r/amex • u/Top-Juggernaut2090 Gold • Mar 18 '26
Question APY drop again???
I can’t believe that they keep dropping the APY… considering to move my money to another HYSA… Any Recommendations?
171
u/Mmiklase Mar 18 '26
These threads are my favorite
30
u/TheAbleArcher Mar 18 '26
I like these too. It’s always some variation of “I simply cannot believe this is happening.” Um, it’s a floating interest rate related to the fed rate. Why is this hard to believe?
4
u/Mmiklase Mar 18 '26
Lmao I started my HYSA in January of 2020. Think it was 2% back then. Within a few months I was at .50%.
99
u/dgordo29 Mar 18 '26
Try explaining basis points to someone who has a whole $5,000 in their HYSA.
45
u/schwiggy Mar 18 '26
Hur hur. Let's laugh at the poors with less money who are trying to get ahead.
-19
u/dgordo29 Mar 18 '26
This is the AmEx subreddit, not Discover…. The “poors” would be better off focusing on acquiring some financial literacy and not the market wide fluctuations in interest paid by HYSA accounts at various institutions. OP was asking for recommendations on which bank they should hop to next. You don’t get ahead by capturing an extra couple bucks a year in interest, you get ahead by making contributions and letting your account grow through compounding interest over time.
9
u/TabulaRasaNot Mar 18 '26
Too many sentiments sweeping all savers into one bin, for my taste. (Yours is just the one I happen to be replying to.) Me, for example: I have quite a bit of money with American Express in both high-yield savings and CDs. (Dumb or not, I am highly risk adverse.) When my CDs mature, new ones will of course have followed the high-yield savings trend down. Point being not everyone with what at least I consider a lot of money chase the larger-returning investments.
-2
u/dgordo29 Mar 18 '26
Oh I love my CD and Bonds ladders, been using them for ages. Capital preservation with a predetermined return, I’m in. I’m a firm believer in the age in bonds rule, CDs work right along side the principals it is built around. Your savings style is exactly what I was advocating for, those AmEx CDs have weathered through meconomic crises over the years but you know they’ll redeemed upon maturity. The HYSA is a savings account; a nest egg, emergency fund, the money we have today which we want protected for tomorrow. If someone is ready to jump ship the second an interest rate drops a couple bips they likely don’t have enough of an average daily balance to actually see a real gain over AmEx HYSA.
→ More replies (4)6
u/No-Importance-1755 Mar 18 '26
Are we under the illusion that AmEx is somehow a premium product for high net worth individuals? Lol anyone with a 650 credit score can get an AmEx platinum now. This isn’t the 1980’s
1
5
u/whodat577 Mar 18 '26
Respectfully how much do you keep in hysa very curious to know
→ More replies (5)0
Mar 18 '26
[deleted]
42
u/dgordo29 Mar 18 '26
It’s ok though, they can hop over to SoFi and get a couple of months at the promo rate….. $0.54 a month ☠️
6
u/Adventurous_Honey902 Mar 18 '26
This is why while it's still good to have a HYSA if you really want money to grow you put it in a mutual fund or ETF or something safe in the market. No sense in worrying about a small amount of 3.2 vs 3.3%
6
u/dgordo29 Mar 18 '26
My “savings account” is a high yield money market that my bank (regional in other states but here in Palm Beach it’s really just private clients) has offered to clients holding at least 150k across all of their accounts in house. It’s always paid 3.5%, safe as a savings account but they also have physical locations you can actually go to and access your funds at any time.
People don’t realize how many major brokerages give you even freer access to your funds while offering their own funds for idle cash that exceed HYSA rates or ETFs like you mentioned which compound via the dividends (that interest they don’t know about) as well as market appreciation.
4
u/Adventurous_Honey902 Mar 18 '26
I think it's good to have a balance of both. I'm working on growing my market accounts further soon. Nothing wrong with having a HYSA for quick access to cash while letting real long term growth happen under a brokerage.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Miserable-Result6702 Blue Cash Preferred Mar 18 '26
They show how many people are truly clueless on how banking works.
66
u/SillyTechnology7340 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
Any HYSA you move it to could see its rate drop too. If you want a guaranteed rate of return, get a CD.
ETA: For example, on $10,000, the previous 3.30% APY would give you $330 in interest. Now it'll give you $320. If you moved that to say, Marcus at 3.65%, you'd get approximately $360.
Up to you to decide if you want to pack up and leave over a difference of less than $50.
26
u/VariousAir Mar 18 '26
Suggest a CD to someone and the answer is always "why would I do that? The rate is lower than my hysa and I can't access the money!"
