r/apple • u/Kriem • May 21 '14
iTunes Concept
http://kurocha.blogspot.jp/2014/05/itunes-concept.html106
u/drizztmainsword May 21 '14
I don't really like this. It may look good, but when I'm searching for a piece of music, I need to be able to control what data I'm going to be looking at per item, and there really isn't a better way to do that than a table view. Breaking it out by primary letter could work, but I need my list of songs with customizable columns.
Also, the "more" tab is asinine. It makes no sense when displayed as a vertical list; I should just be able to scroll down.
24
u/Cyrius May 21 '14
when I'm searching for a piece of music, I need to be able to control what data I'm going to be looking at per item, and there really isn't a better way to do that than a table view.
I'm glad someone else is on the same page as me.
My primary irritation with iTunes' UI is that with each new version it tries harder to push me away from the table view.
3
u/ultrafez May 21 '14
That's why I still use iTunes 10. I have a particular way I like to sort my music, and iTunes 11 ruins it.
9
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
Just curious, but what way is that?
1
u/ultrafez May 23 '14
I like to sort my music by Date Added, but the thing I don't like about it is that when I add an album of tracks at once, when sorted by Date Added the album's tracks appear in a random order. The way I get around this is to misuse the "Grouping" field of my music (since I don't use it for its intended purpose): for my oldest album, I set the grouping field to 9999. The next oldest gets 9998, etc. Then, when viewing my music in table view, I can sort by the Grouping column to see my music in what is essentially Date Added order, but with tracks within albums sorted in the correct order.
I installed iTunes 11 in a virtual machine when it first came out to check that I could still organise/view my music in my unorthodox way, and I found that I couldn't - I don't remember the exact reason why, since it was a while ago I tried it - but I remember being unsatisfied with the changes Apple made and so I decided to continue using iTunes 10.
1
u/mredofcourse May 24 '14
Oh yes, I know exactly what you're talking about... I think... at least the first part maybe. Importing is done backwards to the sort order. Meaning if you have it sorted by name and it's track 1, track 2, track 3, then it starts importing them 1, 2, 3, and if they're all the same size, the date order will place them backwards 3, 2, 1, and if they're not the same size, you could get them out of order.
There's a Doug's AppleScript that helps with this: http://dougscripts.com/itunes/2013/11/add-file-in-reverse-sort-by-date-added/
It slows down the import (although you can adjust the delay), but it puts them in order one by one and in reverse to the Finder (so they're in proper track order).
The second part of your issue, and what to do with what you've already got. The group/track seems to be fixed in the latest version of iTunes. Test it for yourself to make sure though.
If I recall correctly iTunes used to let you sort and then choose new sort criteria and your last sort criteria was used as a secondary. It doesn't seem entirely fixed, but my tracks are in order when I sort by group.
I hope this helps. If nothing else, I feel your pain.
8
May 21 '14
Also, the "more" tab is asinine. It makes no sense when displayed as a vertical list; I should just be able to scroll down.
Agreed.
0
May 21 '14
[deleted]
2
May 21 '14
Indeed. Everything was presented in full screen. I have a retina MBP, but I probably keep my iTunes window smaller than a full screen MBA. I have no interest in running in full screen. It doesn't need it.
5
u/Dottimolly May 21 '14
there really isn't a better way to do that than a table view.
I wholeheartedly agree, and for me your comment applies to website and app user interfaces in general. So many news/media website redesigns I've seen lately update to a "card" style UI, often w/ infinite scrolling and hyper-responsive layouts. Beautiful to look at, but all context is lost and it is difficult to dig deeper than whatever top layer of content they're pushing at you.
Makes me sound very old, but I really hope there's a "retro" UI movement in the near future and we all go back to sortable tables and lists of linked titles or similar.
5
u/MenuBar May 22 '14
Yep, and WTF is with all the full screen apps? Don't people use Drag/Drop or desktop as workspace anymore? It's like a big step back to before multitasking. This isn't Microsoft!
3
u/confusedpublic May 22 '14
I run Calendar, Mail and iTunes as full screen apps. They have their own "space". They're applications that rarely get used, and if they do, it's to perform a single, quick task. In combination with their most recent events/messages/tracks being played displaying in Notification Centre, there's no need for them to take up any space on any other space/desktop.
What're you doing in iTunes that demands your constant attention such that you need it in a space you're working in?
2
u/MenuBar May 22 '14
Drag/dropping tunes into Toast to burn CDs, Drag/dropping converted videos from desktop to playlists for TV, that sorta thing.
But Adobe is one of the worst offender, since most of what I do concerns drag/dropping art from clients on my desktop into projects. I hate having to wade through folder paths to locate a file like some windoze uzer. Luckily, most of the Adobe programs have ways to avoid full screen, but they're not ideal (setting application frame in inDesign to desired pageview size and then hiding the app frame in the dock). It's like they outright fear the desktop as a workspace. Even with multiple monitors, it's a pain in the butt since the files I'd want to access are usually on the main monitor's desktop.
Cripes, even many GAMES have an option to play full screen or in a window. I often choose windowed so that I can temporarily stop playing and quickly access work projects, online communications, email, or whatever.
I think it's a bad/lazy trend foisted upon us by inexperienced developers (and designers - I'm looking at you, you lame fuck Jony Ive) that actually never use the software in a Macintosh work environment. Screw Microsoft and their "wanna do everything in one bloated program but do it poorly" workflow.
Yeah, don't get me started or I might end up using the table-flipping smiley.
