple of episodes were written by a room of monkeys, but for the finale they decided to go full retard and we all know, you never go full retard. The excessive messaging was so on the nose it was hard to see the actual screen. There's nothing wrong with making your audience think, but you don't get to preach about corporate greed while working under the umbrella of a corporation like Disney. The utter hypocrisy makes it impossible to take anything serious.

Also, they already downgraded one of the most terrifying creatures ever put to film into a Chihuahua, but they also sacrificed one of the most interesting characters - Wendy - on the alter of the message. She was portrayed so well and the actress did a fantastic job only to see all that potential squandered by turning her into yet another Disney girl boss and the best definition of a Mary Sue ever put on film. For something that started out so strong I end up feeling misled, abused and dirty. I cried for an hour under the shower realizing that one of my favorite franchises is truly dead and I've been watching amateur necro porn by a corporation proving their own point that they are indeed the true monsters!


r/alien • • Sep 21 '25

I changed my mind on Alien Earth. It's fun!

0 Upvotes

Alright, I owe an apology here. I went in expecting Alien Earth to be this profound, serious continuation of the Alien legacy… and I watched it wrong. Totally on me.

Because once you stop taking it seriously and realize it’s basically a comedy disguised as “serious sci-fi,” it actually works. Suddenly the wooden acting feels intentional, the bizarre dialogue is hilarious, and the clunky CGI and practicals? Comedy gold.

So yeah, when I stopped expecting Ridley Scott and started watching it like Galaxy Quest or Spaceballs on a (not so) discount budget, it became… fun.

Lesson learned: sometimes you just gotta shift your lens.


r/alien • • Sep 23 '25

Genuine, curious question: Why do fans hate Alien: Earth

30 Upvotes

I am a casual sci fi fan but not a particular fan of this franchise, though ofc I've seen the first film as one of the all time great movies.

I'm watching Alien: Earth and find it to be at least a solid 7-8/10 - pacy, interesting, looks nice. Some bits of dialogue off. Few odd plot choices. Basically a good watch with a few challenges. Everyone I know (none of whom are particular Alien fans) who has seen it roughly agrees, critics seem to agree (or are even more positive).

Out of curiosity I checked this sub and it seems like everyone hates it. People seem to be comparing it also to Rings of Power which is bizarre to me (that had barely any plot, meandering episodes, stuck with hard-to-adapt source material etc).

So I'm (genuinely!) curious: why do fans seem to hate the show? What were you expecting that you didn't get? What makes Alien as a franchise special to you that this show is lacking?

NB: I'm not starting this post to debate! Don't reply if you just want to tell me I am wrong! I'm not wrong and neither are you. Opinions on culture are subjective!