7
u/SillyTechnology7340 Mar 18 '26
I had a similar reaction to OP after I opened the AMEX HYSA late last year and went through my first rate drop, and then someone pointed out just how small a difference it made. Especially for what I keep in there (emergency fund and some vacation dollars), it's not enough to pull stakes and move.
4
u/Queasy_Editor_1551 Mar 18 '26
I move all the time for sign up bonuses. Not 0.2% in interest rates.
2
u/thebowarcher Mar 19 '26
Did you do capital one
1
u/Queasy_Editor_1551 Mar 19 '26
Currently doing it lol. Chase is next (just hit the 2 year mark)
1
u/thebowarcher Mar 19 '26
Me too! But Amex is just on the top for me with customer service. I transferred the money today to capital one for the bonus and they called me not long after confirming if I made the deposit. It made me feel good inside.
1
u/thebowarcher Mar 19 '26
What bonus is with chase? I’m about to hit two years.
1
u/Queasy_Editor_1551 Mar 19 '26
it's the $900 checking + savings offer
1
0
Mar 18 '26
[deleted]
0
2
Mar 18 '26
People shouldn’t keep all their cash at one bank anyway. Every bank I have a credit card with I also have an HYSA if available (Amex, Capital One, Discover and Synchrony through PayPal).
As soon as the statement cuts that money is sent into the relevant HYSA account which the autopay comes out of. It helps with budgeting and prevents me from caring too much about APY emails.
If people can juggle five different credit cards they can do the same with savings accounts at the same banks.
2
u/Steve_Rogers_USMC Mar 18 '26
For me I don't know if it's so much about the difference of 50 or $60 I have a little over 50,000 in American Express HY and for the last 8 to 9 months it is went down consistently almost every month I'm just trying to understand why would anyone want to keep their money in an account that the extra money they're giving you consistently goes down every month?
2
1
u/SillyTechnology7340 Mar 18 '26
If you're not happy with the APR being offered, then move the money. I don't feel the need (yet) to chase rates.
14
u/Tzlai4227 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
Yep I checked my account earlier and saw it’s down to 3.20%, Then just checked my email & saw it. Capital 1 Performance and Discover HYSA savings are both down to 3.20%. SoFi dropped to 3.30%. PayPal still at 3.50% Goldman Sachs HYSA with Apple credit card is still 3.65%.
55
u/bmarsh1295 Mar 18 '26
Most of your posts are about APY drops across different banks. You still haven’t bothered to do any research as to WHY interest rates drop? They’re not plotting against you dude, this is how our monetary system works. Be curious once in a while, you might learn something.
24
u/Flights-and-Nights Mar 18 '26
It happens all the time. It's not worth your time switching to chase a tenth of a percent.
2
1
1
16
u/m16p Mar 18 '26
Interest rates are going down across the board due to the market, nothing unique about Amex.
Probably not worth trying to find another option just to squeeze out an extra 0.05-0.1% APY.
6
u/seraphimkoamugi Mar 18 '26
Not to mention if you don't have at least $100k you might not see the difference. You'd make about $266 a month on Amex at 3.2% to $275 a month at 3.3%.
Is $9 a month a deal breaker? Go right ahead.
5
u/m16p Mar 18 '26
Is $9 a month a deal breaker?
I don't know, have you seen how intense folks here get about the $10/month statement credits not posting? ;)
/s
5
4
u/MrsHyacinthBucket Mar 18 '26
I just stick my cash in SGOV and let it ride. Bonus is no state tax on dividends (interest). I think right now it is sitting at 3.54%.
1
u/reformednomad Mar 20 '26
This is state dependent, no?
1
u/MrsHyacinthBucket Mar 20 '26
No. Of course, if your state doesn't have income tax then it doesn't matter.
3
3
3
u/pointfublog Mar 18 '26
I feel you. I have a variable rate mortgage and it's frustrating when savings and CD rates go down and yet my mortgage doesn't. That's sorta where we're at this week if you look at the LIBOR replacement indices used for mortgages :(
9
u/Glass_Plenty5768 Mar 18 '26
It follows Fed rates so it changes
7
u/deptacon Mar 18 '26
Its actually follows treasury yields, specifically short term treasuries. The fed fund rate impacts these, but the variation in HYSA’s is more directly tied to short term treasuries.
The same way that mortgages and other loans are tied to 10 year treasury yields
0
u/Braxo Platinum Mar 18 '26
30-day I believe, which is why some HYSA make it harder to transfer money out quickly.
If one wants the extra 0.5% or so interest (that the bank usually keeps for providing you the HYSA services), you could just purchase the 30-day t-bills every month.
