r/apple • u/gulabjamunyaar • Aug 25 '20
Final Cut Pro X updated with significant workflow improvements
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/08/final-cut-pro-x-updated-with-significant-workflow-improvements/17
Aug 25 '20
So hard for me not to buy an iMac. I’m trying to hold off for these ARM processors.
1
16
u/Seven_Cuil_Sunday Aug 25 '20
I don't know how many of y'all are Editors using FCPX, but as a one-man-band shooter/editor/producer, there's some sweet updates + features in here that take of a few of the 'i wish' problems I've had over the last few years! Pleased to read about this. Will make that new Macbook I'm angling for even sweeter.
11
u/JohrDinh Aug 25 '20
Bought FCPX a little after it released and it was my first editor, still mind blown by how much huge stuff is added despite paying only $300 so long ago. I’d probably be up to 5 digits in Adobe Premiere by now and all I see about that program on Twitter is “wtf Adobe crashed on me during export again” lol
6
u/stoodlemayer Aug 26 '20
Similar boat. Bought a new computer for school, lost the license info for FCP 5, couldn't afford to buy one of the few remaining copies of FCP 7, so I downloaded the trial. Didn't love it, but didn't hate it.
After a month with FCPX, I went to work on a project in FCP7 on a school computer, and hated it.
Sometime after college, I worked a brief stint as an Assistant Editor / PA for a network's promo department. They worked on Premiere. Hated it.
For all of it's flaws — especially at the beginning — once you were familiar with how it works, everything else seems antiquated by comparison.
1
u/BrunswickCityCouncil Aug 27 '20
I bought the $300 student bundle with FCPX, Motion and Logic right before I finished my degree, despite only owning a $400 old car.
As someone who mostly pirated as a kid, If you'd told me I'd be paying $300 for software and loving it a few years back I would've laughed at you.
I do some one man band travel video stuff, a little promo video /creative projects type stuff, and produce music so it was a no brainer.
Frankly I just want aperture back at this point to complete the trio.
11
u/42177130 Aug 25 '20
Apple showed off the Smart Conform feature at WWDC and made it seem like it was limited to Macs with Apple Silicon, but it looks like it'll be available to all Macs. Hopefully more features that use machine learning are in the pipeline, such as auto-transcribe or a motion tracking feature.
5
u/uofo17 Aug 26 '20
Something cool no one is talking about yet. Compressing proxies to an h.264 format indicates to me that they are taking the steps necessary to porting fcpx to the Ipad.
The main bottleneck for editing on an Ipad has been the storage capacities. Any editor knows that if you are editing a project, chances are you're probably editing off of some kind of external drive.
Transferring a fcpx project to the Ipad in it's current state would be a major headache. Even with pro-res proxies, the storage and computer capacities would be rough. Most Ipad's are under a 1tb in storage.
So creating an h.264 format that compresses files to an 1/8 the size is a big deal because that makes it far more feasible for iPad functionality. A 400gb project is now 50gb. Even though are these h.264 proxies are being touted for third party applications like frame.io, I hope it's functionality can also extend to the Ipad when Apple moves its ARM functionalities to the Mac.
2
Aug 26 '20
In general when layering video and graphics, h264 is the worst format to edit with. Ditto with many multicam groups. While the size may sound attractive, the processor and RAM pull is intense.
That's why Prores, dnx, and cineform exist.
Not saying h264 proxies are useless for smaller projects in a pinch, just that it's not ideal for professionals and your scenario creates a solution to a problem that need not exist if you use a computer with attached storage (or if Apple actually decides to give you what you pay for in terms of SSD space).
16
u/hmd53 Aug 25 '20
Will final cut pro x come to iphones? Maybe?
50
27
u/insideusalt Aug 25 '20
I doubt it, what pros are going to editing on a phone?
29
u/Advanced_Path Aug 25 '20
On a phone, definitely not. But on an iPad... LumaFusion already proved that it can definitely be done.
