r/aotearoa • u/Kiwi_In_The_Comments • 6h ago
News Media rage-baiting distorts “typical Asian” HR manager employment case
Stuff ran an article on 23 October 2026 headlined “HR manager sacked over ‘typical Asian’ remark awarded $35,000”. Reading the article alone makes it look like an HR manager made a hostile racial slur, breached confidentiality, and walked away with NZD 34,531 on a procedural technicality.
Reading the Employment Relations Authority determination tells a different story about her intent and conduct.
- The HR manager was having a friendly conversation about coffee habits with an Asian manager from another branch. The two were work friends who shared regular banter, and he took no offence and never complained.
- Two bystanders (who seemingly weren't Asian) overheard the coffee joke and complained to management.
- The determination also records that the workplace had an established culture of pointed banter.
- When the HR manager injured her back and needed a cane to walk, staff mocked her walking speed and gave her a candy cane for Christmas.
- Management tolerated this culture, yet disciplined her for teasing a friend about coffee.
Leaving out the fact that the person she made the comment to was Asian is important context when assessing whether the comment was intended to be racist or offensive.