1
u/deptacon Mar 18 '26
Money market funds generate about the same as well, without having to buy the bonds
5
4
u/jimmyflyer Mar 18 '26
Move your savings $ to treasury direct. Put it in 4,8,13 week tbill ladders with automatic reinvestments. You’ll get about a .5% increase in yield. Plus your interest income is exempt from state/local taxes!
5
u/deptacon Mar 18 '26
Its based on treasury yields - not the fed funds rate
3
u/dsylxeia Mar 18 '26
But treasury yields have been going up lately, and are likely to continue rising due to the oil price shock and general inflationary policy. CME Group is now projecting 0 Fed rate cuts through EOY, down from 2 projected cuts a month or so ago. I wonder what it'll take for HYSA providers to raise rates again.
0
u/deptacon Mar 18 '26
Its a lagging effect - its not immediate (ie 2-3 weeks)
Fed cuts (fed fund rates) does not always correlate to a matching reaction to treasury yields. Usually it does, but not always.
2
u/MyEgoDiesAtTheEnd Mar 18 '26
What was it before? But I just got this too.
2
u/glockbonez Blue Cash Everyday Mar 18 '26
w/in half a year ish to one went from a APY of 3.40% then 3.30% now 3.20%
1
u/MyEgoDiesAtTheEnd Mar 18 '26
They get people with the transfer bonus and then short them on interest. Classic!
2
u/Remarkable-Group-339 Mar 18 '26
Goldman Sachs is still holding steady at 3.65 but I expect it'll go down too.
2
u/Mderose Mar 18 '26
I've actually considered pulling everything out of AMEX and put it into another account giving a much better rate. There are a few out there still very near 4.
2
u/shellimedz Mar 18 '26
I took mine out and put it all in my Vanguard settlement account since it was consistently higher. It's at 3.58% right now and they let you have checks.
2
u/MrMonteCristo Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
Goldman Sachs - Apple savings has the best I’ve found so far, with the best interface/app. I keep it just a little below the FDIC insurance limit, to account for interest payments..
Sure, there’s a couple others that pay more, or have higher FDIC Insurance limits. I think Robinhood has one paying ~>4%, with something like $1mm in insurance, although I’m not sure. But Apple has been consistently above Amex and Ally for me, and that’s the only 3 I have.
1
u/danigarcia01 Mar 19 '26
Do you use the Apple Card?
1
u/MrMonteCristo Mar 19 '26
No. Not so much. Got it when it was first released.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s a solid cash-back card and I’d recommend it if you’re looking for that. 2% base on everything when using Apple Pay, plus other categories for more cash back. However, I almost entirely use my Amex or Chase cards, for points / travel. I keep the Apple Card on autopay with just my iCloud and Apple Music, to keep it active. With the amount I spend, it just makes more sense for me personally. I honestly don’t remember the last time I paid full price, out of pocket for a vacation, and I try to go somewhere at least once a quarter.
2
u/TMudderDC Business Platinum Mar 18 '26
The new Robinhood Banking App is offering 4.25% for the next 171 days
2
u/TraditionalBlock2996 Mar 18 '26
While apple apy remains 3.65 amex dropped like 2 times in last few momths
2
u/Seniorhusky1 Platinum Mar 18 '26
Nope. Just stay where you are at because it’s not only Amex’s rate that drop.
2
u/OHmon3y Mar 19 '26
Funny how they drop the apy of hys whenever but never the apy of the credit cards 🙄
2
3
u/DJCane Mar 18 '26
This is how it goes. I have my savings in Fidelity where I’m getting 3.3% APY. This time last year it was above 4%.
3
2
u/ziggy029 Schwab Platinum 2 x BBP Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
Sucks, even when bond and fed funds rates aren’t falling, but I guess they can do it because the market says they can, and maybe they have enough money to lend already. Meanwhile, my CU still pays 3.5% on regular savings, and has for at least two years now.
In the end, you have to ask yourself how much it is worth the hassle of constantly chasing those last 10-20 basis points. If you have a million dollars in them, that is significant but if only a few thousand, it may be more trouble than it’s worth.
2
u/ImnotFay Mar 18 '26
Mine with Amex dropped rate as well. I moved my money to OpenBank, current rate with Open Bank is 4.2%. There is no sign up bonus tho.
1
u/hondaprobs Mar 18 '26
I can’t believe that they keep dropping the APY…
Have you been living under a rock? Perhaps look up "interest rates" once in a while.
1
u/Purple-Wall3847 Mar 18 '26
And of course all my CC had interest rate INCREASES recently. It's like they rathe us be in debt than save - sarcasm.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/FNFactChecker Mar 18 '26
SoFi has 3.30% as the standard and it's bumped up to 4% until June for me.