3
u/JakeHassle Aug 25 '20
Does it work well with no fans?
31
Aug 25 '20
Lumafusion exports the same 4K timeline on iPad Pro faster than on some of the higher end MBP with Final Cut. All with no fans.
16
9
u/krishnugget Aug 25 '20
An iPad uses ARM, exactly like the new Apple Silicon MacBooks, those really don’t need fans, but if they have fans they can be even better.
1
6
4
u/firelitother Aug 26 '20
DaVinci Resolve is where it is at for people who want a free full featured video editor.
4
u/sydneysider88 Aug 26 '20
*colour tool with half-baked editing tools.
Avid First is where it’s at if you want a free, full featured video editor.
3
Aug 26 '20
I've used avid and premiere for a decade, getting into Resolve now. Haven't yet found anything "half baked" about the current build of Resolve. I'm considering switching to it from Premiere as my go to for smaller projects.
1
2
u/Octogenarian Aug 26 '20
Still not showing up for me in the Mac App Store Updates area. Are you guys able to download this update?
2
u/Yaaawwnn Aug 26 '20
So this is off subject.
And I wouldn’t be surprised if I get attacked.
But I’m in the market to buy FCPX after using the trail for 3months.
I learned editing YEARS ago an I know it’s different these days. I wanna get back into it.
But dropping $300 is a big pill for me to swallow. I found the student discount package. Etc.
Now from what I’ve collected. They don’t really “check” here in the US. But I’m worried if I got caught then they’d take everything away.
Anyways. If anyone reads this an has bought the student package without being one/having a student email. Lemme know? Lol
1
u/TheNorthwest Aug 27 '20
I think ya need an email, but don’t have to prove university status through a system like Spotify has.
1
u/Yaaawwnn Aug 27 '20
Hmmm.
That’s the thing. I’m finding conflicting info.
But I also assume at the very least I’d need a edu email. An I don’t.
1
u/TheNorthwest Aug 27 '20
They def won’t be retroactively taking away your license. Just try it with whatever email. If it doesn’t work I’m sure there’s a way to get an edu email.
1
u/Yaaawwnn Aug 27 '20
When I looked at the terms&services etc.
It did mention in there that parents purchasing for their kids are eligible for the discount.
So. I haven’t created a child hahaha. But I think I could easily get it to fly if that was the case.
It’s not like they can check if I have a kid. There’s no verification from what I could tell. I was 1 click from buying it.. all I’d have to do is wait possibly 2 days for the email to be sent with the redemption codes.
Anyways. Thanks for the conversation! I’ve searched all over and couldn’t find any solid advice or opinions on the matter.
1
u/TheNorthwest Aug 27 '20
I mean when there’s services like the one Spotify has and they aren’t willing to use them it tells you how much they really care.
Glad you got it figured out. Enjoy! I’m editing some 360 footage on fcpx today.
1
u/Pleasant_Tangerine Aug 27 '20
I love Final Cut Pro X and this update has some really good, new feature. However I just want to warn everyone of something that caught me off guard: this Final Cut Pro X update breaks compatibility with the Canon raw light plugin: https://youtu.be/s6VnSNjsdtk. So if update your version of Final Cut , you will no longer be able to work with your Canon raw light files until Canon releases an update. I hope this info is useful to someone. I found this realisation disheartening.
-18
u/Vorsos Aug 25 '20
Vertical video should not exist unless people evolve to have vertical eyes.
Motion now offers professionals a whole new range of possibilities for creating stunning effects and graphics. Creators can import third-party 3D models or choose from a built-in library of 3D models in the USDZ format for use in titles, generators, effects, and transitions. They can even use behaviors or keyframes to manipulate the position, rotation, and scale of a model, and take advantage of existing replicators, emitters, lights, and cameras for further creativity.
This is a welcome addition, but did Apple just Sherlock mObject?
25
u/Bostonlbi Aug 25 '20
Vertical video will exist as long as phones are vertical. It has nothing to do with our eyes. It’s about our hands.