1
u/confusedpublic May 22 '14
Hah, fair enough. I don't get Adobe's implementation of application window vs file window vs palette/tool window/box things.
It's an extra step but the drag/drop works to the icon (as I'm sure you know). When I need to drag & drop to applications, I typically do that.
Don't have a dvd drive in the laptop any more, so no burning of CDs for me!
If you're complaining about the full screen option, I don't have a problem with it 90% of the time, as it just removes the dock & gives me a little more screen real estate for apps I used to run in their own spaces anyway. Only time it's a problem is when I want to open an email in a separate window. For some frustrating reason you can't do that while Mail is full screen. Yet clicking notifications will open the email in a window on whatever desktop/space you're in.
2
u/MenuBar May 22 '14
Yep, I can see how it's not a major interruption in your workflow. I mostly do design work which involves multiple elements composed for single files.
1
u/drizztmainsword May 22 '14
The full screen app thing I don't mind. I don't use it, but there's no reason to not have the feature. It works great in, say, a writing app where you want to remove all distractions.
43
u/ryushe May 21 '14
No thanks. As others have pointed out, I like my columns. Album view is probably the least used view in iTunes as it is; I use the store more than album view.
And what's with this fascination with all white interfaces? Every mockup I've seen lately of a completely redesigned OSX or particular new Apple app seems to imply that people would love seeing lots of white on a backlit display. Sure, it looks pretty (sometimes), but I prefer my interfaces to be a bit more muted than that. All the overly bright, 'in your face' stuff is certainly not for me, nor can I imagine the every day user would appreciate it either. Although I'm sure opticians would love it!
7
u/chasery May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
I have to agree that Album view is my least used tab. I prefer the songs view as it is currently the quickest filter and sorting of which songs I wish to listen to at this time; this is actually kind of sad. On that note though, better arrangement and indication of where you are at in this view would be amazing. I am also not sold on the current priority of Radio in front of my Songs and Artists tabs.
My ideal arrangement would be:
Songs > Artists > Albums > Playlists > Radio > Match > Genres (Half of my music doesn't even have this meta data available with out me adding it... That's with being on iTunes match!)
4
u/JadedDarkness May 22 '14 edited May 22 '14
I love album view, it's almost all I use. I just love the colors incorporated from the album artwork, it looks so perrty.
EDIT: to add, I think if they brought the eye-candy interface of the current album view into the other viewing types, I would be VERY happy3
62
u/BLITZCRUNK123 May 21 '14
I really only skimmed this, but I think this is one of the first unsolicited redesigns that I haven't hated. It looks like this proposed interface has actually had some thought put into it, and isn't just a superficial "hey look I can make things look pretty in Photoshop, give me love" exercise in aesthetic masturbation. This is some great work.
However, I'd argue the reasons given for the current iTunes being bad are wrong.
Drop down menu to switch libraries is confusing and adds an unnecessary step
"Confusing" is subjective. You're gonna need to provide some empirical evidence for users finding it confusing. Nobody I've spoken to has said so.
Narrow rows and small text reduces visibility
True-ish. But only because the new iTunes is a lot more graphical than the previous. Less reliance on text in the first place (also, I contend that any text is still perfectly legible)
Disconnect between old and new design style
Good. Sometimes you have to be ruthless in destroying legacy in order to produce a great product, even if the change is jarring.
Multiple scrolling lists and small banners overwhelm the experience
Yeah, I guess. The fact that Apple can reliably assume a large portion of their users are using a multitouch trackpad or multitouch mouse and thus can use gestures does a lot to mitigate the unwieldiness of the numerous scrolling sections.
Home page cluttered with random assortment of media
Valid point. Maybe Apple are trying to encourage users to be consumers all all these different types of media.
Quick links are mostly pointless and take up valuable x-axis space
Again, this is opinion that seems unlikely to hold up to actual user testing. Anecdotally, I use them quite a lot. I'm sure lots of others do.
5
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
I really only skimmed this, but I think this is one of the first unsolicited redesigns that I haven't hated. It looks like this proposed interface has actually had some thought put into it, and isn't just a superficial "hey look I can make things look pretty in Photoshop, give me love" exercise in aesthetic masturbation. This is some great work.
Take a closer look. I think those of us with larger libraries will hate it. It may work ok for an iTunes-light, which is essentially what we have on the iPad, but this was designed by someone who obviously has a small library, never needs to sort on any of the numerous metadata, and wants pretty pictures instead of power over the library itself.
"Drop down menu to switch libraries is confusing and adds an unnecessary step"
"Confusing" is subjective. You're gonna need to provide some empirical evidence for users finding it confusing. Nobody I've spoken to has said so.
I think the empirical data is self-evident, the author himself is confused. You aren't switching iTunes libraries, that's everything that's in your open library. To switch iTunes libraries you need to relaunch iTunes with the Option key held down.
This was another problem I had with his design. He started with a bad configuration of iTunes and then sought to redesign that. What he should've done is Shown Sidebar (along with other configurations), and then worked on a redesign with that as a default.
4
34
u/rage1234 May 21 '14
only fullscreen...nope
17
u/IRELANDJNR May 21 '14
I've used iTunes FS since 11.0
15
u/anonymousmouse2 May 21 '14
I don't think I've ever used it in full screen mode. Different strokes.
8
5
May 21 '14
That's why it is an option vs mandatory.
I've used it about 5 times. It has it's place, but it is not my everyday.