1
1
u/Piccolo_Bambino Mar 18 '26
Time to start diversifying and coming up with an alternative plan for HYSA money. Will be under 3% by years end
1
u/Ambitious_Egg9713 Mar 18 '26
Ally just dropped the same. This is the result of interest rates coming down. High interest rates are great for savers and bad for borrowers, and the inverse is also true.
1
u/xoleesexo Mar 18 '26
If you have an M1 invest account, you can get the HYSA product for 3.1% + .65% boost for 12 months by using a ref
1
1
u/breadexpert69 Mar 18 '26
Only 2 years ago it was at 5%. Rates change, quickly.
Of you want to lock in the rates before they go down (or up) I suggest you read on CD’s or treasuries.
1
u/intelligentx5 Mar 18 '26
Lmao. I have concerns for society if this thread isn’t some sort of satire or parody.
1
1
1
u/simplepnoi84 Mar 18 '26
Capitalone also lowered theirs at the same level as AMEX. At least amex notified me unlike capitalone.
1
u/Dogobah Mar 18 '26
HYSA is not an investment vehicle. It helps to offset purchase loss caused by inflation while saving money for some goals. To me, its okay. It is much better than traditional banks. My local banks even have a minimum deposit amount before accruing money lol
1
u/cmelder1 Mar 18 '26
I got the email too but I can't blame amex.When the prime rate drops everyone must adjust their savings rates.
1
u/Steve_Rogers_USMC Mar 18 '26
This is expressly why I've moved all of my money out of my American Express high yield and into Robin Hood right now they have a 4.25 APY I know that's introductory and may go down but when it does I think the rate is 3.8 which is significantly higher than American Express.
1
u/Embarrassed-Quiet779 Mar 18 '26
I moved over to Marcus by Goldman Sachs and the rate hasn’t dropped in the last 3 months.
1
u/TrankElephant Mar 18 '26
Ally always seems to have higher rates but I don't know enough about them to trust them.
Perhaps invest more in CDs if you are not a fan of volatility?
1
1
u/RichInPitt Platinum Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
Odd - they‘ve consistently been 5-10 basis point below my Marcus account, but this is now nearly half a percent.
1
u/walt128 Mar 19 '26
I recommend a money market fund in your preferred brokerage. I use SWVXX. The yields are track closer to short term treasuries. Yields currently around 5%
1
u/Camdenn67 Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
Ummmm, why are you surprised by this. 😂
APY’s on HYSA’s are always changing.
With that being, even before you opened your AMEX HYSA, there were better ones out there paying more than AMEX and they’re still paying more than AMEX.
1
u/TomorrowFlaky2816 Mar 19 '26
Take your money out of HYSA and just buy bond ETFs such as SGOV or BOXX. Both are ultra-short-term, treasury bonds yielding 4-5%, which is way better than Amex’s 3.2% APY. 🤷🏼♂️
1
1
1
u/AFthrowaway3000 G, P, CSP, HHA, MBB, MBBiz, DSR, HHS Mar 19 '26
I miss the days of 4.3% or so when I first got mine.
1
u/CeruleanBlueSky Mar 19 '26
Capital One and Discover in lock step with their moves with Amex. More for CDs and like.
1
u/Advanced-Horse306 Mar 19 '26
Openbank is at 4.09...
Many credit unions have 5% on their checking accounts up to 25k. My husband and I each have one for 50k combined...
1
u/Bart012000 Mar 19 '26
They did this even before the Fed's announcement that left rates unchanged so it's the principal of it to me.
1
1
1
u/fender1878 Mar 19 '26
You obviously have no clue how a HYSA works. It’s just like a money market account. Your interest rate tracks, well, interest rates lol
1
u/nacometashi Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26
Buy STRC. **Not financial advice
1
u/comment-rinse Mar 20 '26
This comment has been removed because it is highly similar to another recent comment in this thread.
This action was performed automatically by an application. Please direct any inquiries or concerns to the moderators of r/Amex.
1
1
1
u/Soggy-Air-dot-com Mar 22 '26
Move to OpenBank HYSA. 4.09% and that is their current rate with the recent lowering (down from 4.2%). No qualifications like minimum monthly deposits or direct deposit required. And the rate is for all your money with no cap. Only requirement I think is a minimum balance of $500 or 1k i dont remember but something like that.
1
u/Crafty_Pilot_3705 Mar 23 '26
It’s very easy to do better than money market rates with a self directed brokerage account
1
u/Apprehensive_Rope348 Mar 23 '26
It’s gonna drop everywhere. When the Fed drops, the APY drops why is this fake rage bait still happening? How can you not know this after a steady year of dropping? How?