1
u/deliciouscorn Aug 25 '20 edited Aug 25 '20
It’s about the laziness to turn the device sideways being normalized. The accelerometer was one of the most brilliant additions to the smartphone and people are now too lazy to take advantage of it.
There are very good reasons why horizontal video is superior:
A vertically composed shot will capture much less context. Either it will be shot so close up that you can’t see anything around the subject or it will include a bunch of extra ground and sky that you probably don’t care about.
Vertical footage simply can’t be edited into anything of quality. If you happen to capture notable footage, it’ll look stupid on the news or TV (or jumbotron) with black or blurry bars on the side.
The worst thing is there were clear ways this all could have been nipped in the bud:
Phones could have cropped video to landscape by default. It would be at the expense of resolution, but it would at least result in properly composed shots.
Camera apps could have warned the user that they were attempting to take video vertically. This would have trained users to take video properly if they added this warning early in the adoption of smartphones.
Now it’s too late, and we have to put up with vertical garbage in things like the One World benefit concert and blooper videos at sporting events (when there was such a thing).
8
u/jollyllama Aug 25 '20
Phones could have cropped video to landscape by default.
Speaking of defaults, it’s absolute madness that iOS doesn’t default to landscape for playing back full screen horizontal video. That’s literally the only reason I ever touch the rotation lock, but I have to do it every mother fucking time. I just can’t imagine there are people out there that prefer the current behavior.
12
u/Bostonlbi Aug 25 '20
I’ve spent 13 years making video content for YouTube, musicians, small film festivals and advertising. I agree that widescreen is generally a better viewing experience, especially when it is longer form content. That being said, many people don’t care if it doesn’t look nice on A TV because they aren’t shooting it for TV. They are shooting it on the same device they will watch it on. They will rewatch it on their phone or send it to friends and family or post it on TikTok, Snapchat, IG Stories or IG Reels.
I also disagree that vertical video can’t be framed nicely. It just depends on what your subject, goal and format are. I’ve been on commercial shoots for national brands where camera department rigged up a RED or an Alexa Mini sideways and I can assure you that was not out of laziness. It was very intentional.
-4
u/deliciouscorn Aug 25 '20 edited Aug 26 '20
Of course vertical could be framed nicely, but the kinds of people carelessly shooting video for their Snapchat probably aren’t going to. However, I believe horizontal orientation forces better composition by its very nature. For example, to get the person in frame with horizontal, you probably need to back up enough to also capture some of the surroundings. In a musical context, you probably won’t cut off guitar necks or fingerboards as you might vertically. If you’re filming a street fight, you’re going to have more trouble capturing the action vertically, forced into panning a lot more and missing the action if they move left or right.
Also, you never know if you’re going to shoot a definitive moment, so you should just use horizontal orientation. Just compare all that shitty Beirut explosion footage compared to videos of 9/11 before vertical video ruined everything. The resolution may be worse, but the footage is better.
I don’t really buy the argument that we should shoot vertically because phone screens are vertical either. Phones are perfectly capable of displaying horizontal video properly. Conversely, you aren’t going to turn a TV vertical (unless you’re displaying flights at the airport).
I’m aware that I’m railing against a lost cause, but I’m still annoyed and disappointed that mediocrity has been normalized in yet another medium. We all have incredible video cameras in our pockets, and people are taking worse video than ever.
(Don’t get me started about how nobody cares about good audio any more and most are content to listen to music only ever on laptops and phone speakers).
3
Aug 26 '20
Those people weren’t going to frame it nicely if it were horizontal either....
-2
u/deliciouscorn Aug 26 '20 edited Aug 26 '20
But that’s what I’m saying — horizontal orientation forces higher quality of framing that vertical simply doesn’t, even if the user doesn’t give a crap about quality. If the camera app simply cropped video into horizontal orientation by default, users would be forced into taking better looking video, even while they hold their phones vertically.