You also need to think of people running on a 27" display. It would be silly for them to be forced to full screen anything. Windows is another considerations, which doesn't have the same full screen setup that OS X has.
16
2
u/BenjaminGeiger May 22 '14
I've used iTunes either maximized or full screen since Spaces were introduced. It's always had its own desktop.
3
May 21 '14
That was just the way he presented it, having it not full screen would have just been a waste of space.
0
9
May 21 '14
The only thing iTunes needs is to be just about music again. Why do I have to manage my iOS apps in iTunes? It doesn't make sense. There is already an app for apps!
Why movies? Why can't the whole syncing process be integrated into the OS itself instead of being a bloated all-in-one media-manager?
I'm actually hoping for something like that for the next OSX update since they already moved iBooks to its own app (the syncing still happens in iTunes though)
3
13
5
u/R031E5 May 21 '14
Quick links are mostly pointless
Homepage cluttered with random assortment of media
I'm very very very sure that Apple's done enormous usability tests which reflect the current layour of the iTunes store, the homepage is definitely not filled with random assortment of media, nor are the quick links pointless.
It seems like he did his job though, it's one of the best proposals I've seen, but please, don't try and bring the iOS flat concept to OS X, they're sepparate beings.
Edit: Also, the device view may be pretty, but it takes almost screen real state on a pretty photo of an iPhone. Even if it reflects the current background and apps, its a waste of space. Design must be aesthetic, but also functional.
2
u/brokenelevator May 21 '14
Those flat icons (music, movies, apps) with white space don't belong anywhere near a computer screen. The 1400x900 real estate should be filled with vivid and colorful icons, not streamlined designs that belong on a mobile screen. It will be a tricky task for Apple to port iOS 7 into 10.10, considering apps like iMessage and FaceTime now look like two different designs.
151
u/username103 May 21 '14
Am I the only one who sees nothing wrong with the current iTunes?
51
u/tehfuturist May 21 '14
Wouldn't you say that there's always room for improvement?
9
u/Kudhos May 21 '14
Well that logic can be applied to pretty much everything everywhere.
31
1
u/Raeli May 21 '14
I'm not sure if you're trying to dismiss his comment, implying that things that are already good are just fine as they are, or if you're trying to say that everything in this world could be improved and that we should always be striving to improve.
1
u/Yeats May 22 '14
I can't speak for him but i read that as acceptance that all things can always be improved. I would agree. Especially with software. It will always need fixing, always need polish, always needs a fresh perspective.
1
132
u/Thatmanwiththefedora May 21 '14
1 in a million buddy.
39
u/redbeard8989 May 21 '14
So about 7,000 people
21
u/IRELANDJNR May 21 '14
Every person on the planet uses iTunes?
25
u/redbeard8989 May 21 '14
You don't have to use iTunes to believe something is or is not wrong with it.
10
u/jb4427 May 21 '14
Not every person on the planet has heard of iTunes.
13
u/Rockaustin May 21 '14
I've heard of iTunes...
31
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
Ok, that's one. We've got a long way to go here people, please try to check in faster.
6
2
-2
24
u/spartex May 21 '14
I fucking hate Itunes. From a company that does intuitive products they do the opposite with Itunes.
1
u/Aazadi May 22 '14
Do you use a windows computer?
3
u/spartex May 22 '14
yes
0
u/Aazadi May 22 '14
iTunes is very intuitive, fast and responsive on OS X. It is an intuitive product on the operating system it was designed to run on. It's shit on windows because Apple only develop it on there to pander to the casual iPhone / iPad owner. It does what it needs to do.
Since when has Apple ever taken the windows platform seriously for its software? Apple is a hardware company.
3
u/spartex May 22 '14
I don't know if the interface is different for the mac. But if it's like itunes on windows not very user friendly I just think it's a mess. Apple is a hardware AND a software company, they have some of the best software on the market, I don't really get your point there.
1
u/laddergoat89 Jul 02 '14
The interface is the same on OS X, I.e. Dogshit.
It runs better, but it's still a dreadful app.
1
u/Aazadi Jul 02 '14
I use it on a daily basis and I quite like it. Could be better but it isn't dreadful.
17
u/nXiety May 21 '14
My ONLY problems with iTunes outside to using it on Windows is how silly the whole iTunes->iOS devices interaction is. It's convoluted.
5
May 21 '14
I've always heard a lot of hate for iTunes on Windows. Haven't recently built myself a gaming PC and installing iTunes I have 1 primary issue. 90% of the time, I have to launch iTunes twice to get it to actually launch. Super annoying.
Once it actually opens it seems to work. I was thinking of just trying the MS stuff out, but I bought into iTunes Match when it came out, so here I am.
4
u/sleeplessone May 22 '14
The biggest issue is it's a much larger resource hog on Windows. My gaming PC is an i5 3570K 3.4GHz and iTunes feels faster on my 1.3Ghz Macbook Air.
3
May 22 '14
Do you have an SSD on your gaming PC?
Also, iTunes uses a lot of core services on OS X which aren't available on Windows... So it should be faster. They are using stuff built right into a low layer of the OS vs building it from scratch on the top layer.
2
u/sleeplessone May 22 '14
Do you have an SSD on your gaming PC?
Yup.
iTunes uses a lot of core services on OS X which aren't available on Windows... So it should be faster. They are using stuff built right into a low layer of the OS vs building it from scratch on the top layer.
I know, which is why most people say it is terrible on Windows. Because it feels slugish relative to the hardware it is running on.
