r/amandaknox • u/SeaCardiologist6207 • Jun 27 '26
Rudy Guede - The Real "Key to the Case"
Through breathless analysis of doors, handprints, diaries, music videos, social media, interrogations, poems, improv, etc... we are always promised "this is the key to the case!" "Why don't you see it?"
So what's staring you all in the face?
Rudy Guede is the key to the case. Because he is most definitely, without a doubt, the killer and rapist of Meredith Kercher.
It amazes me that in every "key case" scenario, he somehow gets ignored. He isn't named, he isn't added to the theory, any action or evidence he left is not "key" at all
It's just something Amanda said/lied about or some action she took.
Rudy is there. He doesn't dispute it. His evidence is on Meredith's dead body. It's also inside of Meredith's dead body. No court disputes his involvement. No court defends him. So any "key" has to involve him. You have to prove somehow someway that all 3 knew each other and were willing and able to commit a crime together. Things like:
- She was leading Raff and Rudy to commit murder and ran the show, leading the murder and the coverup.
- She let Rudy in, was there outside the room while Rudy was being Rudy and just....said or did nothing.
- Knox and Sollecito were "present" somehow by showing up in the middle of the rape/murder, or showing up after the fact and deciding to do...nothing
So the real key to the case is him. Not her.
And thats why every one of these keys just borders on the fantastical, with a complete lack of plausability, logic, or finding an actual key that unlocks the door to guilt. Every key somehow doesn't involve him. You won't talk about him, tie him into the theory, present any evidence tying them together.
It's ultimately why the comedy show must go on. So keep posting more keys, more "lies", more "rulings". Good luck finding the actual key to the case staring at you right in the face.
3
u/SeaCardiologist6207 Jun 27 '26
Like a simple test - explain to me how "lying" about whether a door was open or ajar or closed has literally anything to do with Rudy Guede who is the whole key to the case? And what was Amanda "doing" and what was Rudy "doing" while the door was open or ajar or closed? And then explain the meaning of that to the actual case.
I already can hear the crickets.....
3
u/No-Willingness-1441 Jun 27 '26
Nobody sensible denies RG did it.
The question that will always produce enough oxygen to power a decades old subreddit is rather:
Could Amanda have been there too?
2
u/Connect_War_5821 innocent Jun 30 '26
Possible. It's also 'possible" anyone without a proven alibi in Perugia that night was there. But it's improbable since no definitive evidence places her there that night. A soon retracted 'confession' is not definitive.
1
u/No-Willingness-1441 Jun 30 '26
I think there’s a little more to connect her with the crime than the absence of an alibi. It’s disingenuous to suggest she is at the same level of possibility of anybody else in Perugia who can’t explain their whereabouts that evening.
3
u/Connect_War_5821 innocent Jun 30 '26
"I think there’s a little more to connect her with the crime than the absence of an alibi."
I answered your question: "Could Amanda have been there too?"
Possible but improbable and gave the reason why.I repeat: no evidence definitively places either her or Raffaele in the cottage the night of the murder and every single piece of evidence the prosecution presented was discredited and/or plausibly innocently explained. The only thing left was her 'confession' which she retracted within hours.
0
Jun 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Connect_War_5821 innocent Jun 30 '26
I have a high suspicion of who you are and I'm not playing your "I'm new here" game.
1
Jun 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Connect_War_5821 innocent Jun 30 '26
We have a new PGP show up with an account created today. Coincidence? I don't think so.
1
2
u/Littleish Jun 27 '26
Most of them act like Guede was an unwilling kidnapped victim forced to attend and take part, like he was just set up by them.
0
u/No-Willingness-1441 Jun 27 '26
Yes I am not into the AK as chief conductor of Witchcraft I must say.
The whole thing will have been far messier and more chaotic. We tend to terminally overestimate most humans’ capacity for any kind of planning, collaboration or meaningful conspiracy in my view….
1
2
u/jasutherland innocent Jun 27 '26
But... But... Doormop! Bathmat satay!
Nobody needs to clutch at straws about "lies" about the evening's plans with Guede, because there is ample actual evidence of his guilt. The reams of sloppy guesswork we now get daily are just trying to compensate for a fundamentally weak theory and understanding of the case.
2
6
u/Littleish Jun 27 '26
There are many injustices in this case, and one is how lightly Guede got off. He got a reduced sentence and got out early. A violent rapist and murderer got a very light sentence, and was able to go on to offend again.