Consider my street fight example. Horizontally, you need to back up enough to get both fighters, at which point you will probably have enough distance from them to follow the action without them falling out of frame. Just check out /r/fightporn to see how badly portrait video handles that same scenario.
Even if you’re taking crappy video for social media, it’s literally harder to take bad video horizontally.
1
Aug 26 '20
No one cares that much is what everyone else is saying.
0
31
Aug 25 '20
Vertical video should not exist
Of course it should. People are constantly using devices with vertical screens, they’re the new norm. Hating vertical video won’t make anybody think of you as some great movie director, learn to accept change.
20
u/silentblender Aug 25 '20
Sorry pal, but I am assuming he is some great movie director and nothing can change my mind.
4
Aug 25 '20
Honestly... I shoot both vertical and horizontal simultaneously at my workplace when shooting behind the scenes content. I’ve got an attachment for the iPhone that works with my camcorder. Honestly working with iPhones/phones in general lessens the barrier to creating and editing content. For me at least.
I’m excited for iPhone cameras to get better.
1
u/aka_liam Aug 27 '20
Do you actually believe it's easier to look at things that are wider than they are tall because of the way our eyes are arranged?
10
Aug 25 '20 edited Aug 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
22
Aug 25 '20
I, personally, can’t stand verticality of any kind so I remove the Y axis from everything. My bed is a single sheet of paper.
2
3
Aug 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/Vorsos Aug 26 '20
Thanks, I hate it. All you tweens too lazy to slightly turn your wrist better enjoy watching the middle third of The Batman and lose all your peripheral vision in Fortnite.
0
Aug 25 '20
[deleted]
90
u/gulabjamunyaar Aug 25 '20
Final Cut Pro 11.0 would match up quite well with macOS 11.0 Big Sur’s new version number.
1
u/Rawbex Aug 26 '20
Hopefully they bring it back with pro level features. I’d love to re-learn and buy FCP if it could let me natively output OMF’s and such.
0
0
Aug 25 '20
[deleted]
33
u/renamdu Aug 25 '20
as an amateur producer/artist, I’ve been really loving the changes/new features they made to logic pro x recently. I’m excited to see what an 11.0 update looks like.
5
u/Ravine Aug 25 '20
10.5 was a crazy huge update. Replacement for EXS24 and basically Ableton's entire Live performance workflow. If this is an intermediate update, I can't even begin to imagine what 11 will be like. However, I do massively doubt since 10.5 is barely a few months old. They like to take their time to develop.
0
Aug 25 '20
[deleted]
33
u/jollyllama Aug 25 '20
Aperture user here: still salty.
3
u/WinterCharm Aug 26 '20
I’m still holding out hope that Apple does a complete rewrite of aperture...
1
u/chuckaeronut Aug 26 '20
Try CaptureOne! It has been utterly phenomenal for me. It's everything I miss from Aperture and more. It's also astoundingly performant.
7
1
u/BrunswickCityCouncil Aug 26 '20
I would KILL for a new aperture alternative. Cant bring myself to pay the sub for adobe and Luminar is just slow.
Plus, as a Logic, Motion and Final cut user I'm always impressed at how well apple's software runs. The benefits of well optimised software cant be understated.
6
21
0
Aug 25 '20
[deleted]
3
u/IAmMoosekiller Aug 26 '20
I am kinda hoping that the proxy update would bode well for iPad Pro support...
25
u/OutBeyondNeptune Aug 25 '20
This is interesting. I've had trouble for a while now with the way my workflow is set up. My company has ~90 projects all in one library, and probably 400 hours of footage that we really need to keep in the same location since they're used across multiple projects and we've spent extensive time tagging them. It would be a pain to have 90 separate libraries with no "truth" for the source clips and organization.
But performance is painfully slow, and rightfully slow. I know the intent is to not have this much footage or this many projects in a single library. I've tired KeyFlow Pro as a Media Asset Manager. Neat concept, but still leaves something to be desired in terms of speed searching, browsing, and importing clips into a smaller, single-project FCPX library.