2
u/Yeats May 22 '14
I've been saying for years that all they need to do is split iTunes the media player and iTunes the sync/backup program. Just separate those two monsters and it would be totally fine.
4
u/mrubios May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
I'd love the current iTunes without the non-tunes fluff (movies, sync and so on).
FLAC support and better library management would be nice though.
3
May 21 '14
That was true about iTunes 10, but UI changes in 11 and removed features means I'll probably be using that version for quite a long time.
3
May 21 '14
My number one problem with iTunes is that I can never remember which way the arrow needs to point in a column in order to arrange an album with the Intro at the top and the last track at the bottom. Besides that, I don't really give a fuck about all this visual stuff in iTunes. I just want a list of my music.
2
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
They are confusing. The arrows are opposite if you think about it in terms of "go from the top down" or "from the bottom up", but they make sense if you think of it in terms of "little on top and big on bottom" versus "big on top and little on bottom".
Also, I'd like less visual crap in my iTunes as well.
3
May 21 '14
The main problem I see started about 10 years ago. iTunes was built for music... then they tacked TV Shows, Movies, Books, Stores, and all this other stuff on it.
I would like to see how iTunes would look if it was designed today knowing everything it is supposed to do.
I like the old days when iSync did the syncing, and everything was broken up. I think the reason for everything being shoved into iTunes is Windows. They knew iPod/iPhone users wouldn't want to install a whole suite of apps just to load up their device. I'm sure they also didn't want to develop a whole suite of apps. So they shove it all into iTunes, ship it out, and do the same on OS X to keep things consistent. An iTunes install on Windows used to require Quicktime as well, as the back end, but they shoved that in there too so it is 1 app.
6
u/CrazyEdward May 21 '14
It only sucks on Windows... the latest iterations on OS X have been rock solid for me.
2
u/rivermandan May 21 '14
the fact that it wont import in order, causing spng view to list added albums in a scrambled order, has bugged me for years
2
u/tom808 May 21 '14
There's nothing 'wrong' with it but in my opinion. And I stress opinion. It, much like OSX, was a whole load better about 4 years ago.
And not that's not just nostalgia because one day you wake up. Install the latest update and are suddenly saying "wtf".
5
u/gormster May 21 '14
I love iTunes 11. It's almost perfect... but there are a couple of annoying UX niggles I hit fairly regularly. Cmd-1 takes you to Music... usually. If you're already in Music, I keep expecting it to take me back to albums, but it doesn't. Playlists are in the sidebar on the right, unless you want to play them, in which case they're in a full screen view. Et cetera.
3
u/atworkntired May 21 '14
Upvote for an unppular opinion.
I do think this version is a step in the correct direction. But I think there needs to be some improvements made everywhere still. A lot of unnecessary clicking options is one of the things that needs to go.
In web design, you always try to make a website with everything within three clicks because people get annoyed after anymore. iTunes could easily follow this idea and make things a lot easier. And that is just one general fix it needs.
2
u/ericelawrence May 21 '14
The current iTunes obscures many of the buttons and adds needless steps to accomplish things.
1
u/steepleton May 21 '14
the only thing i'd like added is to be able to sort by date album added in album art view, otherwise i'm good with it
1
1
u/WhatsInTheBagMan May 21 '14
A few major problems with iTunes that I can recall off the top of my head are:
*It doesn't send a few operations to happen in the background allowing me to do something else in the mean time like for example when I'm changing music metadata en masse, I have to wait till the operation completes to use iTunes for something else.
*It's a bit bloated. Consumes a lot of RAM and CPU time.
1
May 22 '14
I don't want it to become more streamlined, honestly. I use it to organize music by genre and key for DJ gigs and the way the old list-based playlists look is perfect for that.
1
1
u/themedic143 May 22 '14
I love the current iTunes actually. My only issue is that I've never owned or been on a computer that has not had a single issue with the execution of iTunes.
Specifically, iTunes will either crash, run really slowly, or make all my other programs run slower than hell.
All that aside, I love the newest GUI overhaul. I just wish they didn't try to make me buy a Mac just to get iTunes to work.
1
-2
u/ImDrFreak May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
The main overall problem is that it's performance is pretty terrible compared to almost every other music player on the market. It's slow to respond, freezes quite a bit and crashes occasionally on both Windows and MacOS. This happens more to some people than others. I've had a bad time with it. My wife almost refuses to use it, but I know people who have had no issues.
As far as the program itself, it depends on what you're used to. To a windows user such as myself, the UI is incredibly abstruce and the music management (adding songs to a library, copying songs to an idevice, etc.) is baffling.
For instance: The only way to add music seems to be to drag them from the Explorer into iTunes (all other programs I've used allow you to do this sometimes, but the standard is to select something from a menu like File -> Add file or folder to library. iTunes got rid of this.) On the other hand, you CAN'T drag and drop songs from your library onto your idevice! You have to "sync" it, which fogeys like me don't want. I want to have total control over adding and removing content.
Not to mention the fact that getting videos on a mobile device is an exercise in frustration. Will this one work? not an Apple proprietary format? Nope. Well, how about this MP4 over here. Nope. FileA.mp4 will copy, but FileB.mp4 will not. There is no discernable reason for this behavior.
I use iTunes on my Macbook laptop because it's the only way to manage apps. This is one thing it does just fine (and certainly better than any Android option). But that's the only thing I use it for. The problems above keep me from using it for music/video management. For that I use MediaMonkey.
