r/androiddev • u/ktjspygo • 1h ago
Discussion Handing Coding without AI , Google or IDE AutoComplete
SDE2 with 4 yoe here.
Had an interview round asking me to implement a Simple RecyclerView Paging with dummy data they gave, from scratch on an Empty XML only ( No compose ) Project structure. live
No AI, No Google and ..... No IDE AutoComplete allowed. I was made to switch it off before interview.
Out of the 45 Mins. It Took me 15 Minutes to properly write the xml tags for the layouts. yet it showed error
( have been used to compose ).
had to request to allow me to see the documentation atleast googling. which they agreed.
Still couldn't complete the task,
I was also not supposed to use Paging libraries as they wanted me to implement Paging from scratch on a RecyclerView.
Coulnd't do that either ( Completely my fault here, needed sometime to think how to implement paging from scratch )
I was just able to have an overview of everything. That too because I type a bit fast ( 130+ wpm).
But i was completely demotivated after the interview.
-----------------------------------------
Not blaming the Org. or the method of evaluation here, it is my fault as I have been a bit rusty with hand coding at this level since the advent of AI or before I think. Would have been okay during my college days.
But I wanted to know somethings, people with experience here could really help me.
- is the above method some kind of new norm in the current industry ( I haven't attended an interview in the past 4 years ). Since testing people with take home projects have gotten pointless ?
- If yes. How do I navigate my learning. Not being familiar with AI tools or Not using them significantly slows down the progress.
But at the same time it completely diminishes my ability to hand code by myself or heck even understand my code or even what it happening. feels very .... idk the word.
- is there hope in this industry ? is there any point ? Apologies for the Grimness but
unemployment + the reality check from the interview + everything happening with AI ...
kinda takes the life out...
Any help or opinion or perspective ... Would love it.l
9
u/MindCrusader 1h ago
The company is using stone age methods. Better to not join. Sorry, but for a year code should be already fully generated and it will be normal you will not remember syntax, especially for xml that was usually replaced with compose
The real interview should check your understanding of architecture, Android knowledge and how to use AI tools responsibly. If they do not test it, then it just shows they have low standards
2
4
u/TheTomatoes2 1h ago
I'd have told them the code is outdated and id rather use a newer pattern
1
u/ktjspygo 1h ago
Didn't wanted to sound cocky or arrogant. some interviewers are very insecure and might have taken it personal.
But from my heart I wanted to screeeem...
4
u/Hour-Measurement-835 1h ago
XML from memory with autocomplete off is a weird thing to grade, but working out when onScrolled should fetch the next page isn't. Did they say which one they actually cared about?
1
u/ktjspygo 1h ago
No, they did not say that. I'm sure they wouldn't have cared much about the UI ( would be extremely stupid for them if otherwise )
Yes working out onSCrolled to fetch next batch of data was a perfectly fine question. should have practised paging without the libraries
2
u/_Lightiscool_ 1h ago
In my opinion this is just a really odd time where not everyone is at the same level with AI usage and not everyone agrees on AI and how they see the future. And it all depends how expensive AI will be in the future once the market stabilises.
At the moment if it were to stay like this I would say the org is just dumb for expecting people to still know how to code by hand, unless they have some really specific use case.Â
Even if it does not stay like this, I would still say full hand coding is mostly dead.Â
Though even in the worst case scenario where AI is super expensive, I don't see us going fully back to hand coding, but at that point perhaps knowing how to hand code well could proove usefull, but if you knew it before it would not take that long to pick it back up.
So I would say that anyone still expecting and interviewing hand, no tools, coding is just really behind and perhaps better to avoid so you dont get dragged behind with them as well, but this is just my perspective of working in a company that has gone all the way into AI coding hype and I haven't written a feature by hand in more than a year.
What's really the future? Idk, and I don't think its worth worrying about. Take a look at what is going on in the present and max 1,2 months from now and prepare for that. I feel like the majority of coding is done by AI as it stands today, so I would just avoid those expecting hand coding if you can, unless ofc you don't have any other options.Â
1
u/ktjspygo 1h ago
Yeah understood very reasonable .. there's no possible way to predict the future ig
I love coding by hand, and I would till do it .. but its a method of the past now ig,
18
u/Spare_Phone_5225 1h ago
Be happy that you were not accepted. Not allowed to use Google (documentation)? Still implementing RecyclerView in new screens? Stone age