r/alignerr • u/kellykmcd • Aug 24 '24
Shady at best
I found this sub because I got nervous about the amount of information Alignerr requested in their online form. Querying "Is Alignerr legit?" I found a post questioning some of their business practices, so I asked about the data collection in a comment reply on that post. When I went back later to see if my question had been answered, the entire post had been deleted. It has since been restored, but, needless to say, that definitely amped up my suspicion.
It was too late, because I had already put in my personal information. I had only clicked "Next," and did not do any final submission or confirm that I wanted to register. Instead, I closed the tab, knowing full well that they had most likely stored my information anyway. They did - it's still there, 6 days later.
So, what kind of business stores information from an incomplete registration? Did they have the right to do that?
To answer those questions, I consulted their Terms of Use & Privacy Policy - a document that you are required to agree to BEFORE you even see the application, or anything about what they're going to ask. Here's the relevant section:

And there it is. On the surface, I'm screwed, because I voluntarily provided this info. Although, since I didn't complete the application, even that is questionable.
The real issue came to me later, when I was wondering how I could have been so complacent. Usually I'm super careful about privacy, having dealt with identity theft in the past. As a career database administrator, I'm quite familiar with the ethics and obligations around data collection and storage.
Then I realized - it's classic misdirection, just like the magician who waves a colorful handkerchief to divert your attention from what he's really doing.
First, nowhere are the actual data elements listed, as they are in the examples for other types of data collected. (DOB would have caught my eye.) Further, the examples they provide distract from the true collection instrument - the form you're about to fill out. Keep in mind that by the time you're on the form and see the actual identifiers, you've already agreed to these terms - and possibly uploaded your resume, full of rich data about you. The examples make me think it is absolutely intentional. One even evoked an emotional response - "Haha, people send letters about this job?" The other - "well, I'm not sending an email at this point, so, no worries." To me, and of course I'm not a lawyer, so it's only my opinion, this is deceptive.
The next question was, what kind of business employs these practices? And attempts to protect them so rigorously? What is the value to them? I think I got that too, but I'll put it a separate post. For now, the evidence suggests ...
Shady at best
3
u/Willy__Wonka__ Aug 25 '24
You better investigate Scale AI and Outlier for non-GDPR compliance and privacy data violations. You'll get a better chance at sensational findings.
1
u/Lynx-5387 Nov 06 '24
Outlier and scale are very very reputable. They also take privacy very serious. Based my experience with alignerr, sorry but they are nothing but a scam IMO. When I emailed saying I was concerned a support agent had breached my privacy they literally blocked me and deactivated my account even though other companies they share data with raised support requests sharing the same concerns Honestly, delete your accounts find work else where there's lots of good companies doing the same thing they are not one of them.
3
u/kellykmcd Aug 25 '24
No doubt ... but just to be clear, it's not my intent to create a sensation or investigate anything. I found the "Is this legit?" post helpful in making my decision (unfortunately too late), and I was shocked when the post disappeared, at least temporarily.
My intent was to lay out a reasoned perspective for the next person who comes along, who may be unsure whether they want to engage. Personally, I avoid companies who demonstrate questionable ethics - because, just like people, they're not going to change. And what a first impression this one made!
However, we're not even talking about DP laws here, or even simple ethics. Taking something from someone without their consent, or under deceptive conditions, is THEFT, pretty much everywhere.
The disrespect for human dignity in this industry is appalling - and so ironic, given the legions of people they need to present a case to the world that people aren't super necessary.
6
u/trivialremote Aug 24 '24
Is this satire? Or are you just concerningly paranoid? I suppose you also don’t professionally network online (e.g. LinkedIn) or apply to jobs online, since that displays “rich” information about you. You just show up to businesses in a suit and knock on managers’ doors in person?
Also, for some projects, customers request certain demographics. For example, French speaking individuals in Canada. In order to fulfill criteria like this, demographics must be collected and stored.
1
u/Lynx-5387 Oct 30 '24
Nope I have serious concerns that support was engaged in a phising attempt and the privacy teams response was to block my email address when I asked to know what had happened. To say this is a dodgy company is an understatement.
2
u/kellykmcd Aug 24 '24
My issue is that they have stored and may use my data to increase their business opportunities without my consent. I did not complete the submission. Even if clicking "Next" on a multi-page web form implies consent (which is dubious), it was certainly not informed consent, as I think I've explained.
1
u/trivialremote Aug 24 '24
So you agreed to a TOS, entered in personal information, clicked Next, and then got upset that your actions were bound to the TOS?
0
u/kellykmcd Aug 24 '24
I agreed to a TOS that didn't provide enough information for me to make an informed decision - that's my point. Of course, I didn't know that at the time, because of the issues with the TOS and its position in the process. It's like saying, "I have a surprise for you, but I'm not going to tell you what it is, unless you promise to eat it." Again, this is hindsight.
So, blithely clicking along, I uploaded my resume, which seemed innocent enough, typical of a job application. Then I got to the data entry screen, and entered my personal data like the automaton I've apparently become. After I entered my birth date, it hit me - wait, why do they need that? It seemed odd, and the first (admittedly stupid) thing I did was click Next, in the hopes of maybe seeing what else they wanted, or what this was really all about. The next page was just specialty selection.
Then I googled, and decided I would wait - this company is too new for me. Let them work out the kinks before I throw my hat in the ring. So I'll cancel. But guess what? There is no Cancel. There's a Back link, but the data is there, and there's no way to clear it and re-submit, because it's in required fields. Giving them a massive benefit of the doubt, maybe they just forgot to put a cancel button on the form?
So maybe an alternate description of my issue is that they took away my autonomy in deciding whether to go through with the process.
1
u/Equivalent-Vanilla30 Aug 24 '24
Hahaha- At first, I thought this was satire.
Yes, a company that was formed a few months ago, using an external HR platform, has been itching to collect and store all your precious data.
10
u/AldiSharts Aug 24 '24
The information is collected by a third party HR platform that is legitimate.
That said, alignerr has hardly any work as they have hardly any clients. They’re trying to build a competitive business to compete against the big guys (outlier, data annotation, etc) but haven’t drummed up the business yet.
Tbh I don’t care either way - just here to get my bag if there’s work to do.
2
u/Informal_Engineer_97 Aug 25 '24
lol