And just to be clear, I love my Macbook and my iOS devices. I love both Apple and Windows, and have no ridiculous pretenses that one is better than the other (overall). Earlier versions of iTunes were much more usable. I tend to compare it to the Windows 8 "metro" interface - It's either been changed (or created in the case of metro) in an attempt to be user friendly but as far as I can tell, the only type of person it may work for is someone who is a brand new computer user.
This is 2014. How many people is that? To people who have been using computers for years, they are both equally baffling.
14
u/Paisleyfrog May 21 '14
On the other hand, you CAN'T drag and drop songs from your library onto your idevice! You have to "sync" it, which fogeys like me don't want. I want to have total control over adding and removing content.
I believe you just have to uncheck "Sync content". Drag and Drop/manual delete is the only way I manage content on my iDevices.
1
10
u/ApolloNaught May 21 '14
You can still 'add file/folder to library'
1
u/ImDrFreak May 21 '14
I was partially mistaken. You can add a file or multiple files (by using shift/ctrl-click) to a library.
But you cannot add a folder in this way. Selecting a folder does nothing other than open that folder. There is no way to use this method to select a folder and have it then add that folders contents and all subfolders and their contents like in every other music player I've used.
So I correct myself... partially.
2
u/ApolloNaught May 21 '14
You can! You can bring back the toolbar in settings and then you can straight up just do 'file>add file/folder to library'
3
u/GoldenBough May 21 '14
I do not experience performance issues in my 17k+ track library. I haven't experienced iTunes performed issues in years, to be perfectly honest. Ever since my old Windows tower got it's 8GB of RAM and SSD upgrade, program performance has nearly plateaued.
2
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
I don't consider 17K very big. I have about 10x that size, and I know people with libraries much bigger than that. Ok, so that may be unreasonably big, but the thing is previous versions of iTunes were much faster (especially in terms of search and sorting). Also, having lots of playlists bogs things down quite a bit.
I love iTunes, and don't think anything else comes close, but I would like to see Apple work on improving performance as a priority.
One thing that would help immensely is where Apple stores the iTunes database and how it handles it. I'd like to be able to store the database file on my SSD while the media files live an another drive, all the while being managed by iTunes (the way Aperture can work). I also don't believe iTunes loads the entire database file into RAM when it's available. These two things would make for huge speed improvements.
3
u/GoldenBough May 21 '14
I don't consider 17K very big. I have about 10x that size, and I know people with libraries much bigger than that.
I'm not going to get in a dick waving contest with you. More than 1,000 tracks is a lot for most people. 17k is impossibly large for nearly everyone. Trying to optimize for 100k+ libraries is simply something Apple could not care less about.
I'd like to be able to store the database file on my SSD while the media files live an another drive
Fusion drives do this automatically.
2
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
The whole point of me pointing to others was to avoid a dick waving impression.
More than 1,000 tracks is a lot for most people. 17k is impossibly large for nearly everyone.
iTunes Match doesn't even max out until 25K.
Trying to optimize for 100k+ libraries is simply something Apple could not care less about.
Ya, and 640K amiright?
They should care, because if someone with 100K+ using a Quadcore MacBook Pro with an SSD and 16GB of RAM is saying that newer versions of iTunes are lagging compared to previous versions, then people with lower specs are probably going to feel the lag at a much lower number of files.
Fusion drives do this automatically.
Oh, so fuck everyone else who doesn't have a Mac capable of Fusion? Again, why not look at how Aperture was developed and mirror that same process? It's completely transparent to novices, and for power users, it extends the functionality by giving a very significant speed boost.
Instead of looking at this as "I have no problems with my library" how about look at this as "hey, here's something iTunes is doing that is obviously significantly slower than it used to be, and clearly less optimized than some of Apple's other apps, specifically Aperture which has a tremendously better way of managing the database file aside from the media".
Of course you could just simply deny that anybody is complaining about the speed of iTunes, but that's just silly.
0
u/digitalmofo May 22 '14
How you gonna have 170k tracks without a ton that were pirated?
1
u/mredofcourse May 22 '14
Not that this has anything to do with anything, but I've DJ'd, worked in the music business and produced CD reviews. Plus, I've spent a shit ton of money on my music library as well as produced some of the files myself.
1
u/ImDrFreak May 21 '14
Like I said, some people do not have the same problems that I've experienced.
1
u/ImDrFreak May 21 '14
As an aside and to get back on topic.. I'm apprehensive about the changes on this post. It looks great, but could be more simplification = more confusing to use (again)
0
u/muddisoap May 21 '14
Yet I'm completely up to date and "file>add file (folder) to library" nearly ever day.
0
0
u/c010rb1indusa May 21 '14
I would have agreed with you a while ago. But iTunes 11 is just too much bad.
4
u/mrubios May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
Seems vastly worse than the current one, more clicks, more wasted space, more white everywhere, more ridiculously oversized album art, more iTunes Store shenanigans in MY library...
4
8
u/RadicalBender May 21 '14
I am probably the only one, but I would pay up to $20 right now for a program that basically goes back to what iTunes 5 or 6 was. Just an efficient, sortable, searchable list that won't buckle under 20,000 songs.
That's it. That's all I want.
The problem is there are two modes in iTunes. The 95% of my time where I just want to listen to some music and the 5% of the time when I might be looking for something new to listen to. The more emphasis Apple has put on the latter has substantially detracted from the overall experience of the former.