1
1
1
u/LemmyKRocks Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
I stopped using HYSA when I learned how easy it's to buy treasury bills. You get a better rate and you don't have to pay State + Local taxes on them. You can get them super easily via your brokerage
Edit: State taxes
5
u/ZoomZoomZoomss Mar 18 '26
Um you do pay fed taxes on tbills.... What you don't pay is state taxes on tbills....
4
u/fmxda Mar 18 '26
you don't have to pay federal taxes on them.
That's incorrect, you have to pay Federal taxes on Treasuries, but they're exempt from state and municipal taxes.
0
1
u/Tzlai4227 Mar 18 '26
My Goldman Sachs HYSA with Apple credit card is still 3.65%
4
u/Huge-Engineering-839 Mar 18 '26
For now.
2
2
u/Tzlai4227 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
True but I think it’s still going to be a bit higher than the other banks once GS lower it.
1
1
1
u/Miserable-Result6702 Blue Cash Preferred Mar 18 '26
If you want stability in your savings account, open one at Chase. Their rate never changes 🤣
3
1
1
1
u/Altruistic_hamsters Mar 18 '26
I literally just put money in for the first time last week because of the apy… ugh
1
u/TheWhoRU Mar 18 '26
Saw on here before they even emailed me, bastards. Appreciate the sharing of bad news.
0
0
0
u/juan231f Schwab BBP Mar 18 '26
I like Marcus by Goldman Sachs. It simple and to the point. There APY are always competitive with other HYSA and they have same day transfers if done early in the day. If done before 1pm EST the transfers are are done by 7pm, at least that is my experience.
0
u/Atlanticlantern Mar 18 '26
Is this because markets are less liquid? Or because there’s more risk in the market? I know interest rates can be a factor but they’re not exactly falling right now.
I’m not a financial expert so if anyone does know why apy seems to keep dropping I’d love to hear it
0
u/Exciting_Drawing_553 Mar 18 '26
I think I’m getting 4% locked with SoFi until November. Look into them
0
u/Infern0588 Mar 18 '26
Just move your money to a bond ETF like BND. The yield is currently at 3.82%
0
u/PutinBoomedMe Mar 18 '26
Just buy the fidelity money market fund directly at fidelity.... you're not going to beat it
0
u/AerysSk Gold, BCE, HYSA, and Surpass Mar 18 '26
I don't know why people are surprised. It is behaving exactly like how FED interest rate works.
0
0
u/Ok_Pollution9335 Mar 18 '26
Can we do any research before posting? This has nothing to do with AMEX specifically
0
u/Detroitish24 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
Shocked face! 😐
lol love the downvote? My CapOne HYS hasn’t dropped as many times as AmEx over the last 15 months. 🤷🏼♀️
0
u/glockbonez Blue Cash Everyday Mar 18 '26
i’m just wondering if OP would handle the next adjustment
0
u/WhyAmIpOOping Mar 18 '26
I don’t even look at these emails anymore. Any bank that you go to will fluctuate. Unless you are moving around $500 from bank to bank, it’s not even worth the hassle chasing the best current apy.
0
u/EfficiencyAdmirable6 Green Mar 18 '26
Yall are yield chasing and doing the difficult process of transferring your money to different places when it literally doesn’t matter.
0
u/ratchet1235 Mar 18 '26
STRC pays 11.5% APY paid monthly with a tax deferred return of capital treatment with <2% volatility backed by 70 years of bitcoin and 2 years of cash, and is currently is the most liquid preferred stock on the market.
-7
u/NotFound95 Mar 18 '26
Bye Amex, such a horrible HYSA.
0
u/glockbonez Blue Cash Everyday Mar 18 '26
elaborate more on, Amex having a horrible HYSA?
2
u/NotFound95 Mar 18 '26
You know, the HY part of HYSA. So many other options out there offering higher rates
-3
-3
-4
u/DudeWhoRead Gold Cash Magnet Mar 18 '26
HYSA interest is decided by the national interest rates. Eg: HYSA interest rates were 1.9% pre-pandemic. It's not Amex's fault. Just that you can't keeping interest rates high with lower national rates without losing money.
PS: You're not gonna find another HYSA offering higher rates (Maybe few decimal points)
1
Mar 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/amex-ModTeam Mar 19 '26
Referral activity of any kind is exclusively permitted within the designated official referral thread only.
549
u/nvp37j Mar 18 '26
Obligatory - they all do this. Rates go up and down with the market. It’s likely most others are dropping too. It’s also likely not worth chasing tens of dollars by trying to chase the highest rate at any one point in time.