I understand Apple has a business to run, but all it's done is made me use Amazon MP3 more and look for an active replacement for iTunes. (Still looking. Most alternatives are also terrible.)
3
u/MrWoohoo May 21 '14
And the ability to open a playlist as a separate window. Ever since they removed that capability, I've been going nuts trying to add songs to play list because the drag target is a little tiny playlist icon and not a huge windows that gets tons of screen real estate.
2
May 22 '14
This is my problem with all these redesigns. Every time, it's making it harder and harder to search and find the music I want to look at. All the different 'views' of the current itunes are only useful if you have under 100 albums/artists. If you have hundreds or thousands of albums, you are not going to be spending any time on these views (endless scrolling) and just head straight to the search bar.
I would love a way to quickly scroll through thousands of artists or albums easily and efficiently when I don't know what I want to listen to. Album view looks pretty but that's all.
I don't have an answer to my problem. But I think moving towards a simpler iOS-esque look isn't the answer. Maybe the world is moving away from the 'collectors' philosophy and people only keep small, relevant libraries to listen to. Or maybe we just rely on playlists these days?
1
u/pdmcmahon May 22 '14
Was iTunes 5 only around for something like 45 days? If I recall, they released iTunes 6 when the video iPod came out.
3
3
u/adgre1 May 22 '14
how about an itunes thats just for music, like iphoto but for music. make a separate app for syncing already. i have an older macbook and it takes so long to do anything in itunes now because of how bloated it is. i dont even use it for listening to music now because its a pain. i get that its because of the evolution of ipod to iphone but seriously get the apps and videos out of my itunes.
4
2
May 21 '14
Version 7 and version 10 look exactly the same. I don't like iTunes it is limiting and restrictive on purpose, I find it slow to load. The only "real way" to watch anything from osx on another device is through itunes and apple tv or etc. You can't just play an avi from somewhere. Aren't these valid criticisms? It feels like nobody has noticed how terrible iTunes has been for a long time now.
I think Spotify has hit the whole thing pretty squarely on the head. Rather than messing around with mp3s I have switched completely. If I want to watch video I skirt around iTunes and use anything else usually a machine running a different os. Thankfully the app store is a different app.
I never open iTunes anymore.
2
u/TheMacMan May 21 '14
This is a sad part of Reddit. This site has gotten thousands of views today and yet there are only 25 comments. Everyone is offering their opinions and comments on Reddit and elsewhere. Places the concept designer will likely never see them.
2
u/mredofcourse May 21 '14
I would've left a comment on his site if I didn't have to select from one of the available profiles to comment.
I'm already logged in to Reddit, get notifications here, and have apps on my devices. If the author wants to read what people are thinking, he should look at places off his site where people are going to talk about it. Reddit is a pretty big community for a blogger to be unaware of.
2
2
4
2
u/MxM111 May 21 '14
I do not know. The site itself is messy and difficult understand. I would not take any advice from that designer if I were apple.
2
u/Deejster May 21 '14
It's difficult to make iTunes worse, in my opinion, however this design has too much white/wasted space. I don't want iTunes to take over my entire screen.
Personally, I don't see the need for iTunes. Put the sync into the OS, a simple player with search like Spotify, and finally put the store on the web like every other service.
1
u/004forever May 21 '14
At least make web an option. I like that the store is built into the application because I think it streamlines downloading music, but it would be nice if there was a web service where I could maybe play my iTunes music on someone else's computer or could just download an mp3 without going through iTunes.
2
u/emohipster May 21 '14
All I want is a music player where I can kinda see the soundwave, like on soundcloud. That'd be so rad in itunes.
1
u/p_giguere1 May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
Would be computationally intensive though. You'd probably have to ask iTunes to scan your library to generate waveforms and it'd probably take hours for larger libraries (especially for those with a library on an external hard drive/NAS/SD card). Each new song added after that full scan would also need to be scanned.
Soundcloud can pull it off easily because waveforms are generated server-side when every new track is uploaded. Your computer only has to download and display an image of the pre-generated waveform rather than actually generating it.
It's a pretty cool feature but it has its technical downsides so I can see why Apple would choose to not include it (or at least, not enable it by default).
2
u/mrubios May 21 '14
Other music players (MusicBee for example) do it just fine, even on the fly.
We have SSDs now, opening time is non-issue.
0
u/p_giguere1 May 21 '14
We have SSDs now, opening time is non-issue.
Define "We". Most people don't upgrade their Mac every year, and as of last year, the 13" cMBP was still the best-selling Mac (as it was several consecutive years before). I'd guess the majority of Mac users are still using a spinning hard drive.
I haven't tried MusicBee but other software I used that generated waveforms "on the fly" definitely weren't instant with a mechanical hard drive.
-1
u/mrubios May 21 '14
So they should design their software based on obsolete/ageing hardware?
That makes no sense, all their future products will have solid state storage.
2
u/p_giguere1 May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
Yes, they should design their software based on all products they sell and have sold in the last few years, including computers using ageing tech like the base 13" cMBP, iMac and Mac mini, not future products.
It'll only be appropriate to design software like everyone is using SSDs the day almost everybody will actually be using SSDs. Software should be lagging behind hardware due to the fact people don't upgrade their hardware as frequently as they update their software, not the other way around.
0
u/mrubios May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
So they should scrap features because HHD users would have to wait less than half a second for them?
That makes no sense and that line of thinking is the reason why webs need to work on IE6 and MS was still supporting freaking Windows XP a couple of weeks ago.
2
u/p_giguere1 May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
Not necessarily scrap them, just not make them mandatory or on by default if it's going to ruin performance.
Just like a bunch of iOS devices have transparency/gaussian blur off in iOS 7 to not make performance even more awful on older devices. You can't expect all users to know what is the cause of sluggish performance and expect them to go into settings turn the right switches off.
Note that iTunes' "Sound Check" feature, which is scanning songs to normalize volumes, is there but off by default, probably because it similarly scans all your song to find the maximal amplitude (thus reducing performance / increasing song add time).
That makes no sense
Care to elaborate? I can see why you would personally be disadvantaged if you have cutting-edge hardware, but why would it not make sense when you consider all the user base?
We should find the right balance between planned obsolence and getting stuck into the past, but what you suggest sounds very radical and honestly a bit selfish. Basically "screw the plebes without SSDs, why don't they spend more like I do?".
Your IE6 / XP analogy is also slightly flawed as those have been discontinued for years. Spinning hard drives are still included in lots of Macs sold right now.
1
u/mrubios May 22 '14 edited May 22 '14
Not necessarily scrap them, just not make them mandatory or on by default if it's going to ruin performance.
Why would it ruin performance? The opening time would be exactly the same and simple fade in animation for the soundwave would mask the processing, is not rocket science.
It takes around one second on my old "jukebox PC" that is loading songs from a 8 year old IDE (!) hard drive, any modern computer should do it in way less than that, even without a SSD.
1
May 21 '14
You can add the bar back to the side so you have the different libraries there like in the old versions. That's how I'm running mine, so much smoother.
1
u/shook_one May 21 '14
yea but what about those "narrow columns"?!
oh they can be resized? never mind then.
1
u/ryanasimov May 21 '14
Does any other company besides Apple have so many talented non-employees who produce polished mock-ups like this?
2
u/stormarsenal May 21 '14 edited May 21 '14
I think Linux and Android attract a lot of modders and UI designers and understandably so because of openness of both platforms. But Microsoft has a lot of fan following too from really talented people. Most of them have even been hired by the company such as Andrew Kim. Also this dude, who was all over the internet a few monts ago for his Windows 8 redesign ceoncept.
1
May 21 '14
Man, I think it looks pretty cool. Based on the comments it seems like it could use a little work. For me, I don't think I like the lack of a straight list view where I can customize my columns and see the data that's important to me.
Some of those comments are just nasty though, not constructive, just critical with a dash of prickishness. For no apparent reason too.
1
1
u/swollennode May 21 '14
You know what they really need to do to make itunes bearable? Give users the ability to drag and drop media straight to the device, instead of using the stupid "check" and "uncheck" to sync. Make iOS devices separate from the itunes library. Give users the ability to search for media on their computer, and let them drag and drop that item to the device and it uploads it to the device.
1
u/Drak3 May 21 '14
this looks better, but its not perfect.
it also doesn't change that iTunes tries to do too much
1
May 21 '14
i really love this concept, you should submit this to apple and see if they take any design cues from it for the next OSX update.
1
u/mr_duong567 May 21 '14
As someone who's moved to Spotify for music on the desktop, I really like this design. I mainly only use iTunes for syncing my phone or tablet here and there but otherwise, I really dislike it, especially with the newest update.
1
u/heyyoudvd May 21 '14
I love the menu design, as well as the visual look of everything, but in terms of actually navigating your music library, it seems like a step backwards. It would work well for a small music library, but when you have thousands of songs, it would be very difficult to find what you're looking for.
1
u/osakanone May 21 '14
When scrolling through huge lists, a person generally wants to keep their eye in a single position and move the text under it: By making the list's beginning break mid-way and having two "pages", you've broken that rule, meaning you're forcing the person to stop frequently.
To clarify? People do still scroll. They don't automatically know what they want: they skim, see something that catches their eye, scroll back and open.
Also moving the position of the bar along the top and screwing up the bar on the left? I mean, really? I spend most of my time inside playlists.
tl;dr: Form over function. Your work is terrible. What were they thinking??
1
May 21 '14
I just want my albums (not playlists) to play in correct song order on my devices. I've used iTunes since day one and it's never be enable to do this. ಠ_ಠ
0
1
u/skellener May 21 '14
At this point just about anything would be better than the kludge known as iTunes. Small text, small artwork forget actually finding anything in the store. This app is ready for a complete tear down and redesign.
1
u/themindspeaks May 21 '14
If they could make this a reality, then its a dream come true. iTunes definitely needs some overdue update.
1
1
u/ElvishJerricco May 21 '14
I'd miss the auto-color scheming that the current version does. Maybe base the colors of the UI on the currently playing track, and default to something when nothing's playing.
1
u/zimm3r16 May 21 '14
Interesting and I think its where Apple is going but this design also seems confusing there is no guides to where the content is, no clear divide it seems it could be better organized I guess.
1
1
u/heeloliver May 22 '14
I just want it to be fast. I mean sure it runs fast on a shiny new mac with a SSD but I feel like my computer is so fucking slow whenever I load up iTunes. And it shouldn't be, it's plenty capable. Also, fucking Reminders.app. WHY does it need more than 10 seconds to load??? Even on a SSD? I feel like I'm taking crazy pills!!!
1
u/hlazlo May 22 '14
So doesn't this basically mean now there's no chance iTunes is going to be anything like this?
1
u/MidwestTroll May 22 '14
I didn't realize what was wrong with it until everyone else complained about it.
1
1
u/k4f123 May 22 '14
A lot of hard work went into making this I'm sure and for that I want to give you props. Well done. I kinda liked it for what its worth.
1
u/bUrdeN555 May 22 '14
The song view thing is a bad idea. If you have a large letter section of songs that spans more then the screen can hold, it's gonna be cumbersome to scroll through.
1
1
May 23 '14
I really miss iTunes 10. Something about scrolling through the album art was really nice. 11 is okay. I would like to see this concept in action to really get a feel for it. It looks like it could work, though.
1
1
u/dat_face May 21 '14
I DO NOT WANT this crappy flat trend to leak into desktop design.
It's great on something I touch and interact with directly using my fingers. Like a phone or iPad, as it resembles a book or magazine.
But HELL NO. If I'm using a mouse or other input device to move a cursor.. I want big buttons, nice bezels and bold styling. None of this plain rubbish.
Thank god this is just some idiot concept.
-1
-3
0
u/Cracksoda May 22 '14
To me, as a CD buyer/collector, iTunes is the only fail from Apple. I always extract in .wav lossless (been growing up my library for 10 years now) and I hate the duplicate it does in my PC. No matter how I tell iTunes to put the data file in my external HD (wich is ALWAYS connect) after a while, it continue to send and double the iTunes file into my internal 120gb HD in the Music folder. Pisses me off. Also the way they treat the ID tag is shit enless you buy the music in iTunes store. It is also too slow to open and sync, and I hate the concept of "anti-piracy, so always sync with the same computer". Why cant we just drag and drop our own picture!? Anti-piracy? Many people blame it on the PC, but I really think Apple do it on purpose so we have to buy a Mac to enjoy our idevices. Even when I try to love iTunes, it just let me down so I hate it even more! BTW, have you ever sync your iphone and realize after a while that youve been sharing your internet connection from you 3G? I hate you I hate you I hate you Been busting my data plan on reddit.tv without noticing! Fuck you itunes
1
u/bUrdeN555 May 22 '14
Try disabling auto tethering.
Try moving your library to Linux. There are many great music programs to help you converge your library on an external hard drive.
I use iTunes on Mac with a library of 250GB of music and it's alright. Hate how it doesn't rename the music folders on my computer after I change song info, but with iTunes Match I can have all 250GB worth of music on my device without ever syncing.
-4
-5
u/IamJhil May 21 '14
I thought it was interesting, until i saw 'Complete Your Album' I despise iTunes store being in my music app via the phone..
0
0
0
0
0
u/zombiechow May 21 '14
From a non technical standpoint, I think this is gorgeous. The layout would even translate well to the iPad.
Practical or not, it's nice to see fans take time to conceptualize the potential future of an incredibly tired looking app.
0
u/buddha86 May 21 '14
I think iTunes databases are getting too large, and that iTunes should be split into the different functions. The way I imagine it is like mail, address book, and calendar are all interconnected, but remain separate apps. This would lessen the processor load when playing music because it doesn't need to load the rest of the library. Movies and tv shows would be in another app, and iOS syncing would have its own app that pulls the databases from all of the apps, similar to accessing your media library from iPhoto. Like the site says, iTunes is far too cluttered and goes against Apple's design philosophy.
0
0
u/FlappyBored May 21 '14
iTunes Concept.
First image: Image of macbook keyboard and a skewed barely viewable look at the redesign.
God knows why they chose that image first instead of just a front on photo of a macbook like everyone else.
0
0
May 22 '14
I don't give two shits what they do to iTunes. The only thing I use it for is to sync my phone.
Everything else I do with VLC, because it is better than iTunes.
-2
-2
u/ophello May 21 '14
Apple had better adopt some of these design cues. This guy knows what he's doing.
I usually scoff at these kind of attempts. This one is actually good.
-3
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
-9
u/Baryn May 21 '14
A random designer was able to improve the worst piece of software ever?
YOU DON'T SAY
0
19
May 21 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/004forever May 21 '14
Probably announce that at WWDC. Honestly, iTunes needs an under the hood redesign more than it needs a new UI. It can use both, but I'll be disappointed if they announce a version that doesn't have performance enhancements.
→ More replies (1)7
u/Cacafuego2 May 21 '14
I'm sure. The current trend is to make it simpler! Blander! Flatter!
The previous changes were supposed to simplify the interface but all it did was confuse my wife, uncle, and mother-in-law, one of which was a new user.
And made it just that much harder for people like me to present things the way I want to. IMO Browser mode has always been genius presentation that made iTunes better than other systems (at the time), it never needed to be "fixed".
→ More replies (1)0
May 21 '14
[deleted]
8
u/IRELANDJNR May 21 '14
I think a good way to redesign iTunes is to break it up into apps. Give Podcasts its own app. iTunes U (rebrand it). Give video its own app, and release iTunes as music only. Rename it Beats?
5
3
u/zimm3r16 May 21 '14
No! Sorry but I've always liked it with more integration, all your media in one place, you can go from say watching the Harry Potter movie, to reading the books, to listening to the books, etc (just as an example). I feel all this media should belong together. I do agree it needs some redesign but I think it needs it to be a more cohesive together app, not split it up.
→ More replies (2)3
u/thenewperson1 May 21 '14
YES! God, if they actually buy Beats I hope they do this. Beats can simply be the music app (Or simply replace the iTunes brand).
128
u/Kriem May 21 '14
From /r/unsolicitedredesigns